<http://www.meforum.org/img/blank.gif>                  
<http://www.meforum.org/img/blank.gif>        
        
 <http://www.meforum.org>               
MEF News Mailing List
September 23, 2007

        
         MEF  <http://www.meforum.org> Home   |    Research  
<http://www.meforum.org/docs> & Writings   |   Middle East  
<http://www.meforum.org/meq/> Quarterly   |    Unsubscribe 
<http://www.meforum.org/unsubscribe.php>            
        

Naser Khader and Flemming Rose:
Reflections on the Danish Cartoon Controversy


Middle East Quarterly
Fall 2007
http://www.meforum. <http://www.meforum.org/article/1758> org/article/1758

On March 9, 2007, Middle East Quarterly publisher Daniel Pipes interviewed 
Naser Khader, a prominent Danish parliamentarian, at the parliament building in 
Copenhagen, and Flemming Rose, who as culture editor of Jyllands-Posten 
commissioned the cartoons at the center of the controversy.[1] <>  After a 
brief leave of absence while the controversy cooled, Flemming returned to his 
duties at the paper. At the height of the violence in February 2006, Khader 
founded the Democratic Muslims in Denmark to unite moderate Muslims to stand 
against the radical imams fueling violence and intolerance. On May 7, 2007, 
Khader announced he would leave the Social Liberal Party to form the New 
Alliance after a party member and immigration spokesman donned a Muslim 
headscarf in an effort to pander to religious conservatives.[2] <> 


Naser Khader


Middle East Quarterly: You formed the Democratic Muslims in Denmark 
organization after the cartoon scandal, intending it to be the political voice 
of moderate Danish Muslims. How is it going?

Naser Khader: Before the cartoon crisis, I never wanted to begin a Muslim 
organization. I'm a firm believer that Danish Muslims should aspire to 
integrate into Danish life, and I felt that a Muslim political organization 
would serve to undermine this. But, as Islamists claimed to speak for all 
Muslims during the cartoon crisis rather than speaking for themselves 
personally or organizationally, I changed my view. Moderate Danish Muslims 
needed their own political voice. So, I started the Democratic Muslims in 
Denmark organization in response.

MEQ: What specifically did you do?

Khader: Right after the cartoon crisis broke, I recruited Mustafa Kassem, a 
distinguished scientist who shares my point of view. At first, we had great 
success because we were the opposition within the Danish Muslim community to 
the Islamists creating all the trouble. But later it became clear that although 
united in opposition to Abu Laban and other Islamist leaders, we had many 
differences among ourselves in the organization. For example, our views on 
women wearing the veil and the death penalty differed strikingly from each 
other. So, we hit some rocks and faced some difficulties. Recently, we decided 
to stay away from specific domestic issues and focus instead on our common 
belief that democracy is good and compatible with Islam.

Muslims of Denmark differ widely on politics and religion, and to our delight, 
it turns out that the largest group of Muslims were those who supported our 
work. A year ago, surveys showed our support at 18 percent. It has now gone 
down to 14 percent, but this is still a plurality and the largest group that 
the survey research has found. We were surprised, pleased, and inspired by this 
large number.

MEQ: Moderate Danish Muslims, it is said, are scared to join the network. Is 
that true?

Khader: Many Muslim members dropped out of the Democratic Muslims of Denmark 
because they were threatened. One board member was attacked physically. Young 
females are especially vulnerable. I remember a woman board member, a Somali, 
who said that she could not continue on the board because she was intimidated. 
When I went to visit her with a bodyguard, I encountered five to ten Muslims 
who were hostile to me. When I got out of the car and went to her flat, they 
smashed the police car. Extra police protection was brought in to help us. So 
there is a real and present physical danger.

MEQ: The first of your "Ten Commandments of Democracy"[3] <>  calls for the 
separation of church and state. This is an extremely unpopular view among 
Danish Muslims, is it not? Do you have ideas on how to increase the number of 
Danish Muslims who share your view?

Khader: You are correct that this is not a popular notion among Danish Muslims. 
This is something that we are introducing into the debate. What we would like 
is what exists in France, namely total separation. Taking up this position is, 
indeed, something that makes things more difficult. Many Muslims cannot imagine 
a society without religious interests having a veto. We believe that there 
would be degeneration and severe problems should this not happen. We insist 
that there be a total separation between religion and the state.

MEQ: The Danish Islamist Ahmed Akkari said in March 2006, "If [Khader] becomes 
minister for foreigners or integration, wouldn't there be two guys sent over to 
blow up him and his ministry?"[4] <>  At the time, you said you had to consider 
whether or not to continue in politics. A couple of weeks later you did decide 
to return. Why?

Khader: The cartoon crisis was overwhelming for me. I worked twenty-four hours 
a day. My health suffered, and my family, though supportive, was concerned 
about my welfare. And so when Akkari made his offensive statement, I was unsure 
whether I wanted to continue in politics. But after thinking about it for two 
days, I had no doubts. In fact, Akkari and his companions stimulated me. I 
figured that if I left the field, they would win. This made me angry, and I 
became energized. So in some sense, Akkari got me back into politics.

MEQ: Are Muslims discriminated against in Denmark? If so, how so?

Khader: Muslims are no more discriminated against in Denmark than they are 
elsewhere in Europe. At the same time, one has to understand that Islamism is 
an ideology, not a religion. And Danes are not alone in being afraid and 
apprehensive of this ideology. There are lots of Muslims who also don't like 
Islamism. Generally, Danes give you a fair shake. They accept Muslims if you 
declare that you are loyal to this society, to democracy. If you say that you 
are one of them, they will accept you. If you have reservations, they will 
worry. If you say that you hate democracy and that you want the Shari‘a 
[Islamic law], you will naturally make enemies.

MEQ: Did the publishing of the Muhammad cartoons improve or worsen the 
situation for Muslims in Denmark?

Khader: The publishing of the cartoons was a wake-up call to many of Denmark's 
neighbors—particularly the Swedes who are inclined to ignore such problems—that 
they have to pay attention to radical Islam. They cannot go on blindly with 
their multicultural hopes. Instead, they must come to terms that there are 
radical extremists in their midst who need to be dealt with. This also applies 
to Norway and to a lesser extent to other non-Scandinavian countries.

Inside Denmark, the cartoon crisis made clear that Muslims are not united and 
that there is a real difference between the Islamists and people like myself. 
Danes were shown that talk of "the Muslims" was too monolithic. They discovered 
that there is a more subtle, complex nature to the Islamic community in 
Denmark, that it is not homogenous.

MEQ: Did this have practical consequences?

Khader: Yes. This distinction has led directly to a positive effect on the 
hiring of Danish Muslims. Business owners realized that there are Danish 
Muslims loyal to the Danish state and society. Those who had hitherto been 
skeptical of employing Muslims, worried that they would be getting Islamists, 
now understand that there is a segment—something on the order of 15 percent, 
one‑sixth of the Muslim population—that is overtly, strongly loyal and would be 
great hires.

On the other hand, it had the negative impact that those who are fearful of 
Muslims are now all the more so.

It also had the effect that Muslims outside Denmark see the country as a David 
fighting Goliath. Now Denmark is on the map. Before the cartoon crisis, people 
in my little hometown in Syria thought that Denmark was someplace in Canada. 
Now they know that Denmark is a separate country and that it is in Europe. It 
gave Denmark a presence that it never had before.

The crisis also put Denmark on the Islamists' map, particularly in Saudi Arabia 
and Egypt. Many would say that this is not a good development. Personally, I 
couldn't care less. In fact, I believe that Denmark should boycott states such 
as Saudi Arabia that have the Shari‘a, that we should not have trade with them. 
I realize this is a difficult goal to implement, but I think that Denmark 
should keep this in mind.


Flemming Rose 


MEQ: In a February 19, 2006 opinion piece in The Washington Post, you stated 
that you commissioned the Muhammad cartoons "in response to several incidents 
of self-censorship in Europe caused by widening fears and feelings of 
intimidation in dealing with issues related to Islam." Do you think that 
publishing the cartoons achieved your goal of battling self-censorship? If so, 
could you give some examples of where and how this reversal has manifested 
itself?

Flemming Rose: It remains to be seen, but publication of the cartoons 
definitely raised the level of consciousness about self-censorship. A lot of 
people have said to me, "You didn't achieve your goal because we have more 
self-censorship than we did before." But, if you go back before the cartoon 
controversy, there were many instances of self-censorship that went unnoticed.

MEQ: For example?

Rose: An installation at the Tate gallery in London called "God Is Great" by 
the late British avant-garde artist John Latham. The exhibition depicted the 
Bible, the Talmud, and the Qur'an torn into pieces and layered in a piece of 
glass. After the July 7 bombings, the museum removed that piece of art without 
seeking permission from the artist, or asking the police if they saw any threat 
in exhibiting this piece of art, or consulting with representatives from the 
London Muslim, Jewish, and Christian communities about an appropriate course of 
action. There was no public reaction to this; there was no talk about 
self-censorship although it was an obvious case.

Then, after the publication of our cartoons, a similar incident occurred in 
Berlin. A Mozart opera, Idomeneo, in which the producer planned to show the 
severed heads of the Prophet Muhammad, Jesus, Buddha, and Poseidon, was 
cancelled due to religious concerns. This time there was a tremendous public 
outcry and outrage, including even a lot of German Muslims, and the opera was 
staged. So I think that it is fair to say that the publication of the cartoons 
raised European consciousness about self-censorship, and it remains to be seen 
whether in the long run it will increase or decrease it.

MEQ: Some argue that the self-censorship that exists in Danish society protects 
Muslims who would otherwise be discriminated against in some form or another in 
Denmark. How do you reply to that?

Rose: That is wrong. People who raise that point make an intellectual mistake. 
They do not differentiate between what I would call good behavior—you could 
call it political correctness—and submitting themselves to self-censorship. 
This is because they want to show good behavior and are also afraid. A good 
example of this was the illustrator who refused to illustrate a children's book 
about the life of the Prophet. He is on the record in two interviews saying 
that he insisted on anonymity because he was afraid.[5] <>  This is 
self-censorship, not political correctness. There is a very important 
distinction to be made here between what you perceive as good behavior and a 
fear keeping you from doing things that you want to do. Also, it is 
discriminatory toward Muslims to say that we should not make fun of their 
religion when we are making fun of everybody else's religion. As I wrote at 
that time, I'd like to think that in some sense, the cartoons were an act of 
inclusion because we were not asking more or less of Muslims but exactly the 
same as of everybody else. Danish Muslims should be treated as adults, not as a 
weak minority needing special treatment like small children.

MEQ: Do you wish that other Western journalists would join you in the push 
against self-censorship? Are you satisfied with the record of other journalists 
and editors that they have learned from this? Do you feel that they are pulling 
in the same direction, or do you feel exposed and lonely?

Rose: I do not feel lonely, but I think it is a mixed bag when it comes to 
speaking about specific countries and when you go inside the journalist 
community in every country. It was a surprise to me that more European 
newspapers republished the cartoons than those in the United States. Unlike the 
major U.S. papers, several of the big European newspapers republished the 
cartoons. There are two narratives here: There are those who say that the 
controversy was about self-censorship—about denying a religious group special 
treatment in the public domain. That is my narrative. Then, you have another 
narrative saying: This was not about free speech or self-censorship; it was 
about a powerful newspaper insulting a minority. This was a fair argument until 
the moment when the threats were issued. The twelve cartoonists and I received 
death threats; newspapers were closed in Russia and in Malaysia, and newspaper 
editors were jailed in Jordan and Yemen. At that point, it became an issue 
exclusively about free speech.

MEQ: A French publication is being sued for reprinting the cartoons in question 
and an opinion poll in France on February 6 showed 79 percent of those polled 
thought it unacceptable to ridicule a religion publicly and 78 percent ruled 
out parodies of Jesus, Muhammad, or Buddha.[6] <>  Does this poll suggest that 
you failed to diminish European self-censorship?

Rose: Although the vast majority of people in France are saying that one should 
not be allowed to ridicule a religion, at the same time, the same majority 
would not support a verdict banning the publication of the Muhammad cartoons by 
[the French satiric weekly] Charlie Hebdo. So, it depends on the way the 
questions are being asked. But there is a fundamental problem in Europe that 
has to do with the secular state of our society. We have forgotten what it 
means to be religious. Because we have forgotten, we are afraid of ridiculing 
religion, and we are restraining ourselves from treating religion the same way 
that we treat every other ideology. It is the same thing as when you've lived 
in a homogeneously white society, and you see a black person in town for the 
first time. I think the secular trend is very strong, but there is a search for 
identity. If you compare today to earlier, the difference is that you can go in 
and out of an identity today. I can be Christian today if it fits my need and 
my longing for identity, but in two or three weeks, I can be something else. It 
is a big challenge for Europeans to be confronted with a minority in their 
midst of whom some do have a very strong religious identity.

MEQ: That's something incomprehensible to Europeans?

Rose: Yes, that is why we do not know how to deal with it—because it is so 
strange. It is very difficult for us to identify when we see this religious 
identification in a minority. We have to treat minorities well. We have in 
Western Europe this kind of self-hatred stemming from our colonial past and 
things like that. Logically, we should treat Islam as we treat Christianity. We 
have been criticizing, challenging, and ridiculing Christianity for decades if 
not centuries. But we do not do the same with Islam because we have lost our 
sense of religiosity and are afraid of insulting or being accused of insulting 
a minority. In my mind, this is not a question of insult but of equal treatment.

In Denmark, time seems to be on our side. If I go back a year and compare the 
way I am being treated in the public domain in Denmark, it has definitely 
changed. People show a lot more understanding of my position than a year ago. 
The publication of the Muhammad cartoons was the first very clear-cut case in 
which it was possible to criticize the oppressive features in Islam or Islamism 
without risking being labeled racist.

MEQ: Do you see a connection between Ayatollah Khomeini's edict against Salman 
Rushdie and your own struggle? Could the cartoon controversy be viewed as the 
latest episode in a continuum of self-censorship started in 1989?

Rose: I spoke to [historian of Islam] Bernard Lewis about this, and he said 
that the big difference between our case and the Rushdie affair is that Rushdie 
is perceived as an apostate by the Muslims while, in our case, Muslims were 
insisting on applying Islamic law to what non-Muslims are doing in non‑Muslim 
countries. In that sense, he said it is a kind of unique case that might 
indicate that Europe is perceived as some kind of intermediate state between 
the Muslim world and the non-Muslim world.

If you go back to 1989, the question of Muslim immigrants in Western Europe was 
not that high on the agenda. It was not a political issue in the same sense. It 
has become a hotter issue than it was back then, and there are other 
implications that were not factors in the Rushdie affair—that is, the question 
of integration and immigration.

MEQ: Do you expect further such cases?

Rose: Yes. This is just the first major case in the twenty-first century. We 
will see several others and maybe not only with Muslims. There was the Behzti 
["dishonor" in Punjabi] affair in Birmingham where a Sikh author wrote a play, 
Behzti, which caused grievances among the Sikh community. There were threats to 
burn down the theater. The issue here is cultural difference as a cause of 
conflict.

If you go back to the establishment of the United Nations and the United 
Nations charter of human rights, it was taboo to speak about cultural 
differences because of World War II and Nazism and fascism. There was a strong 
belief that while there were societies dominated by nationalism and also tribal 
societies, every single culture was moving in the same direction toward melding 
into one worldwide culture. Ironically, this was discriminatory in a way—to 
think that everyone else should become like our part of the world. But it 
didn't work out that way. So, the multiculturalists and cultural relativists 
appeared, espousing that if everybody cannot be the same, then you have to 
accept everybody as they are. Muslim immigration was not such a hot issue at 
its inception because it was passively believed that if Muslims and 
representatives of other minorities live long enough among us, then they become 
like us. But now even European progressives would admit that this multicultural 
model has failed. And this has given rise to the debate about Britishness and, 
here, about what it means to be a citizen in Denmark.

MEQ: My assessment is that, in the end, the debate that you began about 
self-censorship has become more, a debate about the Shari‘a and its application 
in the West.

Rose: Exactly. Initially, I thought otherwise. When I wrote the accompanying 
text to the publication of the cartoons, I said that this act was about 
self-censorship, not free speech. Free speech is on the books; we have the law, 
and nobody as yet has thought of rewriting it. This changed when the death 
threats were issued; it became an issue of the Shari‘a trumping the fundamental 
right of free speech.

MEQ: You've said that you did not anticipate the response from the Muslim world 
to the cartoons. Yet, you saw what happened to Rushdie after the publication of 
The Satanic Verses and other lesser cases. Was a massive reaction not something 
you might have anticipated? Given the history of Rushdie and the others, how do 
you answer those who would say to you that you should have known that this was 
asking for trouble?

Rose: This is untrue. I never could have imagined this. Along the lines of 
Bernard Lewis's argument regarding the difference between my case and 
Rushdie's, I never thought that the Muslim world cares about what infidels are 
doing in the land of infidels. I continued to believe this for several months 
after the cartoons were printed.

The explosion in the Middle East and the Muslim world came five months after 
the publication of the cartoons. Even then, one could argue that it was 
propelled by converging political agendas of different groups of Middle East 
powers. Take the burning down of the Danish embassy in Damascus, for instance. 
[7] <>  Syria is officially a secular power, but of course, they used the 
cartoons as an excuse to stand out as defenders of Muslims and appease the 
Muslim Brotherhood. It was the same case with the outrage in Egypt. In Denmark 
in the fall of 2005, several experts on Islam went on the record saying this 
will never become a big international story.

MEQ: If you knew the outrage that publishing the cartoons would generate, would 
you still have commissioned them?

Rose: That's like asking a rape victim if she regrets wearing a short skirt at 
the discotheque Friday night. I have been asked that question many times, and 
no matter how you answer, it is problematic. If I say, I do not regret and 
think it was the right thing to do, a lot of people would say that I am a 
cold-hearted, cynical character. On the other hand, if I say that this was the 
wrong thing to do, I would give in to the kind of intimidation that I am trying 
to fight.

I do not think that one can turn newspapers into real life. For example, I do 
not accept the direct linkage between cartoons and the killing of innocent 
people in Nigeria. We have published interviews with representatives of the 
Copts in Egypt and the Berbers in Algeria. None of these people think that it 
was the wrong thing to do. So, on balance, I do not regret it. We have had a 
very fateful debate in the Western world, and it has spilled over into Germany, 
France, Spain, and other countries. Sometimes you need a disruptive event of 
this kind to focus attention on crucial issues. The debate we have had about 
how to balance what free speech means on the one hand with how to respect 
peoples' religious feelings on the other has been very important. Denmark, 
after this affair, is far better prepared to deal with the conflicts caused by 
cultural differences resulting from globalization both within Danish society 
and across borders.

[1] <>  See Pernille Ammitzbøll and Lorenzo Vidino, "After the Danish Cartoon  
<http://www.meforum.org/article/1437> Controversy," Middle East Quarterly, 
Winter 2007, pp. 3-11.
[2] <>  Jyllands-Posten (Copenhagen), May 7, 2007.
[3] <>  "The Ten  
<http://www.khader.dk/flx/in_english/the_ten_commandments_of_democracy/> 
Commandments of Democracy," Naser Khader website, accessed May 14, 2007.
[4] <>  TV-DR1, Danish National Broadcasting Corp., Mar. 25, 2006.
[5] <>  Weekendavisen (Copenhagen), Jan. 27, 2006.
[6] <>  Deutche Welle (Bonn), Feb. 7,  
<http://www.dw-world.de/dw/article/0,2144,2340200,00.html> 2007.
[7] <>  BBC News, Feb. 5,  <http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/middle_east/4682560.stm> 
2006.

To receive the full, printed version of the Middle East Quarterly, please see 
details about an affordable subscription 
<https://wwws.meforum.org/participation/subscribe.php> .

 <http://www.meforum.org/pf.php?id=1758> Printer-friendly version


Related Items


*       Other items from  <http://www.meforum.org/meq/issues/200709> the Fall 
2007 Middle East Quarterly 

*       Other items in category  <http://www.meforum.org/docs/cat/57> 
Dhimmitude 

*       Other items in category  <http://www.meforum.org/docs/cat/52> Democracy 
and Islam 

*       Other items in category  <http://www.meforum.org/docs/cat/59> Muslims 
in Europe 

*       Other items in category  <http://www.meforum.org/docs/cat/35> Muslim 
apostasy & freethinking 

  
<http://www.meforum.org/list_mefnews/Mzg3fHxzZWN1cmVvcHNAb3B0b25saW5lLm5ldA.png>
      
         
To unsubscribe from the MEF News list, go to http://www.meforum. 
<http://www.meforum.org/unsubscribe.php> org/unsubscribe.php
To subscribe to the MEF News list, go to http://www.meforum. 
<http://www.meforum.org/subscribe.php> org/subscribe.php
To receive alerts of MEF staff media appearances, please sign up for the MEF 
Alerts mailing list at: http://www.meforum. 
<http://www.meforum.org/subscribe.php> org/subscribe.php

You may freely post or forward this text, but on condition that you send it as 
an integral whole, along with complete information about its author, date, 
publication, and original URL.

        

 


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]



--------------------------
Want to discuss this topic?  Head on over to our discussion list, [EMAIL 
PROTECTED]
--------------------------
Brooks Isoldi, editor
[EMAIL PROTECTED]

http://www.intellnet.org

  Post message: [email protected]
  Subscribe:    [EMAIL PROTECTED]
  Unsubscribe:  [EMAIL PROTECTED]


*** FAIR USE NOTICE. This message contains copyrighted material whose use has 
not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. OSINT, as a part of 
The Intelligence Network, is making it available without profit to OSINT 
YahooGroups members who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the 
included information in their efforts to advance the understanding of 
intelligence and law enforcement organizations, their activities, methods, 
techniques, human rights, civil liberties, social justice and other 
intelligence related issues, for non-profit research and educational purposes 
only. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of the copyrighted material 
as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use 
this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' 
you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.
For more information go to:
http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtml 
Yahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/

<*> Your email settings:
    Individual Email | Traditional

<*> To change settings online go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/join
    (Yahoo! ID required)

<*> To change settings via email:
    mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] 
    mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
    [EMAIL PROTECTED]

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
    http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/
 

Reply via email to