Iraq, Unplugged
Beyond the polls, op-eds, and PowerPoints, what's really going on


by Michael Rubin
National Review Online
November 1, 2005
http://www.meforum.org/article/784  <http://www.meforum.org/article/784> 

On Friday, Special Counsel Patrick J. Fitzgerald indicted Scooter Libby on
five counts of obstruction of justice, false statement, and perjury. The
charges are serious but, as columnist David Brooks noted in the New York
Times , Fitzgerald found no evidence of the broad conspiracy hinted at by
journalists, bloggers, and partisan pundits. Nevertheless, opponents of the
Iraq war have painted the indictment as evidence of original sin. The
American Conservative , for example, accused the Bush administration of
"forging the case for war." Liberal blogger Arianna Huffington argued that
"the scandal has reignited a national debate about the White House lies and
deceptions that led us to war in Iraq." 

Washington has always been an arrogant town. Whatever the issue, pundits use
the crisis of the day to score partisan points. Sure, there should be
accountability for intelligence failures not only about overestimating
Iraq's weapons program in 2003, but also for underestimating them in 1991.
Nor should policymakers feel comfortable about previous Central Intelligence
Agency misanalysis of nuclear programs in India, Pakistan, and Libya. But
the Iraqi people should not be sacrificed upon the altar of Bush hatred,
Clinton hatred, or Kerry hatred. 

Too often, countries like Nicaragua, Haiti, Bosnia, Kosovo, and Iraq become
templates upon which U.S. pundits and politicians wage political battles
unrelated to the plight of the people actually living there. The fiercest
critics of the Iraq war have never stepped foot in Iraq. Some professors say
they speak Arabic and volunteer informed comment, but they have yet to visit
the country about which they claim expertise (Iraq Air flies several times a
day to Baghdad from Amman, Dubai, and Istanbul). Many congressmen and
think-tank scholars have visited Baghdad or various forward-operating bases
at the invitation of the State Department or Pentagon, but they have not
escaped the strict U.S. security parameters. Lunch in the embassy cafeteria
gives little more insight into the situation in Iraq than would lunch in
Peoria. Few embassy officials escape the Green Zone or suffocating convoys.
Their PowerPoints seldom correlate to reality, not by design, but rather
because the treatment is too sterile and unchecked by personal interaction
with ordinary Iraqis. 

A Complex Picture

Those who have experience beyond the bubble in Iraq paint a very different
picture. It is not always rosy. Professors Fouad Ajami and Eliot Cohen, both
of Johns Hopkins University, have made critiques that not everyone in the
Bush administration or the foreign-policy elite wants to hear. Kanan Makiya
is often acerbic in his criticism — which is exactly why his input is so
valuable. 

Wherever they stand on the political spectrum, the nuance of debate among
those with experience in Iraq stands apart from those who may cloak
themselves with self-righteousness, but have unrelated political axes to
grind. 

Iraq is a complex country, difficult to crystallize in a simple poll. But
this is exactly what too many news organizations seek to do. On October 24,
2005, for example, the Guardian reported a new poll finding that 82 percent
of Iraqis were "strongly opposed" to the presence of foreign troops in their
country. Critics of the war seized on the poll to demand immediate
withdrawal. 

True: Polls do not lie. Iraqis dislike occupation. They resent stopping on
busy highways for slow-moving military convoys. They juxtapose the Green
Zone's generators with their own worsening electricity supply. They fail to
understand why U.S. diplomats who seldom leave their quarters must block off
the center of their city rather than build their cantonment on its
outskirts. They are annoyed by helicopters hovering over their villages. But
such annoyance with occupation does not translate into demands for immediate
withdrawal. 

Polls in mature democracies like the United States are difficult enough to
conduct and get right. The task is far more formidable in post-autocratic
societies. When pollsters instead ask Iraqis to prioritize their top-20
concerns, withdrawal of Coalition troops usually ranks near the bottom of
the list. Restoring electricity, combating corruption, and maintaining
security are consistently at the top priorities. 

Iraqis are struggling to reconstruct their country and their lives, but they
are not desperate. Unemployment is high — the Iraqi government estimates it
to be 28 percent nationwide. Underemployment is higher. But the war did not
create Iraq's unemployment. Nor, for that matter, is U.S. bombing
responsible for decrepit schools, potholed streets, and poor infrastructure
shown so often on network and satellite-news channels. Forensic auditors who
reconstructed Iraq's prewar budget were astounded by Saddam Hussein's
disdain for his country. In fiscal year 2002, for example, the Iraqi
government spent only $5 million total on the physical plant of school
buildings. Saddam's palaces, though, had elaborate fountains, Italian
marble, and gold-plated inscriptions. This does not mean U.S. officials are
without blame. Neither the Coalition Provisional Authority nor the United
States Agency for International Development has much to show for billions of
dollars spent on grandiose projects.

New Economic Life

Nevertheless, Iraq's economy is booming. Many Iraqis — denied employment
under Saddam Hussein's regime for reasons of ethnicity, sectarian identity,
or for refusal to join the Baath party, now have jobs. Iraqis' own private
investment, aided with capital remitted from family members abroad, has
enabled the private sector to boom. Banks, restaurants, and furniture stores
occupy what just last year were empty lots or abandoned storefronts. In
August 2005, new business registrations have topped 30,000; this figure does
not include the number of start-ups which still ignore Iraqi-registration
rules. 

Ordinary Iraqis are financially better off now than they were at any time in
the past two decades. According to World Bank and International Monetary
Fund estimates, per capita income has doubled since 2003. Iraq's per capita
gross domestic product is today almost twice that of Yemen and nearing that
of Egypt and Syria, hardly a sign of failure in a country in which, just
three years ago, antiwar groups insisted children were starving en masse.
Statistics aside, the Iraqi economic boom is apparent to anyone who visits
an Iraqi market. Not only are appliances and luxuries in the stores, but
customers are actually purchasing them. 

Iraqis today employ technologies that were nonexistent or off-limits to all
but the Baathist elite just three years ago. As of September 2005, there
were more than 3.5 million cell-phone subscribers in Iraq, for example.
Under the Baath party, there was no cell-phone service, and possession of
satellite phones was a capital offense. Internet cafés dot not only Baghdad
thoroughfares, but also dusty back streets in provincial towns. When I
visited the (restored) marshlands of southern Iraq, I checked my e-mail and
sent dispatches from internet cafes not only in the Maysan provincial
capital of al-Amarah and the Dhi Qar provincial capital of Nasiriyah, but
also in small, dusty towns like Islah, a Dawa stronghold on the edge of the
marshes. 

Daily reports of violence suggest Iraq is tearing apart at the seams. Ethnic
strife remains a possibility, but it need not happen. While the Bush
administration has been inept at making its case, the White House has little
for which to apologize. Iraqis debate. They tolerate dissent. Politicians
hash out compromise. The constitution may not be ideal, but it is fair.
Meanwhile, tens of millions of Saudis, Syrians, Iranians, Tunisians, and
Egyptians still struggle under dictatorships. They lack a free press. While
self-described liberal bloggers pillory the White House, they ignore the
plight of Lotfi Hajji, president of the Tunisian Syndicate of Journalists;
Ayachi Hammami, secretary general of the Tunis Section of the Tunisian
League for Human Rights; or Nejib Chebbi, secretary general of the
Progressive Democratic party, all of whom are conducting a hunger strike in
Tunisia to win the same press freedoms now enjoyed by 25 million Iraqis.
Libyan dissident Fathi el-Jahmi continues to rot in prison for demanding
that Libyan strongman Muammar Qaddafi allow contested, multiparty elections.
If only Arianna Huffington, Juan Cole, The Nation, or the New York Times
would focus some of their attention on these dissidents' plights, the world
might be a better place.

Democracy and reconstruction are processes. Progress is slow, but to those
who know Iraq, it is there. Iraqis criticize certain Washington decisions
and embassy strategy. Few, though, see any merits in abandonment.

In both Washington and Baghdad, administrations will come and go. Scandals
will happen. Prosecutors will demand accountability. Courts will rule. The
innocent get exonerated, and the guilty pay a price. In no case, though,
should Iraq be treated a template for cynical politics. Twenty-five million
Iraqis deserve better. So do U.S. servicemen taking extraordinary risks,
more than 2,000 making the ultimate sacrifice, not only for Iraq's freedom
and liberty, but also U.S. national security. For those to whom
inside-the-Beltway games are paramount, some serious soul searching is in
order. 

Michael Rubin, resident scholar at the American Enterprise Institute, is
editor of The Middle East Quarterly. He has spent 20 months in Iraq, all but
three months outside the U.S. security zone.



[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]



------------------------ Yahoo! Groups Sponsor --------------------~--> 
Get fast access to your favorite Yahoo! Groups. Make Yahoo! your home page
http://us.click.yahoo.com/dpRU5A/wUILAA/yQLSAA/TySplB/TM
--------------------------------------------------------------------~-> 

--------------------------
Want to discuss this topic?  Head on over to our discussion list, [EMAIL 
PROTECTED]
--------------------------
Brooks Isoldi, editor
[EMAIL PROTECTED]

http://www.intellnet.org

  Post message: [email protected]
  Subscribe:    [EMAIL PROTECTED]
  Unsubscribe:  [EMAIL PROTECTED]


*** FAIR USE NOTICE. This message contains copyrighted material whose use has 
not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. OSINT, as a part of 
The Intelligence Network, is making it available without profit to OSINT 
YahooGroups members who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the 
included information in their efforts to advance the understanding of 
intelligence and law enforcement organizations, their activities, methods, 
techniques, human rights, civil liberties, social justice and other 
intelligence related issues, for non-profit research and educational purposes 
only. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of the copyrighted material 
as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use 
this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' 
you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.
For more information go to:
http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtml 
Yahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
    [EMAIL PROTECTED]

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
    http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/
 


Reply via email to