http://blogcritics. <http://blogcritics.org/archives/2007/10/13/215936.php>
org/archives/2007/10/13/215936.php
Where is Turkey Heading?
Written by Alamgir Hussain
Published October 13, 2007

Turkey's ruling Islamist-rooted Justice and Development Party's (AKP)
nomination of its foreign minister Abdullah Gul to the country's
presidency to replace a secular incumbent in April set off a political
standoff with the secular military. The staunchly secular army,
apprehensive that Mr. Gul's election may undermine Turkey's secular
and democratic principles, issued a veiled threat of coup. Their main
cause of concern lies in Mr. Gul's public display of piety and his
wife's donning Islamic headscarf. The same applies to Gul's more
religious boss, Prime Minister (PM) Recep Tayyip Erdogan, and his wife.

The worried secular citizens, including women, the likely worst victim
of Islamization of Turkey, also took to the street in large numbers
protesting Mr. Gul's election, with one rally attracting about 1.5
million protesters. These events forced the incumbent Islamist
government call an early election, which gave them a resounding new
mandate, bagging 47% of the votes (surpassing 34% in 2002), over
secular Republican Party's 20%, which enabled Mr. Gul's election to
Turkey's presidency on 28th August.

Commentators and pundits almost universally share the notion that
Turkey is the sole bastion of secular democracy in the crisis-ridden
Islamic world, which may potentially act as the torch-bearer for the
rest to follow. Turkey is, thus, an important test-case for Islamic
nations to demonstrate that they can be compatible with secular
democracy and modernity, and what lies ahead for Turkey will bear
profound significance not only for Muslim countries, but also for the
world at large &#8213; more so, since Turkey is seeking entry into the
European Union.

This victory of ballots in Turkey has elated both Islamist political
movements and their secular-democratic opponents all over the world.
In the post-9/11 era, discussion about Islam's likely incompatibility
with secularism and democracy has gripped the world, which may
potentially lead to a civilizational clash with Islam and the West &#8213;
which, many believe, is already underway.

In this context, Turkey's Islamist party's adoption of ballots - and
its promise to respect the secular constitution - have raised
unprecedented optimism worldwide that secularization and
democratization of the Islamic world is very much possible.
Commentators have emphasized that the victory of the Islamist AK party
in a free election in Turkey was an "affirmation of democracy" and
proof that "Islam and democracy are compatible." Others suggested that
this signaled victory for Muslim democrats in general and its snowball
effect may sweep across Islamic nations. Therefore, the military's
undemocratic interference in the democratic process in Turkey
attracted widespread condemnations internationally.

In the midst of these clashing viewpoints, an investigation of the
history and nature of the modern Turkish republic - and the rise of
the AK Party - is necessary to grasp what may lie ahead for Turkey's
democracy and secularism.

Modern Turkish republic was founded in 1923 by General Kemal Atatürk
by dismantling the theocratic Ottoman caliphate. He held Islam
responsible for the deplorable state of Muslim countries and
instituted secularism as Turkey's inviolable foundation. Atatürk (d.
1938) and his successors aggressively secularized and westernized
Turkey during the 1930s and 1940s, which separated Islam from
politics. Turkish military has acted as the guardian of secularism
ever since. They have intervened four different times to depose
pro-Islam parties from power and safeguard the secular fabric of the
republic.

During the era of secularization, the Islamists, under threat from the
powerful military, laid low before restarting their political revival
in 1970 when Professor Necmettin Ebrakan founded the Party of National
Order. It had clear goals for bringing the state in line with Islamic
holy laws (Sharia), violating Turkey's constitution, which prohibits
any organization from influencing the `basic social, economic,
political or judicial orders of the State (according) to religious
principles and beliefs' and was dissolved in a year.

Prof. Erbakan soon founded the National Salvation Party (NSP), with a
carefully worded manifesto, to avoid conflict with the constitution.
Behind the overriding force of secularization, the presence of an
Islamist undercurrent among the populace soon became evident when the
young NSP won 48 parliamentary seats in 1973, bringing it into ruling
alliance with the secularist Republican Party, ironically founded by
Kemal Atatürk. Prof Erbakan became Deputy PM in January 1974, and his
remarks and speeches during his tenure underlined pan-Islamic
overtures. Prof Erbakan, along with NSP's media mouthpiece, the Milli
Gazette (founded 1973), has since emanated increasingly fanatic verbal
tirades against the Jews, Zionism, and Israel. While promoting his
Islamist Happiness Party (SP) in the latest election, Erbakan gave
interviews in TV channels comparing the Zionists and Jews with
'Bacteria,' and 'Disease'. "Do you know what the safety of Israel
means? It means that they will rule the 28 countries from Morocco to
Indonesia. Since all the Crusades were organized by the Zionists…"

In his election campaign rallies, attracting large crowds, across
Turkey, the professor frequently repeated his anti-Semitic messages.
Furthermore, Milli Gazette published articles in February and April of
2005 which were virulently anti-Semitic, referring to protoypical
anti-Jewish verses (3:112, 2:61 etc.) of the Qur'an. "In fact, no
amount of pages or lines would be sufficient to explain the Qur'anic
chapters and our Lord Prophet's [Muhammad's] words that tell us of the
betrayals of the Jews... The prophets sent to them, such as Zachariah
and Isaiah, were murdered by the Jews...," read one commentary.

Erbakan is the de facto spiritual leader of Islamic politics in modern
Turkey, since all Islamist parties, including AKP, are off-shoots of
his political movement, launched in 1970. Top AKP leaders were groomed
by Ebrakan's political movements. PM Erdogan and President Gul served
as mayoral, ministerial, and parliamentary candidates in Erbakan's
parties to hone their political careers.

This anti-democratic and anti-secular past of AKP leadership raises
concerns among secular Turks. AKP's leaders seek to reassure the
skeptics that they have distanced themselves from their past Islamist
aspirations. "A political party cannot have a religion, only
individuals can," said Erdogan in 2003. Such assurances have led many
western leaders and commentators, to believe that AKP is an Islamic
equivalent of Europe's Christian Democratic parties.

PM Erdogan's various statements and actions in recent years, however,
raise questions about the mindset and ideals of AKP leadership. He has
embraced the militant Islamist Hamas movement of Palestine over the
secular Fatah party and has supported an al-Qaeda financier. His
theocratic aspiration can be gauged from a series of statements
between 1994 and 1996. He sought to turn all secular schools into
religious ones and to inaugurate the parliament by reciting the
Qur'an. He further claimed that he was "a servant of the Sharia" and
"the Imam of Istanbul."

PM Erdogan expressed his dislikes for secularism by deriding Kemal
Atatürk's commemoration events in 1994. He disapproved of a liberal
lifestyle and individual freedom by expressing opposition to New
Year's celebrations, seeking to ban alcohol, and saying that "swimsuit
commercials are lustful exploitations". During his tenure as the mayor
of Istanbul (1994-1998), he consistently pushed for Islamist agendas,
including a ban on alcohol.

AKP's leaders have cut down such theology-inspired statements during
their latest tenure in power. But their occasional statements suggest
that an undercurrent of Islamism is still alive. For example, PM
Erdogan reaffirmed his desire to turn the secular schools into
religious ones again last year. Despite Turkey's many pressing
problems, the ban on headscarf in government institutions has remained
AKP's major concern. Both PM Gul and President Erdogan have, at the
earliest opportunity, started work on a new constitution to reverse
the ban. Moreover, despite serving as the ruling party since 2003, AKP
leaders have never condemned their mentor Prof. Ebrakan's continued
spewing of hatred against the Jews and Israel.

The development in Turkey must also be taken in the context of
developments in the wider Islamic world. Since the European colonizers
evacuated, free Muslim nations have been undergoing steady
Islamization. Pakistan, for example, emerged in 1947 as a secular
nation, but now stands as one of world's most fanatic theocratic
Muslim state. A parallel Islamization of both political and cultural
fabric has been occurring in all Islamic countries, including among
Muslim communities of the West. The triumph of the Islamists in
Turkey, despite serious effort by the secular army and judiciary to
keep them at bay, is simply a manifestation of that Islamization trend.

Islamization is taking an increasingly violent trend in last couple of
decades in Muslim countries, from which Turkey has failed to shield
itself, too. A Turkish Muslim fanatic shot Pope John Paul II in 1981.
Al-Qaeda allied Islamic terrorists conducted double suicide bombings
against the British consulate and HSBC bank headquarters in Istanbul
in a week in November 2003, killing 50 people and injuring 400. A week
earlier, two synagogues were bombed in Istanbul as men, women, and
children gathered for prayers. Last February, an Islamic fanatic shot
a Catholic priest to death, while three Christians were murdered by
fanatics in April by cutting their throats for publishing the Bible.

Moreover, under current trends in Islamic countries, Muslim leaders,
keen to maintain secular fabric of their nations, are losing grip to
the rising tide of Islamizing pressures from among the common masses
and extremist elements. When AKP is elected for their Islamist
credentials, it will be doubly harder for them to ignore the popular
Islamizing pressures, even if they want so.

The Turkish military is not democratic in the true sense of it. Hence,
many commentators hope that AKP's triumph in recent standoff with the
military may enable them to institute Muslim world's first true
secular democracy in Turkey. But they ignore the obvious fact that
democracy has consistently acted as a tool for Islamization, not for
secularization.

For example, free-and-fair democratic elections in Palestine brought
militant Hamas to power, while in Lebanon, Hezbollah became the true
winner. The same applies to Iraq. AKP's victory in Turkey only
reflects a parallel phenomenon of what has happened in Palestine and
Lebanon. Furthermore, many Muslim countries emerged as secular
democracies after achieving independence from European colonial
powers, but have lost much of their secular credentials during last
few decades of often-democratic self-rule.

To the question of whether the ruling AKP will manifest their past
Islamist color; it is unlikely that they will do so, even if they
truly want, as long as the army remains secular and powerful. Their
true intentions will be reflected in how they seek to reform the
secular military and judiciary over the coming years.

However, a few developments since the latest victory of AKP suggest
that an Islamizing trend and pressure is already underway in Turkey.
Economist reports that a public bus had to stop at a mosque for prayer
upon demand from passengers on 2nd October. Such demands are now
reportedly coming from all over Turkey. In another incident, a
28-year-old divorcee woman was detained by Istanbul police on
"indecent exposure" charges for wearing a knee-length tunic and leggings.

These incidents, along with AKP's rushing to work on reversing the
headscarf ban as the top priority, are making Turkey's secularists
concerned that Atatürk's secular republic may be becoming another
theocratic Iran. But PM Erdogan once said, "Democracy was a train,
from which you could alight once you reached your destination." The
democracy-train has brought AKP to their destination. Will they now
alight from it as Erdogan promised remains to be seen?

Economist sees President Gul as an "undoubted democrat" in the ruling
Islamist party, who, it believes, will bolster AK's secular
credentials. If president Gul is the one to maintain Turkey's secular
credentials, he may have to step out of his boss Erdogan's footsteps
and may even have to confront the latter. Will Mr. Gul do so? It needs
to be seen as well, although all emerging indications point to the
contrary.

Veteran American journalist Eric S. Margolis, who disapproves of the
military's undemocratic interference in Turkey's politics, opined that
"AK's victory likely means the end of the cult of Kemalism." By `cult
of Kemalism' he undoubtedly meant Turkey's staunch French-style
secularism. The on-going developments in the Islamic world suggest
that Turkey probably has two ways ahead: keep in the path of Kemalism,
or join the rest of its Islamic brethren.

If Margolis is correct, Turkey's eight decades of secular legacy will
progressively be eroded and may eventually cease to exist. The
obsessive democracyphilia in the post-9/11 era may render the Turkish
military incapable to take actions for safeguarding secularism as in
the past. In a few decades, Turkey may well be left with the kind of
democracy seen in Iran, Palestine, or Sudan.
Alamgir Hussain (PhD) is a co-author in 'Beyond Jihad - Critical
Voices from Inside' (Academica Press). He has completed writing a new
book entitled, 'History of Islam -- Separating Myths from Reality'.



.
 
<http://geo.yahoo.com/serv?s=97359714/grpId=1189140/grpspId=1705323667/msgId
=69172/stime=1192344261/nc1=3848618/nc2=4836045/nc3=4776343> 
 


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]



--------------------------
Want to discuss this topic?  Head on over to our discussion list, [EMAIL 
PROTECTED]
--------------------------
Brooks Isoldi, editor
[EMAIL PROTECTED]

http://www.intellnet.org

  Post message: [email protected]
  Subscribe:    [EMAIL PROTECTED]
  Unsubscribe:  [EMAIL PROTECTED]


*** FAIR USE NOTICE. This message contains copyrighted material whose use has 
not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. OSINT, as a part of 
The Intelligence Network, is making it available without profit to OSINT 
YahooGroups members who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the 
included information in their efforts to advance the understanding of 
intelligence and law enforcement organizations, their activities, methods, 
techniques, human rights, civil liberties, social justice and other 
intelligence related issues, for non-profit research and educational purposes 
only. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of the copyrighted material 
as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use 
this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' 
you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.
For more information go to:
http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtml 
Yahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/

<*> Your email settings:
    Individual Email | Traditional

<*> To change settings online go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/join
    (Yahoo! ID required)

<*> To change settings via email:
    mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] 
    mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
    [EMAIL PROTECTED]

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
    http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/
 

Reply via email to