" Sanctuary cities " by definition invite and attract terrorists in...
 
B
 


 <http://www.salon.com/news/feature/2007/10/04/sanctuary/print.html>
http://www.salon.com/news/feature/2007/10/04/sanctuary/print.html 
 
  

Congress to New York (and Chicago and L.A.): Drop dead

Popular proposals to choke off federal support to immigrant-friendly
"sanctuary cities" would also dry up anti-terror funding for the cities most
at risk. 

By Alex Koppelman

Oct. 04, 2007 | Al-Qaida <http://dir.salon.com/topics/al_qaida/> 's targets
on 9/11 were in New York City and Washington.
<http://dir.salon.com/topics/washington_dc/>  But if Tom Tancredo, R-Colo.,
and 233 other members of the U.S. House have their way, those cities and
others at high risk of terrorist attacks, including some that have
reportedly been the target of foiled plots, would be stripped of the federal
funding intended to keep their citizens safe from attack. 

At issue are so-called sanctuary cities. There is no single definition of a
"sanctuary city," but in essence it is one that takes a "don't ask, don't
tell" stance toward the immigration status of its residents. For example, a
sanctuary city might bar local police from inquiring about or disclosing the
status of a victim or witness of a crime. A comprehensive list of sanctuary
cities would have to include a huge swath of urban America. It would include
the four biggest cities in the United States, the majority of the 25 biggest
cities, and every one of the six urban areas the Department of Homeland
Security says face the highest risk of terrorism -- New York, Washington,
Los Angeles, San Francisco, Chicago and Houston. 

Spurred by the GOP <http://dir.salon.com/topics/gop/>  base's anger over
illegal immigration, <http://dir.salon.com/topics/immigration/>  Republicans
in the House have introduced several bills and amendments that would impose
financial penalties on those sanctuary cities. Two measures, amendments to
larger spending bills, have already passed. Such proposals have also become
an issue in the race for the Republican presidential nomination, and several
candidates have voiced their support. 

But the proposals involve depriving the nation's biggest and most vulnerable
cities of their anti-terror funding. To fight the War on Illegal
Immigration, the party is willing to defund the War on Terror. For residents
of America's major cities, it might therefore be reassuring to know that
most of the measures, even as they're approved by Congress, are written in
such a way that they'll be hard to enforce. 

There are many overlapping lists of sanctuary, none of them definitive. The
Congressional Research Service, a nonpartisan arm of the Library of
Congress, counts 32 cities, towns and counties, as well as two states,
Alaska and Oregon, as sanctuaries. Altogether, the jurisdictions in the CRS
count -- including, for example, New York City, Los
<http://dir.salon.com/topics/los_angeles/> Angeles, Houston, Detroit,
Minneapolis, San Diego, San Francisco
<http://dir.salon.com/topics/san_francisco/>  and Seattle -- encompass
roughly 25 million people, or more than 8 percent of the population of the
United States. And the CRS list is fairly limited; it leaves off some large
cities like Chicago, Boston and Washington, which have similar policies, or
others, like Miami and Denver, that Tancredo has accused of having such
policies. The National Immigration Law  <http://www.nilc.org/> Center, a
liberal advocacy group, has put together a preliminary list of "laws,
resolutions and policies ... limiting enforcement of immigration laws by
state and local authorities." (The NILC doesn't like or use the "sanctuary
city" term, but its list is a fair stand-in for a comprehensive account of
the cities that opponents of sanctuary policies would describe as "sanctuary
cities.") That list includes nearly 70 jurisdictions, and even it doesn't
include some locales considered sanctuary cities by anti-illegal immigration
activists. 

At the moment, several proposals that would restrict funding to sanctuary
cities are wending their way through Congress. Two, attached as amendments
to spending bills, passed the House of
<http://dir.salon.com/topics/house_of_representatives/> Representatives this
summer. One, proposed by Tancredo and attached to the appropriations bill
that funds the Department of Homeland Security, provided that no funds from
the bill -- meaning no DHS anti-terror money -- could go to a sanctuary
city. That amendment passed
<http://www.govtrack.us/congress/vote.xpd?vote=h2007-485>  by a vote of
234-189, and the bill to which it was attached later passed the House by a
large margin. A version of the bill passed by the Senate does not include
Tancredo's amendment -- T.Q. Houlton, Tancredo's spokesman, described the
chance it will be added to the final bill in committee as "slim." A similar
amendment, added to the Commerce, Justice, Science and Related Agencies
Appropriations Act by Rep. Thelma Drake, R-Va., passed by voice vote. The
House has passed that larger bill as well, but the Senate has yet to take it
up. 

Other bills that would punish sanctuary cities are on their way. Among them
is H.R. 3549, The No
<http://www.govtrack.us/congress/billtext.xpd?bill=h110-3549> Sanctuary for
Illegals Act. Introduced by Rep. Dan Burton, R-Ind., the bill cuts all
federal funding to sanctuary cities. Burton's office did not respond to
repeated messages seeking comment. Another recently introduced bill is H.R.
3531, the Accountability
<http://www.govtrack.us/congress/billtext.xpd?bill=h110-3531> in Enforcing
Immigration Laws Act of 2007, sponsored by Reps. Ginny Brown-Waite, R-Fla.;
Brian Bilbray, R-Calif.; Jeff Miller, R-Fla.; Tancredo and Drake. That bill
cuts 25 percent of "non-emergency" DHS funding from sanctuary cities and
gives the head of DHS the discretion to cut an additional 25 percent. 

Punishing sanctuary cities with legislation has a clear political upside.
Such measures enjoy solid support among the anti-immigration segments of the
Republican base. The issue has come up in the race for the 2008 Republican
presidential nomination. Former Massachusetts Gov. Mitt Romney
<http://dir.salon.com/topics/mitt_romney/>  has used the subject in radio
ads and debates, wielding it as a club with which to batter former New York
City Mayor Rudy Giuliani, <http://dir.salon.com/topics/rudy_giuliani/>  a
rival candidate. While mayor, Giuliani was a staunch defender of the city's
policies, even filing an unsuccessful lawsuit to try to protect one part of
the policy, since amended, from federal efforts to end it. In a 1996 speech
<http://www.nyc.gov/html/rwg/html/96/ken.html>  at Harvard's Kennedy School
of Government, given the day before he filed the suit, Giuliani hit out at
the federal government and anti-immigration forces generally, saying, "I
believe the anti-immigration movement in America is one of our most serious
public problems ... I know that our executive order offends some people.
They ask, 'Why should we pay to provide services for illegal immigrants?'
The answer is, It's not only to protect them, but to protect the rest of
society as well." 

But opposition to sanctuary cities is not a purely Republican issue. A poll
<http://www.rasmussenreports.com/public_content/politics/71_favor_requiring_
foreign_visitors_to_carry_universal_id_card> conducted by Rasmussen Reports
in August put the proportion of likely voters in favor of cutting federal
funding to sanctuary cities at 58 percent, with just 29 percent opposed. Up
to 49 Democratic members of the House have supported some versions of the
anti-sanctuary legislation. 

Bilbray says he thinks public support will eventually force the passage of
some anti-sanctuary measure. "I think the Democrats are going to realize,
look, we have to take this one," he said. "Because the areas where they're
demanding sanctuary for illegals, they're not at-risk districts. They're not
the districts where they're going to either hold, or lose the majority. It's
going to be those places where the illegal immigration is a real hot issue,
and the sanctuary city thing will hurt them if they stand by it." 

But there's more at work in the anti-sanctuary movement than just political
considerations, proponents of anti-sanctuary measures say. They argue that
sanctuary cities are a danger to local residents and the country as a whole.
The cities, they allege, shield potential and actual criminals from
deportation; could be allowing potential terrorists to go undetected; and
are in violation of federal law simply by mandating noncompliance. 

"When cities proclaim that they will not check immigration status, they
essentially become a safe haven for not only out-of-status immigrants, but
criminal aliens who have often committed violent atrocities in our country,"
Brown-Waite, whose office did not respond to messages seeking comment, said
in a statement
<http://brown-waite.house.gov/News/DocumentSingle.aspx?DocumentID=74062>  at
the time H.R. 3531 was introduced. "Imagine that Mohammed Atta or one of the
other 9/11 hijackers, who were in the country illegally, had a city they
could reside in to plot terrorist attacks with no fear of ever being checked
or deported. We run the risk of inviting terror into these cities." 

In an interview with Salon, Bilbray echoed Brown-Waite's sentiments. "Can
you imagine anywhere else in the world where a city announces that it will
not only not enforce or cooperate in enforcement of a federal law?" Bilbray
asked. "The chutzpah of this is for a city to say we're not going to
cooperate with the federal government and then demand federal funds to fight
terrorism. The two are linked and have been linked since 9/11." 

Defenders of sanctuary-city policies, however, assert that on balance the
policies keep communities safer and healthier. Ed Koch,
<http://dir.salon.com/topics/ed_koch/>  the former mayor of New York who, in
1989, became the first in a continuous line of the city's mayors to
promulgate a version of the executive order that controls the city's
policies on ascertaining and disclosing immigration status, says he's still
proud of his decision. In an interview, Koch provided examples of instances
in which he said the city's policies both applied and made sense. 

"One, if you have children, send them to school. We do not ask where they
came from. We don't turn in children who are here illegally ... We don't
want children, legal or illegal, walking the streets when they should be in
school and either being victims of predators or predators ... Number two,
what we said was, if you're sick and you can't afford a doctor, come to our
municipal hospitals. We don't turn in illegal aliens. Why? Because if
somebody is sick, particularly if they have a contagious disease, it affects
all of us." 

When it comes to public safety, meanwhile, defenders of sanctuary cities say
their policy deters crime. John Feinblatt, the criminal justice coordinator
for the City of New York, says that the city's policy regarding law
enforcement involvement with immigration status isn't protecting criminals
but helping the NYPD catch them -- and that it is one of the reasons New
York City <http://dir.salon.com/topics/new_york_city/>  is the country's
safest big city. (It should be noted that, like officials in many other
localities accused of being a sanctuary city, New York officials generally,
and Feinblatt specifically in an interview with Salon, deny that the city is
a sanctuary city. It does, however, have some of the policies that
characterize a sanctuary. For example, New York prohibits the police from
investigating a person's immigration status unless there's some other
illegal activity suspected, and from looking into the immigration status of
crime victims and witnesses.) 

"We do smart law enforcement," Feinblatt says. "The elements [of smart law
enforcement] are being proactive, using data, being aggressive about putting
your resources where the problems are, and maximizing information. How do
you maximize information? You do it by having good intelligence, and part of
good intelligence is the ability for victims and witnesses to come forward
no matter who they are ... We are a city of immigrants, and what we want to
do is encourage people to come forward so that we can use their information
to continue to fight crime." 

New York law enforcement isn't alone in believing this. In 2006, an
organization known as the Major Cities Chiefs, comprising the chiefs of
police of the 64 largest police departments in the United States and Canada,
put out a position  <http://www.houstontx.gov/police/pdfs/mcc_position.pdf>
paper that opposed any congressional efforts like the ones currently under
consideration. In the position paper, the Major Cities Chiefs said local law
enforcement did not have the budget or capability to become an enforcer of
federal immigration law. Further, "immigration enforcement by local police
would likely negatively effect [sic] and undermine the level of trust and
cooperation between local police and immigrant communities. If the
undocumented immigrant's primary concern is that they will be deported or
subjected to an immigration status investigation, then they will not come
forward and provide needed assistance and cooperation. Distrust and fear of
contacting or assisting the police would develop among legal immigrants as
well ... Such a divide between the local police and immigrant groups would
result in increased crime against immigrants and in the broader community,
create a class of silent victims and eliminate the potential for assistance
from immigrants in solving crimes or preventing future terroristic acts." 

Perhaps the strongest argument made by opponents of sanctuary cities is that
such policies could shield potential terrorists, using the 9/11
<http://dir.salon.com/topics/911/>  hijackers who were in the country
illegally as an example of the danger. But that argument has its flaws, and
not just because the remedies they've proposed involve, paradoxically,
punishing such cities by cutting their terror funding. Though all nineteen
9/11 hijackers were in the country illegally, most had committed their
violations in applying for their visa and thus could never have been
detected by local law enforcement. As few as two or three of them had
committed violations that would have been evident in the kind of check local
law enforcement is capable of performing. And, says Susan Ginsburg, a
staffer on the 9/11 Commission and the coauthor of a commission staff report
titled "9/11
<http://www.9-11commission.gov/staff_statements/911_TerrTrav_Monograph.pdf>
and Terrorist Travel," it was unlikely that such a check could have been
performed in the pre-9/11 era. 

Ginsburg, now a visiting senior policy analyst at the Migration Policy
Institute, <http://www.migrationpolicy.org/>  a Washington think tank,
opposes the proposals under consideration. "The larger point is that an
immigration enforcement policy cannot substitute for a counterterrorism
policy," Ginsburg says. "It would be counterproductive to obstruct state and
local counterterrorism programs in order to pressure them regarding
immigration policy." 

Moreover, the actual extent to which local authorities are not cooperating
with federal immigration officials appears to be greatly exaggerated.
Earlier this year, the Department of
<http://dir.salon.com/topics/department_of_justice/> Justice Office of
Inspector General (OIG) released a report,
<http://www.usdoj.gov/oig/reports/OJP/a0707/index.htm>  mandated by
Congress, that investigated whether any jurisdictions receiving funds
intended to help them pay for the costs of incarcerating illegal aliens were
not cooperating with the federal agency in charge of immigration,
Immigration and Customs Enforcement. Included in the report's executive
summary was this note: 

"Our review did not disclose any instances of outright failure to cooperate
with ICE in the removal of criminal aliens from the United States. Instead,
we found that local jurisdictions often set the enforcement of state and
local law as a priority, while sometimes permitting or encouraging law
enforcement agencies and officers to work with ICE to some degree on
immigration matters." 

In interviews with Salon, New York City officials stressed that they always
cooperate with ICE, and that though their policy may forbid the
investigation of immigration status by itself, such an investigation is
permitted if there's any suspicion of any illegal activity, even something
as simple as jaywalking. 

"People who want to paint New York or other cities as not cooperating with
immigration officials need to look at the facts," Feinblatt said. "I mean,
perhaps the most vivid example is in our city jail. ICE has its own office
that we supply them. We do joint operations with them. For instance, ICE has
estimated -- conservatively, it says -- that at least 200 new cases each
month are identified through cooperative efforts of New York City." 

Because sanctuary-city opponents imagine the problem of non-cooperation as
much bigger than it is, they may have inadvertently written their
countermeasures so they apply to very few cities, if they apply to any at
all. 

The federal law that sanctuary cities are accused of breaking, the one that
would trigger enforcement of the de-funding amendments proposed by Tancredo
and Drake, is a specific section of the 1996 Illegal Immigration
<http://www.lib.umich.edu/govdocs/text/104208.txt> Reform and Immigrant
Responsibility Act, which says local jurisdictions may not restrict their
officials from exchanging information with federal immigration authorities
about a person's immigration status. On the floor of the House, Rep. David
Price, D-N.C., challenged Tancredo to provide an example of a city with
policies that contravene that section. Tancredo could not, and in
conversations with Salon, neither could Tancredo's spokesman. 

Perhaps that's because there aren't any. The OIG was also asked to look into
the question of what jurisdictions violated that section. In its report, it
said, "Only the City and County of San Francisco gave a qualified 'yes' in
response to our queries about the existence of a local ordinance or a
departmental policy limiting the ability of local law enforcement officers
or agencies to exchange information with ICE relating to immigration
enforcement," but noted that certain exceptions to the city's policies meant
that it might not truly be in violation of the section. 

Even statutes written more broadly, like Burton's, might not hit any of
their intended targets. Burton's bill cuts funding from "any State, or
political subdivision of a State, that is determined by the Secretary of
Homeland Security to be interfering with efforts to enforce Federal
immigration laws." But in a September hearing of the House Homeland Security
Committee, DHS Secretary Michael Chertoff, under questioning from
Brown-Waite about sanctuary cities and the potential effect of bills like
hers, said flatly, "I'm not aware of any city, although I may be wrong, that
actually interferes with our ability to enforce the law." 

 


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]



--------------------------
Want to discuss this topic?  Head on over to our discussion list, [EMAIL 
PROTECTED]
--------------------------
Brooks Isoldi, editor
[EMAIL PROTECTED]

http://www.intellnet.org

  Post message: [email protected]
  Subscribe:    [EMAIL PROTECTED]
  Unsubscribe:  [EMAIL PROTECTED]


*** FAIR USE NOTICE. This message contains copyrighted material whose use has 
not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. OSINT, as a part of 
The Intelligence Network, is making it available without profit to OSINT 
YahooGroups members who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the 
included information in their efforts to advance the understanding of 
intelligence and law enforcement organizations, their activities, methods, 
techniques, human rights, civil liberties, social justice and other 
intelligence related issues, for non-profit research and educational purposes 
only. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of the copyrighted material 
as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use 
this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' 
you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.
For more information go to:
http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtml 
Yahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/

<*> Your email settings:
    Individual Email | Traditional

<*> To change settings online go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/join
    (Yahoo! ID required)

<*> To change settings via email:
    mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] 
    mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
    [EMAIL PROTECTED]

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
    http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/
 

Reply via email to