http://www.boston.com/news/globe/editorial_opinion/oped/articles/2006/08/07/
is_the_west_too_civil_in_war/
Is the West too civil in war?  

   
  Cathy Young The Boston Globe
  Published: August 10, 2006
 
 
BOSTON As war continues to rage in Iraq and Lebanon, appalling pictures of
human suffering and death fill our front pages and television screens.
 
Some people who have previously supported the Bush administration's foreign
policy and who are generally pro-Israel are concluding that the human costs
of the war on terror as currently conducted - both in terms of direct
casualties and human rights abuses - are unacceptably high. Meanwhile,
others are making the startling argument that we Americans may have become
too soft for our own good when it comes to the human costs of war.
 
A recent column by John Podhoretz in the New York Post opens with this
inquiry:
 
"What if liberal democracies have now evolved to a point where they can no
longer wage war effectively because they have achieved a level of
humanitarian concern for others that dwarfs any really cold-eyed pursuit of
their own national interests?"
 
Podhoretz goes on to ask if Britain and the United States could have won
World War II if they "did not have it in them to firebomb Dresden and nuke
Hiroshima and Nagasaki," inflicting massive civilian casualties, and he ends
with this reflection: "Can it be that the moral greatness of our
civilization - its astonishing focus on the value of the individual above
all - is endangering the future of our civilization as well?"
 
In all honesty, the question has occurred to me, too. What if Americans
during World War II had been confronted daily both with reports of American
casualties and with images of dead and wounded German civilians, including
children and old people? What if public opinion had been as troubled by both
American and German casualties as we are by American and Iraqi (or Lebanese)
casualties today? Would there still be a free world to speak of?
 
Yet it is all too easy to move from pondering a tragic paradox to
considering acts from which even the most hawkish among us would recoil in
horror. Thus, Podhoretz inquires: "What if the tactical mistake we made in
Iraq was that we didn't kill enough Sunnis in the early going to intimidate
them ... ? Wasn't the survival of Sunni men between the ages of 15 and 35
the reason there was an insurgency and the basic cause of the sectarian
violence now?"
 
Of course, the targeted slaughter of a population group - known as genocide
- would go far beyond anything done by the Allies in World War II. Indeed,
in a blogpost on the Web site of National Review magazine, Podhoretz reaches
for comparison to the tactics of Saddam Hussein in Iraq and Hafez al-Assad
in Syria, who quelled uprisings by wiping out thousands. He also stresses
that he is not advocating such measures: "I am not upset - far from it -
that they are closed off to us." He simply thinks that we should understand
that our "more civilized approach might represent a form of self-shackling"
against a ruthless enemy.
 
But such a discussion is a slippery slope. Where one person sees a need to
acknowledge our dilemma, others will argue for cutting the Gordian knot by
abandoning some of our scruples. This has already happened, to some extent,
in the discussion of torture. And some of Podhoretz's colleagues at National
Review have been quite outspoken about thinking the unthinkable. In June,
one of the magazine's columnists, John Derbyshire, wrote that he had been
wrong to support the war in Iraq because the Bush administration was too
wimpy to wage it properly.
 
"One reason I supported the initial attack, and the destruction of the
Saddam regime, was that I hoped it would serve as an example," wrote
Derbyshire. "It would have done, if we'd just rubbled the place then left."
Then, he noted, "we would have been seen as a nation that knows how to
punish our enemies ... a nation to be feared and respected."
 
Most of us, I hope, wouldn't want to be part of a nation seen as capable of
such acts. In fact, it troubles me that we are now part of a nation where
such commentary is not beyond the pale of civilized discourse.
 
In fact, even concerning World War II, there are legitimate questions about
whether some Allied actions were truly justified.
 
Moreover, as the blogger and international affairs specialist Gregory
Djerejian notes in a critique of Podhoretz, the danger we face from
terrorism today is hardly comparable to being at war with Hitler's empire.
 
If fear makes us squander our moral progress, it will be a tragic paradox
indeed.
 
(Cathy Young is a contributing editor at Reason magazine. Her column appears
regularly in The Boston Globe.)
 BOSTON As war continues to rage in Iraq and Lebanon, appalling pictures of
human suffering and death fill our front pages and television screens.
 
Some people who have previously supported the Bush administration's foreign
policy and who are generally pro-Israel are concluding that the human costs
of the war on terror as currently conducted - both in terms of direct
casualties and human rights abuses - are unacceptably high. Meanwhile,
others are making the startling argument that we Americans may have become
too soft for our own good when it comes to the human costs of war.
 
A recent column by John Podhoretz in the New York Post opens with this
inquiry:
 
"What if liberal democracies have now evolved to a point where they can no
longer wage war effectively because they have achieved a level of
humanitarian concern for others that dwarfs any really cold-eyed pursuit of
their own national interests?"
 
Podhoretz goes on to ask if Britain and the United States could have won
World War II if they "did not have it in them to firebomb Dresden and nuke
Hiroshima and Nagasaki," inflicting massive civilian casualties, and he ends
with this reflection: "Can it be that the moral greatness of our
civilization - its astonishing focus on the value of the individual above
all - is endangering the future of our civilization as well?"
 
In all honesty, the question has occurred to me, too. What if Americans
during World War II had been confronted daily both with reports of American
casualties and with images of dead and wounded German civilians, including
children and old people? What if public opinion had been as troubled by both
American and German casualties as we are by American and Iraqi (or Lebanese)
casualties today? Would there still be a free world to speak of?
 
Yet it is all too easy to move from pondering a tragic paradox to
considering acts from which even the most hawkish among us would recoil in
horror. Thus, Podhoretz inquires: "What if the tactical mistake we made in
Iraq was that we didn't kill enough Sunnis in the early going to intimidate
them ... ? Wasn't the survival of Sunni men between the ages of 15 and 35
the reason there was an insurgency and the basic cause of the sectarian
violence now?"
 
Of course, the targeted slaughter of a population group - known as genocide
- would go far beyond anything done by the Allies in World War II. Indeed,
in a blogpost on the Web site of National Review magazine, Podhoretz reaches
for comparison to the tactics of Saddam Hussein in Iraq and Hafez al-Assad
in Syria, who quelled uprisings by wiping out thousands. He also stresses
that he is not advocating such measures: "I am not upset - far from it -
that they are closed off to us." He simply thinks that we should understand
that our "more civilized approach might represent a form of self-shackling"
against a ruthless enemy.
 
But such a discussion is a slippery slope. Where one person sees a need to
acknowledge our dilemma, others will argue for cutting the Gordian knot by
abandoning some of our scruples. This has already happened, to some extent,
in the discussion of torture. And some of Podhoretz's colleagues at National
Review have been quite outspoken about thinking the unthinkable. In June,
one of the magazine's columnists, John Derbyshire, wrote that he had been
wrong to support the war in Iraq because the Bush administration was too
wimpy to wage it properly.
 
"One reason I supported the initial attack, and the destruction of the
Saddam regime, was that I hoped it would serve as an example," wrote
Derbyshire. "It would have done, if we'd just rubbled the place then left."
Then, he noted, "we would have been seen as a nation that knows how to
punish our enemies ... a nation to be feared and respected."
 
Most of us, I hope, wouldn't want to be part of a nation seen as capable of
such acts. In fact, it troubles me that we are now part of a nation where
such commentary is not beyond the pale of civilized discourse.
 
In fact, even concerning World War II, there are legitimate questions about
whether some Allied actions were truly justified.
 
Moreover, as the blogger and international affairs specialist Gregory
Djerejian notes in a critique of Podhoretz, the danger we face from
terrorism today is hardly comparable to being at war with Hitler's empire.
 
If fear makes us squander our moral progress, it will be a tragic paradox
indeed.
 
(Cathy Young is a contributing editor at Reason magazine. Her column appears
regularly in The Boston Globe.)


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]



--------------------------
Want to discuss this topic?  Head on over to our discussion list, [EMAIL 
PROTECTED]
--------------------------
Brooks Isoldi, editor
[EMAIL PROTECTED]

http://www.intellnet.org

  Post message: [email protected]
  Subscribe:    [EMAIL PROTECTED]
  Unsubscribe:  [EMAIL PROTECTED]


*** FAIR USE NOTICE. This message contains copyrighted material whose use has 
not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. OSINT, as a part of 
The Intelligence Network, is making it available without profit to OSINT 
YahooGroups members who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the 
included information in their efforts to advance the understanding of 
intelligence and law enforcement organizations, their activities, methods, 
techniques, human rights, civil liberties, social justice and other 
intelligence related issues, for non-profit research and educational purposes 
only. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of the copyrighted material 
as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use 
this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' 
you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.
For more information go to:
http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtml 
Yahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
    [EMAIL PROTECTED]

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
    http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/
 



Reply via email to