http://www.frontpagemag.com/Articles/Read.aspx?GUID=8E531AD7-BFC0-4423-B73B- 4E17EA6FC4CE
Murder and Mendacity in Academe By <file:///C:/Program%20Files/Common%20Files/Microsoft%20Shared/Stationery/aut hors.aspx?Name=Laurie Morrow> Laurie Morrow FrontPageMagazine.com | Tuesday, October 23, 2007 I. BLIGHT IN THE GROVES OF ACADEME Mark Twain once observed, Truth is the most valuable thing we have. Let us economize it. Judging by their mishandling of the murder of Laura Dickinson, Eastern Michigan University must have a mountain of truth squirreled away in some dark corner of its campus. Laura Dickinson, 22, was a transfer student finishing her first semester at EMU. On December 3rd, she was home, celebrating her fathers 51st birthday with the family. She returned to campus for finals, and her parents, Bob and Debra, spoke with her on the 12th, but, after that, they had been unable to contact her. On the 15th, they telephoned the university to ask that someone check Lauras dorm room. Laura was staying in Room 518 of Hill Hall, part of EMUs Hoyt/Pitmann/Hill complex, three massive edifices on the periphery of the 23,000-student universitys campus. Each of these residence halls is 11 stories tall, the complex having been designed to hold over 1400 students, a population of sufficient size that those who roomed there would be unlikely to distinguish readily a fellow resident from an intruder. As it turned out, EMU housing employees had already opened the door to Lauras room, responding to a complaint from an adjoining room of a strong, sickening odor. They found Lauras dead body on the floor, wearing only a tank top pulled up around her shoulders. A bed pillow covered her face. Her discoverers immediately relocked the door, and contacted campus police. Bob Dickinson was at his coffee shop, State Grounds, where Laura occasionally helped out, when EMU informed him that she had been found dead. Dickinson was told few details, other than that the police had been called, and an autopsy performed. Because of the extent of the decompositionLauras body had lain next to a heater for two daysthe autopsy was inconclusive, but the university assured Dickinson that there was no reason to suspect foul play. Lauras stunned family groped for an explanation for their daughters death. Since the university seemed confident that it was from natural causes, her parents attributed it to a sudden resurgence of the stress-related heart arrhythmia with which Laura had been diagnosed two years earlier. Four days before Christmas, with no authoritative cause of death yet offered them, Lauras family held her funeral at the Thornapple Valley Church in Hastings, laying her to rest in Riverside Cemetery. Ten weeks later, the Dickinsons would begin to learn the truth about their daughters death, and about the mendacity that has become a careerist tool for university officials on American campuses. II. BORN TO RUN The ostrich is . . . a flightless bird that can never take to the skies, so instead, its built for running. . . . When danger threatens, ostriches can escape pretty easily by running away. . . . Ostriches like to live in groups [because] . . .at least one of them is likely to see danger coming. . . . Ostriches do not bury their heads in the sand. When an ostrich senses danger and cannot run away, it flops to the ground and remains still, with its head and neck flat on the ground in front of it. . . . Ostriches are omnivores . . . . They mostly eat plants . . . but they also much on insects like locusts and small animals, like lizards. . . . Ostriches eat things that other animals cant digest. --San Diego Zoo, Animal Bytes Assume you are a normal human being. Assume you are also a university president. You have just learned that the body of a female student has been found nearly naked and dead in her campus dorm room. While it is not an absolute certainty that she has been murdered, circumstances strongly suggest this is the case. What do you do? For most people, the answer is eye-rollingly obvious: you alert the campus that the police believe the death of a student in a dorm could be a homicide. You urge everyone, especially women, to take extra safety precautions until the police either rule out homicide or apprehend the person responsible. You ask that any suspicious activity be reported to the police, whom you, personally and frequently, contact regarding the case. You promise to keep everyone who uses the campus updated. And you do so. Was this how EMU President John A. Fallon, III, responded to the murder of Laura Dickinson? Not exactly. Fallon responded to Laura Dickinsons death much in the manner of a skittish ostrich that has spotted a cheetah and sprints away from danger as fast as its legs can take it, putting as much geography as possible between itself and the cats claws and teeth. For Fallon, the danger was that the vicious murder might disturb the serene façade of EMU, disquieting students, alumni, and faculty, while raising doubts about his wise stewardship, which might endanger his career as an academic administrator. While running away wasnt a tactic literally available to him, he could put distance between himself and the murder. We arent privy to the thoughts that darted through Fallons mind as he faced the challenge to his presidency that Dickinsons murder presented but we can make suppositions based upon his actions. He appears to have adopted a four-part strategy that can be summarized as: minimize alarm, cultivate personal ignorance of the facts, delegate responsibility to underlings, and, if challenged, blame those underlings for any mistakes, especially not removing his ignorance, for he would certainly have handled the matter far better if not for their failing to keep him informed. The first part of his apparent strategy, minimizing alarm, is commonly called damage control. Unfortunately, the damage to be controlled is too often damage to the repute of the implementer of the strategy and not the real, physical damage that may be inflicted upon those the damage controllers are duty bound to protect. Here, protecting the lives was less important than protecting the image of the university and its administrators. On the morning of December 16th, the day after Lauras body was discovered, the office of University Communications posted EMUs official response to Lauras death. The headline on the press release was An open message to the EMU community and the public regarding the death of a student. The message was not a warning that a murderer might be on campus, but, rather, was an assurance that the campus was safe: The entire EMU community was saddened to learn of the death of one of our students on campus this week. We offer our most heartfelt condolences to the students family. You may have seen reports in the media regarding this situation. At the request of the family and out of respect for their privacy, EMU will not release the students name or identifying information. EMUs Department of Public Safety is working closely with the medical examiners office to determine the cause and circumstances of death. At this point, there is no reason to suspect foul play. We are fully confident in the safety and security of our campus environment, and our campus officials will remain vigilant in ensuring safety for all members of our campus community. This incommunicative communication conceals Lauras name, date of death, place of death, manner of death, home town, major, and even her sex, allegedly to protect the Dickinsons privacy, a privacy they hadnt invoked. With a few keystrokes, the existence of the nutrition major who dreamt of going to Africa to help children with AIDS was excluded from the universitys official consciousness. Although the entire EMU community ostensibly grieved the loss of, well, whoever the unknown student might have been, the Presidents office arranged no on-campus memorial service for the anonymous deceased. And then, having expressed the universitys grief with remarkably brief dispatch, the press release gets on with the business of marketing in the guise of an Editors Note: Looking for an expert source for a story? Check out EMUs Easter Experts online . . . President Fallon allowed the statement to be posted without verifying with those conducting the investigation the accuracy of the last two sentences. This message remained posted for ten weeks, long after it was evident that a murder investigation was underway, and that campus security measures had clearly been breached. Worse, this needless assertion of the safety of the campus could well have encouraged students to be less, rather than more, vigilant about their safety, at a time when it was likely that a rapist/murder was roaming the campus. This was especially reprehensible, as the Administration was well aware that the set of master keys to every lock on every campus door had been stolen in August 2005, and that, in December 2006, many locks still remained unchanged and vulnerable. Lauras dorm had been re-keyed, but at the time of her death, in clear contradiction to the press release, many areas on campus were still unsecured. So lax was the Administration in addressing this security problem that as late as June 2006, six months after Lauras murder, some 500 faculty offices still had not been re-keyed. The statement, with its unverified assertions, fit with Fallons cultivation of personal ignorance. It presented a vague, bland, uninformative version of the horrific event that he could claim as his understanding of the situation. To preserve his ignorance, Fallon delegated handling Dickinsons death to underlings. Any fault for errors would be attributed to them because he had given them responsibility. The most significant underling to stand as a barrier between Fallon and the facts was EMU Vice President of Student Affairs, James F. Vick. Vick was delegated the task of informing the Dickinsons of Lauras murder. Vick would give them the vague details that they received. It would even be Vick who would represent the university at Lauras funeral. Fallon couldnt make time on his calendar to stand by the grave of one of his students, murdered on his watch. Delegating this courtesy to Vick conveniently kept him from a situation in which he might have to give answers to the grieving parents. Other underlings would also be utilized as necessary. The administrator responsible for preventing and handling campus crime at EMU was Cindy Hall, 50, the Director of the Department of Public Safety (DPS), who had a quarter of a centurys experience as an EMU safety official. An EMU alumna, Hall had earned her bachelors degree in criminal justice at the university where she was now employed. She was also a graduate of the Northwestern University School of Police Staff and Command, and had earned a Juris Doctorate from the University of Toledo College of Law. It was Halls office that had jurisdiction over the crime. Hall entered Lauras dorm room around 1:30 p.m., shortly after the body was discovered, and, according to Michigan State Police Detective Sgt. Fred Farkas, she remained at the crime scene into the late night hours. Suspecting Lauras death was a homicide, EMUs police called in the Ypsilanti Police, the Michigan State Police, and the Major Crimes Task Force of the Washtenaw County (Michigan) Sheriffs Office. Curiously, although the representatives from these disparate law enforcement agencies concurred that what they were looking at was almost certainly a homicide, Hall decided that law enforcements inquiries should be referred to as a death investigation, ostensibly because there was a lack of a conclusive opinion of the medical examiner. Hall purportedly deemed it inadvisable to warn the campus community that a rapist/murderer might be roaming the grounds, until all tests were done and all reports were in. Desirable thought it may be to avoid sensationalizing a probable homicide, this strategy privileged discretion in the conduct of a criminal investigation over the prevention of additional crime through a timely warning. Many would subsequently wonder whether the death investigation were concocted with the universitys reputation foremost in mind, with justice for Dickinson and the safety of other students tying for a distant second place. Vick, Halls immediate supervisor, also appeared at Lauras door soon after the discovery of her body. Yet, having taken the trouble to get to her door, Vick neither crossed its threshold, nor even let his glance dart into her room. He would later claim that, from where he stood, he was able to see the body only below the knees. There are conflicting reports as to whether Vick saw or knew that a bed pillow covered Lauras face. It appears Vick was copying Fallons policy of not knowing too much. Though Hall was Vicks subordinate, he delegated to her key decisions, justifying his doing so on the grounds that she was the person in charge with the credentials to make that decision. When discussing Lauras death with President Fallon, Vick alluded to the homicide investigation as a death investigation, and did not suggest to Fallon the death was most likely a homicide. Vick claims that it was at Halls request that he destroyed an official document, the Department of Public Safetys Initial Draft Report, describing the discovery of the body. He insists that he shredded this document without first reading it. According to the Butzel-Long Report, Vick claimed, he did not read it because he assumed he already knew its contents from what DPS told him earlier about the circumstances of Ms. Dickinsons death. Shred before reading! sounds like something Maxwell Smart would have shouted into his shoe phone, but this approach may well have worked in Vicks favor. The IDR probably included grim details that would have made it obvious Laura was murdered. Vick would subsequently further confuse those who tried to piece together what he knew and when by offering a number of accounts of what he saw, knew, and suspected, accounts which are not entirely congruent with each other. As the weeks passed and the murder investigation proceded, no one at Eastern Michigan University recanted the false assurances given that there wasnt any sign of foul play involved and that the campus was safe. For those in the know, the universitys statement was clearly contradicted by the facts, yet, it remained posted, despite concerns raised by the officer in charge of the case, the university ombudsman, and a member of the public relations staff. While these and other employees raised concerns, no one was actually willing to do something to bring the statement more in line with the truth. Ten weeks would pass, before that statement would be taken down. Only with the arrest of EMU student Orange Taylor, III, on February 23, 2007, for the rape and murder of Laura Dickinson would the truth about the death investigation be made public. It was only then that Fallon announced to the media that Lauras death had been a homicide. He did not, however, call the parents to inform them. He didnt even give this job to Vick. Instead, the task was delegated further down the administrative food chain to the Ombudsman/Dean of Students and, rather than being accompanied by DPS Director Cindy Hall, a lower-ranking DPS police officer was chosen to go with him. Unfortunately, before these worthies were ready to contact the Dickinsons, the media had the story via a university press conference. As a result, Lauras mother learned that her daughter had been murdered not from a representative of the university, but from a reporter. The announcement of Taylors arrest was the first official notification to the EMU community that a rapist/murderer had been walking among them and that the universitys assurances of safety were false. Happily, Taylor hadnt taken advantage of his unwary fellow students to kill again but EMU had chosen to put them at risk. The students might have chosen differently, accepting the risk and taking precautions or leaving EMU for a safer situation, but EMUs mendacious strategy had kept private the information necessary to make that choice. In a coincidence fortunate for EMU, February 23rd, the date the EMU community became aware of how dangerous the campus had been, was one day past the last day on which students could withdraw from the university and receive a refund ( <http://www.emich.edu/registrar/deadlinedates.html> http://www.emich.edu/registrar/deadlinedates.html). III. CRIME AND, PERHAPS, PUNISHMENT He who does not prevent a crime when he can, encourages it. --Seneca Eastern Michigan Universitys reluctance to be open with the university community and the public didnt end with the arrest of Laura Dickinsons killer. Whereas before they had concealed the crime, they now provided only limited information about the alleged killer. They claimed they were constrained by student privacy issues but critics, who now knew of EMUs capacity to dissemble, wondered if the university was concealing actions that had made the crime possible or, perhaps, even probable. Had they had a chance to prevent the murder? Who should be held accountable? Was EMU using student privacy to protect administrators who had failed to protect Dickinson? Where the same policies and people who hadnt kept her safe still in place? EMU wasnt forthcoming with many answers. The Ann Arbor News would have to file a FOIA (Freedom of Information Act) request in order to get a straight answer as to whether this was the first time Taylor had been arrested by EMU security officers. The newspapers investigative efforts revealed that Taylor had been involved in encounters with police at least twice prior to his arrest for Dickinsons murder. On December 23, 2005, a female staff member in King Hall discovered Taylor crawling in through a window. When Taylor saw her, he asked whether the building he was sneaking into was a dorm, and, on learning it was not, he departed, again through the window. When officially questioned about this incident on January 26, 2006, Taylor reportedly admitted having illegally entered the building but claimed his actions were innocently motivated by a search for girls and activity. According to the Grand Rapids Press, in January 2006, Taylor was also questioned about a fire that occurred in the same building, EMUs King Hall, during Thanksgiving Break in November 2005. The fire, which was ruled an arson, destroyed the three offices occupied by EMUs Office of Student Judicial Services, the campus office which administers student conduct policies and which investigates claims of student-to-student sexual harassment. For reasons as yet undisclosed, after police questioned Taylor regarding the arson in King Hall, they obtained a DNA sample from him. It is possible that this sample may have linked Taylor to Dickinsons murder scene. EMU police records do not indicate Taylor was charged with the arson at King Hall. According to the Ann Arbor News, records show that Taylor was charged regarding his December 23rd illegal entry of King Hall, and a trial date set for June, 2006. The records stop abruptly at this point; there are, apparently, no records of any trial. The Ann Arbor News suggests that, since Taylor was under 21, it is possible that he may have been tried under the Holmes Youthful Trainee Act, in which case the record of any trial or conviction would be erased. EMU has chosen not to indicate what, if any, disciplinary action EMU imposed on Taylor as a consequence of the King Hall entry and fire. It has been suggested that, should such records exist, they would enjoy federal privacy protection, as records of campus disciplinary actions and student grades generally do under the Buckley Amendment. Under certain conditions, however, a university can break confidentiality concerning disciplinary matters. The Buckley Amendment Clarification (1992), for example, asserts that campus police records are not considered educational records, and thus do not enjoy federal privacy protection. The Foley Amendment (1998) indicates that student disciplinary records are not protected as private, if the act for which the student is being disciplined occurred in conjunction with a crime. It thus seems that, if EMU wished to reveal information regarding Taylors prior acts on campus, they might be free to do so, assuming, of course, that Michigan state law did not constrain them from doing so. A little more information is available concerning a third encounter by Taylor with police. In November 2006, two officers responding to a complaint someone was selling marijuana at Eastern Eateries found two bags of marijuana in Taylors pocket, and arrested him. On December 13th, 2006, Taylor pled not guilty to the charge of possession of drug paraphernalia, a misdemeanor. A few weeks later, on January 9, 2007, he would change that plea to guilty. What penalty, if any, Taylor received in connection with this arrest, as with the King Hall incidents, has not been made public. On the day Taylor plead not guilty regarding the marijuana incident, his actions caught the attention of law enforcement again, in a different context. Security surveillance tapes of Hill Hall for December 13, 2006 show Taylor slip in a side door around 4:20 a.m., and head upstairs. Around 90 minutes later, the cameras capture Taylor leaving the building. In his hand was the gift bag Lauras Secret Santa had given her the night before, at the womens rowing teams Christmas party. Later that same day, Lauras body would be found. Travis Scott, Laura Dickinsons boyfriend, asked angrily, I want to know why this guy was even enrolled in school, Scott said. He has a criminal history on that campus for breaking and entering. How the hell is he a student? Mr. Scott poses an excellent question. It is doubtful he will receive a straight answer to it, at least from anyone in the EMU administration. IV. THE VESTIBULAR UNIVERSITY The world is a dangerous place to live; not because of the people who are evil, but because of the people who don't do anything about it. --Albert Einstein In March, 2007, the U.S. Department of Education notified Eastern Michigan University that they had received a complaint about EMUs handling of the Dickinson murder, from Security on Campus, an organization which promotes campus safety. The DOE informed the university that they would be evaluating EMUs compliance with the Clery Act. Within a day of learning this, the EMU Board of Regents hired the Detroit law firm of Butzel Long to conduct an independent review. Because failure to comply with the Act could create serious financial and public relations problems, the Regents were well advised to do so. The purpose of the Jeanne Clery Disclosure of Campus Security Policy and Campus Crime Statistics Act (20 USC §1092 f) is to compel campuses to keep and disclose accurate records of campus crime, and to warn the campus community when there is imminent danger. The Act is named after a Jeanne Clery, a Lehigh University freshman murdered in her dorm room by another student; only after Jeannes death did her parents learn that, in the previous three years, there had been 38 violent crimes on the placid-seeming Lehigh campus. To ensure universities told the truth about crime on their campus, the Clerys founded Security on Campus, and worked to get the Clery Act passed. The Clery Act applies to universities participating in federal student financial aid programs, and thus to most universities in this country. To be eligible to participate in these programs, universities must comply with a variety of common-sense provisions. They must, for example, systematically record and disseminate information regarding campus crime, and, if it is reasonable to believe that the campus community might be in danger, a timely warning must be communicated to the entire campus. The Clery Act is enforced by the DOE, which can levy fines against institutions that fail to comply, or stop all flow of federal student financial aid dollars, a penalty which would have grave consequences for most universities. Draconian though such penalties may seem, they are, sadly, necessary. Until the early 1970s, campus safety was a matter of high priority to which considerable campus resources were dedicated. This was a consequence of the universitys perception that, though 18-year-olds may be adults, the institution had a moral obligation to function in loco parentis. They took steps to protect their students that included policies that seem quaint today. Male students were expected to be rowdy, prankish, and to get into minor scrapes such as getting tipsy on Saturday nights but any serious misbehavior brought quick discipline and expulsions were a common punishment for those who went too far. Female students were more closely monitored and restricted. Womens dorms had parietal hours, which limited the times at which men could visit. Male visitors would sign in and, later, sign out, in a register supervised by the dorms duenna-like staff, and violations of these rules could result in suspension or expulsion. World War II vets, cashing in on the GI Bill, caused changes in how male students were restricted. Just as it was hard to get an ex-paratrooper, whod been cutting Nazi throats, to meekly don a freshman beanie and defer to sophomores years younger, it was hard to tell him when he must be in his bed by midnight or that he couldnt get a drink at the end of the day. Womens liberation brought similar freedoms to female students, who began to insist upon equal independence. While less restrictive behavior policies were understandably popular with students, they also won the favor of university administrators, who saw that bowing to student wishes was a handy way to shed the sometimes onerous and expensive duty of enforcing old rules. Unfortunately, in the rush to make dormitories more like apartment buildings and to give students full autonomy over their living arrangements, student safety often got short shift. Universities were also expanding greatly in size, becoming virtual cities with the dangerous anonymity that fosters crime where no one knows who is just another student or a predatory stranger. Crime also intruded more and more on colleges that were located near sometimes deteriorating urban areas. Criminals often found naïve students easy targets. The serial killer Ted Bundy, for example, loved trolling colleges for victims. As students were more and more victimized by campus crime, parents grew alarmed, especially as they learned that university administrators were covering up incidents of fatal violence. The Clery Act was a product of this alarm. It is sad that it takes a federal law to compel those in university leadership to evince what most people would consider the most basic level of human decency--warning others they may be in danger--but even federal law, as the response of EMU demonstrates, does not always suffice. Both the Department of Education report and the Butzel-Long report, authored by attorneys David F. DuMouchel, Michael J. Lavoie, Richard T. Hewlett, and Timothy M. Labadie, conclude that the university failed to comply with the Clery Act in multiple ways. Each report criticizes the university strongly, for continuing to misrepresent the circumstances of Lauras death and the quality of security on campus, and for their failure to issue a timely warning to the campus community that a rapist/murderer might be among them. The Butzel-Long Report attempts to disentangle the conflicting accounts given by Fallon, Vick, Hall and their colleagues at Eastern Michigan University of what transpired in the aftermath of the discovery of Laura Dickinsons body. It is a compelling account of the organizational dynamics that arise among personnel at all levels of university operations, in an institution plagued by self-absorption, moral indifference, cowardice, indecisiveness, and an overriding obsession with image. Disturbing as this failure of leadership is, anyone who has experienced life behind the scenes in academe in recent years will find in EMUs feckless employees recognizable types for, while the EMU story is an extreme case of amorality in academic administration, it does not stray that far from the norm. Consider, for example, the unwillingness of those administrators interviewed to accept personal responsibility for participating in a dangerous lie, and their apparent lack of guilt or shame upon being caught doing so. Each interviewee devises an even more absurd, tortuous explanation than the next, to account for whatever went wrong, which is always a consequence of someone elses failings, and never their own: It is clear to us that what prevailed at least in the aftermath of these events was a belief that one could be excused from responsibility if one simply passed along information to the next highest person in the organizational chart. That is not sufficient. The responsibility of the Chief of Police, the Vice President of Student Affairs, and other similarly-situated University officials is to not only provide information but to also provide meaningful, proactive recommendations regarding that information and what, if any, action should be taken because of it. The various accounts often conflict with the facts, with accounts offered by their colleagues, or with the individuals own prior accounts. At points the document reminds one of Akira Kurasawas Rashomon, a film about a rape and murder, told from multiple, conflicting perspectives. So dense is the web of prevarication that it disturbs even Butzel Longs experienced attorneys who, by virtue of their profession, have long been aware how, in some hands, truth turns to silly putty: We also have documented numerous disturbing and disappointing inconsistencies in the explanations of what happened in connection with Ms. Dickinsons death from many who were involved. Unquestionably, some of this may be a function of the traumatic and unique situation everyone faced. We are not satisfied, however, that all of the discrepancies in what we were told can be innocently explained. The authors of the Report seem dumbfounded, that for ten weeks, not one of the many EMU employees who knew a murderer might be loose on campus, exercised the thimbleful of initiative it would take, to just delete the misleading phrases about campus safety. Not one stirred himself to issue any sort of warning, nor even to raise the subject for consideration: [N]o one stepped forward and engaged in the type of proactive, reasoned and detailed analysis that should have occurred in order to determine whether a timely warning was required. Several EMU officials even contributed to preserving the illusion of safety, assuring parents and students who contacted their office that any worry was groundless, an unconscionable assurance, given their awareness a homicide had taken place on campus. One labors in vain to unearth any expression of shame or guilt for needlessly exposing other peoples daughters to rape and murder, through their complicity in sustaining the illusion of safety. This cohesive adherence to and advocacy of a lie marks a kind of emergent structure that is not uncommon in academic administration. In academic administrative offices in institutions where there is little turnover, a perverse and convenient concern about the welfare of sitting administrators and a certain callousness regarding the welfare of students often sets in. After years working alongside each other with little infusion of new blood and with everyones credentials becoming less competitive with the passing years, university employees can begin to believe their loyalty belongs to their fellow employees, and that their responsibility and interest lie in protecting fellow employees and the image of the school. They feel little loyalty toward the students, who are perceived as pesky transients, in contrast to those who will determine ones salary, teaching load, sabbatical schedule, office allocation, and parking place till retirement. Though individual academics may squabble and have contempt for each other, when the group attracts negative attention from non-academics, herd logic seems to take hold with herd members closing ranks against an outside threat. Morality is often cast aside for the worth of the defended institution is held as greater than that of the institutions victims. And, rather than their unity being eroded as the seriousness of the criticism increases, the greater the group loyalty and the greater the willingness to ratchet up evasion, obstructionism, and secrecy. The uglier the truth the more it justifies the coverup. Some have defended EMUs lower-level employees on the grounds that their motivation to lie was the fear of losing their livelihooda singularly damning defense: how much better to be deemed merely thoughtless and self-centered, than to be the sort a person who weighs, with a cool calculus, the value of human life against the bother and disruption of getting another job. The Butzel Long Report comes to some damning conclusions concerning the EMU employees: With respect to the failure to issue a timely warning regarding Ms. Dickinsons death, we are mindful that hindsight is always 20/20 and note that this failure, at least initially, is not surprising in light of the lack of any material training, experience, policies or procedures in the face of this exceptional and difficult situation. The failure to realize and correct or cure the initial mistake over the course of the ensuing two months is much more disturbing. Even more troubling are the reactions that occurred after an arrest was made, when many who were involved appear to have scrambled to find an explanation as to why any mistakes were not his or her fault, culminating in the varied and conflicting stories we were told. . . . The mission of the Clery Act is to encourage and ensure the safety and security of those persons within the Universitys campus community. The Clery Acts requirements are not just an academic exercise without meaning or importance to the campus community. The trust placed by people in the campus community with the University was violated in a very real and personal way. Upon learning of the tragic circumstances of Ms. Dickinsons death, persons in the campus community voiced widespread concerns of anxiety and a breach of trust. By complying with the Clery Act requirements and establishing a Compliance Program, the Regents and this University will take an important step toward restoring the trust and confidence of the campus community and ensuring the safety and security of those persons currently in the campus is community and for those coming to the University in the future. It is worth noting that if any EMU employee inside the universitys machinery of evasion had made one anonymous phone call to the Ann Arbor News or a local television station, the ensuing press inquiries would almost certainly have triggered the deletion of the problematical safety assurances in EMUs statement about Dickinsons murder, if not prompting a timely warning announcement. Ironically, such changes would have ultimately helped shield the university from criticism. If, at any level, a single employee had felt a sense of accountability to anything but his own personal bottom line, anger over the murder of Laura Dickinson would have been directed solely at her killer and not the university. V. IMPLAUSIBLE DENIABILITY Whats that smell in this room? Didnt you notice it, Brick? Didnt you notice the powerful and obnoxious odor of mendacity in this room? --Big Daddy, in Tennessee Williams Cat on a Hot Tin Roof As the story of the mishandling of Laura Dickinsons murder began circulating through the media, even jaded commentators were shocked at the actions of EMUs administration. Their protestations of ignorance and promises to reform rang hollow when matched against their arrogant concealment of dangerous truths. An especially apt commentary on Fallons assertion of his cluelessness was offered by FoxNews television show host John Gibson, on The Big Show. He reported that Fallon had apologized for mishandling Laura Dickinsons murder, and that Fallon said, hed never let it happen again. Gibson commented acidly, Well, thats good to know. How many murders does he think he might have on the campus of Eastern Michigan that he might be tempted to pass off as natural causes deaths? He blames a university official below him, for not telling him it was a murder. Lets see. The scene goes like this: Were in the University presidents office, and the dean of something or other comes in and says: Mr. President, a student has died. And the president says: Thats a shame. Where are we going to put the library building? It seems to me absurd that the president of the university is saying he didnt know. He should have known, and if he didnt know, he should be fired. If you are in charge of the university, it is a basic requirement that you know if one of the students has been murdered. Rationally, one must agree that Fallon had a duty to know, but knowing isnt always a good thing for the careerist administrator. With knowing comes responsibility, and responsibility is something to avoid. Like Dracula fleeing sunrise, the nimble administrator flees responsibility lest he be consumed and vanish in a puff of ash. Ignorance is a tool to use to avoid the consequences of failure. Fallons ignorance seems not merely cultivated but pruned, clipped, and delicately trimmed into imaginative topiary to strategically hide his errors. He employs a perverse kind of Knowledge Management strategysomething from the Dark Side of business management theory that might better be called Ignorance Management. The savvy administrator places himself at the center of his world. What is good for his career is his guide and the best thing for that career is to avoid making mistakes. The most straightforward way to avoid mistakes is inaction, a favorite of administrators, which can be invoked through endless committees, consensus gathering, report generation, or simple procrastination. Unfortunately, as events present themselves, the administrator may be forced to make decisions. To limit damage, it is wise to hedge ones bets. If the choice is between red and blue, pick reddish purple or purpleish blue. Later, if it turns out you embraced the wrong shade, you can temporize by claiming you knew a little red or a trace more blue would have been perfect. Shifting blame by delegating responsibility is also useful. Your only possible mistake is then that you placed your trust in the wrong person, someone who falsely presented themselves as fit for responsibility, and this mistake can be covered by removing that undeserving failure. Subordinates upon whom blame can be directed are very useful, especially if they can be persuaded that your coattails are handy for them to grab and that loyalty to your protestations of ignorance will be repaid. A useful subordinate may even assume ignorance on your behalf, neatly compartmentalizing things you dont want to know in their own constructed lack of knowledge. These tactics are useful, but the simplest way to avoid making mistakes is to embrace ignorance. If you didnt know there was a problem, how can you be expected to address it. Timing is key to Managed Ignorance. When faced with a problem, an administrator must create time in which to ascertain which way the wind is blowing and with what velocity. What appears to be the most acceptable decision? What facts should be ignored so that this decision appears logical in retrospect? Who should go unconsulted to avoid unwanted information? How long can the appearance of ignorance be plausibly maintained? The last is important because the longer the administrator can be ignorant, the more flexibility he has when he must finally make a decision. While prompt decision making is a sign of good leadership, for those with modest leadership skills, it is useful to keep as many options open as possible so that if your first impulse proves wrong, you can retreat and advance on another front under the banner of new information has come to our attention. Solving a problem prematurely can also be a waste of opportunityall that the administrator gets is a solved problem. A problem allowed to mature from small difficulty to grandiose dilemma can become a triumph when eventually the solution that was obvious at the beginning is applied. Through the use of Managed Ignorance, the administrator may even be able to control the moment at which the problem is set before his Solomon-esque self. The skilled administrator is ever alert for emerging problems which might be exploited to his advantage, mentally thumping every complaint like a cantaloupe to assess its degree of ripeness, so that he may time the pronunciation of a brilliant solution to precede a raise request or contract negotiation. While our observations here about Managed Ignorance are arch, the consequences of it arent amusing. Fallon pushed the strategy too far, exposing his student body and faculty to dangers he should have guarded them against. His evasions since his exposure have further injured EMU, generating contempt for the university and its officials. How blinded by self-interest and institutional butt covering can a university president be? Surely, EMU would deal harshly with such an administrator. Maybe not. If one sets aside moral issues, the cost/benefits ratio weighs heavily in favor of ignorance and passivity, when it comes to campus crime. Having spent the bulk of his long career in academic administration, including as the president of two other universities, Fallon must have known that there was minimal risk the Department of Education would investigate EMUs possible Clery Act violation, and that, even if they did and ruled unfavorably, it was unlikely there would be financial consequences of any significance. DOE has never removed any universitys eligibility for federal student aid, and the largest fine thus far appears to be the $250,000 levied against Salem International University, in 2004. Given EMUs annual budget of over $286 million, a $250,000 fine would constitute less than 12% of that budget. More importantly, the costs of any fine would not be extracted from his pay packet or that of any other administrator, who participated in the violations, but would be passed on to students, which is most likely the reason the DOE is reluctant to exact more serious penalties: it will be innocent students, not the administrators who failed in their responsibilities, who quite literally pay the price. The cost of tuition at EMU this year rose 9.5%. Fallon is certainly an experienced academic administrator. He has served as president of three colleges and, until the Dickinson fiasco, managed to avoid controversy. While some presidents champion a challenging issue, such as raising academic standards, reviving curriculum, or creating new programs, Fallon has only associated himself with one issue, an anti-alcohol abuse program. Standing up against irresponsible student drinking is like standing up for the right of puppies to be adorable. Even bartenders will lift a glass to youthful moderation. Its an easy issue to advocate. When it came to a harder task, handling a murder, he failed. When, at last, the truth came out that Laura Dickinson had been murdered, and that the university had shrugged off in its responsibility to the campus community, not to mention to Lauras parents, Fallons response was an unseemly attempt to pin the blame on underlings. Had only someone informed him it was possible the death wasnt from natural causes, he assured the Butzel Long attorneys, he would have been the very model of academic administrator: Mr. Fallon said any direct or indirect evidence of foul play would have triggered him to think about the Clery Act and the need for a warning. He said if he had heard that the investigators believed homicide was probable, he would have gotten directly involved and assembled a team to determine what to tell the University community. He said he would have engaged in a careful analysis, including seeking advice from legal counsel, in deciding what to say. Mr. Fallon said he would have erred on the side of being overly cautious. He said his default position is openness and transparency in terms of disclosure of information. According to Mr. Fallon, Mr. Vick knew him well enough to know he would find a way to get information out about the case if he knew more. Fallons apology is acrobatic doubletalk, worthy of the wiggliest contortionist in the Cirque de Soleil. He constructs a perfect response that he would have expertly executed if only he had been informed by Vick. Fallon held high the shield of ignorance with a hypocritical gleam of virtue in his eye. Explanatory excuse offered, he took the next step in the malefactors post-exposure playbook: he urged everyone to move on and forget the mistakes of yesterday. He had done so. Where another person might feel obliged to tender his resignation for having made such a mess, Fallon put in for a raise, and complained to EMUs Board of Regents Chairman Tom Sidlik when he didnt receive a quick, positive response. When the Ann Arbor News asked him what disciplinary action the Regents should visit on him, he proposed an admonishment fully short of a formal reprimand, for he had been just part of the machinery (a peculiar, passive and mechanistic image for a self-styled leader) responsible for the mishandling of the death. It must have come as quite a disappointment to the self-excusing Fallon, when, in July 2007, the Regents considered suspending him for just 30 days, after identifying him as the person responsible for the Clery Law violations. Fallon could have simply accepted the modest consequences prescribed for his actions by the Regents and taken an active role in ensuring full compliance with the Clery Act. Instead, Fallon seized the moral low ground. He couldnt possibly be the one who deserved admonition. He grandly informed the Regents that it had become clear to him that they planned to berate me as harshly and publicly as possible, which left him no recourse but to address the issues that have plagued this campus and me personally over the past several years. Unsurprisingly, the Regents responded to this unveiled threat by firing Fallon, albeit, with a years severance pay. By this time, the Dickinson fiasco had made national headlines and Fallon seized the media moment. He went on The Larry King Show, but the explanatory defense he offered was stunningly inarticulate and clumsy: FALLON: I -- I was not told by the vice president for student affairs because I -- I think there was some concern, sensitivity to the university's position. But I also know that there was an intent to keep this under wraps. And in fact I felt betrayed, genuinely betrayed, by the very...?? KING: Because your own people lied to you? FALLON: My trusted vice president for Student Affairs did not tell me the truth. He knew or should have known. And there was also a point in all of this when a police incident report was to have made its way from the Department of Public Safety through his office to the university's General Counsel and it was interrupted, that path was interrupted. And the incident report was ordered shredded by the vice president for Student Affairs. ?? KING: Does he still hold that job? ?? FALLON: He does not. He was separated, shall we say, from the university, he and the director of the Department of Public Service, separated from the university, and I was fired. ?? KING: Because? ? FALLON: Well...?? KING: They didn't like your story or they didn't accept it? ?? FALLON: I -- well, I'm holding here, Larry, a 114-page half a million dollar report that was commissioned by the university. And I daresay any intelligent person that would read this would come to conclude what I did, that there's a direct inverse relationship between the contents of this report and the severity of the actions, the personnel actions that were taken as a result of this. ?? KING: Why do you think they did it? ?? FALLON: The...?? KING: Why did they fire you? ?? FALLON: The Board of Regents? Well, I feel betrayed by them as well. KING: Why? ?? FALLON: Because of that very fact. And I believe that this was, in fact, a cover-up -- these are terms that are not comfortable for me. There was in fact a cover-up and there was a need for a fall guy. These are Elmore Leonard terms, these aren't John Fallon terms, and that's the way it cut. ? A girl had died horribly, the manner of her death had been hidden from her parents, a university had been left uniformed of a murdering rapist on campus, and Fallon cast himself as the victim. V. THE CONCLUSION, IN WHICH NOTHING IS CONCLUDED The princess . . . proposed to found a college of learned women, in which she would preside, that, by conversing with the old, and educating the young, she might divide her time between the acquisition and communication of wisdom, and raise up for the next age models of prudence, and patterns of piety. The prince desired a little kingdom, in which he might administer justice in his own person, and see all the parts of government with his own eyes; but he could never fix the limits of his dominion, and was always adding to the number of his subjects. Imlac and the astronomer were contented to be driven along the stream of life, without directing their course to any particular port. Of these wishes that they had formed, they well knew that none could be obtained. They deliberated awhile what was to be done, and resolved, when the inundation should cease, to return to Abyssinia. --Dr. Samuel Johnson, Rasselas While murders on college campuses are thankfully rare, university presidents like John Fallon and high-ranking academic administrators like Vick and Hall arent unusual. This is no accident; most higher education governing boards prefer administrators whose leadership style keeps the apples, however rotten, tidily arranged atop the apple cart. Through blind pride in their institution, they prefer to preserve the image of the university they govern by concealing sins instead of increasing its prestige through wise management. As long as university governing boards choose to do this, there will be administrators like Fallon, available aplenty to shun responsibility and evade action whenever responsible action is needed. [Non-text portions of this message have been removed] -------------------------- Want to discuss this topic? Head on over to our discussion list, [EMAIL PROTECTED] -------------------------- Brooks Isoldi, editor [EMAIL PROTECTED] http://www.intellnet.org Post message: [email protected] Subscribe: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Unsubscribe: [EMAIL PROTECTED] *** FAIR USE NOTICE. This message contains copyrighted material whose use has not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. OSINT, as a part of The Intelligence Network, is making it available without profit to OSINT YahooGroups members who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included information in their efforts to advance the understanding of intelligence and law enforcement organizations, their activities, methods, techniques, human rights, civil liberties, social justice and other intelligence related issues, for non-profit research and educational purposes only. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of the copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the copyright owner. For more information go to: http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtml Yahoo! Groups Links <*> To visit your group on the web, go to: http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/ <*> Your email settings: Individual Email | Traditional <*> To change settings online go to: http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/join (Yahoo! ID required) <*> To change settings via email: mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] <*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to: [EMAIL PROTECTED] <*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to: http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/
