http://www.wired.com/news/technology/0,72811-0.html?tw=wn_index_1

Top Secret: We're Wiretapping You

By Ryan Singel| Also by this reporter
02:00 AM Mar, 05, 2007

It could be a scene from Kafka or Brazil. Imagine a government agency,
in a bureaucratic foul-up, accidentally gives you a copy of a document
marked "top secret." And it contains a log of some of your private phone
calls.

You read it and ponder it and wonder what it all means. Then, two months
later, the FBI shows up at your door, demands the document back and
orders you to forget you ever saw it.

By all accounts, that's what happened to Washington D.C. attorney
Wendell Belew in August 2004. And it happened at a time when no one
outside a small group of high-ranking officials and workaday spooks knew
the National Security Agency was listening in on Americans' phone calls
without warrants. Belew didn't know what to make of the episode. But
now, thanks to that government gaffe, he and a colleague have the
distinction of being the only Americans who can prove they were
specifically eavesdropped upon by the NSA's surveillance program.

The pair are seeking $1 million each in a closely watched lawsuit
against the government, which experts say represents the greatest
chance, among over 50 different lawsuits, of convincing a key judge to
declare the program illegal.

Belew's bout with the Terrorist Surveillance Program began in 2004, when
he was representing the U.S. branch office of the prominent Saudi
Arabian charity Al-Haramain. Formerly one of the largest charities in
Saudi Arabia, Al-Haramain worked to spread a strict view of Islam
through philanthropy, missionary work and support for mosques around the
world.

Federal officials were investigating the Ashland, Oregon, branch of the
group for alleged links to terrorism, and had already frozen the
charity's U.S. assets. Belew was one of several lawyers trying to keep
Al-Haramain off a U.S. Treasury Department watch list -- an effort that
sent much paperwork flying back and forth between the attorneys and the
Treasury Department's Washington D.C. headquarters across the street
from the White House.

On Aug. 20, 2004, fellow Al-Haramain attorney Lynne Bernabei noticed one
of the documents from Treasury was marked "top secret." Bernabei gave
the document to attorneys and directors at Al-Haramain's Saudi Arabia
headquarters, and gave a copy to Belew. The document was a log of phone
conversations Belew and co-counsel Asim Ghafoor had held with a
Saudi-based director for the charity named Soliman al-Buthi.

Al-Buthi was a Saudi government employee who volunteered as coordinator
for Al-Haramain's North American branches, including the Oregon branch.
In a telephone interview with Wired News, al-Buthi says he's now general
manager for the environmental department of the city of Riyadh, working
on an anti-bird flu project. He denied having any links to terrorism,
now or in 2004. "I feel that Islam is best spread by wisdom not by arms
or violence," al-Buthi says.

Despite al-Buthi's claims of innocence, al-Buthi and Al-Haramain's
American branch were added to the government's public list of terrorists
on Sept. 9, 2004, just weeks after the government turned over the call
log to the charity's attorneys. It's not clear when officials realized
they'd given a highly classified document to an organization they
considered terrorist, but the FBI showed up at Belew's office in October
and demanded the call log back, advising the lawyer not to attempt to
remember the document's contents.

By then, Belew had given a copy of the document to Washington Post
reporter David Ottaway, who had been writing about how the government
investigated and listed individuals and groups suspected of funding
terrorism. Ottaway did not report on the classified call log, and when
the FBI called, the Post dutifully handed over its copy.

That might have been the end of it. But in December 2005 The New York
Times revealed that the government had been spying on Americans'
overseas communications without warrants, and Al-Haramain's lawyers
realized why the FBI had been so adamant about getting the document back.

"I got up in the morning and read the story, and I thought, 'My god, we
had a log of a wiretap and it may or may not have been the NSA and on
further reflection it was NSA," says Thomas Nelson, who represents
Al-Haramain and Belew. "So we decided to file a lawsuit."

The lawyers retrieved one of the remaining copies of the document --
presumably from Saudi Arabia -- and used it to file a complaint in U.S.
District Court in Oregon in February of last year. They sought damages
from the government of $1 million each for Belew and Ghafoor, and the
unfreezing of Al-Haramain's assets, because that action relied on the
allegedly illegal spying.

The lawsuit is poised to blow a hole through a bizarre catch-22 that has
dogged other legal efforts to challenge the Bush administration's
warrantless surveillance.

Since the 2005 Times story, and subsequent acknowledgment of the
surveillance by the Bush administration, some 50-odd lawsuits have
sprung up around the NSA program, taking on the government and various
telecom companies who are allegedly cooperating in spying on their
customers, including BellSouth, Verizon and Sprint.

Justice Department and phone company lawyers have asserted that the
plaintiffs in those cases don't have legal standing to sue, because they
have no proof that they were direct victims of the eavesdropping. At the
same time, the government claims it doesn't have to reveal if any
individual was or was not wiretapped because the "state secrets
privilege" permits it to withhold information that would endanger
national security.

The tangible document makes Belew's case uniquely positioned to cut
through that thicket, says Shayana Kadidal, an attorney with the Center
for Constitutional Rights, which represents individuals being held in
Guantanamo Bay. The center is also suing to stop the surveillance, but
lacks Belew's concrete evidence of monitoring -- arguing instead that
the possibility of being monitored hampers its legal work.

"The government's line is that if you don't have evidence of actual
surveillance, you lose on standing," says Kadidal. "Out of all the
cases, this is the only one with evidence of actual surveillance."

That evidence also gives the courts enough to rule immediately on
whether the president had the authority to spy on Belew and Ghafoor
without a court order, said Jon Eisenberg, one of Belew's lawyers. "We
know how many times he's been surveilled," Eisenberg told a judge last
month. "There is nothing left for this court to do except hear oral
arguments on the legality of the program."

The Justice Department isn't ready to concede that the two attorneys
were swept into the NSA's extrajudicial surveillance. "The government
has never confirmed or denied whether plaintiffs were surveilled, much
less surveilled under the Terrorist Surveillance Program," spokesman
Dean Boyd wrote in an e-mail to Wired News.

But if the document is a harmless memo unrelated to NSA surveillance,
it's unexpectedly agitating government spooks.

Soon after the lawsuit was filed, the document was whisked out of the
courthouse and into a Justice Department-controlled secure room known as
a Secure Compartmented Information Facility in Portland, Oregon.
According to government filings, it remains classified top secret and
contains "sensitive compartmented information" -- meaning information
that concerns or is derived from intelligence sources, methods or
analytical processes, according to the defense and intelligence
communities' own definition.

Even the lawyers who filed the document with the court are no longer
allowed to see it; instead, they've been permitted to file declarations,
under seal, based on their memory of its contents.

Other aspects of the case also support the plaintiffs' interpretation of
the document. Last year, U.S. District Judge Garr King in Portland
examined the document and read classified briefs filed by the Justice
Department. Then he ordered the government to meet with the plaintiffs
to discuss turning over more documents in discovery. It's not likely the
court would have permitted the case to continue if the evidence didn't,
in fact, indicate that the pair had been under surveillance.

And if the surveillance had been court ordered and lawful, King would
have been obliged to dismiss the lawsuit. Under the Foreign Intelligence
Surveillance Act, or FISA, targets of counter-intelligence or
counter-terrorism surveillance can only sue the government when no
warrant has been issued. Lawyers for Belew and Ghafoor seize on this
point. "If there was a FISA warrant, the whole case would have crumbled
on the first day," Nelson says. "Its pretty obvious from the
government's conduct in the case, there was no warrant."

Justice department lawyers have argued that, even if the pair of lawyers
were monitored, judging the president's authority to do so requires
looking at the specific reasons why the duo were surveilled. And those
facts would be national secrets that would tip off terrorists, so no
court can ever rule on the program.

"This is not to say there is no forum to air the weighty matters at
issue, which remains a matter of considerable public interest and
debate, but that the resolution of these issues must be left to the
political branches of government," Justice Department lawyers wrote in a
brief on the case.

But the government has a new, and not necessarily friendly, judicial
audience for its no-judges-allowed argument. In August, a special court
ordered Belew's lawsuit to be consolidated into a single proceeding
comprised of 54 other NSA-related lawsuits, before U.S. District Court
Chief Judge Vaughn Walker in San Francisco.

Walker has presided over the year-old class-action lawsuit brought by
the Electronic Frontier Foundation against AT&T for the phone company's
alleged cooperation with the NSA program. The judge made waves in July
when he issued a landmark ruling that allowed the AT&T case to proceed,
despite the government's claim that the suit must be thrown out because
it involved national secrets. Walker ruled that the state-secrets
privilege did not apply to the entirety of the case, because the
government had admitted the program existed. (Walker recently rejected a
motion filed by Wired News seeking the unsealing of evidence in the case.)

The government has appealed that state secrets decision to the 9th
Circuit Court of Appeals, and asked the judge to put a stop to all 55
cases pending that appeal. But Walker, a libertarian-leaning Republican,
has kept the cases moving, noting that any decision from the appeals
court is likely to wind through the court system up to the Supreme Court
-- a process that could take years.

Belew's lawsuit, his lawyers submit, is a chance to short circuit that
process entirely.

In a hearing in early February, Eisenberg told Walker that the
classified document sets the Belew case apart from the other cases,
because the judge has enough evidence to decide whether the warrantless
surveillance was illegal, without waiting for the 9th Circuit to decide
the state secrets issue.

"You need only read the statutes to decide, 'Does the president have the
right to do this without a warrant?'" Eisenberg said.

Walker is expected to rule in March on whether to stay the case or set a
hearing date, and the document will likely be moved, under guard, from
the Portland secure facility to San Francisco, where Walker can review it.

In the meantime, the NSA program is undergoing changes.

In a separate lawsuit last August, Michigan U.S. District Court Judge
Anna Diggs Taylor found the NSA surveillance program unconstitutional
and illegal -- a decision that's now under appeal in the 6th Circuit.
Facing that ruling and growing political pressure, in early January,
Attorney General Alberto Gonzales essentially announced the end of the
warrantless spying, saying the NSA program will continue, but would
begin getting "innovative" court orders from the foreign intelligence court.

With the program now reformed, the Justice Department has asked for
several of the lawsuits against the government to be dismissed as moot.

Al-Buthi is now a "specially designated global terrorist," according to
the Treasury Department, and he's under indictment in the United States
for failing to declare $150,000 in travelers checks raised to help
Chechnyan refugees when he last flew out of the country. He told Wired
News that he had always declared money when entering the United States,
but wasn't aware he needed to do the same when leaving. He says he's
been interrogated twice by Saudi officials and cleared of any wrongdoing.

+++



------------------------ Yahoo! Groups Sponsor --------------------~--> 
Great things are happening at Yahoo! Groups.  See the new email design.
http://us.click.yahoo.com/lOt0.A/hOaOAA/yQLSAA/TySplB/TM
--------------------------------------------------------------------~-> 

--------------------------
Want to discuss this topic?  Head on over to our discussion list, [EMAIL 
PROTECTED]
--------------------------
Brooks Isoldi, editor
[EMAIL PROTECTED]

http://www.intellnet.org

  Post message: [email protected]
  Subscribe:    [EMAIL PROTECTED]
  Unsubscribe:  [EMAIL PROTECTED]


*** FAIR USE NOTICE. This message contains copyrighted material whose use has 
not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. OSINT, as a part of 
The Intelligence Network, is making it available without profit to OSINT 
YahooGroups members who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the 
included information in their efforts to advance the understanding of 
intelligence and law enforcement organizations, their activities, methods, 
techniques, human rights, civil liberties, social justice and other 
intelligence related issues, for non-profit research and educational purposes 
only. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of the copyrighted material 
as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use 
this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' 
you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.
For more information go to:
http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtml 
Yahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/

<*> Your email settings:
    Individual Email | Traditional

<*> To change settings online go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/join
    (Yahoo! ID required)

<*> To change settings via email:
    mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] 
    mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
    [EMAIL PROTECTED]

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
    http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/
 

Reply via email to