Hi Brooks,
I was merely stating that if you were loading in SWF content modules
into a SWF shell, they would have to use JavaScript to communicate with
the SWF shell in order to be SCORM compliant. Since Flash does not
currently understand JavaScript, you cannot build a fully
SCORM-compliant Flash-only system (ie., one that does not have to go
back to the HTML page to update the LMS unless you use the Ajax hack.)
With the Ajax hack you lose maintainability, gain cross-platform issues
and lose performance.
I re-read my original post and I wasn't very clear in explaining this.
You can't manage state in Flash???
Of course you can. You can't maintain state in HTML without resorting to
Ajax. It would be interesting to see how you're using Flash and Ajax
together (and how it performs) but I still find it very messy (Ajax
alone is very messy.)
At the end of the day, a good development team will create a good
product regardless of the technologies used (within limits, of course).
If I was absolutely forced (at gunpoint by masked soldiers) to create a
SCORM-compliant app, I would probably take the same route you have
(Flash + Ajax) in order to maintain state in Flash in an effort to
provide a usable user experience.
Btw, what the heck are we doing discussing SCORM on an Open Source Flash
list *and* on Friday? Surely there's some rule somewhere against talking
about SCORM on a Friday! :)
Aral
_______________________________________________
osflash mailing list
[email protected]
http://osflash.org/mailman/listinfo/osflash_osflash.org
