http://www.meforum.org/article/702
"The Hell of Israel Is Better than the Paradise of Arafat"
by Daniel Pipes
In the Palestinian Authority's (PA) elections that took place in
January 2005, a significant percentage of Arab Jerusalemites stayed
away from the polls out of concern that voting in them might
jeopardize their status as residents of Israel. For example, the
Associated Press quoted one Rabi Mimi, a 28-year-old truck driver, who
expressed strong support for Mahmoud Abbas but said he had no plans to
vote: "I can't vote. I'm afraid I'll get into trouble. I don't want to
take any chances."[1] Asked if he would vote, a taxi driver responded
with indignation, "Are you kidding? To bring a corrupt [Palestinian]
Authority here. This is just what we are missing."[2]
This reluctance�as well as administrative incompetence�helped explain
why, in the words of the Jerusalem Post, "at several balloting
locations in the city [of Jerusalem], there were more foreign election
observers, journalists, and police forces out than voters."[3] It also
explains why, in the previous PA election in 1996, a mere 10 percent
of Jerusalem's eligible population voted, far lower than the
proportions elsewhere.
At first blush surprising, the worry about jeopardizing Israeli
residency turns out to be widespread among the Palestinians in Israel.
When given a choice of living under Zionist or Palestinian rule, they
decidedly prefer the former. More than that, there is a body of
pro-Israel sentiments from which to draw. No opinion surveys cover
this delicate subject, but a substantial record of statements and
actions suggest that, despite their anti-Zionist swagger, Israel's
most fervid enemies do perceive its political virtues. Even
Palestinian leaders, between their fulminations, sometimes let down
their guard and acknowledge Israel's virtues. This undercurrent of
Palestinian love of Zion has hopeful and potentially significant
implications.
Pro-Israel expressions fall into two main categories:[4] preferring to
remain under Israel rule and praising Israel as better than Arab regimes.
No Thank You, Palestinian Authority
Palestinians already living in Israel, especially in Jerusalem and the
"Galilee Triangle" area, tell, sometimes volubly, how they prefer to
remain in Israel.
Jerusalem. In mid-2000, when it appeared that some Arab-majority parts
of Jerusalem would be transferred to Palestinian Authority control,
Muslim Jerusalemites expressed less than delight at the prospect.
Peering over at Arafat's PA, they saw power monopolized by domineering
and corrupt autocrats, a thug-like police force, and a stagnant
economy. Arafat's bloated, nonsensical claims ("We are the one true
democratic oasis in the Arab region")[5] only exacerbated their
apprehensions.
`Abd ar-Razzaq `Abid of Jerusalem's Silwan neighborhood pointed
dubiously to "what's happening in Ramallah, Hebron, and the Gaza
Strip" and asked if the residents there were well off. A doctor
applying for Israeli papers explained:
The whole world seems to be talking about the future of the Arabs of
Jerusalem, but no one has bothered asking us. The international
community and the Israeli Left seem to take it for granted that we
want to live under Mr. Arafat's control. We don't. Most of us despise
Mr. Arafat and the cronies around him, and we want to stay in Israel.
At least here I can speak my mind freely without being dumped in
prison, as well as having a chance to earn an honest day's wage.[6]
In the colorful words of one Jerusalem resident, "The hell of Israel
is better than the paradise of Arafat. We know Israeli rule stinks,
but sometimes we feel like Palestinian rule would be worse."[7]
The director of the Bayt Hanina community council in northern
Jerusalem, Husam Watad, found that the prospect of finding themselves
living under Arafat's control had people "in a panic. More than 50
percent of east Jerusalem residents live below the poverty line, and
you can imagine how the situation would look if residents did not
receive [Israeli] National Insurance Institute payments." In the view
of Fadal Tahabub, a member of the Palestinian National Council, an
estimated 70 percent of the 200,000 Arab residents of Jerusalem
preferred to remain under Israeli sovereignty.[8] A social worker
living in Ras al-`Amud, one of the areas possibly falling under PA
control, said: "If a secret poll was conducted, I am sure an
overwhelming majority of Jerusalem Arabs would say they would prefer
to stay in Israel."[9]
Indeed, precisely when Palestinian rule seemed most likely in 2000,
the Israeli Interior Ministry reported a substantial increase in
citizenship applications from Arabs in eastern Jerusalem.[10] A
Jerusalem city councilor, Roni Aloni, heard from many Arab residents
about their not wanting to live under PA control. "They tell me�we are
not like Gaza or the West Bank. We hold Israeli IDs. We are used to a
higher standard of living. Even if Israeli rule is not so good, it is
still better than that of the PA."[11] Shalom Goldstein, an adviser on
Arab affairs to the Jerusalem mayor, found likewise: "People look at
what is happening inside the Palestinian-controlled areas today and
say to themselves, `Thank God we have Israeli ID cards.' In fact, most
of the Arabs in the city prefer to live under Israeli rule than under
a corrupt and tyrannical regime like Yasser Arafat's."[12]
So many Jerusalem Arabs considered taking out Israeli papers in 2000
that the ranking Islamic official in Jerusalem issued an edict
prohibiting his flock from holding Israeli citizenship (because this
implies recognizing Israeli sovereignty over the holy city). Faysal
al-Husayni, the Palestine Liberation Organization's man in charge of
Jerusalem affairs, went further: "Taking Israeli citizenship is
something that can only be defined as treason," and he threatened such
people with exclusion from the Palestinian state.[13] Finding his
threat ineffective, Husayni upped the ante, announcing that Jerusalem
Arabs who take Israeli citizenship would have their homes
confiscated.[14] The PA's radio station confirmed this, calling such
persons "traitors" and threatening that they would be "tracked
down."[15] Many Palestinians were duly intimidated, fearing the
authority's security forces.[16]
But some spoke out. Hisham Gol of the Mount of Olives community
council put it simply: "I prefer Israeli control."[17] An affluent
West Bank woman called a friend in Gaza to ask about life under the
PA. She heard an ear-full: "I can only tell you to pray that the
Israelis don't leave your town," because "the Jews are more human"
than Palestinians.[18] One individual willing publicly to oppose
Arafat was Zohair Hamdan of Sur Bahir, a village in the south of
metropolitan Jerusalem; he organized a petition of Jerusalem Arabs
demanding that a referendum be held before Israel lets the Palestinian
Authority take power in Jerusalem. "For 33 years, we have been part of
the State of Israel. But now our rights have been forgotten." Over a
year and a half, he collected more than 12,000 signatures (out of an
estimated Jerusalem Arab population of 200,000). "We won't accept a
situation where we are led like sheep to the slaughterhouse."[19]
Hamdan also expressed a personal preference that Sur Bahir remain part
of Israel[20] and estimated that the majority of Palestinians reject
"Arafat's corrupt and tyrannical rule. Look what he's done in Lebanon,
Jordan, and now in the West Bank and Gaza Strip. He has brought one
disaster after another on his people."[21]
The Galilee Triangle. Nor are such pro-Israeli sentiments limited to
residents of Jerusalem. When Prime Minister Ariel Sharon's government
released a trial balloon in February 2004 about giving the Palestinian
Authority control over the Galilee Triangle, a predominantly Arab part
of Israel, the response came strong and hard. As Mahmoud Mahajnah, 25,
told Agence France-Presse, "Yasir Arafat runs a dictatorship, not a
democracy. No one here would accept to live under that regime. I've
done my [Israeli] national service; I am a student here and a member
of the Israeli Football Association. Why would they transfer me? Is
that logical or legitimate?"[22] One resident quoted what he called a
local saying, that "the `evil' of Israel is better than the `heaven'
of the West Bank." Shu`a Sa`d, 22, explained why: "Here you can say
whatever you like and do whatever you want�so long as you don't touch
the security of Israel. Over there, if you talk about Arafat, they can
arrest you and beat you up." Another young man, `Isam Abu `Alu, 29,
put it differently: "Mr. Sharon seems to want us to join an unknown
state that doesn't have a parliament, or a democracy, or even decent
universities. We have close family ties in the West Bank, but we
prefer to demand our full rights inside Israel."[23]
The entrance to Umm al-Fahm, the largest Muslim town in Israel, sports
the green flags of the Islamic Movement Party that rules the town,
along with a billboard denouncing Israel's rule over Jerusalem. That
said, Hashim `Abd ar-Rahman, mayor and local leader of the Islamic
Movement, has no time for Sharon's suggestion: "Despite the
discrimination and injustice faced by Arab citizens, the democracy and
justice in Israel is better than the democracy and justice in Arab and
Islamic countries."[24] Nor does Ahmed Tibi, an Israeli Arab member of
parliament and advisor to Arafat, care for the idea of PA control,
which he calls "a dangerous, antidemocratic suggestion."[25]
Just 30 percent of Israel's Arab population, a May 2001 survey found,
agree to the Galilee Triangle being annexed to a future Palestinian
state, meaning that a large majority prefers to remain in Israel.[26]
By February 2004, according to the Haifa-based Arab Center for Applied
Social Research, that number had jumped to 90 percent preferring to
remain in Israel. No less startling, 73 percent of Triangle Arabs said
they would resort to violence to prevent changes in the border. Their
reasons divided fairly evenly between those claiming Israel as their
homeland (43 percent) and those cherishing Israel's higher standard of
living (33 percent).[27] So intense was the Arab opposition to ceding
the Galilee Triangle to the Palestinian Authority that Sharon quickly
gave the idea up.
The issue arose a bit later in 2004 as Israel built its security
fence. Some Palestinians, like Umm al-Fahm's Ahmed Jabrin, 67, faced a
choice on which side of the fence to live. He had no doubts. "We
fought [the Israeli authorities so as] to be inside of the fence, and
they moved it so we are still in Israel. We have many links to Israel.
What have we to do with the Palestinian Authority?"[28] His relative,
Hisham Jabrin, 31, added: "We are an integral part of Israel and will
never be part of a Palestinian state. We have always lived in Israel
and there is absolutely no chance that that will change."[29]
Preferring Israel to the Arab Regimes
Palestinians�from the lowest level to the highest ranking�sometimes
acknowledge how they prefer Israel to Arab countries. As one PLO
official observed, "We no longer fear the Israelis or the Americans,
regardless of their hostility, but we now fear our Arab
`brothers.'"[30] Or, in the general observation of a Gazan, "The Arabs
say they're our friends, and treat us worse than the Israelis do."[31]
Here are examples of attitudes toward three states:
� Syria. Salah Khalaf (a.k.a. Abu Iyad), one of the PLO's top figures,
declared in 1983 that crimes committed by the Hafiz al-Assad regime
against the Palestinian people "surpassed those of the Israeli
enemy."[32] In like spirit, Yasir Arafat addressed a PLO figure
murdered at Syrian instigation at his funeral: "The Zionists in the
occupied territories tried to kill you, and when they failed, they
deported you. However, the Arab Zionists represented by the rulers of
Damascus thought this was insufficient, so you fell as a martyr."[33]
� Jordan. Victor, a Jordanian who once worked as advance man for a
senior Saudi government minister, observed in 1994 that Israel was the
only Middle Eastern country he admires. "I wish Israel would just take
over Jordan," he said, his brother nodding in vigorous agreement. "The
Israelis are the only people around here who are organized, who know
how to get things done. And they're not bad people. They're straight.
They keep their word. The Arabs can't do anything right. Look at this
so-called democracy in Jordan. It's a complete joke."[34]
� Kuwait. Palestinians collaborated with Iraqi forces occupying Kuwait
in 1990, so when the country was liberated, they came in for some
rough treatment. One Palestinian newspaper found that in Kuwait,
"Palestinians are receiving treatment even worse than they have had at
the hands of their enemies, the Israelis."[35] After surviving the
Kuwaiti experience, another Palestinian minced no words: "Now I feel
Israel is paradise. I love the Israelis now. I know they treat us like
humans. The West Bank [still then under Israeli control] is better
[than Kuwait]. At least before the Israelis arrest you, they bring you
a paper."[36] With less exuberance, Arafat himself concurred: "What
Kuwait did to the Palestinian people is worse than what has been done
by Israel to Palestinians in the occupied territories."[37]
Many Palestinians already understood the virtues of Israeli political
life decades ago. As one man from Ramallah explained, "I'll never
forget that day during the Lebanon war [of 1982], when an Arab Knesset
member got up and called [Prime Minister Menachem] Begin a murderer.
Begin didn't do a thing [in response]. If you did that to Arafat, I
don't think you'd make it home that night."[38] Before the Palestinian
Authority came into existence in 1994, most Palestinians dreamt of
autonomy without worrying much about the details. After Arafat's
return to Gaza, they could make a direct comparison between his rule
and Israel's, something they frequently do. They have many reasons for
preferring life in Israel:
Restraints on violence. After the PA police raided the house of a
Hamas supporter in an after-midnight operation and roughed up both him
and his 70-year-old father, the father yelled at the police, "Even the
Jews did not behave like you cowards." And the son, when he came out
of the PA prison, declared his experience there much worse than in the
Israeli jails.[39] An opponent of Arafat's pointed out how Israeli
soldiers "would first fire tear gas, and then fire rubber bullets, and
only then shoot live ammunition. They never shot at us without a
direct order to shoot, and then they only shot a few bullets. But
these Palestinian police started shooting immediately, and they shot
everywhere."[40]
Freedom of expression. `Adnan Khatib, owner and editor of Al-Umma, a
Jerusalem weekly whose printing plant was burned down by PA police in
1995, bemoaned the troubles he'd had since the Palestinian Authority's
heavy-handed leaders got power over him: "The measures they are taking
against the Palestinian media, including the arrest of journalists and
the closure of newspapers, are much worse than those taken by the
Israelis against the Palestinian press."[41] In an ironic turn of
events, Na`im Salama, a lawyer living in Gaza, was arrested by the PA
on charges he slandered it by writing that Palestinians should adopt
Israeli standards of democracy. Specifically, he referred to charges
of fraud and breach of trust against then-prime minister Binyamin
Netanyahu. Salama noted how the system in Israel allowed police to
investigate a sitting prime minister and wondered when the same might
apply to the PA chieftain. For this audacity, he spent time in
jail.[42] Hanan Ashrawi, an obsessive anti-Israel critic, acknowledged
(reluctantly) that the Jewish state has something to teach the nascent
Palestinian polity: "freedom would have to be mentioned although it
has only been implemented in a selective way, for example, the freedom
of speech."[43] `Iyad as-Sarraj, a prominent psychiatrist and director
of the Gaza Community Mental Health Program, confesses that "during
the Israeli occupation, I was 100 times freer [than under the
Palestinian Authority]."[44]
Democracy. Israel's May 1999 elections, which Netanyahu lost,
impressed many Palestinian observers. Columnists cited in a Middle
East Media and Research Institute (MEMRI) study remarked on the smooth
transition in Israel and wanted the same for themselves; as one put
it, he envies the Israelis and wants "a similar regime in my future
state."[45] Even one of Arafat's employees, Hasan al-Kashif,
director-general of the PA's Information Ministry, contrasted
Netanyahu's immediate and graceful exit from office with the perpetual
power of "several names in our leadership" who go on ruling in
perpetuity.[46] Nayif Hawatma, leader of the terrorist Democratic
Front for the Liberation of Palestine, wished the Palestinian
Authority made decisions more like Israel:
We want the PNC [Palestine National Council] to discuss the
developments since 1991, particularly the Oslo accords, which were
concluded behind the back of the PNC contrary to what happened in
Israel, for example, where the accords were presented to the Knesset
and public opinion for voting.[47]
His facts might not be completely accurate, but they do make his point.
Rule of law. As the intifada of 1987 degenerated into fratricidal
murder and became known as the "intrafada," PLO leaders increasingly
appreciated Israeli fairness. Haydar `Abd ash-Shafi`, head of the
Palestinian delegation to the Washington peace talks, made a
remarkable observation in 1992 according to a transcript published in
a Beirut newspaper: "Can anyone imagine that a family would be happy
to hear a knock at the door in the middle of the night from the
Israeli army?" He continued: "When the infighting began in Gaza, the
people were happy because the Israeli army imposed a curfew."[48]
Likewise, Musa Abu Marzouk, a high-ranking Hamas official, scored
points against Arafat in 2000 by comparing him unfavorably with the
Jewish state: "We saw representatives of the Israeli opposition
criticize [Israeli prime minister Ehud] Barak and they were not
arrested � but in our case, the Palestinian Authority arrests people
as the first order of business."[49]
Protection of minorities. Christians and secular Muslims particularly
appreciate Israel's protection at a time when Palestinian politics has
taken an increasingly Islamist cast. The French weekly L'Express
quotes a Christian Palestinian to the effect that when the Palestinian
state comes into existence, "the sacred union against the Zionist
enemy will die. It will be time to settle accounts. We will undergo
the same as our Lebanese brothers or the Copts in Egypt. It saddens me
to say so, but Israeli laws protect us."[50] His fear is in many ways
too late, as the Palestinian Christian population has precipitously
declined in recent decades, to the point that one analyst asks if
Christian life is "to be reduced to empty church buildings and a
congregation-less hierarchy with no flock in the birthplace of
Christianity?"[51]
Economic benefits. Palestinians who live in Israel (including
Jerusalem) appreciate Israel's economic success, social services, and
many benefits. Salaries in Israel are about five times higher than in
the West Bank and Gaza Strip, and Israel's social security system has
no parallel on the Palestinian side. Palestinians living outside of
Israel want economically in; when the Israeli government announced the
completion of an 85-mile-long section of a security fence to protect
the country from Palestinian terrorists, one resident of Qalqiliya, a
West Bank border town, reacted with a revealing outrage: "We are
living in a big prison."[52]
Tolerance of homosexuals. In the West Bank and Gaza, conviction for
sodomy brings a three- to ten-year jail term, and gay men tell of
being tortured by the PA police. Some of them head for Israel where
one estimate finds 300 mostly male gay Palestinians living. Donatella
Rovera of Amnesty International comments, "Going to Israel is a
one-way ticket, and once there their biggest problem is possibly being
sent back."[53]
Palestinians living in the West who visit the Palestinian Authority
are vividly aware of its drawbacks compared to Israel. "There is a
difference between the Israeli and the PA occupation," wrote Daoud Abu
Naim, a medical researcher in Philadelphia, while visiting family in
Shuafat:
The Israelis whom I met with over the years have been diverse. Some
have been insensitive to our needs, and some have not been. On the
other hand, the Arafat/Rajoub regime is more than simply "corrupt." It
is exclusively interested in setting up a dictatorship in which
Palestinian citizens will have no civil liberties whatsoever.[54]
Rewadah Edais, a high school student who lives most of the year in San
Francisco and visits Jerusalem regularly, added, "The Israelis took
our land, but when it comes to governing, they know what they're
doing."[55]
Conclusion
Several themes emerge from this history. First, for all the overheated
rhetoric about Israel's "vicious" and "brutal" occupation,
Palestinians are alive to the benefits of its liberal democracy. They
appreciate the elections, rule of law, freedom of speech and religion,
minority rights, orderly political structures, and the other benefits
of a decent polity. There is, in short, a constituency for normality
among the Palestinians, difficult as that may be to perceive in the
hate-filled crowds that so dominate news coverage. Second, many of
those who have tasted Israel's economic benefits are loathe to forego
them; however impervious Palestinians may seem to economics, they know
a good deal when they have one. Third, the percentage of Palestinians
who would prefer to live under Israeli control cited in the estimates
noted above�an overwhelming majority of 70 to 90 percent�point to this
being more than a rarity among Palestinians. This has obvious
implications for Israeli concessions on the "right to return,"
suggesting that Palestinians will move to Israel in large numbers.
Fourth, it implies that some of the more imaginative final status
solutions that involve the redrawing of borders will be hard to
implement; Palestinians appear no more eager to live under Palestinian
Authority rule than are Israelis.
In word and deed, then, even Palestinians acknowledge Israel as the
most civilized state in the Middle East. Amid the gloom of today's
political extremism and terrorism, this fact offers wisps of hope.
Daniel Pipes is publisher of the Middle East Quarterly.
[1] Associated Press, Jan. 6, 2005.
[2] The Jerusalem Post, Jan. 9, 2005.
[3] Ibid.
[4] There is a third expression, of equal importance but very complex
and not covered here, namely the in-migration to Israel by Palestinian
and other Middle Easterners.
[5] Sawt al-Jabal (Shanayh), Mar. 6, 1993.
[6] The Daily Telegraph (London), Jan. 28, 2001.
[7] `Abd as-Samiya Abu Subayh, quoted in The Washington Post, July 25,
2000.
[8] The Washington Post, July 25, 2000.
[9] The Daily Telegraph, Jan. 28, 2001.
[10] Ibid.
[11] The Jerusalem Post, Nov. 8, 2000.
[12] The Jerusalem Report, Sept. 9, 2002.
[13] Reuters, Aug. 17, 2000.
[14] Israel Wire Service, Sept. 4, 2000.
[15] Reuters, Aug. 17, 2000.
[16] The Jerusalem Report, Sept. 9, 2002.
[17] Ha'aretz (Tel Aviv), Dec. 29, 2000.
[18] The Forward, Aug. 11, 1995.
[19] The Jerusalem Post, Dec. 22, 2002.
[20] Ibid., Nov. 8, 2002. For his efforts, he was threatened by the PA
with his effigy on an electric pole, declared an enemy on Hezbollah
television, and finally gunned down, taking five bullets in the
abdomen, shoulder, and leg. (Joseph Farah, "My New Muslim Hero,"
WorldNetDaily.com, Nov. 28, 2001.)
[21]The Jerusalem Post, Dec. 22, 2002.
[22] Agence France-Presse, Feb. 3, 2003.
[23] The Washington Times, Feb. 17, 2004.
[24] Newsday, Mar. 7, 2004.
[25] Associated Press, Feb. 3, 2004.
[26] Conducted by the Peace Research Institute at Givat Haviva, The
Jerusalem Post, May 21, 2001.
[27] Quoted in Newsday, Mar. 7, 2004.
[28] Newsday, Mar. 7, 2004.
[29] Agence France-Presse, Feb. 3, 2003.
[30] Ar-Ra'y (Amman), Nov. 5, 1991.
[31] Quoted in Milton Viorst, Sandcastles: The Arabs in Search of the
Modern World (New York: Alfred A. Knopf, 1994), p. 370.
[32] Al-Majalla (London), Nov. 26, 1983.
[33] The Washington Post, Jan. 1, 1985.
[34] Ethan Bronner, "The Arab Paradox," The Boston Globe Magazine, May
8, 1994.
[35] Al-Fajr (Jerusalem), June 3, 1991.
[36] Quoted in Deborah Amos, Lines in the Sand: Desert Storm and the
Remaking of the Arab World (New York: Simon and Schuster, 1992), p. 180.
[37] Al-Musawwar (Cairo), Nov. 15, 1991.
[38] Peter Hirschberg, "The Dark Side of Arafat's Regime," The
Jerusalem Report, Aug. 22, 1997, p. 25.
[39] The Jerusalem Report, Feb. 23, 1995.
[40] Los Angeles Times, Nov. 19, 1994
[41] The Jerusalem Report, June 15, 1995.
[42] The Washington Post, May 2, 1997.
[43] Neues Deutschland (Berlin), June 16, 1994.
[44] Anthony Lewis, "Darkness in Gaza," The New York Times, May 6, 1996.
[45] Al-Quds (Jerusalem), May 24, 1999, in The Middle East Media
Research Institute (MEMRI), June 4, 1999.
[46] Al-Ayyam (Ramallah), May 22, 1999, in MEMRI, June 4, 1999.
[47] Ad-Dustur (Amman), Feb. 3, 1996.
[48] As-Safir (Beirut), Oct. 22, 1992.
[49] Islamic Association for Palestine, Aug. 16, 2000.
[50] L'Express (Paris), Dec. 24, 1992.
[51] Daphne Tsimhoni, "Israel and the Territories�Disappearance,"
Middle East Quarterly, Winter 2001, p. 31.
[52] The New York Times, July 31, 2003.
[53] Reuters, Sept. 17, 2003. For details of one case, see Molly
Moore, "Down and Out in Israel: A Gay Arab from the West Bank Finds He
Can't Go Home Again," The Washington Post, Feb. 8, 2004.
[54] Encounter-EMEM-for Middle East Peace Activists, Yahoo Groups,
July 16, 2001.
[55] The Washington Post, July 25, 2000.
------------------------ Yahoo! Groups Sponsor --------------------~-->
DonorsChoose. A simple way to provide underprivileged children resources
often lacking in public schools. Fund a student project in NYC/NC today!
http://us.click.yahoo.com/EHLuJD/.WnJAA/cUmLAA/TySplB/TM
--------------------------------------------------------------------~->
--------------------------
Want to discuss this topic? Head on over to our discussion list, [EMAIL
PROTECTED]
--------------------------
Brooks Isoldi, editor
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
http://www.intellnet.org
Post message: [email protected]
Subscribe: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Unsubscribe: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
*** FAIR USE NOTICE. This message contains copyrighted material whose use has
not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. OSINT, as a part of
The Intelligence Network, is making it available without profit to OSINT
YahooGroups members who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the
included information in their efforts to advance the understanding of
intelligence and law enforcement organizations, their activities, methods,
techniques, human rights, civil liberties, social justice and other
intelligence related issues, for non-profit research and educational purposes
only. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of the copyrighted material
as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use
this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,'
you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.
For more information go to:
http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtml
Yahoo! Groups Links
<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/
<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/