Excellent article.right on the money! Bruce http://www.telegraph.co.uk/opinion/main.jhtml?xml=/opinion/2006/08/15/do1501 .xml&sSheet=/opinion/2006/08/15/ixopinion.html Multiculturalism is to blame for perverting young Muslims By Michael Nazir-Ali, Bishop of Rochester (Filed: 15/08/2006) Daily Telegraph
Islamic radicalism did not begin with Muslim grievances over Western foreign policy in Iraq or Afghanistan. It has deep roots, going back to the 13th-century reformer Ibn Taimiyya, through Wahhabism to modern ideologues such as Sayyid Qutb in Egypt or Maududi in Pakistan. The Soviet occupation of Afghanistan gave it the cause it was looking for, and Afghanistan became the place where Muslim radicals were trained, financed and armed (often with Western assistance). The movements that were born or renewed do not have any kind of centralised command structure, but co-operate through diffuse networks of affinity and patronage. One of their most important aims is to impose their form of Islam on countries such as Pakistan, Egypt, Malaysia and Indonesia. This may be why they were not regarded as an immediate threat to the West. Their other aims, however, include the liberation of oppressed Muslims in Palestine, Kashmir, Chechnya and elsewhere, and also the recovery of the Dar Al-Islam (or House of Islam), in its historic wholeness, including the Iberian peninsula, the Balkans and even India. In this cause, the rest of the world, particularly the West, is Dar al-Harb (House of War). These other aims clearly bring such movements into conflict with the international community and with Western interests in particular. So how does this dual psychology - of victimhood, but also the desire for domination - come to infect so many young Muslims in Britain? When I was here in the early 1970s, the practice of Islam was dominated by a kind of default Sufism or Islamic mysticism that was pietistic and apolitical. On my return in the late 1980s, the situation had changed radically. The change occurred because successive governments were unaware that the numerous mosques being established across the length and breadth of this country were being staffed, more and more, with clerics who belonged to various fundamentalist movements. There were no criteria for entry, no way of evaluating qualifications and no programme for making them aware of the culture that they were entering. Until quite recently, ministers and advisers did not realise the scale of the problem, even though it was repeatedly brought to their attention. Secondly, in the name of multiculturalism, mosque schools were encouraged and Muslim pupils spent up to six extra hours a day learning the Koran and Islamic tradition, as well as their own regional languages. Finally, there are the grievances. Some of these are genuine enough, but the complaint often boils down to the position that it is always right to intervene where Muslims are victims (as in Bosnia or Kosovo), and always wrong when they may be the oppressors or terrorists (as with the Taliban or in Iraq), even when their victims are also mainly Muslims. Given the world view that has given rise to such grievances, there can never be sufficient appeasement, and new demands will continue to be made. It is clear, therefore, that the multiculturalism beloved of our political and civic bureaucracies has not only failed to deliver peace, but is the partial cause of the present alienation of so many Muslim young people from the society in which they were born, where they have been educated and where they have lived most of their lives. The Cantle Report, in the wake of disturbances in Bradford, pointed out that housing and schools policies that favoured segregation, in the name of cultural integrity and cohesion, have had the unforeseen consequence of alienating the different religious, racial and cultural groups from one another. A very significant number of policies will have to be rethought. In this, the Government will need expert help. There must be greater encouragement for moderate Muslim voices to be heard more clearly. All religious leaders, representing any faith, wanting to work here, must be required to show that they are properly qualified, can speak English and are willing to undertake courses in adaptation to culture in this country: a number of suitable institutions offer such courses. Immigration policy should be shaped in such a way as to be able to discover whether potential immigrants have sympathy for characteristically British values and for the way of life here. The cultural heritage of people who come here must be respected. They should be able to take pride in their language, literature, art and spiritual background. At the same time, if they are to adjust to life in this country, they should be prepared to live in mixed communities, and not on their own. Their children should attend school along with those who come from the host culture, or from other cultures and traditions. They should be willing to learn through the medium of English and to be socially mobile, rather than "ghetto-ised" on the basis of religion, language or culture. Politicians keep talking about the need to teach British values so that there can be national cohesion. But what are these values, and whence do they come? The most fundamental of these has to do with the innate dignity of all human beings, with fundamental equality, with liberty and with safety from harm. Those learning such values will know how to respect the dignity of people who are quite different from them in appearance, language or belief. They will not see themselves as superior because of their religious or cultural roots, but regard every human life as of equal worth. They will be committed to freedom of belief and of expression. They will know that their fellow citizens have the right to safety from harm and that this extends not only to individual security, but also the safety of those institutions, such as democracy or a free press, that make liberty possible and actual. Values, however, are not free-standing; they are deeply rooted in a vision of society. Whether we like it or not, characteristic British values arise out of the Christian faith and its vision of personal and common good. These were clarified by the Enlightenment and became the bed-rock of our modern political arrangements. The Enlightenment, however, by consigning Christianity to the private sphere, also removed the basis and justification for these values in the public sphere. It is this basis and justification that needs to be recovered if our values are to be secure, and if they are to help inculcate the virtues of generosity, loyalty, moderation and love that lead to personal fulfilment and social wellbeing. The author is the Bishop of Rochester. Rachel Sylvester is away Comments Thanks Richard, for highlighting the real problem- the state charity of the welfare state. Virtually every social problem today has it's roots in this system that positively rewards irresponsibility, laziness and self-destruction. Posted by John R on August 15, 2006 11:13 AM <mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]:%20xml=/opinio n/2006/08/15/do1501.xml%20John%20R%20-%20August%2015,%202006%2011:13%20AM> Report this comment A very helpful and interesting analysis but how can any "basis and justification" for Christian values be reintroduced to "the public sphere" if only a small minority of the population is committed to them ? Posted by G Cawston on August 15, 2006 11:03 AM <mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]:%20xml=/opinio n/2006/08/15/do1501.xml%20G%20Cawston%20-%20August%2015,%202006%2011:03%20AM > Report this comment Michael Nazir-Ali is well-informed, thoughtful and always helpful in his writing. I do hope he gets invited regularly to the Home Office and Number 10 to brief our leaders. Posted by Andrew Martin on August 15, 2006 10:54 AM <mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]:%20xml=/opinio n/2006/08/15/do1501.xml%20Andrew%20Martin%20-%20August%2015,%202006%2010:54% 20AM> Report this comment It is nice to see a Bishop from the normally equivocal CoE actually putting the blame where it lies - in the fallacy of multi-culturalism. In our schools and other institutions, we need to re-establist the primacy of the host culture in order to instill a sense of belonging. It will take a long time, but now is the time to start. Posted by Richard Marriott on August 15, 2006 10:44 AM <mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]:%20xml=/opinio n/2006/08/15/do1501.xml%20Richard%20Marriott%20-%20August%2015,%202006%2010: 44%20AM> Report this comment When I went to school in the 70s and 80s in Canada, my friends were from a wide range of backgrounds. I also was part of the first generation to go to university with the most diverse population in the country's history. It worked for a reason: we were focused on one thing: being Canadian and being in Canada. But I saw something disturbing take hold in the 1990s: identity politics. It believed that in order to have a multicultural society, we must divide people into their groups and preserve these groups with government funds. A defacto apartheid started to take hold. It is most apparent in the UK, where I have been shocked at the lack of contact between race groups outside of bumping into each other on the street or maybe at work. This is a volatile situation. The government's strategy of pursuing maximum identity politics by fracturing the delivery of education and other services, is dangerous and well advanced. In the next ten to twenty years, I do not see any improvement in the tension in this society since the government stands by this policy. We need to separate identity politics from mainstream politics and to stop the behaviour of ethnic minority politicians only looking after their own group. Posted by Bob Macdonald on August 15, 2006 10:11 AM <mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]:%20xml=/opinio n/2006/08/15/do1501.xml%20Bob%20Macdonald%20-%20August%2015,%202006%2010:11% 20AM> Report this comment At last, some common sense comment from a religous leader. This neatly expresses the direction which our political leaders need to take to recover the "british values" ground - bring back Christianity to the centre stage. Posted by Tom Dickinson on August 15, 2006 10:07 AM <mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]:%20xml=/opinio n/2006/08/15/do1501.xml%20Tom%20Dickinson%20-%20August%2015,%202006%2010:07% 20AM> Report this comment It's nice to read such common sense - but when will it be fulfilled. I am not a christian, but accept that Britain is a Christian country and therefore accept that Christian values and beliefs come first in the UK. We are very fortunately indeed that all other religions are accepted and welcomed, but non-christians must accept that they are in a Christian country and abide by Christian values. Please will the government take on board the words of the Bishop and ensure that people are taught to put Britain first. Posted by Jane Weitzmann on August 15, 2006 10:05 AM <mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]:%20xml=/opinio n/2006/08/15/do1501.xml%20Jane%20Weitzmann%20-%20August%2015,%202006%2010:05 %20AM> Report this comment Thank god for a voice of good sense. Posted by mary grimshaw on August 15, 2006 9:48 AM <mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]:%20xml=/opinio n/2006/08/15/do1501.xml%20mary%20grimshaw%20-%20August%2015,%202006%209:48%2 0AM> Report this comment I do hope that our politicians and religious leaders (Muslim as well as Christian) will take this to heart. I am a christian woman married to a moderate, kind, gentle muslim, living in the UK. We agreed before we married to respect and understand each other's beliefs and culture. This means that when I visit his family and home country with him, I adapt my dress code accordingly so that I do not offend. This is relatively easy for me to do as I have been raised in a multi-cultural society. He respects (and is in awe of!) our laws and our democracy, and wishes the same were true of his homeland. It is possible for us to live together peacefully with those from other cultures and religions, but it has to come from respect for one another. I hope that the UK will always be a Christian-based society, but if incomers are able to become demanding and to run rough-shod over our culture and history, where will it end? Posted by Anna on August 15, 2006 9:45 AM <mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]:%20xml=/opinio n/2006/08/15/do1501.xml%20Anna%20-%20August%2015,%202006%209:45%20AM> Report this comment Christianity is a main part of England heritage.Christianity has built and run hospitals,sport centers,schools,many charities helping people in need with given food and drink,clothing,shelter. Some of the great songs and arts is from Christianity too,lots of fine hymns too. Many Christian churches such as Lutheran,Baptist,Church of England,Pentecostals,Roman Catholic teach good morals and ethics plus many gain good friendships there and fun events there too. Of course the King James Bible is the greatest work in all of literature-also now a New King James Bible version also. The Bible contains history,prophecy,good-philosophy,poetry and real-Spirituality.Christian Pastors have helped many people too.Christainity also helped push for democracy in the western world.As for Jesus Christ whom is a real historical fact,He is the greatest Spiritual leader and universal King. Posted by Larry on August 15, 2006 9:42 AM <mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]:%20xml=/opinio n/2006/08/15/do1501.xml%20Larry%20-%20August%2015,%202006%209:42%20AM> Report this comment The bishop's views reflect what France has been doing for years Posted by martin swash on August 15, 2006 9:41 AM <mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]:%20xml=/opinio n/2006/08/15/do1501.xml%20martin%20swash%20-%20August%2015,%202006%209:41%20 AM> Report this comment Well said. Any self-contained group will at some point, concentrate on the differences and fall into a "them or us" attitude. How to remedy this? Any changes will probably be seen as a challenge as the human instinct in general is to resist change. Wiser heads than mine need to seek the answer. Posted by Violet on August 15, 2006 9:19 AM <mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]:%20xml=/opinio n/2006/08/15/do1501.xml%20Violet%20-%20August%2015,%202006%209:19%20AM> Report this comment If you wish to raise my blood pressure, all you have to do is mention multiculturalism. Those who champion such nonsense can charitably be described as myopic. You mention that those who migrate to this country must be allowed to take pride in their culture etc, but I do not accept that is a prerogative. If they are so keen to maintain that cultural identity, then I must question both their motive for coming to this country and their value to society. As you mention, segregation causes its own problems, but this can be achieved in one room, by appearance and use of language. The ignorant promotion of multiculturalism has denied the native population the opportunity to celebrate their own traditions and practices, resulting in a confused national identity. This identity is further confused by the removal of the teaching of history as a core subject at schools. There is a desire for national pride, as illustrated by the display of St George's flags during the latest football disappointment, and two things must be clearly defined. How we do things and where the exit door is if you have no desire to fit in. Posted by Hamish Hossick on August 15, 2006 9:18 AM <mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]:%20xml=/opinio n/2006/08/15/do1501.xml%20Hamish%20Hossick%20-%20August%2015,%202006%209:18% 20AM> Report this comment Good to read such lucid analysis from the Bishop of Rochester. One can only hope that the members of the Anglican hierarchy have enough wits to listen to him. One has to hope as well that those who govern us and are practising Anglicans have been calling upon his counsel over the last few years. In this last group, of course, we number Queen Elizabeth and the Prime Minister. "Wake up and strengthen what remains." Posted by William on August 15, 2006 8:55 AM <mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]:%20xml=/opinio n/2006/08/15/do1501.xml%20William%20-%20August%2015,%202006%208:55%20AM> Report this comment I very much respect the ethos behind this piece. However, I wonder if it is time for our country to become secular? We have absurd levels of political correctness of which multiculturalism is near the top of the list. I do not wish to deny our Christian heritage on which our way of life and laws are based, but I do wish to protect our Christian heritage from the slow dilution and contamination that forced change through multiculturalism brings. Everything changes over time through the natural evolution of ideas. Our country is no different. We must stop taking Muslim sides or adding Muslim ideals to our culture. I would now like our country to become a secular state where religeous bigotry, fundamentalism and zelotry of any faith has no place in government or decision making. Posted by Philip Congdon on August 15, 2006 8:32 AM <mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]:%20xml=/opinio n/2006/08/15/do1501.xml%20Philip%20Congdon%20-%20August%2015,%202006%208:32% 20AM> Report this comment Is the Bishop of Rochester an old hippy from the 1960s? "Peace and love, man, and dig the Christian church," seems to be the substantive message of this otiose piece, and I lost count of the number of times he uses the word "should" when describing what he feels "should" be done about what he himself implicitly identifies as a massive Muslim problem. Let's get things straight from the perspective of a working class Englishman of Irish roots. One: I don't give a tinker's cuss about medieval Islamic schisms. I'm busy enough trying to live my own life within the parameters of my own culture without needing lectures in the arcane history of an utterly alien faith. We're not remotely interested, Bishop. In my simple-minded way I would like the people charged with governing this country to protect me from these plots by ejecting, for good, those responsible. If they detest the way of life Britain offers them (and they must do), then Iran or Pakistan would be a better place for them to live. Wherever it is I, and tens of millions of other secular non-Muslims like me, don't really care as long as it is a long way away from our country. The Bishop of Rochester, however, is one of those hand-wringing appeasers who condemn us to perfidy through their effete idealism. Posted by Mike Collins on August 15, 2006 8:29 AM <mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]:%20xml=/opinio n/2006/08/15/do1501.xml%20Mike%20Collins%20-%20August%2015,%202006%208:29%20 AM> Report this comment Michael Nazir-Ali,has told us what many suspected all along,the idea so loved by the liberal elite that multiculturallism, is all things wonderful is nothing but a lie and will bring nothing but death and distruction on us in the long term,this is a real problem as most of us suspected of world domination by Muslims,will never go away the way we must deal with it in this Country, is to allow no more Mosques to be built on our lands,(many of these places are promoting radical ideology to devout followers)we must also stop all immigration immediately, (particullarly of more Muslims to these shores),we must also remove( and change our laws if necessary) all trouble makers immediately, and make sure they never return,we should return our servicemen from Iraq,and Afghanistan,now (Blair is sacrificing human life for what reason because of his ego, these countries will never be democratic they don't want it)to safeguard our shores, if we do not implement any of these necessary changes so desperately needed we could see human carnage as not seen since WW2 in our country,also very important as the death toll so far as been in England and not the rest of Briton,these Scots, who manage our Country at this time, owe it to us to protect us, and not treat us as a foreign nation to finance their own Countries inadequacies, We should demand our own Parliament, free from the interference of foreign MPs,with selected English Mps, who sole interest is our protection, and not self interest as is all to apparent with this present regime. Posted by banachech on August 15, 2006 8:27 AM <mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]:%20xml=/opinio n/2006/08/15/do1501.xml%20banachech%20-%20August%2015,%202006%208:27%20AM> Report this comment The Bishop of Rochester articulates what sounds to me like an eloquent, contemporary Christian view. He is to be commended for it. His credentials are matchless. I'm sure that any Muslim seeking freedom from the faith that binds them tight and condemns them to endless conflict, would find profound understanding and a sincere welcome under the Bishop's roof. And Peace. Posted by sebastian on August 15, 2006 8:25 AM <mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]:%20xml=/opinio n/2006/08/15/do1501.xml%20sebastian%20-%20August%2015,%202006%208:25%20AM> Report this comment I do not think that this government, or any government that this country might elect, would be capable of bringing in legislation that would sort out this sorry mess. There has been too much weakness in allowing this situation to develop. We have given away too much of our own culture and standards. Retrieving the situation will be almost impossible. Posted by Alan Challoner on August 15, 2006 8:14 AM <mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]:%20xml=/opinio n/2006/08/15/do1501.xml%20Alan%20Challoner%20-%20August%2015,%202006%208:14% 20AM> Report this comment Surely the most cogent and accurate analysis of this crisis yet seen in the British press. More please from this gifted Christian theologian, born and raised in Pakistan. Posted by Hildebrand on August 15, 2006 8:13 AM <mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]:%20xml=/opinio n/2006/08/15/do1501.xml%20Hildebrand%20-%20August%2015,%202006%208:13%20AM> Report this comment I quote from today's Independent. Dr Syed Aziz Pasha, secretary general of the Union of Muslim Organisations of the UK and Ireland, said he had asked for holidays to mark Muslim festivals and Islamic laws to cover family affairs which would apply only to Muslims. Dr Pasha said he was not seeking sharia law for criminal offences but he said Muslim communities in Britain should be able to operate Islamic codes for marriage and family life. "In Scotland, they have a separate law. It doesn't mean they are not part of the UK. We are asking for Islamic law which covers marriage and family life. We are willing to co-operate but there should be a partnership. They should understand our problems then we will understand their problems." This is the thin end of the invasive wedge. This will end in tears Posted by gareth d on August 15, 2006 7:35 AM <mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]:%20xml=/opinio n/2006/08/15/do1501.xml%20gareth%20d%20-%20August%2015,%202006%207:35%20AM> Report this comment A very powerful article, Bishop, coming from a man of such faith, humanity and, not least, personal knowledge of the background to the problem. (Just a pity it isn't also appearing in the pages of the mouthpiece of "appeasement", the Guardian.) Posted by Gordon on August 15, 2006 7:29 AM <mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]:%20xml=/opinio n/2006/08/15/do1501.xml%20Gordon%20-%20August%2015,%202006%207:29%20AM> Report this comment Mr Nazir Ali is right in his analysis and judgements. It is a shame that the UK politicians are too afraid to articulate these views. What we must now also do is to deal with and destroy the threat of Muslim terror groups and Iran's nuclear capability, that seek to destroy non-Muslim civilisations without thought of the suffering that comes to their own kind. Until we do this the situation in the West will get much worse, and if we thought that communist threats of domination and war were unpleasant some years ago then this current situation is going to be much worse. Posted by J GARDNER on August 15, 2006 6:37 AM <mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]:%20xml=/opinio n/2006/08/15/do1501.xml%20J%20GARDNER%20-%20August%2015,%202006%206:37%20AM> Report this comment Suggest you ask your wonderful reporters and commentators on the bbc world service for explanations and answers to this problem. You Brits have missed the train - and together with most of Europe are going to lose a lot of your culture - blame us Israelis and your local Jews for all your problems. We have so many - a few more won't break our backs! Posted by uzi lowenthal on August 15, 2006 6:36 AM <mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]:%20xml=/opinio n/2006/08/15/do1501.xml%20uzi%20lowenthal%20-%20August%2015,%202006%206:36%2 0AM> Report this comment Hear Hear Posted by Graham on August 15, 2006 6:34 AM <mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]:%20xml=/opinio n/2006/08/15/do1501.xml%20Graham%20-%20August%2015,%202006%206:34%20AM> Report this comment We in Canada are making the same mistakes that you have made in Britain. We have already seen the fruits of those errors, in the still unsolved bombing of Air India Flight 182 Posted by Alan Cobden on August 15, 2006 5:33 AM <mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]:%20xml=/opinio n/2006/08/15/do1501.xml%20Alan%20Cobden%20-%20August%2015,%202006%205:33%20A M> Report this comment The Bishop of Rochester's piece so well sums up a nasty situation brought on England through "do gooders", self seeking politicians and their vote seeking "multiculturism" Posted by Alec on August 15, 2006 5:00 AM <mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]:%20xml=/opinio n/2006/08/15/do1501.xml%20Alec%20-%20August%2015,%202006%205:00%20AM> Report this comment Should you not wait until the boys are charged with any offence before launching into what the Muslim leaders should do to win hearts and minds. Remember Forest Gate, when people were shot and no charges made? Perhaps it is the government that should do more now to win hearts and minds? Posted by Tom Johnes on August 15, 2006 4:10 AM <mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]:%20xml=/opinio n/2006/08/15/do1501.xml%20Tom%20Johnes%20-%20August%2015,%202006%204:10%20AM > Report this comment I believe the Bishop of Rochester has hit the nail right on the head. I only hope that our political leaders will sit up and take notice and really do something for a change. Posted by Geoffrey B. Pratt on August 15, 2006 3:33 AM <mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]:%20xml=/opinio n/2006/08/15/do1501.xml%20Geoffrey%20B.%20Pratt%20-%20August%2015,%202006%20 3:33%20AM> Report this comment I agree with the Bishop's conclusions. It seems we often overlook the fact that every human being operates on their 'world-view'; which is to say, what they believe about the origins and purpose of life on this planet. Whether Atheist, New Age, Muslim or Christian, each belief system works itself out in how humans function and how a society sets up its laws and culture.It is naive in the extreme to imagine that society can operate one way when a large number of its people believe something radically different. Western atheists have long tried to cut the ties to our Christan roots while still keeping its premises. It doesn't work, because if 'survival of the fittest' is the basis for existance, then power is the name of the game so why should we respect the weak, poor and defenceless and those who differ radically from ourselves? We are truly witnessing a clash of world-views and the weaker will go under. Posted by katherine on August 15, 2006 2:50 AM <mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]:%20xml=/opinio n/2006/08/15/do1501.xml%20katherine%20-%20August%2015,%202006%202:50%20AM> Report this comment Thank you, Bishop, for your thoughts. May I suggest another cause of "alienation" - welfare. In Britain today, you can live almost anywhere you choose, especially if you have no job. So we have set up a viscious circle of "deprivation" - immigrants cluster together who are unemployed because they do not have to follow the work. The USA does not have the welfare culture that Europe does, people are more mobile and gravitate towards work. This promotes integration, while the "right" to be housed and fed at the state's expense in Europe promotes ghettoes of state sanctioned indolence. Posted by Richard on August 15, 2006 1:40 AM <mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]:%20xml=/opinio n/2006/08/15/do1501.xml%20Richard%20-%20August%2015,%202006%201:40%20AM> Report this comment How wonderful to hear an Anglican Bishop address the root cause of the current problems so eloquently, and one who actually believes in the strength and values of his own religion. But where is the list of signatories supporting him, and the silence from the Archbishop of Canterbury is quite deafening... Posted by Chatty P on August 15, 2006 1:13 AM [Non-text portions of this message have been removed] -------------------------- Want to discuss this topic? Head on over to our discussion list, [EMAIL PROTECTED] -------------------------- Brooks Isoldi, editor [EMAIL PROTECTED] http://www.intellnet.org Post message: [email protected] Subscribe: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Unsubscribe: [EMAIL PROTECTED] *** FAIR USE NOTICE. This message contains copyrighted material whose use has not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. OSINT, as a part of The Intelligence Network, is making it available without profit to OSINT YahooGroups members who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included information in their efforts to advance the understanding of intelligence and law enforcement organizations, their activities, methods, techniques, human rights, civil liberties, social justice and other intelligence related issues, for non-profit research and educational purposes only. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of the copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the copyright owner. For more information go to: http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtml Yahoo! Groups Links <*> To visit your group on the web, go to: http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/ <*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to: [EMAIL PROTECTED] <*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to: http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/
