http://www.humanevents.com/article.php?id=19728

Coming Catastrophe: Four Solutions to Four Mysteries of America and Iran 

by John Batchelor  (More by this author
<file:///C:\search.php?author_name=John+Batchelor> )

Posted: 03/09/2007

The four <http://www.humanevents.com/article.php?id=19673>  diplomatic
mysteries can now be addressed with the particular twists of the moment.
What unites all of these solutions is that America will make nearly any
concession to its adversaries and allies in order to find a tolerable exit
from Iraq and Afghanistan, yet the adversaries and allies do not and will
not guarantee that America can achieve its aims.

1. Why is America treating with its enemy Iran over Iraq? America is
participating in the regional talks in Baghdad in a hasty and lonely search
for an exit from Iraq. America's principal desire is to end the war and, in
the ringing words of an earlier crisis in American foreign policy, "to bring
peace with honor" to the region. The Maliki government wants America to
leave quickly, yet opposes and sabotages the recently invented American
efforts to mitigate its failures with the so-called surge tactics to impose
security in Baghdad.

What especially bedevils this tangle is that America will not acknowledge
the fait accompli that the Maliki government, and the Shia militias, and the
cutthroats of the Ministry of Interior and Defense, are completely and
willingly allied with Tehran. Also, America will not acknowledge that the
Kurdish faction in the north is completely and willingly allied with Tehran.
Also, America will not acknowledge that Iraq is where it wants to be under a
centralized, well-armed majority, the Shia, who are linked culturally and
practically to Iran.

The odd men out in this scenario, the Sunnis of Anbar and Baghdad provinces,
are not in alliance with Tehran and are on the defensive.

The Sunnis do have protection from the various clan apparatuses in Syria,
Jordan and Saudi Arabia, and they are not likely to be displaced, only
marginalized, in the coming Islamic Republic of Iraq.

Al Qaeda in Iraq, entirely radical-Sunni-based, called Wahhabists, are no
one's ally and are treated by all parties as provocateurs and crazies. At
their worst, al Qaeda characters in Iraq are homicidal maniacs like the late
Zarqawi, who believe slaughtering Shia is a holy pursuit; at their best they
are regarded by Tehran as sufficiently anti-American to be tolerated for
now.

2. Why is Saudi Arabia treating with its adversary Iran? The Saudi princes
have determined that the only way they can survive in the immediate future
is to ally completely and willingly with Tehran.

Saudi Arabia understands that America is trying to make a deal with Tehran
to hand over the whole of Iraq if America can exit without a nightmare. Then
again, America gone from Iraq is the al-Saud nightmare.

The House of Saud knows that Tehran will next come looking to take control
of the Shia of Eastern Arabia, on the Persian Gulf, which is the basis of
the Saudi Arabian oil infrastructure. In order to postpone this gruesome
logic as long as possible, King Abdullah now makes a hudna, or truce, with
Iran that baldly surrenders everything, promising to pay and pay, to
cooperate with energy matters, as well as to support the Tehran plans with
Hamas, Syria and Hizballah to degrade Israel.

The only thing that the House of Saud fears worse than Tehran ascendant is
the Islamist-jihadists ascendant. Saudi princes madly plead with Tehran that
it must protect it from the al Qaeda leadership that will soon enough come
looking for vengeance and victory. Tehran promises, in the words of
Ahmadinejad, "to devise some measures to prevent the enemies from harming
the Muslim world and to foil their plots." However, this is not a guarantee
to the House of Saud -- a hudna lasts only as long as it is expedient for
the parties-- because Tehran cannot and will not constrain al Qaeda.

3. Why is the Taliban leader Mullah Dadullah boasting of a spring offensive
against America? The neo-Taliban, sponsored and protected by the Pakistani
regime, just as was the original Taliban, is also an ally of al Qaeda. The
neo-Taliban, observing that the Americans are retreating from Iraq, aims to
demonstrate its power by displaying its own version of a surge. America
wants to find a tolerable exit from Afghanistan; but rather than accept the
known fact that the neo-Taliban is a Pakistani creature, America is forcing
the Karzai government at Kabul to make even more concessions to the very
same tribal leaders who make up the recruiting strength of the neo-Taliban.

Also, Pakistan's President Pervez Musharraf needs to control Afghanistan in
order to offset the threat of the rising superpower India. Musharraf and his
military and intelligence base in Islamabad are convinced that in order to
survive a clash with India, Pakistan must control Afghanistan to its flank
and rear, as it has since partition, as it did even before it was a state,
with the khanates of the frontier, where the British fought in vain to
protect the riches of India. Today, allowing Afghanistan to become a viable
democratic state under the control of America and NATO would be a mortal
threat to Pakistan’s future as an Islamic republic. Vice President Dick
Cheney’s recent dashing visit to Musharraf yielded a big fish of the
Islamist-jihadists that was meant merely as a facile gesture of obedience.
In order to hurry America out of Afghanistan, Musharraf now sponsors the
neo-Taliban spring offensive to degrade and break the American and NATO
forces. Also, Musharraf certainly knows that al Qaeda is resurgent inside
his cities, and that it openly operates new training camps in the border
region. Musharraf must get America out before al Qaeda strikes mainland
America again and the Americans come hunting with fire in their eyes.

In addition, the recent Pakistani nuclear weapon-capable short- and
long-range missile tests were another way to intimidate India, to
consternate America and to demonstrate Pakistan's resolve to survive no
matter how bad it gets in Iran.

4. Why is America treating with its adversary, the nuclear weapon-wielding
rogue North Korea? America's February concessions to North Korea with regard
nuclear weaponeering, racketeering, drug-running, money laundering and
counterfeiting is a sloppy and frustrated attempt to demonstrate some
statesmanship success to its allies. America knows that North Korea is the
research and development facility for the Iranian ballistic missile program
and for the Iranian nuclear weapons program: Tehran paid for and
participated in the missile tests and nuclear weapon test of last year.
America also knows that North Korea will not change its ways for an
agreement that does not provide intrusive, enforceable inspections. In a
rush, America did not even preclude the possibility of North Korea now
adding a uranium nuclear fuel cycle to its extant plutonium fuel bomb
arsenal. America is beingbullied by its allies in the six-party talks into a
bad deal -- arguably worse than 1994's broken promises -- simply because
American diplomacy has exhausted its nativeshrewdness in these perilous
days. “If we continue this approach, what is already a bad deal will become
a dangerous deal,” writes former United Nations Ambassador John Bolton
recently in the Wall Street Journal, “whether we make it with North Korea
directly or in the six-party talks.”

The collision of America and Iran is viewed by the major powers to be a dark
future, yet no one at this date believes it can be stopped.

Russia thinks it's unstoppable, and will ride out the storm as an energy
supplier for Asia, Europe and Africa while the Persian Gulf energy cutoff
rocks the global economy. China thinks it's unstoppable and will ride it out
as long as it can get energy from Russia. Europe thinks it's unstoppable and
will ride it out dependent upon Russia for energy and upon American power,
even in retreat, for its security.

Finally, there are strong reports from overseas that Russia and Europe,
especially Berlin, have warned Tehran that, in the coming battles, Israel
must not be destroyed, that a mortal attack on Israel is a red line not to
be crossed. Russia especially intends a long-term relationship with Israel,
chiefly because of the nearly million Russian-origin citizens now in the
Holy Land. Israel, keenly aware of the approaching storm, is preparing to
defend itself against Syria, with or without American shoulders alongside.
America aims to support Israel, but in the meantime pressures Israel to make
more and more concessions to Tehran's surrogates in Gaza, the West Bank,
Lebanon and Syria.

  _____  


In March 1914, the mystery of the "Russophobe Chorus" -- why is the
state-directed German press threatening war with Russia and the Triple
Entente? -- engaged analysts across Europe. The explanations were cautious
and credible. Some said it was Germany looking to make a better commercial
deal in the Black Sea region by rattling Russian confidence beforehand. Some
said it was a "counter blast" to recent visits by the Triple Entente
principals, King George to Paris, and President Poincaré of France to the
Romanov court at St. Petersburg. 

This particular interpretation so threatened London counselors that they
defended Britain by reminding Germany that it had said the two extant
competing alliances were a "bulwark," not a danger to continental stability.
Other analysts said that the German bullying of Russia was meant for
domestic ears, to shake loose more money from the Reichstag, perhaps even to
shake loose more money from the lawmakers in Vienna in order better to arm
the fragile Austria-Hungary. "The French bogy is all very well for Germany,"
argued the analysts in the London Times, "but the Russian bogy is preferable
to strike terror on the Danube as well as on the Spree." On balance, the
analysts found in favor of the positive interpretation that the "Russophobe
Chorus" in Berlin would strengthen the bonds of the Triple Entente and
"secure the mass of Frenchmen" in a commitment to military readiness.

A haunting incident on the French border, on March 5 at Montbéliard near
Belfort, a few days after the Russophobe outburst, at first glance seemed to
support the sanguine stronger-bonds interpretation. A postmaster
accidentally distributed French war department circulars announcing
mobilization. Between 9 p.m. and midnight, the men of the town came running,
prepared to go to war with Germany at first light.

"No great harm was done," read the English newspaper report based upon the
French newspaper Temps, adding the happy surprise that Paris had discovered
that even in an industrial, heavily "socialistic" and iconoclastic district,
"the men were quite ready to answer the call of duty."

The London Times headlined the small item, "Mobilization in Error." A deeper
interpretation is that the Frenchmen of Montbéliard knew of the rumors of
war between the Triple Entente and the Triple Alliance, between France and
Germany, from the newspapers reporting the most esteemed diplomatic voices
in the capitals. The Montbéliards were not in error. They were simply early.
The mysteries of war warnings are supposed to be early. Hearing the
mysteries of war warnings is supposed to be difficult. In 1914, what
followed in five months, we know now, was the end of the world that the
Europeans knew, forever.

In 2007, what follows for America is more mysteries of war warnings.

 



[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]



------------------------ Yahoo! Groups Sponsor --------------------~--> 
See what's inside the new Yahoo! Groups email.
http://us.click.yahoo.com/0It09A/bOaOAA/yQLSAA/TySplB/TM
--------------------------------------------------------------------~-> 

--------------------------
Want to discuss this topic?  Head on over to our discussion list, [EMAIL 
PROTECTED]
--------------------------
Brooks Isoldi, editor
[EMAIL PROTECTED]

http://www.intellnet.org

  Post message: [email protected]
  Subscribe:    [EMAIL PROTECTED]
  Unsubscribe:  [EMAIL PROTECTED]


*** FAIR USE NOTICE. This message contains copyrighted material whose use has 
not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. OSINT, as a part of 
The Intelligence Network, is making it available without profit to OSINT 
YahooGroups members who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the 
included information in their efforts to advance the understanding of 
intelligence and law enforcement organizations, their activities, methods, 
techniques, human rights, civil liberties, social justice and other 
intelligence related issues, for non-profit research and educational purposes 
only. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of the copyrighted material 
as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use 
this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' 
you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.
For more information go to:
http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtml 
Yahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/

<*> Your email settings:
    Individual Email | Traditional

<*> To change settings online go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/join
    (Yahoo! ID required)

<*> To change settings via email:
    mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] 
    mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
    [EMAIL PROTECTED]

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
    http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/
 

Reply via email to