"This is an explicit acknowledgement that the decision in Sealed Case
had nothing whatsoever to do with the issue of whether the president
has the inherent authority to act outside of FISA. It's also a tacit
acknowledgement that no one involved the case even knew about the NSA
program. Yet in the responses to the Republican questions, the DOJ
describes this case as the "definitive pronouncement" on the issue of
inherent authority. They devote literally pages to discussion of a
case which they acknowledge has nothing to do with the legal questions
raised by the NSA program and was argued and decided by people who had
no idea that FISA was being circumvented. Indeed, the core holding of
Sealed Case was that FISA is constitutional ("We, therefore, believe
firmly, applying the balancing test drawn from Keith, that FISA as
amended is constitutional because the surveillances it authorizes are
reasonable.")"


DOJ can't keep its story straight on warrantless spying.  New strict
constructionist SC judges might rule spying illegal on stare decisis
grounds.

David Bier

http://glenngreenwald.blogspot.com/2006/03/dojs-responses-to-congress-nsa-scandal.html

Sunday, March 26, 2006

DoJ's Responses to Congress: The NSA Scandal in Microcosm


As Glenn highlighted yesterday, the Bush administration has released 
(http://glenngreenwald.blogspot.com/2006/03/administration-tells-congress-again-we.html)
written responses to questions about the NSA program submitted to the
administration by the Republicans and Democrats on the House Judiciary
Committee. If you haven't already read through these documents, I
highly recommend it. Both the questions themselves and the
administration's responses to them perfectly encapsulate everything
that is so disturbing and frustrating about this scandal.
(http://rawprint.com/pdfs/HJCrawstory1.pdf)
(http://rawprint.com/pdfs/HJCrawstory2.pdf)

The questions submitted by the Democrats are very simple,
straight-forward legal and factual questions, usually no more than one
line long. They are the obvious questions that anyone interested in
understanding this issue (and its legal implications) would ask. The
administration's "answers" to these questions are uniformly
non-responsive and, for the most part, simply repeat boilerplate
language about the classified and sensitive nature of the program.
Even purely legal questions are completely dodged. It takes the DOJ
only 15 pages to respond to all 45 of the questions submitted by the
House Democrats.

The questions submitted by the Republicans, however, are almost all
long, convoluted, argumentative questions, many of which misstate key
legal concepts. They are, for the most part, leading questions which
assume away the most important distinctions in the law. The Republican
questions are clearly not intended to augment anyone's understanding
of the program, but rather to establish a legal and political defense
for the administration. In stark contrast to the Democratic questions,
the administration's responses to the Republican questions are
generally fulsome and detailed (albeit highly misleading). It takes
the DOJ a full 40 pages to respond to the 51 Republican questions.

The administration's responses to the Democratic questions,
particularly when compared side-by-side to its responses to the
Republican questions, are as blatant an example as I've ever seen of
partisan stonewalling. For instance, consider the response to this
important question submitted by the Democrats:


    25. What is the limiting principle of the President's claimed
inherent authority as commander-in-chief? For example, does this
interpretation of the law authorize the opening of first-class mail of
U.S. citizens under the DOJ's interpretation, and if not, why not?


The DOJ response merely repeats the administration's boilerplate
description of the NSA program and then states: "Whether the
President's authority under the Constitution would permit the
interception of mail would require a different legal analysis."

The next Democratic question asks:


    26. Under the Administration's legal interpretation, does the
President have the authority to wiretap Americans' domestic calls and
emails under his inherent constitutional power and the AUMF, if he
feels it involves al Qaeda activity?


The DOJ response merely points out that NSA program is much narrower
than programs authorized by President's Wilson and Roosevelt and ends
by noting: "Interceptions of the contents of domestic communications
would present a different legal question."

Is it even possible to craft a less responsive answer to a legitimate
and important legal question? The entire point of the question is that
there does not appear to be any relevant legal distinction between
intercepting calls to which one party is a U.S. citizen and calls
where both are; the Democrats want to know--for obvious reasons--why
the Bush administration's legal reasoning doesn't extend to purely
domestic calls. In response they are told merely that interception of
domestic communications "would present a different legal question."

That's an insulting and totally unacceptable response to an incredibly
important (and purely legal) question. There is simply no excuse for
this behavior in our system of government. Congress has a right to
have questions like this answered, particularly when the DOJ, at the
same time, offers long-winded responses to Republican questions that
are nowhere near as fundamental or important.

Indeed, the responses to the Democratic questions at times contradict
the responses to the Republican questions. Throughout the Republican
responses, the DOJ plays up the importance of the line of dicta in In
re Sealed Case, the 2002 decision by the FISA court of review. Indeed
the administration's entire legal position hinges on that line; it's
the only case they cite in response to numerous questions. At one
point in the Republican response--citing Sealed Case--the DOJ states
that "the President was entitled to rely on the definitive
pronouncement of the specialized court that Congress created to
address precisely these matters." In other words, In re Sealed Case,
offers the "definitive pronouncement" on the issue of whether the
President has the inherent authority to conduct warrantless
surveillance, regardless of what FISA says.

This is, of course, total rubbish, something the DOJ all but
acknowledges in its responses to the Democratic questions. Given the
administration's clear reliance on this particular line of dicta in
Sealed Case, the House Democrats asked an obvious question:


    36. Was any judge on the FISA court of review informed of the NSA
program as part of the briefing of the 2002 appellate case, In re
Sealed Case? Were any of the lawyers on that case read into the
program? How many?


Here's the administration's response:


    As we noted above, the identity of individuals who have been
briefed into the Terrorist Surveillance Program is generally
classified. We note, however, that In re Sealed Case, 310 F.3d 717
(For. Int. Surv. Ct. Rev. 2002), involved whether the FISA Court had
statutory or constitutional authority to place restrictions on
interaction of criminal prosecutions and foreign intelligence
investigators as a condition for granting surveillance orders. The
Terrorist Surveillance Program would not have been relevant to the
question before the court in that case (emphasis added).


This is an explicit acknowledgement that the decision in Sealed Case
had nothing whatsoever to do with the issue of whether the president
has the inherent authority to act outside of FISA. It's also a tacit
acknowledgement that no one involved the case even knew about the NSA
program. Yet in the responses to the Republican questions, the DOJ
describes this case as the "definitive pronouncement" on the issue of
inherent authority. They devote literally pages to discussion of a
case which they acknowledge has nothing to do with the legal questions
raised by the NSA program and was argued and decided by people who had
no idea that FISA was being circumvented. Indeed, the core holding of
Sealed Case was that FISA is constitutional ("We, therefore, believe
firmly, applying the balancing test drawn from Keith, that FISA as
amended is constitutional because the surveillances it authorizes are
reasonable.")

As an attorney, I can't even express to you how bewildering and
pathetic it is to see the government repeatedly citing as their sole
authority for a legal proposition--that the president's power to
conduct warrantless surveillance survives FISA--a case that so
obviously does not stand for that proposition.

The questions asked the House Republicans and Democrats and the
answers provided by the DOJ are a perfect microcosm of this scandal.
One side asks simple, obvious questions that cry out for answers. The
administration responds by stonewalling. The other side asks silly,
misleading questions, and the administration responds with long,
convoluted and equally misleading answers that fail to address all the
most obvious objections and legal distinctions. And when presented
with these insulting and incomplete responses, neither side does much
of anything about it, and the media pays no attention. Wash. Rinse.
Repeat.

posted by Glenn Greenwald | 4:47 PM


----

Posted by David Bier, CADRE Intel Mgr
http://groups.google.com/group/publicintel

“Most men would rather believe than know” (Ben Franklin)
Cargo Security:
http://msnbcmedia.msn.com/j/msnbc/Sections/Newsweek/Components/Photos/Mag/060306_Issue/060225_perspcartoon_wide.hlarge.jpg
Notes for Converts:
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/jane-smiley/notes-for-converts_b_17662.html






--------------------------
Want to discuss this topic?  Head on over to our discussion list, [EMAIL 
PROTECTED]
--------------------------
Brooks Isoldi, editor
[EMAIL PROTECTED]

http://www.intellnet.org

  Post message: [email protected]
  Subscribe:    [EMAIL PROTECTED]
  Unsubscribe:  [EMAIL PROTECTED]


*** FAIR USE NOTICE. This message contains copyrighted material whose use has 
not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. OSINT, as a part of 
The Intelligence Network, is making it available without profit to OSINT 
YahooGroups members who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the 
included information in their efforts to advance the understanding of 
intelligence and law enforcement organizations, their activities, methods, 
techniques, human rights, civil liberties, social justice and other 
intelligence related issues, for non-profit research and educational purposes 
only. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of the copyrighted material 
as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use 
this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' 
you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.
For more information go to:
http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtml 
Yahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
    [EMAIL PROTECTED]

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
    http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/
 



Reply via email to