<http://www.mercurynews.com/mld/mercurynews/news/politics/15015908.htm>
http://www.mercurynews.com/mld/mercurynews/news/politics/15015908.htm
 

Bush allows terror detainees some rights under Geneva Convention


By Carol Rosenberg and Margaret Talev

McClatchy Newspapers

(MCT)

WASHINGTON - In a major reversal of a keystone policy in its war on
terrorism, the Bush administration announced Tuesday that all detainees in
U.S. military custody, including those at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba, are entitled
to Geneva Convention protections that prohibit humiliating treatment and
torture.

The change reflects the Pentagon's response to the Supreme Court's 5-3
decision last month that struck down the administration's makeshift formula
for military tribunals at Guantanamo, declaring their procedures
unconstitutional and a violation of Geneva Convention obligations.

The two-page Pentagon memo repudiates a core element of the legal foundation
of President Bush's approach to dealing with terrorism. Bush and his legal
advisers initially had said the Geneva Conventions didn't apply to the war
on terrorism because it was a new type of conflict that demanded more
aggressive action.

In a 2002 memo, then-White House counsel Alberto Gonzales told Bush that
this nontraditional war "renders obsolete Geneva's strict limitations on
questioning of enemy prisoners and renders quaint some of its provisions."

Vice President Dick Cheney and White House spokesmen made clear in many
public statements since 2002 that they didn't think that terrorism suspects
deserved the rights that the Geneva Conventions granted to enemy soldiers.
At the same time, Bush has said repeatedly that his administration is
committed to complying with the Geneva Conventions, but he's also reserved
the right to waive them if he sees fit as commander in chief.

The new Pentagon memo doesn't change captives' status as enemy combatants -
not prisoners of war - nor does it suggest that practices will change at
Guantanamo, the remote interrogation and detention outpost at a U.S. naval
base in southeast Cuba where commanders defend the treatment of its 450
captives as humane.

In addition, the memo doesn't bind the CIA in its treatment of detainees,
because the CIA isn't part of the Defense Department. The CIA reportedly
operates a network of secret prisons around the world for terrorism
suspects, and has handed over others to countries that are accused of using
torture.

Senate Democratic leader Harry Reid, D-Nev., was one who suggested that the
Pentagon policy didn't cover CIA activities, but said "that will have to be
dealt with at a different time."

The new memo, signed by Deputy Defense Secretary Gordon England, declared
that Article 3 of the Geneva Conventions "applies as a matter of law to the
conflict with al Qaeda." His memo doesn't, however, embrace all the terms of
the Geneva Conventions.

Article 3 of the international standards prohibits "outrages upon personal
dignity, in particular humiliating and degrading treatment."

The administration's policy shift repudiates a six-week burst of early
Guantanamo practices, which FBI agents described in internal e-mails as
involving chaining captives for so long that they urinated and defecated on
themselves. Military guards or interrogators also allegedly tethered
captives to dog leashes, wrapped them in Israeli flags and exposed them to
extremes of hot, cold and blasting music to break their resistance and spill
secrets.

The Pentagon estimated Tuesday that it had about 14,000 captives in U.S.
military custody: 13,000 in Iraq, 550 in Afghanistan and 450 at Guantanamo.

Critics hailed the developments as a clear-cut commitment to international
treaty obligations.

"After more than four years of lawlessness, the Defense Department took a
big first step toward complying with federal law," a statement from the
American Civil Liberties Union said.

The Pentagon announced the policy change Tuesday as Senate Judiciary
Committee Chairman Arlen Specter, R-Pa., convened the first of three
congressional hearings this week on how to try war-on-terrorism captives as
alleged war criminals without relying on hearsay evidence and possible
secret, coercive interrogations.

Vermont Sen. Patrick Leahy, the senior Democrat on the committee, accused
the White House of adopting policies that "violated fundamental American
values, damaged our international reputation and delayed and weakened
prosecution of the war on terror."

"I find it hard to fathom that this administration is so incompetent that it
needs kangaroo court procedures to convince a tribunal of United States
military officers that the `worst of the worst' imprisoned at Guantanamo Bay
should be held accountable," Leahy said.

In its 5-3 decision last month in Hamdan v. Rumsfeld, the Supreme Court
invited Congress to write a law governing military trials of detainees in
the war on terrorism. At issue is how to shape a court that protects
classified information, allows the government to offer a robust prosecution
and permits alleged war criminals to confront their accusers within a
framework of law.

Witnesses offered contrasting recommendations Tuesday.

At one extreme, former Solicitor General Theodore Olson, whose wife was
killed in the Sept. 11 terrorist attacks, urged Congress to nullify several
key Supreme Court decisions that recognized detainees' rights, such as
civilian attorneys and recourse to U.S. courts. He also warned that a war
court that honors constitutional protections would have a chilling effect on
the battlefield.

"Do you have to knock and announce and wait for a bomb to go off?" said
Olson, arguing that terrorists who "want to destroy the Constitution" don't
get Bill of Rights protections.

On the other extreme, Yale Law School Dean Harold Hongju Koh, sitting beside
Olson, urged Congress to recognize the rights of suspected terrorists not
because they'd do the same for captured U.S. soldiers, but for the sake of
American society.

Even members of organizations that never signed the Geneva Conventions are
entitled to "minimal humane treatment," Koh said, because "it's about what
we are and what we do. . . . Whales have not signed the Whaling Convention.
It's about how we treat them."

In between, Sen. Lindsey Graham, R-S.C., warned administration attorneys
that any new war court would be modeled after the Pentagon's Uniform Code of
Military Justice - a legal system parallel to civilian courts - and would
start with the assumption that terrorism suspects got the same rights as
U.S. soldiers who were facing military justice, before stripping away
certain rights on a case-by-case justification.

"We can get a product that will pass court muster and the nation can be
proud of. If you fight that it's going to be a long hot summer," Graham, an
Air Force Reserve lawyer, told Defense and Justice Department attorneys, who
advocated that Congress legislate the system that the Supreme Court ruled
unconstitutional last month.

When Gonzales, who's now attorney general, wrote his 2002 legal memo waiving
the Geneva Conventions as "quaint," he assured Bush that he was on solid
legal ground, but his argument provoked intense debate within the
administration.

Then-Secretary of State Colin Powell argued that claiming an exemption from
the Geneva Conventions would "reverse over a century of U.S. policy" and
increase the risk that captured American troops would be abused.

Powell also warned, correctly as it turned out, that Bush's approach would
result in "a negative international reaction" that would undermine allied
support and hinder cooperation on other issues.

The White House announced its position on the Geneva protections on May 7,
2003, asserting that al-Qaida terrorists had no claim to international
protections.

"The war on terrorism is a war not envisioned when the Geneva Convention was
signed in 1949," then-White House spokesman Ari Fleischer said at the time.

Cheney offered a similar rationale a year later.

"If you've got somebody who is wearing civilian clothes, killing civilians,
not abiding by the laws of the war, then you've got a set of circumstances
in which you've got unlawful combatants. And those people do not need to be
treated under the Geneva Convention," Cheney told Fox News. "A lot of the
folks down in Guantanamo fall into that category."

In claiming an exemption from the international law on prisoners' rights,
Bush said the United States nevertheless would adhere to the Geneva
Conventions' standards as a matter of policy. The distinction is subtle, but
critics said it signaled interrogators that they could push the limits of
acceptable behavior when dealing with terrorism suspects.

"I think one of the things they are concerned about is war crimes," said
John Hutson, the dean of the Franklin Pierce Law Center in Concord, N.H.,
and a former Navy judge advocate general. "It's harder to be prosecuted for
violating a policy than it is for violating a law."

Raymond M. Brown, a visiting professor at the Seton Hall University School
of Law in New Jersey and an expert on international criminal tribunals,
called Tuesday's developments "a big story. . . . It clearly marks a
departure because the attorney general wrote the famous memo saying the
Geneva Convention was obsolete, in addition to which the Defense Department
has taken the position that it isn't bound by it. The signing statement of
the president on the McCain amendment says in his view the executive branch
believes it has the right to define torture unilaterally."

When Bush signed a statute into law last year sponsored by Sen. John McCain,
R-Ariz., that outlawed torture of detainees, the president attached a
statement to it declaring that he reserved the right to ignore its
restrictions if he felt it necessary as commander in chief.

Brown said it would be disingenuous for the administration to suggest that
it already was complying with the Geneva Conventions. "The only reason
they're changing is because of Hamdan. Hamdan gives them no choice. I'd
argue it gives them no choice even if Congress says they have a choice, but
there will be debate."



[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]



--------------------------
Want to discuss this topic?  Head on over to our discussion list, [EMAIL 
PROTECTED]
--------------------------
Brooks Isoldi, editor
[EMAIL PROTECTED]

http://www.intellnet.org

  Post message: [email protected]
  Subscribe:    [EMAIL PROTECTED]
  Unsubscribe:  [EMAIL PROTECTED]


*** FAIR USE NOTICE. This message contains copyrighted material whose use has 
not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. OSINT, as a part of 
The Intelligence Network, is making it available without profit to OSINT 
YahooGroups members who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the 
included information in their efforts to advance the understanding of 
intelligence and law enforcement organizations, their activities, methods, 
techniques, human rights, civil liberties, social justice and other 
intelligence related issues, for non-profit research and educational purposes 
only. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of the copyrighted material 
as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use 
this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' 
you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.
For more information go to:
http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtml 
Yahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
    [EMAIL PROTECTED]

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
    http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/
 



Reply via email to