http://www.frontpagemag.com/Articles/ReadArticle.asp?ID=28816
My Day in Court         
By Lee
<file:///C:/Program%20Files/Common%20Files/Microsoft%20Shared/Stationery/aut
hors.asp?ID=2106> Kaplan
FrontPageMagazine.com | June 20, 2007 

On May 4, 2006, I went to UC Berkeley to attend an Israel Independence Day
celebration. Unlike in past years, when a large crowd of students would be
present with Israeli flags, balloons and music, there was a dismal turnout:
Less than ten people on a campus that has such a large Jewish population. 

As usual, the anti-Israel crowd was out in full force. Students
<http://www.discoverthenetworks.org/groupProfile.asp?grpid=6379> for Justice
in Palestine (SJP) was handing out flyers calling for a boycott of Israel
and businesses in America that might be sympathetic to the Jewish state.
Part of the International
<http://www.discoverthenetworks.org/groupProfile.asp?grpid=6233> Solidarity
Movement at UC Berkeley, the SJP began the campus divestment campaign
against Israel in 2002. It has since spread to college campuses nationwide.
The effect of this nationwide anti-Israel campaign is that, by 2006, Jewish
groups were reluctant to hold a major event at Cal. 

One of the anti-Israel students that day, Yaman Salahi, a member of the
board of directors of the SJP, handed me a flyer promoting the Arab League
boycott of Israel. I pointed out that the historical information on the
flyer was inaccurate, inflating the number of Palestinian Arab refuges well
beyond their true number. The student at first began to debate me. There was
nothing personal in this encounter, so I handed the student my business card
and suggested that his club invite me to campus where we could have a lively
debate on the issue of the Israeli-Palestinian dispute. After all, this was
a major university and place of learning.

Then Salahi turned hostile. Seeing that I had written many articles and
exposes on the ISM, including here at FrontPage, the student began to berate
me and to call me a "racist." As the others from his SJP group gathered
around me and began ranting at me and photographing me, I beat a hasty
retreat. 

Salahi stalked me across the campus. Before becoming a journalist, I had
worked fourteen years on the Cal campus and had a Palestinian Arab friend
there whom I met that day. As we were chatting, my stalker suddenly showed
up and butted into our conversation. "You wouldn't be talking with him if
you knew who he was," he told my friend.&n bsp; "Why not?" my friend asked.
"Because he supports Israel," came the reply. My friend asked the student if
he was a Palestinian and he replied in Arabic that he was Syrian. He
demanded to know why my friend was even talking to me. My friend, in turn,
replied, "Look, he has his opinion and I have mine. We don't have to agree
with each other to be friends." The student was asked to leave.

But that was not the end of it. A few days later a friend called to tell me
that a blog had been set up exclusively dedicated to attacking me personally
as a journalist. Dubbed Lee Kaplan Watch, it  was supposed to be an
examination of my writing and research about the ISM to "discredit" me. The
headline read, "Lee Kaplan is a self-proclaimed 'investigative journalist'
who "represents the very worst of journalistic integrity and honesty,
violating ethical norms by impersonating others and writing fabricated
biographies of various persons involved in campus activism."

The headline also declared me a threat to academic freedom. The site did not
so much criticize my politics or challenge the information in my articles.
Instead, it sought to smear me, to prevent me from using my right of free
speech to report on the ISM and, ultimately, to render me unemployable as a
journalist.

Over the next several months, articles appeared in bold headlines suggesting
that I had been sued for libel -- harmful to any journalist's reputation --
that I engaged in theft, that I violated confidentiality agreements, that I
solicited donations for terrorist organizations, that I harassed families of
pro-PLO activists, and that I fabricated all of my articles from whole
cloth. These were serious allegations. None of them, however, were true.
Indeed, none of them were even based on any real evidence. 

I decided to take action. To that end, I immediately contacted the school's
Dean of Student Conduct and complained that I should be able to come to
campus without being followed and harassed in person and on the Internet.
The dean claimed that there was nothing he could do. 

That was false. In reality, the dean could easily have reprimanded the
student and warned him against harassing a visitor to campus. Had I been a
woman, UC Berkeley would doubtless have taken disciplinary action. But I was
a writer and a Jew who frequently defends Israel in the press. So, false
accusations of criminal activity and libel were acceptable. A meeting with
the student was suggested to ask him to stop, but ultimately the student
refused to attend. The university did not insist.

Fellow journalists advised me the smear site was actually a compliment: "It
shows how effective your work is that they are doing this to you," they
would say. But there was a downside. As a journalist, as in any other
profession, my reputation for being honest in what I report is vital to my
finding work, anywhere, at any time. The website had few viewers, true, but
it nonetheless contained libelous information about me that could hurt my
career-the aim of its creators.

And it got worse. Salahi -- the site's proprietor -- became even more
obsessed with attacking me. He arranged to have content changed on my
websites and those of my publishers. Unknown to me, he began emailing
threats to people I do business with and to my publishers too. The letters
accused me of defamation against unnamed individuals and of causing
"material damage" to countless people. They concluded with an ominous
threat: If they did not stop doing business with me, the student had a wide
circle of friends on the Internet with whom he could interlink and attack
their businesses. I lost two literary jobs at the same time the emails were
sent -- not because of my work, but because the publishers were concerned
for their businesses after seeing how I was being defamed on the Web.

They were right to be concerned. One Canadian editor discovered that an
article of mine she published had had the photos switched of an ISM cell in
Boston with photos of me as Big Brother like from the book 1984, costing her
considerable time and money to have them fixed, a problem that nearly caused
me to lose my job working for her. 

The Cal student at Berkeley took great glee in what he had done. In detail,
he explained on his site how he had gone about smearing my reputation,
something that would later become evidence in court. He also began
interlinking over with o ther web blogs set up by other students and other
people active in the ISM and even began sending out whatever false
accusations he could to web sources, citing himself anonymously as a viable
news source. Incredibly, many of the other sites printed his calumny. Even
worse, one of his affiliates began running pornographic images of homosexual
and other sex scenes and cartoons with my head photoshopped onto the bodies.
In one, I was a voyeur in a woman's bathroom with an Israeli flag on the
wall. In another, my head was blown off and death threats were included. (It
should be noted these are people who declare themselves "peace activists"
and lovers of humanity. Of course, such people are also frequent defenders
of terrorists and totalitarians overseas.) 

Just as troubling was that, after a while, the site could no longer be
dismissed as obscure. Earlier, an Internet search engine search under my
name brought up in first place archives of my articles at various publishers
like FrontPage, The Israel National News and Canada Free Press.  But through
relentless use of his Internet skills and working with his friends in the
ISM, the SJP student managed to push his smear site to number one on some of
the major search engines whenever my name was entered. The information was
still false. Except now it was more difficult to ignore. Finally, a
colleague at Front Page Magazine contacted me. "I didn't know you were sued
for libel," he said. I wasn't. But even he had seen so much of this stuff on
the Web, he assumed it must be true. It was time to act. 

The student had boasted from day one that I could never sue him. He had a
right to blog, he wrote, no matter what he said that was untrue. Google,
which hosted his blog, and the university were inclined to ignore him.
Besides, as he claimed on his blog, he had offers from lawyers who work with
the ISM to represent him for free if I ever sued. At the same time, a
lawsuit could take years and attorney's fees would cost me more than my
losses that I might never recoup. 

I took the most economical route. I sued him in small claims court for the
maximum amount. But this wasn't easy either. The student began ducking
service of papers for the case. A legal subpoena submitted to UC Berkeley
for the student's address solely to serve him papers was ignored by the
University's attorney even though it was illegal to do so. The student was
again so cocky he posted all the legal documents to the case on the Web
including my personal address, boasting that he was not worried because the
University's and other attorneys advised him he could not be touched. He
then sent me emails demanding "discovery" items for the case. That proved a
mistake. 

By California law, his posting of the legal documents and demands for
information from me that I supplied meant he was legally joined and
established that he knew about the lawsuit. So when the day of the trial
came, and he did not show up because he still managed to duck service, he
lost automatically by a default judgment. He told the judge at a later
hearing that he knew he was sued, but figured by ducking service he need not
appear, he'd just let me chase him. The judge was not impressed, but
permitted him a new hearing anyway.

The student subsequently got the default judgment vacated and a trial was
held. The same tactics of lying and citing himself all over the Web did not
impress the judge and I was awarded over $7,500 in damages after four
hearings over the better part of a year. Still, the legal system allowed him
one last appeal, and this time he could have a lawyer, probably a free one
furnished by another ISM group. I would have to pay for mine.

At the final hearing, Salahi was represented by Adam Gutride of
<http://www.frontpagemag.com/Articles/ReadArticle.asp?ID=25618> Jewish Voice
for Peace, a group that is part of the ISM and
<http://www.nimn.org/articles/whats_new/000343.php> rubs elbows at
Washington conclaves that are funded by Saudi Arabia with the most virulent
and anti-Semitic of anti-Israel groups like
<http://www.frontpagemag.com/Articles/ReadArticle.asp?ID=28299> Al Awda and
even neo-Nazis like David Duke, and which I have exposed in earlier
articles. Most likely Gutride was pro-bono like Salahi boasted. Their
defense? Tons of articles with more libelous accusations that Salahi had
generated by interlinking from his own smear site. They submitted so many
contradictory declarations that the judge didn't buy their defense. I won.

Did Salahi, the SJP and Jewish Voice for Peace learn anything from this? No.
Today on the smear site Salahi writes about the "Failure of the US Justice
System" and vows to persevere in attacking me personally on the Web. He lost
the lawsuit after three judges concurred that he was in the wrong, but to
him it's the fault of the judge, the legal system, my "enormous ego" --
anything and anyone, but himself. And that is the same mentality of those in
the ISM who attack Israel's and America's existence and act as a support
network and as human shi elds for terrorist groups-they are never wrong, and
any amount of lying, or misrepresentation in their goal is a worthy pursuit.

The court awarded me over $7,500 in damages after Salahi's last appeal, yet
Salahi, undeterred, began another Internet campaign claiming the lawsuit had
chilling effects on free speech. Leftist websites cross the country repeated
all his misinformation as if it were true. He was the victim, as was freedom
of speech. All of this despite the fact he was still publishing the libel
against me on his web blog as before. According to Salahi, bloggers should
be allowed to say anything they want, no matter how untrue, on the Web and
reap no repercussions for it. Two Superior Court judges saw things
differently.

At the last trial, the judge tried to probe what was in Salahi's mind when
he conveyed threats to one of my publishers. Salahi claimed he'd made the
threats because I allegedly accused him of being a Nazi (I hadn't) and he
was fearful that should he visit Syria in the future, he might be persecuted
during his visit. The judge only shook his head in disbelief.

Meanwhile, I've learned to set up
<http://www.leekaplandeconstructsleekaplanwatch.blogspot.com/> my own web
log in which I deconstruct the smear articles on Salahi's smear site. Not
one thing he accused me of in my articles has proven true to date save
confusing the nationality of one person in the ISM. Over time my new blog
will appear next to his smear entry on the search engines. Another benefit
of my suit is that another affiliated website of his that was set up with a
different ISP to attack me personally with more smear articles was removed
for violations of service after I showed t hem the results of my lawsuit. I
may sue Google also in the near future. 

One thing is certain: I will continue to expose the illegal and warmongering
activities of the ISM in my research and work. If Salahi and his ISM
supporters thought they could silence me, they were seriously mistaken.

 



[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]



--------------------------
Want to discuss this topic?  Head on over to our discussion list, [EMAIL 
PROTECTED]
--------------------------
Brooks Isoldi, editor
[EMAIL PROTECTED]

http://www.intellnet.org

  Post message: [email protected]
  Subscribe:    [EMAIL PROTECTED]
  Unsubscribe:  [EMAIL PROTECTED]


*** FAIR USE NOTICE. This message contains copyrighted material whose use has 
not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. OSINT, as a part of 
The Intelligence Network, is making it available without profit to OSINT 
YahooGroups members who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the 
included information in their efforts to advance the understanding of 
intelligence and law enforcement organizations, their activities, methods, 
techniques, human rights, civil liberties, social justice and other 
intelligence related issues, for non-profit research and educational purposes 
only. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of the copyrighted material 
as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use 
this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' 
you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.
For more information go to:
http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtml 
Yahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/

<*> Your email settings:
    Individual Email | Traditional

<*> To change settings online go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/join
    (Yahoo! ID required)

<*> To change settings via email:
    mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] 
    mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
    [EMAIL PROTECTED]

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
    http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/
 

Reply via email to