Benedict's attitude toward Islam has, regrettably, been more reserved. In
meetings he has pressed Muslim leaders to fight against terrorism and to
support 'reciprocity,' meaning that Muslim countries should grant the same
religious freedom to Christians which traditionally Christian countries
grant to Muslims. The Pope stunned those familiar with Catholic-Muslim
relations when he removed the highly respected Archbishop Michael Fitzgerald
from his post as president of the Pontifical Council for Inter-Religious
Dialogue. Analysts suggest that the Pope saw Fitzgerald as 'too soft' on
Islam, failing to press Muslim countries on respect for religious freedom. 
 
http://www.tikkun.org/magazine/tik0607/beier
 
  

In early March 2006,  <http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pope_Benedict_XVI> Pope
Benedict XVI puzzled the world by quietly dropping one of his nine titles,
"Patriarch of the West," held by popes since 642. Dropping the
patriarch-title, traditionally reserved for Eastern Christian leaders, was
meant to "be helpful for ecumenical dialogue," explained the Pope, whose
"primary commitment" is unity with all Christian churches. But the gesture
is more ambiguous than that. It also reasserts the Pope's claim to authority
over the entire church, East and West. The true test for Benedict's openness
to genuine ecumenical dialogue depends on whether he is willing to put the
most valuable of his eight remaining titles on the table: Supreme Pontiff of
the Universal Church-something he is least likely to do.

Benedict XVI's first year record is mixed. Although unity, peace, and love
have been key words of his papacy, his actions or inactions are at times at
odds with such rhetoric. While his fashionable wardrobe has received much
attention-flashy redshoes by Prada, hip sunglasses by Gucci, elaborately
imperial gowns by Gamarelli, and, most recently, a stylish white 2GB iPod
Nano-the jury is still out on how open-minded the former top guardian of the
Church's tradition really is. The central question for assessing Benedict's
first year may well be whether his obvious changes in style from rigid moral
watchdog to diplomatic, meeting-happy uberfather are more than merely a
Pope's new clothes. 

Has Benedict XVI truly had a change of heart? Or do these superficial
changes in style conceal the same absolutistic claims to truth and power
which guided him throughout his tenure as the Church's top watchdog? To
explore that question, let us look at four areas that the Pope himself has
highlighted: issues of peace and justice; inter-religious dialogue; moral
values and the fight for Europe; and carrot-and-stick power struggles within
the Church.

On peace and justice issues, Benedict XVI has, for the most part, continued
his predecessor's stance. He frequently speaks out against violence,
terrorism, poverty, consumerism, and economic injustice. Yet his lack of
direct criticism of the U.S.-led invasion of Iraq stands in stark contrast
to John Paul II's unequivocal opposition to the war. As World War II taught
us, a Pope's calls for peace and justice are of little or, worse, negative
consequence, unless they call particular countries or leaders to responsible
action.

In the area of inter-religious dialogue, Benedict XVI has focused
particularly on relations with Jewish and Muslim leaders. Countering initial
fears that a German Pope who once served in the Hitler Youth might harbor
subtle anti-Semitic views, Benedict XVI recently paid a historical visit to
Auschwitz. Visits to synagogues in Cologne and Rome and several meetings
with Jewish leaders helped repair initial tensions with Israel after the
Pope deliberately omitted from a July 2005 statement against terrorism any
mention of a suicide attack inside Israel while, however, referring to
attacks in Britain, Iraq, Egypt, and Turkey. A visit to Israel might come as
early as 2007. 

Benedict's attitude toward Islam has, regrettably, been more reserved. In
meetings he has pressed Muslim leaders to fight against terrorism and to
support 'reciprocity,' meaning that Muslim countries should grant the same
religious freedom to Christians which traditionally Christian countries
grant to Muslims. The Pope stunned those familiar with Catholic-Muslim
relations when he removed the highly respected Archbishop Michael Fitzgerald
from his post as president of the Pontifical Council for Inter-Religious
Dialogue. Analysts suggest that the Pope saw Fitzgerald as 'too soft' on
Islam, failing to press Muslim countries on respect for religious freedom. 

Indicative of tensions between Benedict XVI and the Muslim world was the
unusual delay by one year of a papal visit to Turkey. It had originally been
planned for the fall of 2005 in response to an invitation by Patriarch
Bartholomew I, head of the world's 200 million Orthodox Christians. The
Turkish government refused to open its doors so soon to the new Pope, who,
as Cardinal Ratzinger, had angered Turkey in 2004 by remarking in the French
newspaper Le Figaro that the European Union should keep its doors closed to
Turkey, since "Europe is a cultural continent, not a geographical one." 

As Pope, he has reiterated that Europe's unity is based on its
"indispensable Christian roots." To skeptics, Pope Benedict's argument for
cultural purity is dangerously reminiscent of the Nazi Christian argument
that Jews had no place in a Christian country such as Germany. While
Benedict's intentions for dialogue with non-Christian religions are no doubt
sincere, his fight against the political influence of non-Christian cultures
in Europe may inadvertently fan the flames of discrimination based on
religious creed. 

The intermezzo with Turkey expresses a key feature of Benedict XVI: his
Eurocentrism. The Pope's focus on Europe does not imply that he ignores
other parts of the world, as his plan for a special bishop's synod in Africa
clearly indicates. Much of his fight against secularism in Europe applies
similarly to America, although Benedict XVI has commented surprisingly
little on the U.S. situation. He firmly believes that the moral values of
Christian Europe are the safeguards of civilization around the globe. The
Holy Father considers Europe his most troubled child and laments that it has
fallen ill with secular values. His antidote: to re-evangelize Europe in the
spirit of St. Benedict, the patron saint of Europe, with whom he explicitly
identifies.

The Pope has reason to be concerned. The Church is fighting a losing battle
for control over hot-button issues such as same-sex marriage, birth control,
abortion, divorce, and religious instruction in schools. Just two days after
he was elected Pope, Spain's parliament approved a same-sex marriage bill,
unimaginable only a few years ago in this heavily Catholic country. Similar
bills have been passed or introduced in Britain, Belgium, the Netherlands,
and Canada. Since taking office, Benedict XVI has become increasingly
aggressive in his support for conservative political leaders who could
reverse such bills. He has met twice with Spanish opposition leaders working
to overturn the sweeping liberal reforms of the Socialist Zapatero
government. In Italy he stepped into politics to prevent the repeal of key
provisions of Europe's most restrictive law on medically-assisted fertility,
and, most recently, to launch a staunch attack against same-sex marriage and
abortion rights during Italy's elections.

Of even greater concern to the Pope is the fact that Europeans are leaving
the Church in droves. In Germany alone, his home country, the Church has
lost a record number of more than two million disaffected members, or nearly
10 percent, since 1990. The annual loss of members more than doubled when
Catholic bishops, at the behest of a "deeply worried" Cardinal Ratzinger,
began a drawn-out two year public controversy with the Pope's most potent
challenger in Europe today: the German dissident theologian and bestselling
author  <http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eugen_Drewermann> Eugen Drewermann.
Hailed by Time magazine as a new Martin Luther, Drewermann, who also works
as a psychotherapist with the clergy, has urged the Vatican in more than
seventy books to end the tremendous psychological and spiritual suffering
inflicted on Catholics by the merciless rigidity of traditional teachings on
abortion, divorce, homosexuality, and celibacy. Drewermann's 1989
international bestseller on clergy mentality, The Cleric, exposed more than
a decade before the U.S. sex abuse scandal the devastating effects of the
Church's traditional clergy ideal. As a result, the Church stripped him in
1991 and 1992 both of his license to teach Catholic theology and of his
duties as a priest, imposing one of the most severe punishment meted out to
any priest-theologian in the twentieth century. 

Partly in response to Drewermann's strong resonance with the European
public, the 79-year-old Pope has tried to reinvent himself within the Church
by emphasizing God's love rather than the Church's rules. He did so at his
first World Youth Day in Germany. He did so, too, in his first encyclical,
Deus Caritas Est, which surprised with its positive references to erotic
love, albeit clearly limited to heterosexual marriages. Another hopeful sign
came in September when Benedict amazed the world by granting a request for a
private kaffeeklatsch to one of his best-known critics, the Swiss theologian
Hans Kung-although Benedict XVI stressed he had no intention of
rehabilitating Kung's theology as officially Catholic. During the March
consistory, in which he announced fifteen new Cardinals, among them Boston's
Sean O'Malley and Hong Kong's Joseph Zen, known for his efforts for
religious freedom in China, he made room for an unusually open debate among
Church leaders. 

While the Pope's words of love and openness are noble, they stand in glaring
contrast to several Vatican actions taken under his watch. In an alarming
November 2005 document, Benedict banned all gay men from seminaries and from
ordination, calling gays emotionally immature and homosexuality "objectively
disordered." American Catholics were equally put on alert when the
well-respected editor of the Catholic magazine America, Fr. Thomas Reese,
was forced to resign for allegedly permitting too much open discussion in a
Catholic publication. Then there was Benedict's questionable choice of his
own successor to the post of Prefect of the Congregation for the Doctrine of
Faith, the conservative American Cardinal Levada, who is under intense
criticism from victims of clergy sexual abuse for allegedly attempting to
cover up abuse.

On the whole, Benedict has certainly fulfilled requirements of diplomatic
sensitivity and expressed desire for peace among the world's religions and
nations. But he has shown ambiguous signs about his willingness to embrace a
diversity of viewpoints within the Church. He still has ways to go to
convince the world that trading in his absolutistic Cardinal's hat for the
Pope's new clothes signifies substantial changes of heart. He could begin,
for instance, by retracting the substance of his extremely inflammatory 2000
statement made in Dominus Jesus that labeled all other faiths as "gravely
deficient." Or, by inviting progressive voices such as Eugen Drewermann,
Joan Chittester, Matthew Fox, Hans Kung, and Leonardo Boff, to a truly open
dialogue. Or, by finally admitting that the Church as an institution-rather
than mere individual Catholics-is morally guilty for closing its eyes to the
Holocaust which literally happened at its doorsteps. Who would be more
qualified to express such a sincere apology than a German Pope?!




[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]



--------------------------
Want to discuss this topic?  Head on over to our discussion list, [EMAIL 
PROTECTED]
--------------------------
Brooks Isoldi, editor
[EMAIL PROTECTED]

http://www.intellnet.org

  Post message: [email protected]
  Subscribe:    [EMAIL PROTECTED]
  Unsubscribe:  [EMAIL PROTECTED]


*** FAIR USE NOTICE. This message contains copyrighted material whose use has 
not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. OSINT, as a part of 
The Intelligence Network, is making it available without profit to OSINT 
YahooGroups members who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the 
included information in their efforts to advance the understanding of 
intelligence and law enforcement organizations, their activities, methods, 
techniques, human rights, civil liberties, social justice and other 
intelligence related issues, for non-profit research and educational purposes 
only. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of the copyrighted material 
as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use 
this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' 
you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.
For more information go to:
http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtml 
Yahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
    [EMAIL PROTECTED]

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
    http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/
 


Reply via email to