Bin Laden Tape: Timing Over Substance
Saturday September 8, 2007 8:01 PM http://www.guardian.co.uk/worldlatest/story/0,,-6906754,00.html By PAUL HAVEN Associated Press Writer Osama bin Laden's latest message is a hodgepodge of anti-capitalist vitriol, impassioned Islamic evangelism and what can best be described as a twisted attempt at reconciliation: Join us, or we'll kill you. Analysts say the video that came out days before the sixth anniversary of the Sept. 11 attacks is more about timing than substance, an attempt by history's most wanted fugitive to thumb his nose at the forces arrayed against him and remind the world that he hasn't been caught. He ridiculed President Bush on Iraq, saying events there have gotten ``out of control'' and comparing the American leader to ``one who plows and sows the sea: He harvests nothing but failure.'' Despite widespread fears, al-Qaida has so far failed to launch a second attack on the scale of Sept. 11, and many believe the video message - bin Laden's first since 2004 - was also an attempt to stay relevant. Anne Giudicelli, a former French diplomat specializing in the Middle East who now runs the Paris-based consultancy Terrorisc, said bin Laden is well aware that his reappearance on the world stage - looking fit and with his beard dyed a youthful black - was itself a victory that went beyond anything he actually said. ``The objective is obviously to show that despite everything in place against him, he has survived. That's the No. 1 message,'' she said. ``The mere fact of appearing in a video is already a message.'' Louis Caprioli of the risk management firm Geos, and former head of the French intelligence agency DST's anti-terrorism operations, said, ``What's important is that he made an appearance.'' ``The question everyone was asking is, is he dead or alive?'' Caprioli said. ``Now we have proof that he's alive, surprising a lot of experts who thought he was dead.'' In the tape released Friday, bin Laden mentions the anniversary of the Aug. 6, 1945, atomic bomb attack on Hiroshima. He also refers to the Democratic Party's congressional victory in last fall's election and to French President Nicolas Sarkozy, who was elected in May. Ben Venzke of the IntelCenter, a U.S.-based intelligence group that monitors terrorism messages, said the Hiroshima reference means the earliest the tape could have been made is on or shortly after Aug. 9 - less than a month ago. While this was bin Laden's first message in a year, and the first time he appeared in a new video since 2004, other al-Qaida leaders have been using the airwaves more and more in recent months. They have also been reducing the time it takes to get tapes out, a troubling sign that analysts and intelligence experts say could mean that the terror leaders are in greater command than previously feared, and perhaps better able to launch attacks. The new video, which came just days before Tuesday's sixth anniversary of the devastating attacks on New York and Washington, was released on the heels of two thwarted terror plots in Europe in the past week, both linked to al-Qaida. German authorities say a cell there sought to launch an imminent attack on Frankfurt International Airport and America's Ramstein Air Base, among other targets. In Denmark, officials arrested eight people, all of whom were allegedly in contact with what Danish anti-terror officials called ``leading al-Qaida persons.'' Still, bin Laden made no overt threats of new attacks in the video released Friday. In fact, he seemed more concerned with lecturing on the evils of capitalism and the dangers of global warming, and even making reference to the sub-prime mortgage crisis roiling the United States. In the video, bin Laden tells the American people his fighters are duty bound to ``escalate the fighting and killing against you'' in Iraq. But he adds that there is a solution to the bloodshed, saying: ``I invite you to embrace Islam.'' Caprioli said bin Laden took pains in the video to present himself as a statesman, attempting to put himself on the same level as world leaders. ``He wants to change his role, to be a leader who speaks to other leaders, and to cast himself as a champion of the oppressed.'' ``At other times, he has been a lot more threatening,'' Caprioli added. ``Here we don't have a direct threat, because he's talking on a strategic level. He says, 'we will continue operations,' he doesn't say, 'We're going to blow up your planes, your pipelines, your boats.'' Whether the video will resonate on the Arab or Muslim street is not at all clear. In Iraq, where disillusionment with the United States runs high, most people voiced disgust with bin Laden's latest message. ``This man (Osama) has nothing to do with religion,'' Saad Ubo Mustafa, a local resident in Baghdad, told AP television news. ``He is killing Sunnis, Shiites, Kurds, Christians, Jews and foreign people. Islam has got nothing to do with such kinds of people.'' Added another man, Abu Basheer: ``This man lives in prehistoric times. No one should pay attention or listen to him.'' But even if the tape produces outrage or revulsion in most people, history shows that some will listen to what bin Laden has to say, and a few may even be moved to join him. Bob Ayers, a terrorism expert at London's Chatham House think tank, said that while bin Laden professes to be speaking to the American people, his message is not really aimed at them. ``The people who are going to follow are the ones who are already converts and radicalized,'' he said. The other audience is almost certainly Western leaders - particularly Bush - who have so far failed to find him. Ayers said bin Laden is thumbing his nose at U.S. leaders by ``saying I've killed thousands of your people ... and you're ineffective.'' --- Associated Press reporters Angela Doland in Paris, and Romina Spina in London contributed to this report. _____ Bin Laden Unplugged Analyzing the latest video. by Daveed Gartenstein-Ross 09/08/2007 2:14:00 PM http://www.weeklystandard.com/Utilities/printer_preview.asp?idArticle=14090 <http://www.weeklystandard.com/Utilities/printer_preview.asp?idArticle=14090 &R=114FC35EFB> &R=114FC35EFB OSAMA BIN LADEN'S STRENGTH as an orator has always been his ethos. He is an eloquent and seemingly honest speaker, proud of his role in the attacks of 9/11, a principled spokesman for radical Islam's war against the West. Though bin Laden may not have penned all his words personally, the force of his ideas always shines through. As Bruce Lawrence notes in Messages to the World, "these messages are not ghostwritten tracts of the kind supplied by professional speechwriters to many politicians in the West, whether American Presidents, European Prime Ministers, or their Middle-Eastern counterparts." In bin Laden's last video--released on October 29, 2004, on the eve of America's presidential election--bin Laden mocked <http://abcnews.go.com/print?id=215913> President Bush: "Free men do not forfeit their security, contrary to Bush's claim that we hate freedom. If so, then let him explain to us why we don't strike--for example--Sweden?" But even while skewering President Bush for his simplistic framing of the conflict, bin Laden has been hesitant to explain the roots of the struggle to a Western audience. (His rhetoric differs when the target audience is Western rather than Muslim.) The closest he has come was the October 2004 video, where bin Laden outlined his grievances at length and urged his audience to look for 9/11's "causes in order to prevent it from happening again." This vagueness has led some commentators to conclude that bin Laden is fundamentally a political terrorist rather than a religious one. The sociologist Michael Mann wrote, "There is a simple reason why he attacked the United States: American imperialism. As long as America seeks to control the Middle East, he and people like him will be its enemy." Doug Bandow of the American Conservative Defense Alliance--after quoting bin Laden's quip about Sweden--declared <http://www.antiwar.com/bandow/?articleid=10877> that al-Qaeda's attacks are "in pursuit of specific geopolitical objectives. The evidence is overwhelming that they attack Americans because they believe Americans are at war with them." A NUMBER OF COMMENTATORS have described bin Laden's latest video <http://counterterrorismblog.org/site-resources/images/SITE-OBL-transcript.p df> , released yesterday, as breaking new ground--and it does. One way the tape does not break new ground is through the breadth of topics covered. The video is somewhat of a tour de force. Bin Laden's complaints run the gamut from the invasion of Iraq to Hollywood, global warming, and interest-bearing loans. The authorities he cites to bolster his case include Noam Chomsky, Michael Scheuer, and a soldier he calls only "Joshua" (presumably from a mid-summer ABC News report <http://abcnews.go.com/print?id=3383389> ). But broad lists of grievances and a complex narrative have always been signatures of bin Laden's rhetoric. This is not the first time he mentioned the Kyoto Protocol, nor is it the first time he cited leftist intellectuals. One discernable shift in this speech is that bin Laden is far friendlier to the Jews than ever before. He declares that if the Nazi holocaust had occurred closer to Muslim countries, "most of the Jews would have been saved by taking refuge with us." Bin Laden also recalls how Jews found shelter in Muslim countries during the Spanish Inquisition. A second discernible shift is that the speech is more anti-imperialist and anti-capitalist than past work. Bruce Lawrence writes in Messages to the World, "The word 'imperialism' does not occur once in any of the messages he has sent out. He defines the enemy differently. For him, jihad is aimed not at an imperium, but at 'global unbelief'." But this speech is more explicit. Bin Laden describes the media as "a tool of the colonialist empires," and refers to America as an empire twice, predicting its collapse. More to the point, he says that capitalism lies at the heart of the current struggle. In the West, bin Laden says, "those with real power and influence are those with the most capital." He continues: And since the democratic system permits major corporations to back candidates, be they presidential or congressional, there shouldn't be any cause for astonishment . . . in the Democrats' failure to stop the war. . . . As you liberated yourselves before from the slavery of monks, kings, and feudalism, you should liberate yourselves from the deception, shackles and attrition of the capitalist system. THE VIDEO'S EMPHASIS on the evils of empire and capital make its third rhetorical shift all the more odd. Up through bin Laden's denunciation of capitalism and plea that his audience should "search for an alternative, upright methodology," it seemed that his speech would successfully appeal to a certain audience. Those who believe that curtailing American power is critical to solving the terrorist threat could find bin Laden's words at least somewhat reassuring: there was enough meat to suggest that the root cause of al Qaeda's grievance is an aggressive American foreign policy. I have previously noted <http://www.weeklystandard.com/Content/Public/Articles/000/000/005/942belym. asp> that, after the Madrid train bombings swung the Spanish elections to the Socialist Party, al Qaeda's rhetoric seemingly attempted to better appeal to some segments of Westerners. Though they emphasize grievances, past al Qaeda videos have provided Westerners little idea of how to avoid the terror group's wrath. In addition to bin Laden's October 2004 video, his deputy Ayman al-Zawahiri released videos in November 2004 and February 2005 speaking platitudinously of dealing with al Qaeda "on the basis of respect and mutual interests" and of "mutual cooperation with the Islamic nation." The third rhetorical shift in the new video is that it is markedly more concrete: he actually names the "alternative, upright methodology" that should replace capitalism. Those familiar with bin Laden's ideology may not be surprised that he declares: "The infallible methodology is the methodology of Allah." But when he pronounces this alternative, the speech takes a drastic turn: in that moment he is transformed from anti-imperialist rebel to an imperialist of another flavor. Bin Laden makes clear that his is a theological imperium. His problem is not just capitalism, but lawmaking that is not derived from the sharia. "What you have done is clear loss and manifest polytheism," he claims. "You believe that Allah is your Lord and your Creator and the Creator of this earth and that it is His property, then you work on His earth and property without His orders and without obeying Him, and you legislate in contradiction to His Law and methodology." Bin Laden continues to make dawah (Islamic evangelism) for much of the latter half of his speech. The dawah's blandness stands in contrast to his thundering condemnations of America and the West. "And did you know," bin Laden asks, "that the name of the prophet of Allah Jesus and his mother . . . are mentioned in the Noble Qur'an dozens of times, and that in the Qur'an there is a chapter whose name is 'Maryam,' i.e. Mary, daughter of 'Imran and mother of Jesus?" THIS LAST TWIST in bin Laden's speech makes it a confused work, an unworthy sequel to his last video for an American audience. The fact that the speech's only proffered alternative to capitalism is Islamic rule means that bin Laden is unlikely to truly reach the "people of America" whom he purports to address. At least bin Laden is honest about what he stands for. He has made his uncompromising theological vision clear to his Muslim audience since releasing his first public statement designed for a wide audience: a theological critique of Saudi Arabia's Sheikh Abdul Aziz bin Baz released in late 1994. The new video should leave his Western audience, too, with little confusion. In evaluating what al Qaeda represents, it is unwise to simply discard large portions of bin Laden's public statements in an attempt to see him as something that he is not: a political rather than a religious terrorist. The fact that bin Laden's largely (though not entirely) secularized analysis of the ills plaguing the West transitions so smoothly into his theological solution makes it more difficult for those who would like to superimpose their own ideological gripes onto him. In that way, the speech is not effective: rather than bolstering bin Laden's standing with the target audience, it will likely make parts of his worldview more menacing, more difficult to apologize for. Daveed Gartenstein-Ross is the vice president of research at the Foundation for Defense of Democracies, and the author of My Year Inside Radical Islam <http://www.amazon.com/dp/1585425516?tag=daveegarteros-20&camp=14573&creativ e=327641&linkCode=as1&creativeASIN=1585425516&adid=0HBNJDMY6SPT3RRCTJ7D&> . C Copyright 2007, News Corporation, Weekly Standard, All Rights Reserved. _____ Experts warn of attack clues in Bin Laden video Agence France-Presse http://www.abs-cbnnews.com/storypage.aspx?StoryID=91648WASHINGTON - Intelligence experts scouring the latest video of Osama bin Laden for clues warned on Saturday that his message offers hints that Al-Qaeda is planning another attack on US interests. In his first video appearance in three years, the elusive Al-Qaeda chief mocks the United States as "weak" and vows to escalate fighting in Iraq, all the while using language similar to the kind used ahead of other past attacks. At times, bin Laden speaks directly to Americans, using plain language that "appears to be crafted in a way as to be understood by the average person on the street in Europe or in the US," said intelligence analyst Ben Venzke. The latest video "contains phrases ... which serve as indicators that OBL's message is part of Al-Qaeda's efforts to fulfill its requirements to provide warning and a chance for the enemy to change its ways before executing an attack," Venzke said. However, the message, delivered days ahead of the sixth anniversary of the September 11, 2001 attacks on the United States in which 3,000 people were killed, gives no clues "to indicate when an attack ... would be attempted," he said. The language, saying peace will befall "he who follows the guidance," mirrors that used in bin Laden's "European truce offer" of April 2004 in which he said: "Peace upon those who followed the right path." The similarity in terms is important because the 2004 message appealing to Europeans to change their ways was the final message aimed specifically at Europeans before the July 2005 bombings in London which killed 52 people, said Venzke of the Virginia-based Intel Center. In the video, bin Laden also discusses current events but issues no direct threats, and offers two ways of ending the Iraq war, according to a transcript released by the US-based SITE Intelligence Group which monitors Islamic militant websites. "The first is from our side, and it is to continue to escalate the killing and fighting against you," he says. The second is to do away with the US democratic system of government, which he says merely serves the interests of major corporations. "Your security is in your own hands. And every state that doesn't play with our security has automatically guaranteed its own security," he says, adding: Allah is our Guardian and helper, while you have no guardian or helper." Bin Laden appears in the video with a trimmed beard that is apparently dyed black, hiding the streaks of gray seen in previous footage, and wears a beige cloak over a white robe. According to Azzam Tamimi, head of the London-based Institute of Islamic Political Thought, the beard dye is a "sign of war." The rigorous Salafi Islamic school to which bin Laden belongs "condones this dye only in preparation for war," he said. A US intelligence official speaking on condition of anonymity said agencies believe the video is authentic and was produced as recently as August because of a reference to the 62nd anniversary of the bombing of Hiroshima on August 6. "I think people are pretty confident it is his voice," the official said. Prior to this release, the last video message from bin Laden, who has a 25-million-dollar US bounty on his head, came in October 2004, while a CIA-authenticated audio clip was posted on the Internet in May 2006. CIA Director Michael Hayden on Friday also warned that Al-Qaeda was planning new, large-scale attacks on US targets. "Our analysts assess with high confidence that Al-Qaeda's central leadership is planning high impact plots against the American homeland," Hayden said. In the rambling message, bin Laden mocks the United States for its troubles in Iraq and the effect of the September 11, 2001 attacks. "Despite America being the greatest economic power and possessing the most powerful and up-to-date military arsenal as well ... 19 young men were able -- by the grace of Allah, the most high -- to change the direction of its compass," he said in a reference to the September 11 hijackers. "America is weak despite its apparent strength," he says. Believed to be hiding in the remote tribal areas along the Pakistan-Afghanistan border, bin Laden verbally attacks US President George W. Bush as well as the US Democratic Party, which he says has done little to halt the Iraq war. Bush, in turn, used the video to support the US military presence in Iraq. "If Al-Qaeda bothers to mention Iraq, it's because they want to achieve their objectives in Iraq, which is to drive attacks and develop a safe haven," Bush said. Addressing the American people directly, bin Laden refers to domestic opposition to the Iraq war. "The world is following your news in regards to your invasion of Iraq, for people have recently come to know that, after several years of tragedies of this war, the vast majority of you want it stopped." He says the Democrats who now control the US Congress have failed to stop the war, and even "continue to agree to the spending of tens of billions to continue the killing and war there." Bin Laden also refers to recent US headline stories, referring to "the burden of interest-related debts, insane taxes and real estate mortgages; global warming and its woes." "To conclude," he says, "I invite you to embrace Islam." _____ Bin Laden Expert: He's Winning NEW YORK, Sept. 8, 2007 http://www.cbsnews.com/stories/2007/09/08/terror/printable3244193.shtml _____ (CBS) "People of America," he says, "lend me your ears." So says the most wanted man in the world, Osama bin Laden, appearing in a new videotape which has surfaced nearly six years after the attacks of September 11, 2001. In it, he rails against Western corporations, neoconservatives, and Democrats in Congress, telling Americans they had voted for Democrats to stop the war, but in his words, the majority party hasn't made a move worth mentioning. CBS News consultant Michael Scheuer, a former CIA analyst and author of "Imperial Hubris: Why the West Is Losing the War on Terror" and "Through Our Enemies' Eyes: Osama bin Laden, Radical Islam, and the Future of America" (Potomac), has been critical of the administration's efforts to capture bin Laden, and says the newly-released video shows an al Qaeda leader taunting the U.S. for failing to catch him. Scheuer spent years tracking al Qaeda as the head of the CIA's bin Laden unit. Discussing the video with CBS Saturday Early Show anchor Maggie Rodriguez, Scheuer said, "First of all, the setting is very relaxed, very comfortable. He is not in his camouflaged jacket. There's no rifle. What he is trying to say is that he is under no pressure from the Americans. The Americans are failing in their effort to kill him, and in their effort to destroy al Qaeda." Of our progress in battling al Qaeda, Scheuer said, "It points directly to the fact that we failed utterly in Afghanistan to send enough either intelligence officers or military people. "You know, we have about 30,000 troops there, and we've asked them to defeat the Taliban, keep President Karzai's government in power, build a democracy, eradicate the opium industry - and in their spare time go after Osama bin Laden." The mere appearance of bin Laden, four years after the last new video recording and six years after the 9/11 attacks, "is the reminder of a failed policy." The tape's script seems calculated to authenticate its currency by including pointed references to the British Prime Minister Gordon Brown and French President Nicolas Sarkozy, both of whom took office earlier this year. Informed sources tell CBS News they now believe he is holed up in a rugged no-man's land in Northern Pakistan. "Well, I think they're blowing a little bit of smoke," Scheuer said. "They have to say something now that he is back in the public eye, but if you look at the territory, it is impossible to find any single person up there, and we don't have enough people to do it, and we respect Pakistan's sovereignty. I guess they're not going to go into Pakistan." Bin Laden makes mention of Scheuer's writings, saying in the tape, "If you would like to get to know what some of the reasons for your losing your war against us, then read the book by Michael Scheuer." Scheuer said the referral makes the point that the former CIA analyst communicates what recent American presidents have not said about the nation's war against Islamic fundamentalism. "The war is motivated on the enemy's side by the impact of our policies," he said. "It's not about democracy. It's not about women's rights. It's not about freedom or elections. It has everything to do with the impact of our foreign policy in the Muslim world. It's not to say that our policy is wrong, it's simply to try to understand the motivation of your enemy." The Intel Center, an independent analysis group which has studied the tape, said that bin Laden makes no overt threat, no indication of an impending attack upon America or its citizens. Homeland Security Director Michael Chertoff has also said there is no reason to push the panic button now. But Scheuer is not convinced. "The Intel Center is almost always right," he said. "I think there's an overwhelming threat in it. Bin laden, again, offered us a chance to convert to Islam, which is required in their religion before they attack us. So to say there's no threat in this message is just 180 degrees incorrect." And the timing of the message, on the eve of the anniversary of the September 11 attacks, "is not a coincidence at all." "He is gloating. They think they're winning, and I think they're probably correct at the moment." C MMVII, CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. (F)AIR USE NOTICE: All original content and/or articles and graphics in this message are copyrighted, unless specifically noted otherwise. All rights to these copyrighted items are reserved. Articles and graphics have been placed within for educational and discussion purposes only, in compliance with "Fair Use" criteria established in Section 107 of the Copyright Act of 1976. The principle of "Fair Use" was established as law by Section 107 of The Copyright Act of 1976. "Fair Use" legally eliminates the need to obtain permission or pay royalties for the use of previously copyrighted materials if the purposes of display include "criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research." Section 107 establishes four criteria for determining whether the use of a work in any particular case qualifies as a "fair use". A work used does not necessarily have to satisfy all four criteria to qualify as an instance of "fair use". Rather, "fair use" is determined by the overall extent to which the cited work does or does not substantially satisfy the criteria in their totality. If you wish to use copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the copyright owner. For more information go to: http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtml THIS DOCUMENT MAY CONTAIN COPYRIGHTED MATERIAL. COPYING AND DISSEMINATION IS PROHIBITED WITHOUT PERMISSION OF THE COPYRIGHT OWNERS. [Non-text portions of this message have been removed] -------------------------- Want to discuss this topic? Head on over to our discussion list, [EMAIL PROTECTED] -------------------------- Brooks Isoldi, editor [EMAIL PROTECTED] http://www.intellnet.org Post message: [email protected] Subscribe: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Unsubscribe: [EMAIL PROTECTED] *** FAIR USE NOTICE. This message contains copyrighted material whose use has not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. OSINT, as a part of The Intelligence Network, is making it available without profit to OSINT YahooGroups members who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included information in their efforts to advance the understanding of intelligence and law enforcement organizations, their activities, methods, techniques, human rights, civil liberties, social justice and other intelligence related issues, for non-profit research and educational purposes only. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of the copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the copyright owner. For more information go to: http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtml Yahoo! Groups Links <*> To visit your group on the web, go to: http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/ <*> Your email settings: Individual Email | Traditional <*> To change settings online go to: http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/join (Yahoo! ID required) <*> To change settings via email: mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] <*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to: [EMAIL PROTECTED] <*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to: http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/
