http://volokh. <http://volokh.com/posts/1190502423.shtml>
com/posts/1190502423.shtml

[Ilya Somin, September 22, 2007 at 7:07pm 
<http://volokh.
<http://volokh.com/archives/archive_2007_09_16-2007_09_22.shtml#1190502423>
com/archives/archive_2007_09_16-2007_09_22.shtml#1190502423>]

Radical Islamism and Frank Herbert's Dune

WARNING: This post contains spoilers for Frank Herbert's classic science 
fiction novel Dune.

Frank Herbert's Dune 
<http://www.amazon.
<http://www.amazon.com/Dune-Chronicles-Book-1/dp/0441172717>
com/Dune-Chronicles-Book-1/dp/0441172717> is one of 
the greatest science fiction novels of all time. And, as famed sci fi 
writer Orson Scott Card points out 
<http://hatrack.
<http://hatrack.com/osc/reviews/everything/2007-09-09.shtml>
com/osc/reviews/everything/2007-09-09.shtml>, there are 
many parallels between the plot of Dune and the rise of radical Islamism 
in the real world:

There was considerable irony in Dune's use of Arabic culture and
language as the explicit basis of the "Fremen," the desert dwellers
who become the source of Paul Atreides power and, when he unleashes
them, the scourge of the universe.

Herbert traces the roots of Fremen culture from world to world, and
makes it clear that, while the specifics of Islamic belief are never
laid out, the customs and culture of these people have been Muslim
all along . . .

The emotional core of the novel, then, comes from a T.E.
Lawrence-like character, Paul Atreides, coming to dwell with and
learning to live as an Arab Muslim, until he is able to lead them to
victorious battle.

Paul, being a non-Muslim, treats the idea of jihad as an abhorrent
one; he long tries to resist the blood and horror of such a thing,
though by the end of the book he has given up and realizes that the
jihad will happen and cannot be prevented or even controlled.....

[A] Muslim would not read this book the same way I did. To an Arab
Muslim, the Arabic words and names would leap off the page; the
Fremen characters would be the ones an Arab reader would most
identify with.....

And when, at the end of the book, the Arab jihad is triumphant, this
reader --- [if like] Osama or another of his ideology --- would not
only feel great emotional satisfaction, he would have the blueprint
for his own future.

Because the Fremen in Dune triumph, not just because of the force of
their arms or their courage in battle, but because they control the
only source of the "Spice," a substance only created in the complex
desert ecology of Arrakis, the planet they control. Without Spice
the starships cannot navigate, and interstellar trade would grind to
a halt.

The whole economy of the interstellar empire is dependent on and
therefore under the ultimate control of the Fremen. Anything the
offworlders do to them will hurt the offworlders far more than it
hurts the Fremen. The parallel with oil is obvious.....

Remember that Herbert wrote Dune in the 1960s, before the first oil
embargo, before any Islamist government was ever formed.

Whether Dune had any causal influence on the rise of Al Qaeda,
Herbert certainly did a superb job of predicting the rise and the
power of such an ideology. I would be surprised if there were not,
among the followers of Osama bin Laden, at least a few readers of
Dune for whom this book feels like their future, their identity,
their dream.

In other words, Herbert got it horribly right.

Unlike Card, I highly doubt that Dune played any role in influencing 
Osama Bin Laden or his followers. However, Card is right to note the 
striking parallels between the jihad in Dune and the later rise of 
radical Islamism in our world. The parallels are imperfect (e.g. - Dune 
is the only source of "the Spice," while in our world there are many 
non-Arab oil producers). But they are there nonetheless.

This leads me to another interesting aspect of Dune: at first reading, 
many readers (myself included) fail to pick up on the fact that the 
victory of Paul and the Fremen is a tragedy, not a happy ending. 
Although they succeed in overthrowing the evil Harkonnens and the 
corrupt Empire, it is only at the cost of unleashing a religious war 
that will kill billions. The point is made more clear in the later (and 
inferior) sequel Dune Messiah 
<http://www.amazon.
<http://www.amazon.com/Dune-Messiah-Chronicles-Book/dp/0441172695/ref=pd_bbs
_sr_1/102-2806535-2827342?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1190501786&sr=1-1>
com/Dune-Messiah-Chronicles-Book/dp/0441172695/ref=pd_bbs_sr_1/102-2806535-2
827342?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1190501786&sr=1-1> 
(where Herbert notes that Paul's victory has resulted in the slaughter 
of many more innocent people than the Holocaust). But it is evident on a 
close reading of Dune itself as well.

The mistake is understandable. Paul and his Fremen allies are brave and 
sympathetic, while their enemies have few if any virtues. Nonetheless, 
the Fremen victory ultimately creates far more evil than it prevents. 
The danger of religious fanaticism and hero worship was in fact one of 
the themes that Herbert sought to emphasize in Dune. These days, when I 
reread Dune, I can't help but sympathize just a little with the Emperor, 
or even the Baron Harkonnen:).

UPDATE: There is one other interesting parallel between the Fremen 
religion in Dune and the ideology of radical Islamism. While the Fremen 
think of their religion as god-given, in actuality much of its content 
was deliberately manipulated by the Bene Gesserit (a powerful political 
organization in the Dune Universe) for their own purposes. Similarly, as 
I discussed here 
<http://www.volokh.
<http://www.volokh.com/archives/archive_2007_09_09-2007_09_15.shtml#11>
com/archives/archive_2007_09_09-2007_09_15.shtml#11>, 
many elements of the radical Islamist ideology can be traced back to 
European fascist origins, and their rise was partly facilitated by the 
propaganda efforts of Nazi Germany and Fascist Italy in the 1930s and 40s.

*Comments:*
(link <http://volokh. <http://volokh.com/posts/1190502423.shtml#271635>
com/posts/1190502423.shtml#271635>)
Dr. Kynes (mail <mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
<mailto:kynes%40imperialplanetology.gov> tology.gov>):
One difference between the Fremen and the Arabs is that the Fremen are 
superb fighters.
9.22.2007 7:24pm
(link <http://volokh. <http://volokh.com/posts/1190502423.shtml#271637>
com/posts/1190502423.shtml#271637>)
Guest101:

This leads me to another interesting aspect of Dune: at first
reading, many readers (myself included) fail to pick up on the fact
that the victory of Paul and the Fremen is a tragedy, not a happy
ending. Although they succeed in overthrowing the evil Harkonnens
and the corrupt Empire, it is only at the cost of unleashing a
religious war that will kill billions.

In Herbert's world, the Fremen jihad was a necessary evil justified by 
the need for the rise of the God Emperor, who would orchestrate the 
Scattering necessary toprevent human extinction. Of course, there is no 
parallel necessity in real life, but I don't think it's true that in the 
fictional world of /Dune/, the Fremen jihad and the concomitant rise of 
House Atreides was not, on balance, a good thing.
9.22.2007 7:38pm
(link <http://volokh. <http://volokh.com/posts/1190502423.shtml#271638>
com/posts/1190502423.shtml#271638>)
Nessuno:
I concur with Ilya that it is very doubtful that Dune had any affect on 
the founding or development of Al Qaeda for two reasons. First, the 
intellectual and spirtual roots of Al Qaeda are found in the Muslim 
Brotherhood, which was founded in 1928, long before Dune was written.

Second, as this study discusses 
<http://www.worldpre <http://www.worldpress.org/Mideast/663.cfm>
ss.org/Mideast/663.cfm>, an appallingly low number 
of books are translated into Arabic. Only about 330 books are translated 
into Arabic each year, about 1/5 of the number that are translated for a 
tiny nation like Greece. The odds that Dune was even translated into 
Arabic, let alone read widely, is quite small.

And also from Dr. Kynes above,

One difference between the Fremen and the Arabs is that the Fremen
are superb fighters.

This is quite funny and quite true.

9.22.2007 7:41pm
(link <http://volokh. <http://volokh.com/posts/1190502423.shtml#271639>
com/posts/1190502423.shtml#271639>)
Ilya Somin:
/In Herbert's world, the Fremen jihad was a necessary evil justified by 
the need for the rise of the God Emperor, who would orchestrate the 
Scattering necessary toprevent human extinction./

I think that Dune and Dune Messiah strongly suggest that it was evil on 
balance. I regard God Emperor of Dune as a later addition grafted on to 
the story, one that Herbert didn't anticipate when he wrote the original 
book. However, your interpretation also has some validity.
9.22.2007 7:44pm
(link <http://volokh. <http://volokh.com/posts/1190502423.shtml#271640>
com/posts/1190502423.shtml#271640>)
Ilya Somin:
/One difference between the Fremen and the Arabs is that the Fremen are 
superb fighters./

I don't think the Arabs are bad fighters. They're just (usually) badly 
led and organized - much as the Fremen were before Kynes and (later) 
Paul, changed things. With good leadership and planning, Arabs can fight 
quite well, as they did in the Yom Kippur War, for example. However, I 
will resist the temptation to analogize Sadat's use of artillery to 
breach the Israeli Suez Canal fortifications in 1973 with the 
destruction of the Shield Wall in Dune:).
9.22.2007 7:48pm
(link <http://volokh. <http://volokh.com/posts/1190502423.shtml#271642>
com/posts/1190502423.shtml#271642>)
Laura S.:

life, but I don't think it's true that in the fictional world of
Dune, the Fremen jihad and the concomitant rise of House Atreides
was not, on balance, a good thing.

Apparently you haven't read the whole series. Paul Atreides consistently 
expresses horror at what will happen as a consequence of his 
rise--something which he viewed as fate. A fate he chooses not to resist.

It's Leto II, his son who names himself "God Emperor" who takes the 
justification further--dubiously I must add.
9.22.2007 8:00pm
(link <http://volokh. <http://volokh.com/posts/1190502423.shtml#271643>
com/posts/1190502423.shtml#271643>)
Guest101:
Laura,

Actually, I have read the whole series, and I'm aware of the fact that 
Paul resisted his fate. But Leto makes clear that this was a weakness on 
Paul's part-- an inability to sacrifice his own humanity for the sake of 
saving the race from extinction. You can call that claim "dubious," but 
I don't recall any indication in the book that this was self-delusion on 
Leto's part.
9.22.2007 8:02pm
(link <http://volokh. <http://volokh.com/posts/1190502423.shtml#271644>
com/posts/1190502423.shtml#271644>)
Ilya Somin:
/Paul Atreides consistently expresses horror at what will happen as a 
consequence of his rise--something which he viewed as fate. A fate he 
chooses not to resist.

It's Leto II, his son who names himself "God Emperor" who takes the 
justification further--dubiously I must add./

Yes, I tend to agree. Just because Leto II THINKS that his policies are 
necessary to save humanity doesn't mean that Herbert intended for 
readers to agree. Moreover, the God Emperor's policies, even if they 
were necessary, may not have been so if not for the destruction wreaked 
by Paul and his jihad earlier.
9.22.2007 8:02pm
(link <http://volokh. <http://volokh.com/posts/1190502423.shtml#271646>
com/posts/1190502423.shtml#271646>)
Guest101:

Yes, I tend to agree. Just because Leto II THINKS that his policies
are necessary to save humanity doesn't mean that Herbert intended
for readers to agree. Moreover, the God Emperor's policies, even if
they were necessary, may not have been so if not for the destruction
wreaked by Paul and his jihad earlier.

It's been many years since I read the series, but weren't Leto's 
convictions the result of a prescient Spice vision? I don't recall any 
suggestion at all that Herbert intended there to be any doubt about the 
veracity of that conviction. Moreover, the God Emperor book indicated-- 
retrospectively, of course-- that Paul had foreseen the necessity of 
Leto's sacrifice even before the Fremen jihad, which would suggest that 
the Scattering was not made necessary as a result of the jihad, but 
rather that the jihad was a necessary step to the preservation of the 
human race.
9.22.2007 8:08pm
(link <http://volokh. <http://volokh.com/posts/1190502423.shtml#271647>
com/posts/1190502423.shtml#271647>)
Dale C. Wyckoff (mail <mailto:Domain.Name@
<mailto:Domain.Name%40DaleWyckoff.Com> DaleWyckoff.Com>):
Regarding Bene Gesserit: Much like Nazi Germany the Bene Gesserit, with 
their breeding program, were interested in genetic manipulation. 
Eugenics in the extreme.

As Paul, the Bene Gesserit's Kwisatz Haderach, turned around and bit the 
Bene Gesserit so too does radical Islamism threaten Europe.
9.22.2007 8:24pm
(link <http://volokh. <http://volokh.com/posts/1190502423.shtml#271648>
com/posts/1190502423.shtml#271648>)
PersonFromPorlock:
I must be deficient but when I read /Dune/ back when it first came out, 
I thought it was pretty routine; and when I reread it recently, it still 
seemed humdrum. Not bad, mind you, just undistinguished. Jack Vance, for 
instance, used to write the same sort of one-man-against-the-world 
stuff, usually more entertainingly.

What I really suspect is that /Dune/'s cult status comes from it's 
ecological subplot having caught the rising tide of pop environmentalism 
at an opportune moment.

As far as Arab or pseudo-Arab warriors are concerned, Lawrence's /Seven 
Pillars of Wisdom/ had had quite a flutter a few years before /Dune/ was 
published, both as a book and a movie (/Lawrence of Arabia/). The action 
in /Dune/ follows /Lawrence/ at least as much as it foreshadows Radical 
Islam.
9.22.2007 8:30pm
(link <http://volokh. <http://volokh.com/posts/1190502423.shtml#271649>
com/posts/1190502423.shtml#271649>)
Annonymous Coward (mail <mailto:ClarkEMyers@
<mailto:ClarkEMyers%40hotmail.com> hotmail.com>):
Certainly my own clear understanding that Herbert intended the complete 
original as a tragedy in one volume and it was only the necessity to 
break the original for publication that hid this from the reader who 
read only book one.

See also Under Pressure or one of its other titles for an early 
discussion of oil politics and The God Makers for more quasi political 
speculation on war and politics.
9.22.2007 8:41pm
(link <http://volokh. <http://volokh.com/posts/1190502423.shtml#271652>
com/posts/1190502423.shtml#271652>)
Laura S.:

Moreover, the God Emperor book indicated-- retrospectively, of
course-- that Paul had foreseen the necessity of Leto's sacrifice
even before the Fremen jihad, which would suggest that the
Scattering was not made necessary as a result of the jihad, but
rather that the jihad was a necessary step to the preservation of
the human race.

I agree that it plausible for Paul to have seen the same future course 
of events as Leto, but then that is manifestation of his decision to 
give way to fate. Consequently, I do not think you can conclude form 
this that the jihad was not the proximate cause of what happened next.

Leto's rule is described several times as "depraved despotism". Indeed 
this is why each Duncan Idaho in turn tries to kill him.
9.22.2007 9:06pm
(link <http://volokh. <http://volokh.com/posts/1190502423.shtml#271653>
com/posts/1190502423.shtml#271653>)
SenatorX (mail <mailto:X>):
Lets not forget that Paul was creating the future by seeing it and Leto 
was smarter than this. Part of his scheme was to not only spread 
humanity and save it from the inevitable death by machines but to spread 
humans who a) would never live under a tyrany like the one he imposed 
again and b) would be immune to others who could see the future.

Interesting to think of the third book as separate from the first two. I 
wonder if there is any evidence it was "tacked on". I like it so much 
better than the first two books. Paul was kind of a wussy.
9.22.2007 9:23pm
(link <http://volokh. <http://volokh.com/posts/1190502423.shtml#271655>
com/posts/1190502423.shtml#271655>)
Daniel San:
Whether Paul's jihad was made necessary by fate or to prevent a much 
later (and worse) horror, Herbert makes it clear that it was a tragedy. 
By the end of Dune, we know that jihad engulfs humanity, but for no end 
but jihad itself. There is no anticipated noble end to war, only death 
and destruction.

I think the sense Herbert is seeking is ambiguity. There is certainly 
the exhilaration at the triumph of the heroes and the defeat of the evil 
and the craven. But the vision of the future is not a vision of hope. 
And the direction of Paul's victory is the direction of horror.
9.22.2007 9:45pm
(link <http://volokh. <http://volokh.com/posts/1190502423.shtml#271657>
com/posts/1190502423.shtml#271657>)
Sean O'Hara (mail <mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] <mailto:seanohara%40gmail.com>
com>) (www 
<http://diogenes- <http://diogenes-sinope.blogspot.com>
sinope.blogspot.com>):
I remember on the night the Iraq War started, I kept flipping between 
the Sci Fi Channel's Children of Dune miniseries, in which a significant 
part of the plot involved Paul's Fadaykin, and the news channels that 
were discussing Saddam's Fedayeen. Very surreal.

However, while I think al Qaeda members would probably enjoy the first 
three Dune novels, I don't think they'd like the later ones, especially 
Chapterhouse: Dune which features Jews ... in ... SPAAAAAAAAACE!
9.22.2007 9:50pm
(link <http://volokh. <http://volokh.com/posts/1190502423.shtml#271661>
com/posts/1190502423.shtml#271661>)
JohnEMack (mail <mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] <mailto:jmack49168%40aol.com> com>):
What strikes me about the Dune series is how dated they seem today. I 
just finished reading "Sandworms of Dune," which he son finished from 
his father's notes. It is not really a bad book, and it shares 
faithfully both the virtues and vices of Frank Herbert's writing: Wild 
imagination, cosmic sweep, cereal-boxtop characters, stilted dialogue, 
total lack of feeling for the passage of time, and high seriousness 
bordering on pretentiousness. Unlike Frank, however, the authors of 
"Sandworms" do not seem to be trying to make a point. Moreover, Frank 
had a tendency to rob history and put it into his novels. As Somin 
points out, the Fremen are based on Arab culture. But the Bene Gesserit 
("She will have performed well" in Latin) is remeniscent of medieval 
monastic culture, the female equivalent of the warrior orders. Liet 
Kynes is reminiscent of liberal scientism. Choam is reminiscent of the 
Hanseatic League. The list goes on. Herbert appropriated all of history 
for his saga. That is what makes his work so fascinating. But in a real 
world which is accelerating so quickly we do not have even a general 
idea of what it will be like in 200 years, it also has a strangely dated 
quality. As Damon Knight put it in the context of A.E. van Vogt, after 
ten thousand years of chaos, his hero drives down the street in a 
Studebaker. Sometimes, Herbert's Dune world has a similar feel.
9.22.2007 10:34pm
(link <http://volokh. <http://volokh.com/posts/1190502423.shtml#271663>
com/posts/1190502423.shtml#271663>)
Kurt9 (mail <mailto:kurt2100kimo@ <mailto:kurt2100kimo%40yahoo.com.tw>
yahoo.com.tw>):
Actually, the whole Dune imperium is based on Arab culture. The emperor 
and his saudukar warriors seemed derived from Arab culture. Also many of 
the names of stuff seemed Arab-like as well. The Fremen were simply more 
Arab-like. Think of the fremen as being bedouin Arabs and the imperium 
as being "city" Arabs.
9.22.2007 10:53pm
(link <http://volokh. <http://volokh.com/posts/1190502423.shtml#271664>
com/posts/1190502423.shtml#271664>)
Captain Ned:
I've always read Paul Muad'Dib as someone who saw the Golden Path and 
knew what needed to be done but could never stump up the courage to deny 
the Fremen their Jihad. His prescience saw that the Jihad was the wrong 
path, yet the personal cost to him in stopping the Jihad was more than 
he was willing to pay. In his return as The Preacher he correctly 
foretold events, but had passed beyond the point of being able to move 
the masses to his views.
9.22.2007 10:55pm
(link <http://volokh. <http://volokh.com/posts/1190502423.shtml#271668>
com/posts/1190502423.shtml#271668>)
Cro (mail <mailto:wonderbingo@ <mailto:wonderbingo%40yahoo.com> yahoo.com>):
Paul is a tragic figure. Although a leader of the Fremen, he is appalled 
at the violence that his movement will unleash. He's horrified by the 
future of Jihad that he is unleashing. He is trapped in his destiny, and 
he eventually embraces it. He changes into the role created for him by 
the Fremen. I think that the turning point is when he takes the water of 
life. After that, he can't help it. He becomes a prisoner of the future.

"Mua'Dib" sounds a lot like "Mohammed," to me. It seems to me that 
Herbert is telling the story of Mohammed. He's exiled, he returns to 
defeat his enemies in Mecca, then his forces eventually maim and destroy 
the Byzantine and Persian empires. I wouldn't push the analogy too far, 
but the life of Mohammed is a pretty good story.
9.22.2007 11:35pm
(link <http://volokh. <http://volokh.com/posts/1190502423.shtml#271670>
com/posts/1190502423.shtml#271670>)
Aleks:
Re: I regard God Emperor of Dune as a later addition grafted on to the 
story, one that Herbert didn't anticipate when he wrote the original book.

Did he even anticipate the events of Dune Messiah (where the Jihad is 
fully realized) when he wrote the original Dune? You can read the 
original book by iteslf as the triumph of an oppressed people over 
brutal tyranny and of the fairly just and decent Atreides over the 
vicious Harkonnens and the corrupt Emperor. It's only in the later books 
that the cost of that the larger cost of that victory is explored.

Re: The emperor and his saudukar warriors seemed derived from Arab culture.

You're right: the Emperor was even named "Shaddam". Still, it has more 
the feel of Byzantium, or maybe of the old Persian Empire (the empror's 
title is "Padishah", which sounds Persian)
9.22.2007 11:59pm
(link <http://volokh. <http://volokh.com/posts/1190502423.shtml#271673>
com/posts/1190502423.shtml#271673>)
Sean O'Hara (mail <mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] <mailto:seanohara%40gmail.com>
com>) (www 
<http://diogenes- <http://diogenes-sinope.blogspot.com>
sinope.blogspot.com>):

Did he even anticipate the events of Dune Messiah (where the Jihad
is fully realized) when he wrote the original Dune? You can read the
original book by iteslf as the triumph of an oppressed people over
brutal tyranny and of the fairly just and decent Atreides over the
vicious Harkonnens and the corrupt Emperor. It's only in the later
books that the cost of that the larger cost of that victory is
explored.

Paul spends quite a bit of the first book angsting over the cost of his 
revenge, and clearly notes that his actions will lead to the Jihad.
9.23.2007 12:17am
(link <http://volokh. <http://volokh.com/posts/1190502423.shtml#271674>
com/posts/1190502423.shtml#271674>)
Thomass:
[quote]Unlike Card, I highly doubt that Dune played any role in 
influencing Osama Bin Laden or his followers.[/quote]

I have zero proof available that it did, but it would not surprise me in 
the least to find out later, if more information became available, that 
it did.

Dune, like Tolkien, IMO appeals to the far right... and I don't mean 
what we call that in the US... but rather the European, and I would 
imagine the Arab world, if we used 'right' and 'far right' in their 
proper contexts (re: rather than to bash Bush or American 
conservatives)... The key themes they embrace are all there...

PS
And Paul's self chosen freeman name translates to 'the base',,,re: al 
qaeda..
9.23.2007 12:30am
(link <http://volokh. <http://volokh.com/posts/1190502423.shtml#271675>
com/posts/1190502423.shtml#271675>)
Tom.P (mail <mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] <mailto:tomp%40earthlink.net> net>):
In high school, Dune was my favorite novel for some years and I read it 
many times (along with the sequels, as they appeared). When I first 
heard about Al Qaeda, (many years later, of course) it struck me that 
Paul's Fremen name, Usul, was explained to mean "the base of the 
pillar", and that Al Qaeda apparently also meant 'the base'.
9.23.2007 12:31am
(link <http://volokh. <http://volokh.com/posts/1190502423.shtml#271677>
com/posts/1190502423.shtml#271677>)
Thomass:
Oops... just came back to me... 'the base' was his assigned name for 
time of danger... not his, self chosen, everyday name...
9.23.2007 12:45am
(link <http://volokh. <http://volokh.com/posts/1190502423.shtml#271682>
com/posts/1190502423.shtml#271682>)
David Sucher (mail <mailto:dsucher2000@ <mailto:dsucher2000%40yahoo.com>
yahoo.com>) (www 
<http://citycomforts
<http://citycomfortsblog.typepad.com/cities/2007/06/a-communication.html>
blog.typepad.com/cities/2007/06/a-communication.html>):
I read /Dune/ for the first of many times in 1970 and so this statement 
(from Card) surprises me:
"[A] Muslim would not read this book the same way I did. To an Arab 
Muslim, the Arabic words and names would leap off the page; the Fremen 
characters would be the ones an Arab reader would most identify with..."

And "the Arabic words and names" didn't "leap off the page" to Card the 
first time he read /Dune/? Herbert hits you over the head with it: 
vaguely Arab names, deserts/little water, control of a substance which 
is the key to long-distance transportation, etc etc. It was obvious; it 
never occurred to me then that Herbert wasn't warning of global resource 
dynamics coming into clear view. /Dune/ is first and foremost about a 
planet. It was published in the build-up to Earth Day, (though I don't 
think it had much influence in creating Earth Day). Herbert was 
explicitly interested in the transformation of /American/ society into 
an /ecologically-sustainable/ one, though that word hadn't yet become 
popular.

But above all, /Dune/ is a story and entertainment, even though it can 
teach us a lot. I wouldn't look too deeply for its influence on American 
environmentalism because it's not there; and is it even translated into 
Arabic? I would assume so but can't find any verification on the web.
9.23.2007 2:47am
(link <http://volokh. <http://volokh.com/posts/1190502423.shtml#271683>
com/posts/1190502423.shtml#271683>)
Inferior?:
*Choke* Inferior Dune Messiah? Where the very heroes of the previosu 
book become mired in power plays? Where a 7 year old child convincingly 
acts as a harem of souls trapped in a child's body and succesfully 
challenges every idea around him? I don't think so.

Partisanship aside, there is a key to understanding the portrayal of the 
Fremen, that they were truly oppressed. The Bene Gesserit may have added 
their twists, but their Sayyadina ritual is something else entirely, and 
thei live with the hatred born of their persecution. The Muslim world 
has no such excuse, unless manufactured. That the Fremen, shorn of this 
hatred (the water cure) become more dangerous than anything before is 
another twist in the tragedy, that they move from one extreme to 
another. Do not free a people from oppresion without giving them the 
tools to succeed and expect success (slaves, Soviet Russia, apartheid to 
name a few examples).

The later Leto II is more science fictiony because we only know he is 
correct for having seen the future in a vision, the extinction of 
humanity. Though the portrayal along the way is entirely human.
9.23.2007 3:04am
(link <http://volokh. <http://volokh.com/posts/1190502423.shtml#271688>
com/posts/1190502423.shtml#271688>)
PEG (mail <mailto:NOSPAM>) (www <http://www.impulsio
<http://www.impulsionleblog.com/> nleblog.com/>):
Yes, the parralels are obvious.

By the way, I wouldn't be so sure Dune hasn't influenced Bin Laden. I 
read somewhere that back when Osama was a completely westernized spoiled 
brat, he was a fan of science fiction literature. In particular, one of 
his favorite authors was Isaac Asimov.

I haven't read anything about him and Dune, but I can't imagine a SF, 
Asimov fan who hasn't at least read Herbert. And, as the point points 
out, anyone with a Muslim background (or even a modicum of international 
culture) would have the parralels with Islam "leap off the page" at him.
9.23.2007 4:06am
(link <http://volokh. <http://volokh.com/posts/1190502423.shtml#271689>
com/posts/1190502423.shtml#271689>)
Ryan Waxx (mail <mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] <mailto:none%40hotmail.com> com>):

It's been many years since I read the series, but weren't Leto's
convictions the result of a prescient Spice vision?

True, to an extent. But remember that prescience in the world of Dune 
isn't quite the same as the movie cliche.
9.23.2007 4:37am
(link <http://volokh. <http://volokh.com/posts/1190502423.shtml#271698>
com/posts/1190502423.shtml#271698>)
advisory opinion:
Dune = boring.

Anybody else fascinated by the Warhammer 40k universe? (I mean the 
backstory and 'fluff', I don't actually play the game.)
9.23.2007 7:50am
(link <http://volokh. <http://volokh.com/posts/1190502423.shtml#271707>
com/posts/1190502423.shtml#271707>)
Thorley Winston (mail <mailto:thorleywinston_at_yahoo_dot_com>) (www 
<http://entitlementr <http://entitlementreform.blogspot.com/>
eform.blogspot.com/>):

Anybody else fascinated by the Warhammer 40k universe? (I mean the
backstory and 'fluff', I don't actually play the game.)

Yep, I own pretty much all of the RPG source books and have most of the 
novels. I started reading the first book in the Horus Heresy but haven't 
had the chance to pick it up for a while. I got "Fire Warrior" for my 
PS2 very cheap and it's a pretty entertaining FPS and I really liked the 
look of the game.

I always thought WK40K as a darker sci-fi version of LOTR with elements 
of Dune and the Eternal Champion liberally added. The thing about WH40K 
(and its true for Dune and the Eternal Champion as well) is that there 
aren't any "good guys" in the sense of people that you can actually 
cheer on because they represent some ideal to strive for, but only an 
option that seems (correctly or not) to be less awful than the others. 
The forces they're fighting against usually represent the extinction of 
the human race (although in the Eternal Champion, so did the protagonist 
on more than one occasion) with the best they have offer being at least 
a chance for survival usually under the rule of a tyrant.

I generally prefer stories like Honor Harrington or the Prince Roger 
series for my military sci fi. They show some pretty admiral characters 
(who are human and hence flawed) who generally try to do what they think 
is right who work for systems that while flawed are still worth fighting 
for and against enemies who aren't monolithically evil.
9.23.2007 10:08am
(link <http://volokh. <http://volokh.com/posts/1190502423.shtml#271712>
com/posts/1190502423.shtml#271712>)
Redlands (mail <mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] <mailto:vrstull%40aol.com> com>):
This discussion illustrates what I always enjoyed about reading Sci-Fi. 
I stopped trying to explain to friends what could be learned by reading 
"glorified comic books."
9.23.2007 10:46am



.
 
<http://geo.yahoo.com/serv?s=97359714/grpId=2420737/grpspId=1705303292/msgId
=119314/stime=1190560709/nc1=3848607/nc2=4507179/nc3=4706133> 
 


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]



--------------------------
Want to discuss this topic?  Head on over to our discussion list, [EMAIL 
PROTECTED]
--------------------------
Brooks Isoldi, editor
[EMAIL PROTECTED]

http://www.intellnet.org

  Post message: [email protected]
  Subscribe:    [EMAIL PROTECTED]
  Unsubscribe:  [EMAIL PROTECTED]


*** FAIR USE NOTICE. This message contains copyrighted material whose use has 
not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. OSINT, as a part of 
The Intelligence Network, is making it available without profit to OSINT 
YahooGroups members who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the 
included information in their efforts to advance the understanding of 
intelligence and law enforcement organizations, their activities, methods, 
techniques, human rights, civil liberties, social justice and other 
intelligence related issues, for non-profit research and educational purposes 
only. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of the copyrighted material 
as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use 
this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' 
you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.
For more information go to:
http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtml 
Yahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/

<*> Your email settings:
    Individual Email | Traditional

<*> To change settings online go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/join
    (Yahoo! ID required)

<*> To change settings via email:
    mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] 
    mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
    [EMAIL PROTECTED]

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
    http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/
 

Reply via email to