http://www.propeller.com/viewstory/2007/10/14/the-silencing/?url=http%3A%2F%
2Fpajamasmedia.com%2F2007%2F05%2Fthe_silencing.php
<http://www.propeller.com/viewstory/2007/10/14/the-silencing/?url=http%3A%2F
%2Fpajamasmedia.com%2F2007%2F05%2Fthe_silencing.php&frame=true> &frame=true
 
The Silencing 

Before CAIR and the Flying Imams.the Islamic Society of Boston had already
pioneered the use of lawsuits to silence their critics and the media. 

By Martin Solomon

 

 


You are a graduate of Egypt's Al-Azhar University, the foremost religious
school in Sunni Islam. You've grown up in Egypt, earned a BA, MA and PhD
from the prestigious academy, and have spent your life as a believing and
devout Muslim in the heart of the religious establishment. Your religion,
and your belief that Islam is a force for good in the world, is something
you've built your life around. You believe there is no contradiction between
your faith, democracy, and modern standards of human rights, and you
dedicate yourself to writing and speaking in support of your beliefs.

And it's for those beliefs that a canonical court expels you from Al-Azhar.
You are imprisoned for a short time by the Egyptian Government. Finally a
Wahhabist fatwa calling for your assassination forces you to flee the
country.

You flee to political asylum in America, where you can, you hope, continue
to explore your beliefs and practice your religion without fear for life and
limb at the hands of fanatics. 

Then one day you visit a local mosque..

In late 2003, after visiting the local Islamic Society of Boston mosque in
Cambridge, Massachusetts, Ahmed Mansour and his wife emerged in what can
only be described as a state of shock. Mansour's wife had attended a
religious lesson and Mansour himself browsed the literature on display.
According to the  <http://davidproject.org/materials/AffidavitDH.pdf>
affidavit of Dennis Hale (PDF), Episcopal Lay Minister, Boston College
Professor and founder of  <http://www.hatefreeamerica.com/> Citizens for
Peace and Tolerance, Mansour informed him that "both the religious lesson
and the Arabic newsletters inside the mosque were full of hateful references
against the West and Jews." In particular, he noted that the mosque was
touting a fund-raising endorsement for their new mosque project featuring
infamous Wahabbi cleric and pitch-man for the Muslim Brotherhood, Sheik
Yousef Al-Qaradawi.

Shocked to see that the poison he thought he had left behind, the poison he
thought was an ocean away but was following him to America, Mansour spoke
out about what he had seen.

As thanks for stepping forward, Mansour has found himself a defendant in a
wide-ranging defamation lawsuit, a lawsuit that has involved television and
print media outlets, activist organizations, and individuals - anyone, it
seemed, who had dared speak or repeat anything less than complimentary about
the  <http://www.isboston.org/v3.1/default.asp> Islamic Society of Boston.

What the Wahhabis had failed to do in Egypt, the exploitation of the
American legal system threatens to do here - ruin the life of a moderate
Muslim and anyone who stands with him.

A Flawed Founding

The Islamic Society of Boston was founded in 1982 by then university student
Abdurahman Alamoudi, who became its first president. Ten years later,
according to the Hale document, Alamoudi "appeared in a videotaped rally in
Washington, D.C. where he publicly supported Hamas and Hezbollah." In "2003
and 2004, Alamoudi was indicted and pled guilty to a series of
terrorist-related charges arising from a fraudulent scheme to assist Libya
in raising money to assassinate Crown Prince Abdullah of
<javascript:void(0)> Saudi Arabia." This scheme included, according to a
background piece appearing in
<http://www.tnr.com/doc.mhtml?i=w060522&s=morad052606> The New Republic,
"providing approximately $1 million to an organization that supports
<javascript:void(0)> Al Qaeda." Alamoudi "was sentenced to 23 years in
prison."

The ISB was organized under the tax exempt umbrella of the Islamic Society
of  <javascript:void(0)> North America, which was itself a spin-off of the
Wahhabist Muslim Student Association, and has
<http://www.frontpagemag.com/Articles/ReadArticle.asp?ID=19191> been called
"an influential front for the promotion of the Wahhabi political,
ideological and theological infrastructure in the United States and Canada."

"This is how it should be. Religion must lead the war. This is the only way
we can win."

>From humble beginnings came big plans. A
<http://www.solomonia.com/blog/archives/001312.shtml> 2003 Boston Herald
article quotes an ISB attorney as saying their new project had been in the
works for a decade. According to the article: 


.A project update in the Islamic Society of Boston's May 2000 newsletter
reported that in the previous month alone, the group raised $2 million in
Saudi Arabia and other Persian Gulf states. 



One source familiar with the project who spoke on the condition he not be
named said the leaders of the Islamic society have made it clear that
virtually all the financing for the cultural center is coming from Saudi
Arabia, Egypt and other Gulf states.

Many mosques and Islamic institutions in the U.S. are funded by wealthy
individuals and foundations in Saudi Arabia. Those financiers are almost
without exception followers of Wahhabism, a harsh Saudi-based fundamentalist
interpretation of Islam, and they make sure the American mosques they
bankroll adhere to the sect's anti-Western ideology.

In fact, the Boston Herald, with its two part special report (both articles
available here, on the web site of The David Project:
<http://www.davidproject.org/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=74&It
emid=103> Radical Islam: Outspoken cleric, jailed activist tied to new Hub
mosque,
<http://www.davidproject.org/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=75&It
emid=103> Under suspicion: Hub mosque leader tied to radical groups) was one
of the first major media outlets to pick up on what was soon to become a
burning controversy, pulling into the public consciousness something that
had up until then been passing well under the radar. 

The articles noted the involvement and history of terror-connected
Abdurahman Alamoudi in the ISB, as well as, and just as disturbingly, the
involvement of the Muslim Brotherhood's spiritual adviser, Sheik Yousef
Al-Qaradawi. Qaradawi is quoted as supporting terrorist attacks against
Israelis and Americans. He has
<http://www.solomonia.com/blog/archives/006101.shtml> boycotted interfaith
efforts where Israelis were invited. He has
<http://www.solomonia.com/blog/archives/006338.shtml> justified the stoning
of homosexuals. He has
<http://www.solomonia.com/blog/archives/007768.shtml> called for a "Day of
Rage" following the Danish Cartoon Crisis. He has
<http://www.solomonia.com/blog/archives/007848.shtml> said the following: 


."They fight us with Judaism, so we should fight them with Islam. They fight
us with the Torah, so we should fight them with the Koran. If they say 'the
Temple,' we should say 'the Al-Aqsa Mosque.' If they say: 'We glorify the
Sabbath,' we should say: 'We glorify the Friday.' This is how it should be.
Religion must lead the war. This is the only way we can win.". 



."Everything will be on our side and against Jews on [Judgment Day]; at that
time, even the stones and the trees will speak, with or without words, and
say: 'Oh servant of Allah, oh Muslim, there's a Jew behind me, come and kill
him.' They will point to the Jews.

On and on like that goes Qaradawi's record. He is regularly referred to,
without intentional irony, as a "moderate" in his Middle Eastern milieu.

Qaradawi, according to the Herald, was listed as an ISB board member for at
least three years, and was, and still is, a proposed trustee on the real
estate trust as well. In a widely circulated response to the series,
including in a  <http://www.solomonia.com/blog/archives/001334.shtml>
comment on my blog, the ISB stated that his inclusion had been in effect an
"administrative oversight," and that Qaradawi does not accept such positions
in any case. The point, it seems to me, is that they wanted him. He was,
according to the statement, invited due to his "popularity within the
<javascript:void(0)> Muslim community."

The ISB maintains a page in response to the articles on
<http://www.isboston.org/v3.1/viewitem.asp?DocID=1825&ItemTypeID=6> their
own web site. They claim no significant connections to either Alamoudi or
Qaradawi. In fact, they claim no contact with Alamoudi since he left Boston
in 1984, though discovery brought about by the ISB's lawsuit (more on that
later) has  <http://www.solomonia.com/blog/archives/010417.shtml> uncovered
a check on behalf of the ISB to pay Alamoudi's expenses for a speaking
engagement in late 2000, and ISB Trustee Osama Kandil (himself targeted in
the Herald series with accusations denied by the ISB) signed the "
<http://www.petitiononline.com/alamoudi/petition.html> Free Abdurahman
Alamoudi" petition - a petition that calls the terror-supporting Alamoudi
"our community leader" -  <http://www.nysun.com/article/24211?page_no=4>
sometime in '03 or '04.

"Connections to radicals have plagued the Mosque."

Following the ISB's denial of a Qaradawi connection, the Herald
<http://www.solomonia.com/blog/archives/003253.shtml> uncovered the fact
that the Sheik's endorsement was used in an Arabic-only fundraising brochure
in 2003 which the paper obtained and had independently translated.

Other apparent connections to radicals have plagued the Mosque. For
instance, the group has invited the Muslim Brotherhood
<http://www.solomonia.com/blog/archives/010210.shtml> connected Dr.
<http://www.solomonia.com/blog/fastsearch?query=soltan> Salah Soltan as a
speaker. Soltan is an  <http://www.solomonia.com/blog/archives/006765.shtml>
advocate for suicide bombing, and has
<http://memri.org/bin/articles.cgi?Page=archives&Area=sd&ID=SP116806>
praised terrorist Sheik Al-Zindani among
<http://www.frontpagemag.com/Articles/ReadArticle.asp?ID=28089> other
things. Another society guest has been Imam Siraj Wahaj, a character witness
for the "blind sheik" Omar Rahman, and a man who "
<http://www.solomonia.com/blog/archives/005004.shtml> calls for replacing
the American government with a caliphate."

But perhaps the most embarrassing series of episodes involved Saudi
Arabia-based ISB trustee, Dr. Walid Fitaihi. After an initial charm
offensive targeted at Boston's Jewish Community which had prominent Rabbis
singing Fitaihi's praises, disturbing facts soon came to light which had the
community humming a different sort of tune.

It emerged that Fitaihi, in more comfortable surroundings back home, had
been more candid about his feelings. The  <http://memri.org/> Middle East
Media Research Institute had found some of Fitaihi's writings. Shortly after
September 11, Fitaihi
<http://memri.org/bin/articles.cgi?Page=archives&Area=sd&ID=SP30101> had
written: 


"Despite the attacks of distortion coordinated by the Zionist lobby, to
which it has recruited many of the influential media, there are initial
signs that the intensive campaign of education about Islam has begun to bear
fruit.Jewish institutions have begun to contact Muslim institutions and have
called on us to hold dialogues with them and cooperate [with them]. They are
afraid of the outcome of the Islamic-Christian dialogue through the
churches, the mosques, and the universities." 



"Thus, the Muslim community in the U.S. in general, and in Boston in
particular, has begun to trouble the Zionist lobby. The words of the Koran
[3:113] on this matter are true: 'They will be humiliated wherever they are
found, unless they are protected under a covenant with Allah, or a covenant
with another people. They have incurred Allah's wrath and they have been
afflicted with misery. That is because they continuously rejected the Signs
of Allah and were after slaying the Prophets without just cause, and this
resulted from their disobedience and their habit of transgression.'"

"The great Allah spoke words of truth. Their covenant with America is the
strongest possible in the U.S., but it is weaker than they think, and one
day their covenant with the [American] people will be cut off."

When confronted with this information, Fitaihi's response was to claim he
was a victim of a false, "insulting," translation. The Herald, ever on the
case, commissioned their own translation, and
<http://www.solomonia.com/blog/archives/003253.shtml> found MEMRI's
interpretation of Fitaihi's writing to be correct.

"Jews will be 'scourged' because of their 'oppression, murder, and rape of
the worshipers of Allah.'"

Fitaihi and the ISB retreated into embarrassed silence.

Seven months later, the ADL got involved,
<http://www.solomonia.com/blog/archives/004750.shtml> sending a letter to
the ISB with their concerns, calling upon them to "seize the opportunity to
condemn and disassociate expressions of anti-Semitism," and noting that, "In
the absence of such a clarification, other allegations against the ISB are
gaining greater resonance, and there remains a contradiction between your
values statement and your actions." The  <javascript:void(0)> Boston Globe
also noted that the ADL had a further translation of Fitaihi's writing,
stating that he "wrote that Jews will be 'scourged' because of their
'oppression, murder, and rape of the worshipers of Allah.'"

The ISB finally responded with a clarification that still appears on their
web site today,
<http://www.isboston.org/v3.1/viewitem.asp?DocID=2424&ItemTypeID=6> dated
September 2004 (it's not clear why this pre-dates the ADL's October
statement): ".the articles were intended to condemn particular individuals
whom he believes were working to destroy one of Islam's holiest sites,
killing innocent children, and thereby blocking the possibility of peace in
the  <javascript:void(0)> Middle East; the articles were not meant to incite
hatred of an entire faith or people." In other words, "He wasn't talking
about you GOOD Jews, he was talking about those BAD Jews."

No better was ISB Board Chairman, Dr. Yousef Abou-Allabans response in a
conversation with the
<http://72.166.46.24/boston/news_features/this_just_in/documents/04224640.as
p> Boston Phoenix about the incident: 


Judging from Abou-Allaban's comments, its a stretch to say any repudiation
actually took place."So how about Fitaihi's comments in the original Arabic?
'We are against the statement as it was quoted in the paper,' he replied
with a chuckle."

Ha ha. 

"The overlap between the Muslim American Society and ISB is so great that
it's difficult to unravel where one group ends and the other begins."

One more apparent connection between the ISB and radicals is worth noting at
this point. The overlap between the Muslim American Society and ISB is so
great that it's difficult to unravel where one group ends and the other
begins. Until very recently, the ISB shared space with the local chapter of
the Muslim American Society, the ISB's email list is now hosted and run by
the MAS, and
<http://misskelly.typepad.com/miss_kelly_/2007/03/incestuous_rela.html>
commentators have noted what a considerable amount overlap there is among
the leadership of local Muslim groups overall.

The Muslim American Society is widely believed to represent the face of the
<http://www.solomonia.com/blog/archives/007199.shtml> Muslim Brotherhood in
America, though MAS leaders have denied the connection. In fact, missives
showing the MAS's radical face began appearing with such frequency on the
MAS/ISB email list that I inaugurated a new feature on my blog -
<http://www.solomonia.com/blog/fastsearch?query=%22mas+watch%22> MAS Watch.
Emails urging  <http://www.solomonia.com/blog/archives/009945.shtml> support
for jailed Palestinian Islamic Jihad leader Sami Al-Arian,
<http://www.solomonia.com/blog/archives/009156.shtml> welcomes to the PLO
Ambassador,  <http://www.solomonia.com/blog/archives/009235.shtml> petitions
urging support for Hamas,
<http://www.solomonia.com/blog/archives/009466.shtml> invitations to events
proclaiming "Israeli Apartheid," and emails containing veiled threats
against  <http://www.solomonia.com/blog/archives/006985.shtml> those who
cooperate with the authorities, among other items have ensured that I am
rarely at a loss for material. In one embarrassing incident, then Public
Affairs Coordinator for the Boston Chapter of the MAS, Hamza Pelletier,
appeared on a local radio show and
<http://www.solomonia.com/blog/archives/007739.shtml> made statements to the
effect that he did not believe Hamas was a terrorist organization, prompting
a quick official  <http://www.solomonia.com/blog/archives/007783.shtml>
retraction/clarification from Mahdi Bray, Executive Director of the MAS
Freedom Foundation.

Mahdi Bray has been one of the principal actors in the
<http://www.michellemalkin.com/archives/006427.htm> staging of the "Flying
Imams" drama, in which, as Act 2, the Council for American Islamic Relations
(CAIR) has  <http://hotair.com/archives/2007/03/28/i-am-john-doe/>
threatened to sue the "John Doe" passengers who spoke out about the threat
they perceived on the flight that day.

Breaking Ground

 isb_mosque.jpg <http://pajamasmedia.com/upload/2007/05/isb_mosque.jpg> 

In 2000, the City of Boston agreed in principal to convey a lot of land at
Tremont and Malcolm X Boulevard in the City's Roxbury neighborhood to the
ISB for $175,000 cash. Both the ISB and the Boston Redevelopment Authority
(the authority tasked with managing the city's land development whose
employees are appointed by the Mayor) agreed the real value of the land was
closer to $400,000, but fundraising was difficult at the time for the ISB,
so the city and the group came to an agreement where the project would be
completed in stages and the ISB would perform other ways to make up for the
short cash payment by performing services such as maintaining a park,
helping with fund-raising, performing lectures on Islam and setting up an
Islamic Law library at Roxbury Community College.

The idea that the City might be subsidizing Islamic proselytizing (Dawa) of
itself did not go unnoticed in the greater community.

In November of 2002, a
<http://www.weeklystandard.com/Content/Public/Articles/000/000/006/459hffer.
asp> very public groundbreaking took place for the ISB's massive new $20
million+ Mosque and Islamic Center project. Mayor Thomas M. Menino was
proudly on hand, though a few years later, with the ISB mired in
controversy, he imitated Sergeant Schultz
<http://www.solomonia.com/blog/archives/009929.shtml> in an appearance on a
local talk radio show as he denied he was even Mayor at the time the land
deal had gone down. He had actually been mayor for almost a decade at the
time of the groundbreaking.

A few hours after the ceremony, festivities and further fundraising were
conducted at Boston's Sheraton Hotel - a function at which Sheik Qaradawi,
"barred from entering the U.S., delivered a videotaped message to the
attendees encouraging them to
<http://www.davidproject.org/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=74&It
emid=103> support the project."

In early 2003, with the paperwork returned from Saudi Arabia where it was
signed by ISB trustees resident there, the land transfer became official.

Lawsuits for Everyone

In September 2004, Boston resident James Policastro filed a lawsuit against
the city, claiming that it had violated the separation of Church and State
by providing a subsidy to the ISB in exchange for what the suit claims
amounts to religious services to be rendered. As part of the discovery
process - a process which the BRA vigorously fought, refusing by turns to
either turn over documents or make them available, and refusing to answer
questions from the press or even the City Council - it emerged that one
internal document had even valued the land at
<http://www.davidproject.org/materials/BRArecords_doc1.pdf> over $2 million
[PDF], making the city's "contribution" even greater than previously known.

A large number of disclosures have involved the ISB's ultimate insider,
Muhammad Ali-Salaam. Ali-Salaam was simultaneously involved with the ISB as
its principal Middle East fundraiser and a confidential adviser to the ISB
board, while also serving as Deputy Director for Planning with the Boston
Redevelopment Authority and working on the ISB deal as part of his official
duties. While in the BRA he shepherded the ISB's efforts, traveled to the
Middle East on fundraising junkets, advised the ISB on the proper way to
deal with the city in order to get the best deal possible, and attempted to
arrange a trip to Saudi Arabia for Mayor Menino and some of the Mayor's
supporters ( <http://www.solomonia.com/blog/archives/010438.shtml> the trip
never came off).

The first of what were to be several other shoes dropped in February of
2005, when, according to the
<http://www.boston.com/ae/media/articles/2005/02/24/islamic_leader_sues_wfxt
_for_defamation/> Boston Globe, ISB board chairman, Dr. Yousef Abou-Allaban,
sued WFXT-TV (Channel 25), Fox Television Stations Inc., reporter Michael
Beaudet, and producer Jonathan Wells for a story they had done claiming that
Abou-Allaban was a member of the infamous Muslim Brotherhood.

It was only the beginning. At the time, FOX-25 was, along with the Boston
Herald, one of the few mainstream media outlets taking the issues
surrounding the Mosque seriously (see  <http://www.hatefreeamerica.com/>
this page where the top video clip still shows one of Beaudet's stories). In
May, the ISB expanded their lawsuit to include the Herald. In October, they
expanded it yet again, this time, massively. In fact, by the time of its
last revision, the list of individuals and entities the ISB's leadership
<http://misskelly.typepad.com/miss_kelly_/2007/05/for_the_record_.html> was
suing encompassed:


*       Boston Herald, Inc. 

*       Jonathan Wells (Herald reporter) 

*       Jack Meyers (Herald reporter 

*       Thomas Mashberg (Herald reporter) 

*       Maggie Mulvihill (Herald reporter) 

*       Kevin Wisniewski (Herald reporter, also Fox News) 

*       Fox Television Stations, Inc, dba WFXT-TV 

*       Michael Beaudet (Fox News) 

*       The Investigative Project, Inc. 

*       Steven Emerson (Investigative Project) 

*       William R. Sapers 

*       The David Project 

*       Anna Kolodner (The David Project) 

*       Citizens for Peace and Tolerance, Inc. 

*       Steven A. Cohen 

*       Dennis Hale 

*       Ahmed Mansour

They allege, among other things, that "the Defendants publicly portrayed the
ISB and its then-current leadership as Muslims who supported radical Islamic
terrorism, and who were themselves active members of terrorist
organizations." that the defendants had "substantially delayed the
completion of the ISB's project," and that "donations to the ISB have
decreased."

To prove all this, subpoenas for private communications, including private
emails and notes have gone out far and wide. The list of recipients has
included:


*       Tamar Morad 

*       The Anti-Defamation League (twice) 

*       Hillel Stavis 

*       Josh Katzen 

*       Boston College 

*       Simon & Schuster 

*       Anna Kolodner's cell phone provider 

*       Anna Kolodner, Steven Cohen and William Sapers' banks 

*       Jack Fainberg 

*       Avi Goldwasser 

*       Gloria Greenfield 

*       Shulamit Reinharz

Radio host Michael Graham
<http://www.solomonia.com/blog/archives/009067.shtml> received a subpoena
demanding his "personal phone records, show notes and other materials
related to. on air conversations" after he had the temerity to discuss the
issue on the air.

Discovery is a double-edged sword of course, and interesting disclosures
have come fast and furious, several of which I've already noted. For
instance, it emerged that just three months before filing its lawsuit
alleging monetary damages (donations had
<http://www.boston.com/news/local/massachusetts/articles/2005/12/18/praised_
as_beacon_mosque_project_stalls_amid_rancor/> "slowed to a trickle", Mosque
representatives have claimed), an internal ISB email called fundraising "
<http://www.solomonia.com/blog/archives/010254.shtml> robust" - not exactly
the type of thing you'd like made public when alleging you've been damaged.
Particularly embarrassing considering the quote came from the very same ISB
attorney who also filed the lawsuit.

It has also emerged, and I am publicizing this for the first time here, that
in early 2003, fully eight months before the Boston Herald wrote their
series of articles, BRA/ISB official Muhammad Ali-Salaam, wrote to the FBI
in Washington, D.C. to request help in setting up a "Know Your Donor
Program" to help ensure the project remained clear of taking money from
those with known terrorist ties. Ali-Salaam admits in his letter that he has
concerns with people both outside and inside the ISB: 


While I believe that neither the religion of Islam, nor the collective
loyalties of the sponsors of the Cultural Center to the Constitution of the
United States are being called into question, I must acknowledge the
existence of individuals [both internal and external] who may be determined
to undermine the public's confidence in the Project.

So this was before any supposedly slanderous media reports, before any
supposed conspiracy.the ISB insider was noting, in writing, that there were
individuals that might well run afoul of an anti-terror program. Yet to date
Ali-Salaam remains off the list of defendants. [Ali-Salaam's letter to the
FBI is available here:
<http://www.solomonia.com/blog/images/may07/alisalaamtoprouty1.jpg> Page 1,
<http://www.solomonia.com/blog/images/may07/alisalaamtoprouty2.jpg> Page 2] 

Further, and this is also being made available for the first time here,
liberal Congressman Michael E. Capuano, immediately after the publication of
the Herald series (the facts of which have never been in question), sent
letters to
<http://www.solomonia.com/blog/images/may07/capuanotoallaban.jpg> ISB board
chairman Abou-Allaban, and to
<http://www.solomonia.com/blog/images/may07/capuanotozarate.jpg> Juan Carlos
Zarate, Deputy Assistant Secretary, Exec. Office of the Terrorist Financing
and Financial Crime of the US Department of the Treasury. He asks the
Treasury Department to open an investigation into the allegations, and he
advises Abou-Allaban to cooperate with the investigation and "respond
publicly to each and every one of these allegations."

Capuano is clearly alarmed by the charges, as any reasonable person would
be, and starts demanding answers. Capuano remains off the defendant list,
yet ordinary citizens who share the same concerns have not been so lucky.

Damage Control

ISB spokespeople have been out on the stump trying to get groups and
individuals to sign on to an amicus brief in support of the suit.
Particularly of interest have been well-meaning Jewish groups who may want
to be seen as good neighbors to the Muslim members of their community. Good
news came for the ISB in February of this year when a judge
<http://www.solomonia.com/blog/archives/010103.shtml> dismissed the
Policastro suit on a technicality. An appeal
<http://www.solomonia.com/blog/archives/010156.shtml> has been promised, but
the short-term victory prompted excited emails from ISB spokesperson Jessica
Masse, one of which noted the numerous organizations that had signed on to
the amicus.  <http://www.solomonia.com/blog/archives/010134.shtml> As I
noted at the time, a closer look showed that the list was the usual
collection of "Islamists, Arabists, [and] FAR-Leftists" - groups like Jewish
Voice for Peace, the National Lawyers Guild, United for Justice and Peace,
and the Muslim Public Affairs Council.

More recently Masse sent out a
<http://misskelly.typepad.com/miss_kelly_/2007/05/wowee_maui_this.html>
lengthy email continuing the ISB as victim line, and distributing a
<http://www.solomonia.com/blog/images/may07/DPEmailsAttacktheMosque1.pdf>
series of emails [PDF] obtained from some of the lawsuit's defendants
purporting to support the conspiracy accusation. In fact, what the emails
show is that there were discussions among these people whose "interest[,in
the words of one of the emails] is based on the premise that some of the
senior people in the ISB are supporters of terrorism and sworn enemies of
America and Jews, and that the construction of the mosque may be funded by
Wahhabis.If we are going to convince others to support our cause, especially
in the media, we will need reasonably well-supported allegations." In other
words, what's been "exposed" is indistinguishable from the private
discussions of a group of people who recognize a threat and begin to discuss
among themselves what to do about it - something the ISB's lawsuit is
attempting to criminalize. Some conspiracy of defamation.

The latest act in the drama to date came in early April, in the form of a
cameo walk-on by ISB trustee Walid Fitaihi. The Fitaihi statements had never
quite been put to bed, and had continued to haunt claims of ISB moderation,
hanging around the necks of ISB spokespeople like a stinking albatross.

So, in early April, Fitaihi parachuted into town from Saudi Arabia, and,
before a hand-picked invitation-only interfaith audience at the headquarters
of left-wing Jewish group, Workmen's Circle,
<http://www.solomonia.com/blog/archives/010338.shtml> issued an "apology."
The press was not allowed in. We do not have a transcript nor do we have
video of the statement, nor do we know what, if any, questions were asked of
him. Workmen's Circle officials were impressed, but Workmen's Circle has
been one of the primary Jewish groups pressing the defendants in the suit to
agree to accept mediation, so it is unlikely that their standards for
sincerity were particularly exacting. As I asked at the time, what is the
meaning of an apology given in front of a bunch of people who weren't
looking for one in the first place? In fact, as Islamic history scholar
Andrew Bostom  <http://www.solomonia.com/blog/archives/010396.shtml> points
out, it would have been difficult for the Saudi Fitaihi to issue a sincere
apology when much of what he said was sanctioned by the Koran.

The "apology" was issued on a Friday. By that Sunday, Fitaihi was on a jet
back to Saudi Arabia.

But not before he had resigned from the ISB Board of Trustees.

Yes, in addition to his closed-door appearance, Fitaihi had some other,
perhaps more pressing business to attend to. You see, a few weeks before,
the judge in the defamation case had, for technical reasons, ordered that
the plaintiffs had 30 days to amend their complaint and include the trustees
as individual plaintiffs. The deadline for changes to the board was April
11.

Fitaihi's resignation was officially filed on April 10 (as was the
resignation of
<http://misskelly.typepad.com/miss_kelly_/2007/04/shrinkage_conti.html>
Egyptian trustee Ali Yusuf Tobah), one day before the deadline, and one day
before Fitaihi would have been locked in as a trustee, a party to the
lawsuit, and subject to deposition and the discovery process, all of which
was ably explained at the time by blogger
<http://misskelly.typepad.com/miss_kelly_/2007/04/the_incredible_.html> Miss
Kelly.

Fitaihi had been involved with the ISB for over a decade, since the trust's
founding in 1993, yet according to an
<http://misskelly.typepad.com/miss_kelly_/2007/05/wowee_maui_this.html> ISB
broadcast email, his obligations at home had suddenly become so pressing he
had had to resign.

Worry not, however, for according to the same email, Fitaihi "remains a key
leader of our community" and "will soon assume a new position with the ISB."

And that is where things stand at the time of this writing.

Final Thoughts

If you've read this far, you've gotten a fairly good primer on the various
twists and turns that brought us here.

It should be obvious by this point that there is and was enough known about
the financing and characters involved at the highest levels of the Islamic
Society of Boston that a reasonable man acting prudently would be compelled
to look closer at this group, their connections, and their financing.

And that's just what was done. And when those reasonable people found
themselves disturbed by what they had found and began speaking out about it,
they found themselves silenced by a lawsuit, their personal lives violated
by subpoenas and their private emails exposed to the world. 

"The intolerant export-version of Wahhabi Islam, driven by petrodollars, has
made itself a scourge the world over."

Neither the Boston Herald nor FOX-25 have done a hard-hitting report on the
issue since the lawsuit was filed, and I have been told by more than one
person, in the media and out, that they were reluctant to speak about the
issue publicly in any way for fear of either being drawn into the suit or
affecting the outcome. Involvement with the court system is a burdensome,
unpleasant, expensive affair that most people avoid if at all possible.
(This begs the question of who is paying the bills for this wide-ranging
suit.)

It's possible that there are what we would recognize as moderate Muslims
somewhere in Saudi Arabia, but that is not the type of Islam that is being
exported and financed world-wide from the Kingdom. On the contrary, the
intolerant export-version of Wahhabi Islam, driven by petrodollars, has made
itself a scourge the world over - in the Middle East, the Balkans, Africa,
and Asia.Saudi Wahhabism has made sure it is the Islam people find when
newcomers look to discover Islam, and when nominal Muslims seek to
rediscover their religion.

One need only look at the Kingdom itself to see where its image of Islam
leads - misogyny, anti-Semitism, Islamic supremacism, contempt and the most
extreme intolerance for non-Muslims.Jihad. It's not hard to understand why
anyone would be urging a loud NO to any institution with funding from Saudi
Arabia, or even significant funding from anywhere else in the Middle East.

Moderate and reformist Muslims
<http://www.solomonia.com/blog/archives/010428.shtml> do exist, and we do
them and ourselves no favors by remaining silent for convenience's sake and
to avoid ruffling a few feathers.

If a truly moderate, reformed version of Islam is to emerge in the West, it
won't come through funding from the Near East, and it will happen because
ordinary Americans insist that emerging institutions and organizations are
compatible on a deep level with American values, not simply using the
trappings of the Enlightenment West - our tolerance, our courts, our freedom
of speech and association - to subvert those very things that make us great.

And it won't happen if ordinary Americans are afraid to speak for fear of
financial and personal ruin at the hands of malicious court filings.

Maybe that's the idea.



[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]



--------------------------
Want to discuss this topic?  Head on over to our discussion list, [EMAIL 
PROTECTED]
--------------------------
Brooks Isoldi, editor
[EMAIL PROTECTED]

http://www.intellnet.org

  Post message: [email protected]
  Subscribe:    [EMAIL PROTECTED]
  Unsubscribe:  [EMAIL PROTECTED]


*** FAIR USE NOTICE. This message contains copyrighted material whose use has 
not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. OSINT, as a part of 
The Intelligence Network, is making it available without profit to OSINT 
YahooGroups members who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the 
included information in their efforts to advance the understanding of 
intelligence and law enforcement organizations, their activities, methods, 
techniques, human rights, civil liberties, social justice and other 
intelligence related issues, for non-profit research and educational purposes 
only. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of the copyrighted material 
as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use 
this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' 
you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.
For more information go to:
http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtml 
Yahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/

<*> Your email settings:
    Individual Email | Traditional

<*> To change settings online go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/join
    (Yahoo! ID required)

<*> To change settings via email:
    mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] 
    mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
    [EMAIL PROTECTED]

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
    http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/
 

Reply via email to