Aspects of Climate Change  

by John Thompson, Director of the Mackenzie Institute (October 2006)

Given some of our contemporary educational standards, our society does seem
to produce an inordinate number of young people who have been taught that
passion is a good substitute for reason; and consequently that their
'feelings' matter more than turning to some patriarchal logo-centric
European- constructed abstraction as a method to puzzle things out.  Baiting
these kids is a cheap thrill, but is amusing only for a few minutes before
one worries about the consequences of their exercise of the franchise or the
potential of their sitting on juries.

Still, we all have our guilty little pleasures; and one could be to keep
introducing woolen toque-wearing, Bush-hating, politically correct
youngsters to the dangers of dihydrogen monoxide (DHMO) contamination.  Many
of them seem alarmed when told that there are high concentrations of DHMO in
everything we eat and drink; or that Neo-Nazis and George Bush make frequent
use of it; that over-exposure to it is often lethal, and almost all us die
saturated with the stuff (of course, we die really quickly if not saturated
with it too... but why give the game away).  The looks of alarm and
damning-of-evil-corporations and those filthy capitalist Americans for
contaminating the world are a lot of fun until they suddenly realize that
dihydrogen monoxide is also known as H2O.

The debate over the presence and cause of climate change is almost as much
fun. especially now that proponents of the man-made global warming theory
have decided that they are the new orthodoxy and that only so-far unburned
heretics could dare dispute the new truth.  Millennialist visions of dire
consequence abound, and if you don't believe that climate change is coming,
just watch Al Gore's 'An Inconvenient Truth' or if you want some
entertainment with your disaster prognostications, watch 'The Day After
Tomorrow'.

These must be true warnings, because we are told that a 'majority of
scientists' agree that disaster is looming.  Hmmm.  Centuries ago, a
majority of scientists also thought that the sun orbited the Earth.  Decades
ago, a similar majority thought that continental drift was an absurd notion.
In 1830, the theory that much of Europe and North America had been once
covered with ice was treated with howls of derision. A lot of the 'facts' we
take as proven are based on consensus; and proponents of climate change
should at least note that Noam Chomsky himself argues that consensus can be
manufactured and manipulated.  The Kyoto Agreement ought to be proof enough
of that.  One could also remember Paul Erlich and the doom-saying of the
1960s and '70s (again, apparently accepted by a 'majority of scientists' at
the time).

Is climate change occurring?  It seems so, but then the climate is
constantly changing - with which a majority of geologists, paleontologists,
meteorologists and honest environmentalists would agree.  The questions are:
How much will our climate change, and what is the cause?  Human pollution
may not necessarily be the most significant cause - not when any ambitious
volcano can pump more greenhouse gases and ozone destroying chemicals in an
afternoon than human industry can in a decade.  Lest one think that is an
exaggeration, this is exactly what Krakatoa did in 1883, Mount Pinatubo in
1991, and have a number of other volcanoes.  Still, it doesn't make much
sense to let human pollution go unchecked, global warming or no.  



Mount Pinatubo in 1991 was busy lowering temperatures across the world by
-0.5C and pumping 17 million tons of sulfur dioxide into the upper
atmosphere - to the great detriment of the ozone layer.

The Climate Change issue contains many matters for considerable debate, but
the hysteria that has accompanied the debate so far is certainly not
helpful.  There are some things we should all remember without diving into
discussions about sunspot cycles, Mander Minimums, the HALE Cycle, deep
water currents, and the innumerable other aspects of the arcane minutia of
historical meteorology.

Human beings are a result of climate change.  600,000 years ago, Homo
Erectus (aka 'Peking Man', 'Java Man', etc) was very much a going concern
and had been so for over 1,200,000 years with little change.  Spread widely
through Europe, Africa and Asia, this remote cousin of ours was a highly
successful species.  But then so were a variety of earlier hominids --
themselves also products of climate change after the world cooled and dried,
forcing some apes to come out of Africa's retreating jungles.  Some of these
earlier hominids had also managed to perpetuate themselves for hundreds of
thousands of years.  The world's ecosystems didn't seem to be demanding a
self-cognitive aggressive and highly opportunistic tool user just yet.
Then, as it so often does, the world changed again.
<mhtml:mid://00000020/#_ftn1> [1]

For the last 30 million years, Earth has had permanent ice at its polar
regions.  The last time this happened was back in the great dying of the
Permian Era (around 250 million years ago) when rapidly fluctuating ice-ages
helped kill off some 90% of the species in existence at the time.  One of
the immensely successful subphyla that vanished were the trilobites, ending
their 300 million years of life on the seabed.  The Pleistocene Epoch itself
(from 1,800,000 to 12,000 years ago) was also a time of a major ice age, but
600,000 years ago it got even worse with rapid shifts between severe
glaciations - sometimes covering as much as 30% of Earth's landmass - and
sudden warmings.

Why does the earth's temperature keep changing so?  There are many causes:
A minor wobble in the Earth's axial tilt can influence the amount of
sunlight received in the Polar Regions by as much as 20%, which happens
quite often in geological time scales.  Periodically, our sun burns a little
more warmly, or a little cooler.  Admittedly, it's hard to think there could
be much difference when the mean surface temperature of old Sol is around
5,000 degrees Celsius. But when one is basking in its glow some 150 million
kilometers away, a degree or so of difference has a real effect on the
energy we receive.

There are many other reasons why temperature has fluctuated so much in
geological history - and there have been times when the Earth was much
warmer than it is now.  When Tyrannosaurus Rex was chasing Triceratops
around in the Cretaceous, the mean global temperature appears to have been
about 10 degrees Celsius higher than now.  Over the past 10,000 years - as
some ice core samples suggest -- the mean average temperature on Earth has
been wobbling up and down over a range of 8 degrees Celsius from century to
century.  During the Medieval Warming period, Vikings settled Greenland to
farm and raise goats and sheep. then when the Mini-Ice Age of 1400-1850
began, they died off to the last man and farm animal.   

So why bring up poor old Homo Erectus?  Well, the long jump between us was a
time of frequent environmental stress.  Some 600,000 years ago, Erectus was
doing just fine, while his remote cousin Homo Heidelbergensis was not nearly
as widespread or numerous, being confined largely to Europe.  At first
glance, most of us would be hard put to place much difference between the
two and the stone tools both used were much alike.  Heidelberg man did have
a larger brain case - sometimes rivaling our 1350 cubic centimeter (the
human average) as theirs ranged between 1100 and 1400 CCs.  Erectus came in
with something between 950 and 1100 CCs.



Dear old Great (20,000 times removed) Grandpa Heidelbergensis.

It's hard to deduce behavior from what little we know, but it also seems
Heidelbergensis was a bit more partial than Erectus to big game hunting -
which implies a brain with more capability for planning, decision making and
teamwork.  It also seems he buried his dead sometimes, which hints at the
possibility of a bit of a spiritual dimension to their thinking, or at least
a firm grasp of elementary hygiene.

Starting about 600,000 years ago until about 12,000 years before today,
Europe (like Northern Asia and North America) turned into a bad place to be.
The world alternated constantly between severe ice ages and then short
intense warming periods which usually lasted for about 10,000 years.  The
wooded uplands Heidelberg man favored turned into tundra, and some of these
distant ancestors turned back south.  According to current Anthropological
theory (which may be dead wrong of course), Heidelbergensis left two
legacies - one was Homo Neanderthalensis, who didn't seem to mind Ice Age
Europe too much and stuck around until the descendents of the other legacy
turned up.  The other legacy appears to have been Homo Rhodesiensis, who
looked pretty much like Heidelbergensis, but made his home in Southern
Africa between 600,000 and 125,000 years ago.

Rhodesiensis gave rise to Homo Sapiens Idaltu - our last direct ancestor --
remains of which were found in Ethiopia dating back some 160,000 years.
Rhodesiensis and h.s. Idaltu were not yet finished with rapid climate
change. Africa might not be nearly as cold as Europe, but the ice ages often
led directly to severe desertification in Southern Africa.  During a warming
period, humanoids would venture out into the grasslands of the African
interior, thrive and multiply, and then a few centuries later intense
desertification would set in and the survivors had to move.  Some
paleontologists call this the 'heat pump' effect.  Survival favored the
adaptable and, eventually, some of Idaltu's descendents seemed more
adaptable than the others and Homo Sapiens Sapiens at last appeared on the
scene sometime around 100,000 years ago.

Of course, life was still rough.  Human genetic diversity is much less than
that of most other animal species, and sometime before our kind began to
radiate out of Africa (courtesy of the 'heat pump' effect outlined above),
our ancestral population was reduced to something like 1,000 to 10,000
related individuals.  The probable cause was the Toba volcanic eruption in
Indonesia about 70,000 BC - which had catastrophic effects around much of
the world; shortly afterwards Humanity started to spread across the planet.

Climate change was still not finished with us, and probably never will be.
Lower sea levels around 13,000 BC let mankind cross over the Bering Straits
into the Americas and had earlier let us radiate rapidly through Southeast
Asia.  The Neolithic agricultural revolution also owes much to rapid climate
change.  This is the thesis in Brian Fagan's The Long Summer:  How Climate
Changed Civilization (Basic Books, New York, 2004).  Fagan concludes his
survey of the subject by reminding us that severe climate change could be a
true challenge to our civilization.

However, while global warming seems to be happening - we surely do not yet
have a consensus on the cause, nor are we really able to predict its
effects.  Several scientific disciplines being applied in concert can
sometimes puzzle out what has happened in the past, but accurately
predicting the future or understanding the present is always problematic.
For all we know, we might even be staving off the appearance of mile-high
glaciers bulldozing their way out of the north once again.  After all,
interglacial intervals in the late Pleistocene usually only lasted 10,000
years - which could mean our time will run out soon.

But we are the product of 600,000 years of rapid climate change.  Actually,
we are the descendents of 600,000 years worth of survivors; one would think
something instinctual might have come out of this.  For the toque-wearing
youngster, however, scientific doubt doesn't matter.  All he knows is that
Al Gore is right, a 'majority of scientists' are in agreement, and the only
thing that can save humanity - or at least him and the bits he thinks
deserve to be saved - is an immediate shutdown of industry and high
technology civilization.  Even the idea of an increase of a degree in the
global temperature must surely be an unparalleled planetary disaster. but
then someone who would be alarmed by the idea of dihydrogen monoxide
contamination will buy almost anything.


  _____  

 <mhtml:mid://00000020/#_ftnref1> [1] A number of papers were consulted for
this column, but one of the more interesting and thought provoking was 'The
Pleistocene and the Origins of Human Culture', Peter J. Richersen and Robert
Boyd, University of California, February 1998.  These two are behavioralists
and point out that complex behavior is often non-selective in a
deteriorating environment, but that the Pleistocene seems to have unusually
favored survival by both Homo and animals that were capable of changing
complex behaviors.   The meek might inherit the Earth, but right now it is
owned by opportunists.



[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]



--------------------------
Want to discuss this topic?  Head on over to our discussion list, [EMAIL 
PROTECTED]
--------------------------
Brooks Isoldi, editor
[EMAIL PROTECTED]

http://www.intellnet.org

  Post message: [email protected]
  Subscribe:    [EMAIL PROTECTED]
  Unsubscribe:  [EMAIL PROTECTED]


*** FAIR USE NOTICE. This message contains copyrighted material whose use has 
not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. OSINT, as a part of 
The Intelligence Network, is making it available without profit to OSINT 
YahooGroups members who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the 
included information in their efforts to advance the understanding of 
intelligence and law enforcement organizations, their activities, methods, 
techniques, human rights, civil liberties, social justice and other 
intelligence related issues, for non-profit research and educational purposes 
only. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of the copyrighted material 
as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use 
this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' 
you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.
For more information go to:
http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtml 
Yahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/

<*> Your email settings:
    Individual Email | Traditional

<*> To change settings online go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/join
    (Yahoo! ID required)

<*> To change settings via email:
    mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] 
    mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
    [EMAIL PROTECTED]

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
    http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/
 

Reply via email to