http://english.daralhayat.com/opinion/OPED/04-2007/Article-20070429-3d148721
-c0a8-10ed-01b2-ede8b9201299/story.html

Childish Bet In American Circles to Win Over Syria and Iran


Raghida Dergham      Al-Hayat     - 29/04/07//



American intellectual and academic institutions are mistaken if they allow
their rage against US President George W. Bush's war on Iraq to make them
disregard the necessary roles they have to assume in formulating a correct,
reformative and intelligent US policy toward the Middle East. Some of them
promote 'winning over' as a recipe for the US forces' withdrawal from Iraq,
criticizing the US President for his refusal to engage in charming Syria and
Iran, in particular. Others totally overlook the requirements of
establishing a partnership with the government and popular moderation ranks
to form the most important sequence of defeating the extremist forces and
terrorism in Iraq, as well as in the Arab and Islamic World. The advocates
of this stance instinctively refuse anything that would put Israel under
scrutiny or expose it to inevitable pressure if the US is serious in fixing
its relationship with the Arab and Islamic World and protecting its national
interests.

They invent every pretext and excuse to exempt Israel from accountability
for its violations and discharge it from the requirements of peacemaking.
Some others resort to activate bilateral negotiations between Syria and
Israel to ease the international pressure meant to achieve a breakthrough in
the Palestinian-Israeli track and forestall the Arab Peace Initiative, which
has brought the Palestine issue to the fore.

There are some who deliberately turn a blind eye on the crucial importance
of the establishment of an international tribunal to put an end to the
impunity era that shaped the political assassinations trend, thus striking
their own morality. The establishment of such a tribunal is the key to
democracy, accountability and transparency, not only for Lebanon but also
for the entire Arab region, contrary to what is perceived or alleged by
think-tanks, experts and politicians that the war on Iraq was for the sake
of democracy. There are also many advocates of winning over the Islamic
Republic of Iran - some of them are promoting a deal in order to avoid a
military confrontation or to possess nuclear capabilities. Others are
talking about the need to strengthen Iranian supreme leader Ayatollah Ali
Khamenei and veteran politician and former President, Ali Akbar Rafsanjani,
to be able to overthrow the current president, Mahmoud Ahmadinejad, as if
toppling him is the key to the salvation of the US from Iraq. This serious
trend ignores what these two men are presenting, mainly overthrowing
democracy, strengthening personal powers, and suppressing any opposite
popular Iranian attitudes.

The American uprising against the war on Iraq came belatedly, although the
public opinion, the media, Congress and the Republican and Democratic
parties did not scrutinize the consequences of dragging the US into this war
during the period of preparation, planning and justification. What is
happening now is almost an uprising on the self and on the George W. Bush
administration, as well, because of the consequences of this war, which
exposed the US and uncovered shameful stories about practices of the US
army, in addition to causalities and slipping into the quagmire of
occupation and the cycle of civil war.

The Liberals, Democrats and Republicans who are at loggerheads with the
neoconservatives, who are washing their hands today of the failure of the
war on Iraq: they are all blaming George W. Bush, completely forgetting
their roles, which ranged from silence, voting for the war and failure to
assume the responsibility of opposing the war and forestalling the
neoconservatives and their definite arrogance.

They are bidding higher on their deliberate missing what they had failed to
do when it was crucial, as they could have actually opposed the rush to the
war under various pretexts. When the matter turns to mere hatred of the
president without self-accountability, everything seems to be opposable as
long as it is approved by George W. Bush. In fact, this act implies somewhat
childish behavior. So long as these sectors had not borne their
responsibilities before the war, which was waged by its makers in the name
of vengeance, they are not shouldering their responsibilities in deeply
examining how to get out of the war in the least possible rational way.
Therefore, they call for winning over Syria and Iran, as if it was a magic
wand.

May Tehran be ready to accept this charming campaign since it may spare the
region, if ready, the disasters in Iraq and which may possibly move to
Lebanon upon a decree by the Islamic Republic of Iran. In fact, the ruling
institution in the Islamic Republic wants to take back the rule and
popularity from the president, who has taken off the white gloves and
exposed the true nature of the ruling regime in Iran. It is an internal
battle between the pillars of the ruling regime itself, in light of the
mobilization of popular and government consensus over Iran's 'right' to
possess nuclear capability, which the government is claiming to be confined
to peaceful and developmental applications, even though it insists on
enriching large quantities of uranium.

This internal disagreement is not about the foundations of foreign policy,
nor is it about the identity of governance in the Islamic Republic. It is
not about how to correct relations with the US, nor is it in facilitating
the desired withdrawal of the US from Iraq. The traditional ruling
institution in Iran is no less enthusiastic to support Hezbollah in Lebanon
than Mahmoud Ahmadinejad, nor is it less generous in transferring funds and
weapons to Hezbollah via Syria and others than the Presidency and the
Revolutionary Guard.

What is not wanted by the leaders of the traditional ruling institution,
especially Rafsanjani, is that Ahmadinejad's preparation for a military
strike on Iran may lead to a considerable financial loss they would incur.
Ahmadinejad has not entered the 'club' of the seniors who gain personal
benefits from wars and from 'practicing' patriotism and nationalism. This is
why he is using foreign policy to enhance his internal political, and not
financial, stand. Indeed, he is troubling the water of Khamenei and
Rafsanjani and their followers, since he is using artificial stupidity and
reveals the opposite of what this class of the ruling regime has pretended
to be; that is to say, that they were different. In fact, the difference is
about the methods, not the nature and orientations of the authority in Iran.

Some advocates of the war on Iraq betted on Rafsanjani as a natural partner
for the expansion of 'Petrolstan'm stretching form eastern Saudi Arabia to
Iraq and Iran. But Ahmadinejad's arrival to power put the spoke in the wheel
of the Iraq war philosophers who wanted a sectarian war to serve their
partition and fragmentation schemes. They believed that Rafsanjani was the
best sponsor in a silent partnership with Israel and in the Iranian-Israeli
and Iranian-American bargain relationships. Ahmadinejad used the Israeli
issue to implicitly expose Rafsanjani in a way that strengthens
Ahmadinejad's internal position and expands his Islamic popularity against
the Arab regimes.

Toppling the Arab regimes is a common denominator between the Iranian
revolution - especially Ayatollah Khomeini, Khamenei, Rafsanjani and
Ahmadinejad - and the neoconservatives, who claimed a wish to spread
democracy. However, the war on Iraq strengthened most Arab regimes and
provided great services to Israel and Iran by removing Iraq from the
strategic equations of each of them. Now, in time of American wrath over
this war and its cost, the beneficiaries want to pretend to be the victim;
hence the danger of the standpoints sponsored by some in the US.

A young expert, who is enthusiastic about having different, new ideas in the
absence of American options in Iraq and Iran, innovated a notion based on
empowering Rafsanjani and Khamenei to make them capable of seizing
Ahmadinejad's authority. Thus, according to in his own view, the rug will be
pulled out from under the feet of Hezbollah. At this point, China and Russia
can be addressed in the language of interests, so that China can give energy
guarantees and Russia give guarantees in the field of the development of
Iran's peaceful nuclear program, as well as in the field of re-armament.
Hence, it would be possible to find a face-saving formula for the US
withdrawal from Iraq.

By so doing, according to this view, through a deal with Rafsanjani and
Khamenei to topple Mahmoud Ahmadinejad comes salvation.

This idea is somewhat childish and dangerous to a greater extent, unless it
is based on prior garantees from the Rafsanjani-Khamenei camp for the
nuclear and regional ambitions of the Islamic Republic.

It is childish and serious; for one reason, because it entraps the US in the
speculations of the Iranian experienced politicians and will never come out
victorious no matter what it does. Rather, strengthening a camp at the
expense of another inside the ruling institution of the Islamic Republic
means that the US will enter once again as a party in a coup in Iran, but
that of a different kind. Moreover, strengthening any wing in the Islamic
Republic with American effective assistance means another betrayal of the
democracy promises in the Middle East. Some parties in Iran will consider
the US as the biggest traitor if the latter embraces the idea of
strengthening the Khamenei-Rafsanjani camp to have control over the ruling
regime in Tehran. The effect will be a further stringency in the despotic
rule of the mullahs over women, freedom, and democracy in the name of
getting rid of the phenomenon of Mahmoud Ahmadinejad, as if this phenomenon
is the whole problem and extremism is confined to Ahmadinejad, while the
section alleging moderation is as radical as Ahmadinejad himself.

It is important for the traditional institution of the ruling regime to rein
in the revolutionary and hazardous presidency, but to gain confidence now
depends on the guarantees it will provide at the nuclear and regional levels
and within the framework of internal freedoms. If there are some within the
American intellectual and academic establishment who believe that winning
over Tehran is the key to a happy ending, they should consider beyond the
disapproval of Rafsanjani-Khamenei along with Ahmadinejad's denial of the
Holocaust or beyond the anger at George W. Bush's policies in Iraq.

The division of Iran's roles in Iraq is looming on the horizon, alongside
the rivalry between Iranian leaders on how to deal with the US in Iraq and,
at the same time, not to push it for immediate or near withdrawal. Iran,
with its two wings of the presidency and the traditional institution, does
not want the withdrawal of the American forces, because these forces are
undertaking missions instead of it, leading to securing the balances of
power that are loyal to Tehran. A US withdrawal now would turn Iraq into a
dangerous neighbor for Iran, threatening Iranian regional ambitions,
restricting its powers and threatening the Islamic Republic if the war in
Iraq extends to it, at a time when its economy is on the wane. Accordingly,
one of the available options within Iraq and toward Iran is not military
action, strengthening the Islamic Republic, but rather a military withdrawal
from Iraq and redeployment aboard aircraft carriers.

If the traditional institution in Iran is willing to conclude a deal for
cooperation and understanding with the US, it must include Iraq, Lebanon and
Palestine, along with understandings on the nuclear issue. In this context,
the wooers should understand the US central relations with Arab moderation
ranks at the government, elite and popular levels, rather than drifting to
winning over Tehran and its allies, instead of the constant fear of
addressing the issue of Israel and the importance of resolving the
Israeli-Palestinian dispute.

The two major beneficiaries of the Iraq war, namely, Iran and Israel, owe
the US. Their benefit from the Iraq war is enormous. Since the American
national interest is threatened by this war, the wooers should support the
US policy when it is good, rather than rising above the scrutiny of its
benefits for the American national interest simply because it is the George
Bush administration's policy. In this regard, the Arab Peace Initiative with
Israel, which was adopted in the Riyadh Summit last month, is an example.
The Bush administration, as well as the majority of the world, supports this
initiative, but most intellectual institutions and advocates of friendliness
brush this very important initiative aside and reduce it to the inability of
the 'lame duck' administration to make a US main foreign policy toward
Israel in the last two years and amid early elections.

These attitudes are locked in some sort of bankruptcy, particularly as the
requirement of dealing with the Israeli-Palestinian issue is clear to all
and that the protection of Israel from peace and its commitments will cost
the US dearly, not only in the Iraq war, but also in the war on terror.
Israel itself will pay dearly if it continues to refuse to make peace,
sometimes under the pretext of the weakness of the government or allegation
that it is unable to make concessions, and sometimes under the arrogance of
a government that needs nothing but to dictate. Perhaps a day may come when
moderation ranks say to Israel: "That's enough. We're washing our hands of
attempts to make peace. The arena is now open between you and extremism,
where moderation is no longer a buffer zone."

In other words, the American intellectual, political and media institutions
are required to assume their responsibilities toward the requirements of
protecting the US national interests rationally and bravely, instead of
codifying their anger at Bush, wooing Syria and Iran, or supporting Israel
blindly without scrutiny or accountability. For example, what is happening
in the Lebanese arena draws the attention of the American media institutions
casually without understanding the dimensions of the events in Lebanon and
their impact on regional relations, the future of democracy, and the need to
end the era of impunity. What is happening in Lebanon is a clear indication
that George W. Bush's policy in Iraq was different from that in Lebanon. His
policy in Lebanon comes within the framework of international consensus,
while that in Iraq was individual. This is exactly what those who are
enraged and the camp of wooers in the American arena are missing: they do
not differentiate between policies and anger blinds them and prevents them
from rational thinking.

 



[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]



--------------------------
Want to discuss this topic?  Head on over to our discussion list, [EMAIL 
PROTECTED]
--------------------------
Brooks Isoldi, editor
[EMAIL PROTECTED]

http://www.intellnet.org

  Post message: [email protected]
  Subscribe:    [EMAIL PROTECTED]
  Unsubscribe:  [EMAIL PROTECTED]


*** FAIR USE NOTICE. This message contains copyrighted material whose use has 
not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. OSINT, as a part of 
The Intelligence Network, is making it available without profit to OSINT 
YahooGroups members who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the 
included information in their efforts to advance the understanding of 
intelligence and law enforcement organizations, their activities, methods, 
techniques, human rights, civil liberties, social justice and other 
intelligence related issues, for non-profit research and educational purposes 
only. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of the copyrighted material 
as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use 
this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' 
you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.
For more information go to:
http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtml 
Yahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/

<*> Your email settings:
    Individual Email | Traditional

<*> To change settings online go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/join
    (Yahoo! ID required)

<*> To change settings via email:
    mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] 
    mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
    [EMAIL PROTECTED]

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
    http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/
 

Reply via email to