http://www.countercurrents.org/glazebrook111007.htm
 

Moazzam Begg: "We Need More
'Punk-Ass Kids'"

By Dan Glazebrook

11 October, 2007



"I was relieved." A stunned silence from the audience. Hang on - what? Did
we hear that correctly? Wasn't Moazzam Begg just asked how he felt when he
was told he was going to be sent to Guantanamo Bay? Yes, he was. "You have
to understand that at that time, I was being held at Bagram." The US base in
Bagram, where Moazzam was held for a year, is notorious. This was where he
had had to endure being kept awake for nights on end by the terrified
screams of fellow detainees - both women and men - two of whom were beaten
to death before his eyes, and where he was threatened with being sent to
Egypt for extreme torture, before being hooded, shackled and beaten himself.
After a year here, "I was looking forward to Guantanamo." 


Moazzam became politicized at an early age through his experiences of racism
growing up on Birmingham's Sparkhill estate. It was these experiences that
led him to join anti-racist gang 'the Lynx', who played a part in clearing
racism off the streets of Birmingham. His political consciousness deepened
as he began to educate himself about international issues during the First
Gulf War. Always tending to back the underdog his sympathies lay with the
Iraqis, and as he read more widely he found himself broadly supportive of Ho
Chi Minh and Fidel Castro in their struggles against US imperialism, as well
as Mandela and the Palestinians in their struggles against apartheid and
occupation. 


His growing internationalism led him to take part in eight aid convoys to
Bosnia, and finally to start work as aid worker in Afghanistan. When the US
began bombing in 2001, he and his family fled to Pakistan, from where his
nightmare began. Kidnapped by the Pakistani police (who were being paid by
the US military for each foreign Muslim they captured), and delivered into
US custody, his journey took him from Kandahar to Bagram, where he stayed
one year before ending up in Guantanamo's Camp Echo. 


Once there, Moazzam was kept in solitary confinement for two years, never
once being informed of any charge against him. How did he survive? "In
reality, I didn't always survive. There's not much you can do. I often felt
I couldn't use the experience for any kind of benefit. I would dream of
escape, but I would also try to memorise my copy of the Koran, and I would
make lists of everything I could think of - all the foreign words I knew,
all the capital cities, what I would do when I got out. I also started to
write poetry." The methods used at Guantanamo Bay - 24 hour lighting,
sensory deprivation, public humiliation, half-drowning. - have been widely
reported in this paper and elsewhere. I don't want this interview to dwell
on the details, but I do want to know what Moazzam believes is the purpose
of this abuse. It is becoming increasingly clear that the Guantanamo/ Bagram
methods, far from producing the quality intelligence the US claim is their
purpose, are actually designed to break prisoners down until they admit to
anything. In other words, the US torture system is designed not to extract
information, but to manufacture it for dubious political purposes. In his
book, Enemy Combatant, Begg notes that Ibn as-Shaykh al-Libbee was tortured
into signing a 'confession' that Saddam Hussein had trained Al-Qaeda in
using WMD, which was used as 'evidence' during the buildup towards the
invasion of Iraq, before later being retracted. After several particularly
brutal interrogations and threats, Moazzam himself "began to think that the
only thing I could do to end this misery and terror was to pretend to admit
to being involved in some terrorist plot. eventually I did agree to say
whatever they wanted me to say, to do whatever they wanted me to do. I
agreed to be their witness to whatever." 


But Moazzam believes there is also another reason for Guantanamo. "It is a
stark warning to the rest of the world: this is what happens to people who
dissent, or who live in countries whose governments dissent. We can pick you
up, anywhere in the world, without charge, and do these things to you for as
long as we want: and no one can do a thing about it." And let's not kid
ourselves that we are talking only about the US here: Contrary to the widely
propagated image of the British government as an appalled, if ineffectual,
bystander in the case of the British Guantanamo detainees, in Moazzam's case
at least, they were central to the whole process of his incarceration. MI5
were present at his very first interrogation, and at several others
subsequently. Indeed, it was they who had suggested to the Americans that he
be picked up in the first place. Why? Their suspicions seem to have been
raised by his internationalist work over the years - driving aid convoys to
Bosnia, visiting, and subsequently moving to Afghanistan to work in a girl's
school set up under the Taliban - but particularly by a letter he had
received from an acquaintance alleging torture and requesting legal
assistance. 


It seems clear that a big part of what MI5 had against Moazzam was his model
of internationalism - a practicing example of aiding just struggles and
supporting those less privileged than ourselves. Is part of the 'War on
Terror' aimed at terrorizing and criminalizing the whole concept of
international solidarity? The Terrorism Act 2000, by banning even symbolic
support for mass resistance groups such as Hamas, certainly gives that
impression.


"One of the things that people don't recognize in this country - or seem to
have forgotten - is that there was a time when Britain could well have been
occupied; in fact Jersey and Guernsey were occupied. There was a
counter-occupation plan drawn up by the Ministry of Defence, which included
what would today be termed terrorism. It included dad's army - the real
dad's army - taking up arms against not only the occupiers, but also
collaborators. We seem to have forgotten that. How do we recognize the
legitimacy of, say, the French Resistance, who were using 'terrorism'
against the Nazis, and not recognize the right of people to defend
themselves in Iraq or elsewhere? It's a principle: are you allowed to resist
occupation or not? To say that it is only legal 'when we say so' is to
remove the principle of self defence. It is a time honoured tradition for
people to resist occupation. The Terrorism Acts in this country attempt,
with a series of legislation, to criminalize not only attacks against
civilians - but any ability or idea to support resistance movements against
occupation, whether in Iraq, Palestine, or anywhere else." 


Do people outside the Muslim community have anything to fear from the
Terrorism Acts? "We've already seen it being used against people like Walter
Wolfgang [elderly Labour Party member arrested under the Terrorism Act for
heckling Jack Straw at Labour Conference]. I think it is just a beginning.
Clearly they are not targeting the non-Muslim community, but I would only
add the caveat "yet". And that is because the idea of dissent is being
demonized. It's not only just the [Muslim] community that is being
demonized, as much as we are, but what is really being demonized is dissent.
Because we are regarded as having traitorous voices, not supporting our boys
back home because we are against the war; when in fact, the reality is that
the government doesn't support them. The government, by introducing this new
legislation, is beginning to try to suppress dissent. One example of this is
the glorification of terror. Having a certain interpretation could very
easily include situations where the British government themselves would have
supported terrorism; for example during the Russian invasion of Afghanistan.
The Russians called the mujahadeen terrorists. The British, on the other
hand, were bringing mujahadeen to Scotland and to Snowdonia to train them
and sending them anti-aircraft missiles; but the Russians always maintained
they were terrorists. So it's paradoxical to recognize just how the tables
have turned, but in essence the idea of criminalization will not just be
limited to the Muslim community, but to wherever opposition is." 


I ask Moazzam if he sees parallels between the criminalization the Muslim
community is now facing, and what the Irish community here faced in the
1970s and 1980s. "There is, and one parallel stands out in particular - the
major lesson of Northern Ireland - unpalatable as it may be to some - is
that the people the government need to think about talking to, are the very
people they are currently demonizing." 


It turns out Moazzam has just returned from his third visit to Ireland,
where a plaque bearing his name was unveiled as part of the annual Bloody
Sunday commemoration. Moazzam's activism has clearly not been blunted by his
time in US custody - not even, it seems, for its duration. In Bagram, he
successfully agitated to improve the prisoners' conditions on two occasions
- once to be allowed to exercise, and once for more daily water - the latter
through that time-honoured Irish prisoners' tactic of the hunger strike. 


Back in Britain, what does Moazzam think is the way forward for the anti-war
movement, given the fact that government are not bothered by marches? His
answer is unequivocal: "I can tell you that with a lot of people I have been
speaking to across the board, Muslim and non-Muslim, the idea of a campaign
of civil disobedience is really starting to take off. That could well be the
next step I think." 


How would the government respond? "The response would be arrests of people.
I think this goes out to the crux of the matter - how much are people
willing to sacrifice for the greater cause? As a lot of Americans also say,
our country is now internationally hated - and I think anybody that cares
about how their country appears to the rest of the world should take note of
that, because whether we like it or not, we're all British. When we go out
of this country, people regard us as ambassadors to our nation. How can one
be proud to say, yes, I'm British, to, not just somebody in Iraq, but in
Brazil or Guatemala or anywhere else, when people regard you now as war
criminals? Britain has invaded Afghanistan more times than Alexander the
Great or Genghis Khan, and it continues to do so." 


Could a campaign of civil disobedience really take off? "I often get asked
when I speak at universities and elsewhere, 'what do you think should be
done'? And I remember a soldier, a Southern Alabaman who served two tours of
duty in Vietnam, who said, "listen, son, we didn't lose Vietnam, it was
those punk-ass kids - they're the ones who lost us Vietnam". So what I said
at the University is: we need more punk-ass kids."


Moazzam is clearly a serious political thinker and strategist of whom the
British anti-war and anti-imperialist movement can be immensely proud. Maybe
we should start doing as he suggests. 

 



[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]



--------------------------
Want to discuss this topic?  Head on over to our discussion list, [EMAIL 
PROTECTED]
--------------------------
Brooks Isoldi, editor
[EMAIL PROTECTED]

http://www.intellnet.org

  Post message: [email protected]
  Subscribe:    [EMAIL PROTECTED]
  Unsubscribe:  [EMAIL PROTECTED]


*** FAIR USE NOTICE. This message contains copyrighted material whose use has 
not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. OSINT, as a part of 
The Intelligence Network, is making it available without profit to OSINT 
YahooGroups members who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the 
included information in their efforts to advance the understanding of 
intelligence and law enforcement organizations, their activities, methods, 
techniques, human rights, civil liberties, social justice and other 
intelligence related issues, for non-profit research and educational purposes 
only. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of the copyrighted material 
as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use 
this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' 
you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.
For more information go to:
http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtml 
Yahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/

<*> Your email settings:
    Individual Email | Traditional

<*> To change settings online go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/join
    (Yahoo! ID required)

<*> To change settings via email:
    mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] 
    mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
    [EMAIL PROTECTED]

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
    http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/
 

Reply via email to