Anatomy of a disaster 

*
http://www.theage.com.au/news/world/anatomy-of-a-disaster/2007/03/09/1173166
985751.html?page=fullpage#contentSwap2

Mark Forbes, Ian Munro and Karen Kissane.
March 10, 2007

ONLY the good die young, they say, and this was a plane full of both the
good and the young. Liz O'Neill had worked in Australia and Hong Kong with
refugees before joining the Department of Foreign Affairs, where she looked
after families and journalists in the ghastly aftermath of the Bali bombing.

Allison Sudradjat, who worked with AusAID to fight Third World poverty, was
"the heart of the Jakarta post," said colleague Helen Moody. "Some quite
awful things happened - the tsunami, the embassy bombing - and she was the
one constant, the heart and soul of this agency up there. She was never
cynical about anything."

Journalists are thought of as cynical creatures but even the reporter who
was to die, the handsome, charming Morgan Mellish, 36, must have had a
belief in the power of the individual to work for the common good. A
tenacious business journalist, he had helped hammer nails into the
metaphorical coffins of shonky businessmen such as Rodney Adler and Ray
Williams, winning for his trouble a Walkley Award - and the foreign posting
that he wanted so badly.

Many of the passengers squeezed onto Garuda Airlines flight GA200 thought
themselves lucky to have made it aboard. Several journalists had not been
able to get seats on Wednesday's 6am trip to Yogyakarta, part of an
entourage for the visit of Foreign Minister Alexander Downer, and were left
behind at Jakarta airport. They would be chief among those who would tell
the story of what was to come.

The front of the plane, business class, carried members of the Australian
embassy's most senior aid, information and police officers. Journalists do
not always travel so comfortably, but Mellish and journalist Cynthia Banham
had grabbed the last tickets offered by the embassy.

Also in business class was Federal Agent Brice Steele, who was building an
enviable record as an investigator with a career that included work on
child-sex tourism in the Asia-Pacific and transnational narcotics
operations.

He joined the Australian Federal Police at 18 and had come to epitomise a
new era of policing. He was fluent in several Chinese dialects, held a
degree in Modern Asian Studies and had been seconded to the Australian
Securities and Investments Commission. After a posting to Beijing in 2002 he
was promoted to the role of international manager of counterterrorism.

He was an expert on the Indonesian extremist group Jemaah Islamiah. He was
on the Garuda flight in his capacity as manager of the AFP's Indonesian
operations, a key area for the AFP as it strives to help police forces in
South-East Asia build counter-terrorism capacity.

Federal agent Mark Scott was newly arrived in the Indonesian capital, having
earlier been posted to Burma. He was working closely with the Indonesian
National Police on counterterrorism. Earlier still, the 43-year-old father
of three was a general duties cop in the ACT.

He had paved the way for police from a Canberra background looking to
further their careers with international duties.

Now assigned to Jakarta, his CV began with community police stations at
Tuggeranong and Woden. Like Brice Steele, he was a career officer with the
AFP, well known throughout the service.

Back in economy were more junior officials and two Indonesians working for
Channel Seven, cameraman Wayan Sukarda and assistant Ardi Rahman. As many
cameramen do, Sukarda cradled his camera during the flight. He was about to
get the most distressing scoop of his life.

For Mellish, the trip was part of a future he had envisioned for himself
ever since reading Christopher Koch's books Highways to a War and The Year
of Living Dangerously. It was after reading those stories that he decided
that he wanted to become a journalist and a foreign correspondent.

For Allison Sudradjat, the pull was a lifelong fascination with Asia. She
had first been posted to Indonesia in 1992, just three years after beginning
her career with the Australian Government aid agency AusAID.

Sudradjat returned to Indonesia after the Boxing Day tsunami and headed an
Australian team of more than 100 aid workers. She was a key figure in the
growth of AusAID's programs and widely admired for a rare combination of
qualities: great professionalism and competence, and personal warmth.

Liz O'Neill came from a strong Catholic family with an equally strong sense
of social justice. Her mother and father had both worked for the Kings Cross
soup kitchen run by their local Sydney parish, St Canice's, and her father,
a retired army colonel, had also worked as a volunteer Catholic social
justice counsellor in Sydney. "He had a passion for East Timor," says Father
Peter Hosking, O'Neill's boss when she worked at a Sydney centre for
refugees.

O'Neill was a committed Catholic; she prepared seriously for her marriage,
and her baby Lucinda, born last year, was brought home to be christened with
the family. "I think her religion meant something to her," Hosking says.

In her time with Foreign Affairs and Trade, O'Neill had been to Japan and
Bougainville. She was best known, though, for her work after the Bali
bombing, when she helped the grieving families and liaised with a swarm of
reporters. Says Hosking, "It had quite a profound effect on Liz. I think she
was very touched by people's resilience but also she was very close to the
suffering of families and other people who were involved. She had a good
heart."

These were people who believed in the future.

The hour-long trip passed smoothly until close to the end. Approaching
Yogyakarta many passengers - all too aware of recent Indonesian airline
crashes - became alarmed.

University professor Murni Indarti said that minutes before landing, "We
felt something was wrong. The plane didn't seem to fly properly. We could
see the land already. I joked with the passenger next to me that maybe this
is what they call a hard landing. Then suddenly the situation was out of
control."

Two Australian air force officers, Michael Hatton and Kyle Quinlan, had
exchanged nervous glances. Quinlan, watching trees and buildings flash by
his window, thought the plane was coming down "too fast, too hard".

"I've taken my earphones out and looked over at Mick. I said to him, 'This
is coming in way too fast'," Quinlan said. "He nodded at me, and the plane
started bouncing. It was a pretty rough ride. I grabbed my legs and braced
for the impact."

Santi Hendra was one of four World Vision staff sitting in row eight of
flight 220. To him, too, it was clear before they landed that the plane was
in trouble. The air crew seemed unprepared, running to their seats as the
plane approached landing.

In the cockpit, Captain Marwoto Komar and co-pilot Gagam Rohman were
wrestling to control the 15-year-old Boeing 737-400. They could not fully
extend the plane's wing flaps and were rapidly approaching the airport, they
have told Garuda officials, including its Pilots' Association president
Captain Stephanus.

Just 300 metres above the runway, "the captain felt a downdraft and the
aircraft sinks so rapidly", Stephanus said. Hendra said passengers were
screaming even before the plane touched down.

Stephanus said the pilots "just felt the aircraft hit the runway and bounce
and then because the speed is very fast the aircraft over-ran. Then the
engines hit the ground."

Normally pilots would try to "fly around" and attempt another landing.
Captain Komar felt he had to complete the touchdown after the shock of the
initial impact.

But, already more than a third of the way down the runway, the speeding jet
was out of control. Investigators believe the nosewheel had snapped when it
hit the runway. The plane crashed through the airport fencing, then across a
roadway. Landing gear and engines were ripped off. With a fuel tank
ruptured, explosions began and flames soon followed.

Inside the plane, Sukarda said, "People say 'Oh my God, oh my God!' There
was smoke and fire. All the luggage just fell down, many people were crying,
hysterical."

Cockpit indicators did not warn of a fire but, as the crumpled jet slid to a
halt, Captain Komar saw smoke outside the window and ordered stewards to
open the emergency exits and evacuate the passengers. The plane filled with
smoke and flames.

Sukarda said, "The cabin staff opened the back door and directed passengers
out. It was too, too quick. Very, very quick."

Hendra escaped fast. He said, "We jumped out of the emergency exit. We were
all sitting next to the emergency exit. We were 200 metres away from the
plane when it burst into flames."

The fire made people panic, according to Indarti. "Things were just chaotic.
People tried to get out of the plane, everybody was helping themselves."

Primal fear triggered Darwinian scenes. Raham's left leg was trapped
underneath his seat. Stumbling into the aisle, he fell and other passengers
"were stomping on me".

The passengers broke his ribs but when Raham heard a steward calling people
to the exit, he struggled up and jumped. Then he ran: "All I could think of
was to get as far as possible from the plane."

Sukarda grabbed his camera and headed for the rear exit. Jumping into the
rice paddy, his boots lodged in the thick mud. He pulled his feet free and
ran barefoot from the plane as aviation fuel sparked a series of explosions.

"I jump and run, I felt a big blast," he said. "I got away from the aircraft
and I film. I am a cameraman, everywhere I go the camera is with me."

Turning his camera towards the wreckage, he captured Captain Komar jumping
to safety from the cockpit as passengers struggled from the exits. "I don't
know why the pilot not help the passengers," he said.

There were also flashes of heroism. Co-pilot Rohman had turned back towards
the cabin and saw a large elderly woman trapped in her seat with the flames
approaching. He couldn't lift her and frantically beckoned through the
gaping hole in the plane's side to three Indonesian air force officers
outside. Together, they pulled her to safety.

Quinlan and Hatton were sitting in economy's emergency row above the wing,
but the nearest exit door to their right was covered in flames. Hatton had
been nearly knocked out by an overhead locker, so Quinlan grabbed him and
headed for the exit opposite.

"We were probably among the first five people who got out, and I looked back
at the body - it was engulfed in flames, and I knew if there was an
explosion and we stayed there, we wouldn't be alive," Quinlan said.

"Everything pretty much from two seats in front of us was gone. I can't
imagine how anyone survived in the front of the plane."

Business class took the hardest impact, with the cockpit almost severed from
the body of the plane.

But there was at least one survivor, a most extraordinary one. A dazed
Cynthia Banham looked down and saw flames around her legs and on both sides.

Her back was broken by the impact, but Banham's physique was strong.

She had embarked on a get-fit training program several years ago so that she
could take part in marathons. That - and the kind of adrenalin rush sparked
by impending doom - gave her the strength she needed.

Somehow she pulled herself from her seat and dragged her badly burned body
towards an exit. She tumbled from the plane, then rolled herself across a
rice paddy before being rescued by onlookers.

By then flames had engulfed the front section of the plane and those inside.
Several died still trapped in their seats.

The passengers on either side of Banham, Mellish and O'Neill, never emerged.
Australians Sudjarat, Brice and Steel were also among the 21 dead.

IN INDONESIA, tough questions are being asked about possible human error, or
maintenance failure, or the state of the 15-year-old plane. The pilot and
crew are being held by authorities as the investigation continues.

In both countries, the mourning has begun.

The Canberra press gallery stopped work and gathered quietly on Thursday in
memory of their colleague Mellish. There was a suggestion that TV cameras be
brought in to film the moment; it was resisted. This was not to be
journalists inserting themselves into the news but journalists privately
mourning one of their own. It had been a painful 24 hours as they waited,
along with Mellish's family and friends, for news of his fate. "For a while
we hoped that he may have goofed off and gone surfing," said Laura Tingle,
Mellish's bureau chief when he was assigned to Canberra from 2002 to 2004.

"Then the reports started to come through that he had indeed been on the
plane. Then there were conflicting reports that he had been found alive in
hospital only suffering a broken leg. Unfortunately, this was not the case."

Mellish, who would have turned 37 next week, was the Jakarta correspondent,
a job he recently described as perfect for him: "I can do what I want,
there's lots going on over here and I can write what I want, no one is
telling me what to do and I go surfing when I want."

His younger sister Caroline, who flew to Jakarta after the crash, yesterday
said that he had achieved both his dreams before he died: to be a foreign
correspondent and to win a Walkley Award. "He was living the dream life and
I'm sure there were a lot of people who were envious of what he was doing,"
she said. "I don't think there was ever a dull moment and he loved
everything he did."

His former boss Tingle said in her eulogy, "If you met Morgan, it was hard
not to notice how he looked like he had just skipped off some Elysian scene
on a Grecian urn. His relaxed view of life meant I, personally, would not
have been surprised if he'd absent-mindedly pulled a lyre out from his desk
drawer occasionally and given it a few zings.

"We all have different ways of dealing with the sometimes confrontational
and intense demands of press gallery journalism. Some of us enjoy the thrill
of the chase. Some of us live off our indignation. Sometimes we are just
dragged along by the drama.

"Morgan's laid-back, almost diffident style could leave the more excitable
amongst us somewhat alarmed on occasion. You'd find yourself saying to him,
'Now, Morgan, you are going to mention that the Prime Minister has been
kidnapped in the lead to your story, aren't you?' He'd beam at you
seraphically and you'd never be quite sure whether he was quite taking in
the drama of the moment.

"Yet there the copy would be the next morning, impeccable, thorough and
professional." Mellish's greatest journalistic triumph was a series he wrote
on former Reserve Bank board member Rob Gerard, which won a Walkley award in
2006.

Elizabeth Strutt is a parishioner at St Canice's. She remembers Liz O'Neill
as someone who had a mischievous sense of fun, as well as a strong moral
compass: "If I were to use one word in regard to Liz, it would be that she
had great integrity. She was honest and she followed through. If she said
something she meant it. It was all based on good old-fashioned values."

It is difficult to imagine how her family will recover from her death. They
have already lost one adult daughter, O'Neill's sister: "That was sudden
too. She died of an aneurism. (O'Neill's mother) rang me yesterday. She said
'I've just got over the first one. How do I get over losing another
daughter?' "

Jo Hutton, Oxfam's humanitarian co-ordinator for East Asia, said she had
worked with Allison Sudradjat in PNG arranging rice, oil and flour drops to
remote settlements. She said Sudjarat moved between government, military and
aid personnel with equal skill.

"She had a very warm, very professional manner. Certainly for AusAID she was
among the most liked and respected of staff," Hutton said. "She was one of
the best bosses I ever worked for, and you don't say that very often."

Sudradjat met her Indonesian husband, Ris, when she was working at the
Indonesian embassy in Canberra, before she joined AusAID. Her interest in
Asia was triggered when she began studying Indonesian at high school in
Perth, from where she won a rare scholarship to study at the ANU.

Her colleagues were taking some comfort this week that Ris and their four
children aged from 11 to 17, had the support of Indonesian relatives.

Speaking of the AFP's losses, Assistant Commissioner Frank Prendergast, the
AFP's counter-terrorism chief recalled: "Brice Steele (was) an individual of
outstanding ability, very intelligent, a very good communicator.

"Mark Scott was clearly a high calibre individual with a distinguished
policing career," Prendergast said. "We have lost two people of very high
quality. It's a really heavy blow to lose people of that calibre.

"It's fair to say it's clearly a heavy blow, personally and professionally."

He spoke for many Australians touched by the tragedy.

with AAP

Mark Forbes is The Age's Indonesia correspondent. Ian Munro is a senior
writer and Karen Kissane is law and justice editor.

(F)AIR USE NOTICE: All original content and/or articles and graphics in this
message are copyrighted, unless specifically noted otherwise. All rights to
these copyrighted items are reserved. Articles and graphics have been placed
within for educational and discussion purposes only, in compliance with
"Fair Use" criteria established in Section 107 of the Copyright Act of 1976.
The principle of "Fair Use" was established as law by Section 107 of The
Copyright Act of 1976. "Fair Use" legally eliminates the need to obtain
permission or pay royalties for the use of previously copyrighted materials
if the purposes of display include "criticism, comment, news reporting,
teaching, scholarship, and research." Section 107 establishes four criteria
for determining whether the use of a work in any particular case qualifies
as a "fair use". A work used does not necessarily have to satisfy all four
criteria to qualify as an instance of "fair use". Rather, "fair use" is
determined by the overall extent to which the cited work does or does not
substantially satisfy the criteria in their totality. If you wish to use
copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you
must obtain permission from the copyright owner. For more information go to:
http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtml 

THIS DOCUMENT MAY CONTAIN COPYRIGHTED MATERIAL. COPYING AND DISSEMINATION IS
PROHIBITED WITHOUT PERMISSION OF THE COPYRIGHT OWNERS.

 



[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]



------------------------ Yahoo! Groups Sponsor --------------------~--> 
Great things are happening at Yahoo! Groups.  See the new email design.
http://us.click.yahoo.com/lOt0.A/hOaOAA/yQLSAA/TySplB/TM
--------------------------------------------------------------------~-> 

--------------------------
Want to discuss this topic?  Head on over to our discussion list, [EMAIL 
PROTECTED]
--------------------------
Brooks Isoldi, editor
[EMAIL PROTECTED]

http://www.intellnet.org

  Post message: [email protected]
  Subscribe:    [EMAIL PROTECTED]
  Unsubscribe:  [EMAIL PROTECTED]


*** FAIR USE NOTICE. This message contains copyrighted material whose use has 
not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. OSINT, as a part of 
The Intelligence Network, is making it available without profit to OSINT 
YahooGroups members who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the 
included information in their efforts to advance the understanding of 
intelligence and law enforcement organizations, their activities, methods, 
techniques, human rights, civil liberties, social justice and other 
intelligence related issues, for non-profit research and educational purposes 
only. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of the copyrighted material 
as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use 
this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' 
you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.
For more information go to:
http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtml 
Yahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/

<*> Your email settings:
    Individual Email | Traditional

<*> To change settings online go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/join
    (Yahoo! ID required)

<*> To change settings via email:
    mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] 
    mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
    [EMAIL PROTECTED]

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
    http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/
 

Reply via email to