http://www.villagevoice.com/news/0743,thompson,78154,6.html/full
 

Secret Agent Schmuck
The spooky truth behind the media's favorite 'spy'
 
by Chris Thompson
October 23rd, 2007 8:56 PM
It was a morning a little more than a year ago: A dapper, gray-haired
gentleman was discussing his recently published novel with the two hosts of
Fox & Friends, the morning show on the Fox News Channel. Anchors Tiki Barber
and Kiran Chetry appeared enthralled by the author, Juval Aviv, who said
that his book was actually a barely disguised account of the life and
alleged 1991 murder of millionaire media tycoon Robert Maxwell. 


Aviv provided his bona fides: He runs a Madison Avenue corporate-espionage
firm named Interfor and had been hired to investigate some aspects of
Maxwell's complex finances. But during his investigation, Aviv had
discovered explosive truths. Maxwell, Aviv said, had actually been a spy for
the Russian, British, and Israeli intelligence agencies, and had paid with
his life when his spymasters discovered that he'd double-crossed them. Aviv
claimed to his Fox News hosts that the revelations in his book were so
stunning that he'd had to novelize the tale to protect himself. If he'd told
the actual truth, he hinted, he'd have been killed. 


"I couldn't write it as a nonfiction," said the Israeli man in his accented
English. "It had to be fiction. I don't think I would have survived the
nonfiction version of it." 


Barber and his co-anchor looked duly impressed. And why not? Here was the
real deal, a former Israeli spy who had reportedly spent the 1970s hunting
Palestinian radicals around Europe and the Middle East, whose life story was
so terrible that he could only allude to it. "You were a top assassin for
Mossad, which is Israel's secret service," said Chetry. "In your book, the
main character has a situation where he's supposed to knock off 12 leading
terrorists and kill them." 


"Yes," Aviv said. 


"How realistic is that?" 


"It's very realistic." Laughing modestly, he added: "I can't talk about it."



It was just another day in the life of Juval Aviv, an "international
security expert" and post-9/11 media celebrity who has parlayed his
mysterious past into countless appearances on local and national television.
Most famously, Aviv has promoted the idea that he was the lead Mossad
assassin tasked with avenging the 1972 massacre of Israeli Olympic athletes
in a secret operation that was portrayed in Steven Spielberg's 2005 film
Munich. It was Aviv that actor Eric Bana was supposedly playing, though his
name in the movie was "Avner." 


At least that's what Aviv wants people to believe. 


Aviv has chatted on air with ABC's George Stephanopoulos and CNN's Mary
Snow. Bill O'Reilly has consulted Aviv on preparedness and homeland
security. Fox business anchor Neil Cavuto has often invited him onto his
show Your World with Neil Cavuto to discuss everything from Middle Eastern
politics to the latest dispatch from Osama bin Laden. 


Thanks in part to Aviv's high TV profile, his company Interfor has won some
of the most lucrative corporate-espionage contracts in the business. Earlier
this summer, for example, Hollinger hired Aviv to trace assets allegedly
hidden by the disgraced media tycoon Conrad Black. Life as a former spook is
apparently very lucrative. 


But throughout Aviv's rise as one of New York's biggest corporate spies and
as a terrorism expert on television, there have been nagging questions about
his legitimacy. Is this guy really who he says he is? Officially, the
Israeli government says that Aviv is full of it. According to a 1990 letter
from Yigal Carmon, then the Israeli prime minister's counterterrorism
adviser, Aviv was never an assassin, let alone the person chosen by Golda
Meir to avenge the Munich massacre. "Aviv does not work and has never worked
for the Intelligence Community of the State of Israel," Carmon wrote in
response to an inquiry from the U.S. government. 



  <http://images.villagevoice.com/issues/0743/thompson2.jpg> 
A still from Munich -- Robert ( Mathieu Kassovitz) and Avner (Eric Bana.)
Juval Aviv claims that the part played by Bana is actually based on Juval
Aviv's real life story.
photo: Universal Studios and Dreamworks LLC     
In fact, Carmon added, the closest that Aviv ever came to intelligence work
was as a security official for an El Al office in New York. "His work in
that capacity was terminated at the initiative of the employer because of
unsuitability resulting from negative character traits," Carmon wrote.
"During the course of his work Yuval [sic] Aviv was found to be unreliable
and dishonest." 

Nonetheless, Aviv has built a remarkable career for himself. In 1989,
following the Pan Am 103 bombing that killed 270 people in Lockerbie,
Scotland, airline officials hired Aviv to investigate the incident. His
report—alleging that the bombing was a CIA gun- and drug-smuggling operation
gone terribly wrong—was leaked to the press, reportedly by Aviv himself.
News outlets like Time, NBC, ABC, and Barron's picked up the story. But as
more skeptical journalists began to examine Aviv's report, Pan Am officials
suddenly dropped their plans to use it as a defense, and the media outlets
that had run Aviv's allegations squirmed under the scrutiny. A Brooklyn
federal magistrate later found Aviv's report to be utterly without merit. 


Today, American intelligence officials who were charged with investigating
the Pan Am 103 bombing are still furious with Aviv—and they fume over the
fact that national television outlets treat him as anything but a fraud.
"This crud, this piece of dirt, went around inventing stories about how this
plane got destroyed, because he was paid money to do so," says Vincent
Cannistraro, the former chief of operations and analysis at the CIA's
Counterterrorism Center. "The man is not worth being in human company,
frankly." 

  _____  


"This guy's full of shit," says Larry Johnson, who served in the CIA and as
a deputy director in the State Department's Office of Counterterrorism.
"What's true is, yes, he has a security and corporate-intelligence firm, and
he's big at playing up the Israeli mystique. If you say it with a foreign
accent, you're good to go." 


Aviv, these senior counterterrorism officials insist, is no terrorism
expert; instead, he's a liar who's been spreading falsehoods about his
résumé and his prowess as an investigator. 


But even Aviv's most virulent critics express astonishment at what he's been
accused of doing lately. 


Court documents allege that in 2003, Aviv signed an intelligence contract
with the NXIVM Corporation, an Albany-based company that offers seminars in
achieving personal and business goals, and whose devotees include heirs to
some of the richest fortunes in America and Mexico. In the last few years,
former members of NXIVM have come forward to claim that the company is in
fact a predatory personal-growth cult that subjects its members to intensive
brainwashing and requires them to swear their lives to its leader, an
accused pyramid-scheme operator and self-styled genius named Keith Raniere.
According to court papers, NXIVM hired Aviv to dig up dirt on someone that
Raniere considered an enemy: New Jersey–based cult expert Rick Ross, a
controversial figure himself who is also a frequent guest on television news
programs. 


Ross had been working with people who wanted his help to get family members
out of NXIVM, and had been posting damaging news stories about Raniere on
his website. 


Ross is now suing NXIVM and Aviv, claiming that over the course of several
months, Aviv and Interfor compiled an extensive report on him that included
private financial and telephone records—information that Ross says was
illegally obtained. Ross complains that he was even the target of an
elaborate sting operation orchestrated by Aviv on behalf of NXIVM, which
involved trying to lure him onto a ship in the Caribbean. 


NXIVM and Raniere have denied the allegations and are suing Ross as well,
charging him with copyright infringement, misappropriation of trade secrets,
and product disparagement. But the Voice has learned that Aviv has done
other work for Raniere, an odd figure who requires his followers to refer to
him as "Vanguard." The Voice has obtained evidence that Aviv agreed to
investigate Raniere's ex-girlfriend, a woman who says she has been
systematically harassed, intimidated, and terrorized by members of NXIVM. 


Juval Aviv: trusted Fox News terrorism expert, or a fraudulent tale teller
willing to hire himself out to a thuggish cult leader? It's a question that
is at the heart of three lawsuits in two jurisdictions, with as many twists
and turns as an espionage potboiler. 



  _____  

Much about Aviv's life remains a mystery, but here's what he's claimed. Born
in Israel in 1949, Aviv supposedly became a major in the Israeli Defense
Force and joined the Mossad in the late 1960s. After spending a few years
doing spook work for Israel, a disillusioned Aviv left the Mossad and was
banned from re-entering Israel for a time. So he stayed in New York and
drove a cab while he figured out how to put his life back together. In 1979,
Aviv founded Interfor, which today says it has 500 employees and 23 offices
worldwide. 


The notion that Aviv was the leader of a Mossad assassination squad that
murdered the terrorists responsible for the Munich massacre dates back to
the mid-1980s, when Canadian journalist George Jonas wrote Vengeance, a
nonfiction account of the killings that later became the template for
Spielberg and screenwriter Tony Kushner. Jonas gave the name "Avner" to the
person he said he relied on for his account, the person he claimed was the
lead assassin of the group. After the book's publication, Aviv claimed that
he was in fact the "Avner" character. But Jonas later denied that he and
Aviv ever collaborated at all. 


These days, Aviv is more coy about his Munich claims. Last year, when Aviv
was hawking his Robert Maxwell novel, correspondent Andrew Billen of The
Times of London asked him if he'd led the Mossad team. "I can't tell you
that," Aviv replied. "Let me just tell you one thing. There is no statute of
limitation to the events in the book Vengeance and in the movie. It has
become a popular thing lately for families of those who were killed to sue
Israeli officials and ex-Mossad agents." 


Indeed—and if Aviv really were the "Avner" figure portrayed in the movie,
one would expect the Mossad to deny that he had been an assassin on its
payroll. But investigative reporters and CIA officials have strenuously
challenged Aviv's claims since as early as 1992. Producers for the CBS show
60 Minutes, for example, initially considered Aviv a treasure trove of
intelligence, and planned to put him on retainer as a consultant for their
stories about Pan Am 103 and international terrorism. But after vetting his
background, they dropped him as fast as they could. "He comes across as very
believable and can cite all kinds of people that he knows," says the 60
Minutes producer who worked with Aviv (and who refused to be identified).
"But when you start checking, you find out it's not there." 


According to Larry Johnson, who worked on counterterrorism for the CIA and
the State Department, all it takes to disprove Aviv's claims is to consider
that he supposedly worked for the Mossad in the late 1960s and early '70s.
But Aviv was born in 1947. In 1972, he was only 25 years old. "Right—they're
gonna put somebody that young and inexperienced to be the lead Mossad
assassin? It's bullshit," Johnson tells the Voice. 

  _____  


Yossi Melman, an Israeli journalist who specializes in intelligence issues,
has written in Haaretz and The Guardian that Aviv was not only never in the
Mossad, but he even failed basic training as an Israeli Defense Force
commando. When asked to comment, Aviv told the British newspaper The
Independent that Melman is angry because Aviv refused to cooperate with him
on a book project. Melman promptly called Aviv a liar—again. 


According to Interfor's public-relations director, Stephen Braswell, Aviv
has been "traveling" and is unavailable for comment. However, Braswell
added, Aviv stands by his claim to have been an Israeli intelligence agent,
just as he stands by his investigation of the Pan Am 103 bombing. But it's
his work on the Lockerbie affair that has led so many intelligence officials
and investigative reporters to denounce him as an unscrupulous fraud. 


On December 21, 1988, Pan Am 103 was directly over Lockerbie en route to New
York when roughly one pound of Semtex explosive detonated in the forward
cargo hold. The explosion punched a hole in the fuselage, and shock waves
tore the plane apart, killing 259 passengers and crew, including at least
four CIA agents. 


Law-enforcement agencies scrambled to investigate. Meanwhile, families of
the victims sued the airline, claiming that Pan Am officials had ignored key
security procedures and let the unaccompanied suitcase containing the bomb
onto the plane. As Pan Am's lawyers began preparing their defense, they
hired Juval Aviv to investigate the bombing. 


Aviv submitted his report a few months later. It was a masterpiece of
boilerplate spy stuff, with unnamed intelligence sources, a secret
drugs-for-hostages swap overseen by rogue CIA elements, and a multilateral
terrorist network that Aviv dubbed the "Interterror Group." According to
Aviv's report, a Frankfurt-based CIA group had cut a deal with the Syrian
arms and drug smuggler Monzer al-Kassar (for more on Kassar, see the recent
Voice story "Busting
<http://www.villagevoice.com/news/0730,thompson,77325,6.html> the Merchant
of War," July 24), in which the rogue CIA group would let Kassar ship drugs
to America on Frankfurt Pan Am flights in return for his help securing the
release of American hostages in Beirut. Kassar also allegedly used his drug
profits to finance the shipment of arms to the Nicaraguan contras.
Meanwhile, Aviv wrote, Kassar's terrorist friends decided to exploit his
access to Pan Am cargo holds to smuggle a bomb on board one of the planes. 


As the terrorists carried out their operation, West German intelligence
agents allegedly warned the rogue CIA group that a bomb was about to be
placed on a Pan Am flight. But the group did nothing to stop it. Why? Aviv
suggested that a second CIA unit had gotten wise to the drugs-for-hostages
deal and was flying back to Washington—on that very flight—to rat out their
colleagues and even go to the press, if necessary. The implication was
clear: An outlaw group of CIA spooks let the plane be destroyed in order to
cover up a vestigial limb of the Iran-contra scandal. 


Despite the outlandish claims and the lack of named sources, Aviv suggested
that his story could play very well in the national media. "From the
perspective of journalists," he wrote, "it is publishable speculation." Sure
enough, Time magazine published a version of this very story a few months
later, headlined "The Untold Story of Pan Am 103." But after a little
digging, reporters with the English Sunday paper The Observer claimed that
almost all of Aviv's "inside" information about Kassar had been cribbed from
a recently published German book about the arms dealer. Aviv, they
concluded, "had pieced together known events and facts in a wild
conspiracy." (Interfor representatives defended the Pan Am report in an
e-mail message to the Voice but didn't go into detail.) 


Pan Am eventually dropped the Aviv defense and was found liable in federal
court for willful misconduct. According to plaintiffs' attorney Jim
Kreindler, the Interfor report seriously damaged Pan Am and Aviv personally.
"He made up all this nonsense and then leaked it to the press," Kreindler
says. 


Pan Am wasn't the only one embarrassed by Aviv's work. In 1992, Steven
Emerson, a former CNN correspondent who specializes in security and
terrorism, wrote a detailed Washington Journalism Review account of just how
Time, NBC, and ABC had bought into Aviv's story. When told that Aviv now
regularly appears on national television as a credible terrorism expert,
Emerson was flabbergasted. "It's amazing to see how many times he fooled
people," he says. On the other hand, Emerson adds, television news bookers
have neither the time nor the procedures to vet the "experts" who show up at
their studios: "It's so easy to go on the air and pretend you're something
you're not. . . . The trick in television is just to fill up the time." 


As the former head of the CIA's Pan Am 103 investigation, Vincent
Cannistraro still feels bitter about Aviv's involvement. "I knew people
killed on the flight," he says. "And [Aviv] comes around and points the
finger at everyone except the people responsible for it. . . . He'll invent
anything, create any kind of scenario always referring back to intelligence,
because it's murky and no one can check his credentials. That's the kind of
person he is. He's an awful person—a despicable person." 


The government apparently agreed: In 1995, the U.S. Attorney's office in
Manhattan charged Aviv with wire and mail fraud. 

  _____  


The U.S. Attorney's office charged that, in 1991, General Electric had hired
Aviv to submit a report on the security of Caribbean vacation sites that
G.E. employees planned to visit, and that Aviv falsely claimed to have
interviewed five government officials and one FBI agent for his report. 


However, it was a weak accusation: Aviv was paid only $20,683 for the job,
G.E. officials had never complained about his work earlier, and, during the
trial, Aviv was able to produce telephone records to refute the main charge.
His attorney, Gerald Shargel, argued in court (rather convincingly) that the
case was really about the government's lingering anger over Aviv's
involvement in the Pan Am matter. 


"It is an obvious vendetta," Shargel wrote in response to the indictment,
"with agents and prosecutors determined to dig and dig into Mr. Aviv's past
at whatever expense, and to manipulate and contrive until they can formulate
a theory of criminal liability that can be used to discredit Mr. Aviv here
and abroad. It is by discrediting him that the government hopes to stamp out
the vexatious and powerful public concern over its distasteful involvement
in the Lockerbie affair." The jury agreed and acquitted Aviv of all charges.



And so Aviv was free to rebuild his reputation—a surprisingly easy task,
thanks to 9/11, his reputed Mossad history, and the short attention span of
television producers. To be fair, Aviv's reputation as an expert in asset
recovery and researching overseas accounts has never been disputed. In
addition to his novel about Robert Maxwell, he has also written two books on
how to protect one's home, family, and business against terrorist attacks
and "minimize your exposure to the next catastrophe." But given his taste
for the clandestine, it was perhaps inevitable that controversial, even
allegedly sinister figures would crave his services. In October 2003, the
leaders of NXIVM Corporation sought him out. 



  _____  

It had been a tough month for NXIVM. The Albany Times-Union had been running
stories all year detailing the company's compulsive secrecy, its members'
dazed expressions, the exorbitant fees for its 10-hour-long self-help
"seminars," and the demand that initiates bow whenever leader Keith Raniere
walked into the room. A lengthy Forbes article depicting NXIVM as a strange,
manipulative cult was about to go to press. And the family of Kristin
Snyder, who had allegedly committed suicide after fleeing one of NXIVM's
16-day "intensive" courses, was starting to raise a fuss. According to
Joseph O'Hara, a local attorney who worked as a liaison between NXIVM and
Aviv, Interfor was initially hired to investigate the circumstances
surrounding Snyder's death. 


The Times-Union account of Snyder's last few weeks described a vivacious,
confident farm girl whose personality quickly disintegrated after she
attended her first 16-day NXIVM session. Her family claimed that she had
become an angry, moody insomniac. Snyder told her family that she'd recently
learned she had been sexually abused as a child, and that she was morally
responsible for the destruction of the Columbia space shuttle. In February
2003, while attending another NXIVM seminar in Alaska, Snyder vanished
without a trace; authorities concluded that she paddled a kayak into the
middle of a freezing lake and then capsized it. 


When police discovered Snyder's truck, they found a notebook inside. "I
attended a course called Executive Success Programs (a.k.a. Nexium)," Snyder
wrote. "I was brainwashed and my emotional center of the brain was
killed/turned off. I still have feeling in my external skin, but my internal
organs are rotting." 


According to the accounts by Forbes and newspapers around Albany, NXIVM was
founded by Keith Raniere, a self-proclaimed genius who, at 12, allegedly
took less than a day to teach himself high-school math. While working as a
computer programmer in the late 1980s, Raniere became a devotee of Ayn Rand
and soon was convinced that self-interest was the apogee of ethical
behavior. Setting up a company called Consumer Buyline, he allegedly hawked
memberships in a nonexistent discount-consumer-goods club, wowed crowds with
his extraordinary charisma, and promised lucrative commissions for members
who recruited more customers into the group. But in 1993, as the company's
bills began to stack up, the New York attorney general filed suit, charging
that Consumer Byline was just another pyramid scheme designed to sucker
membership fees out of unwitting customers. As 24 other attorneys general
began investigating the company, Raniere shut it down and agreed to pay
$40,000 to make the lawsuit disappear. 


Asked about the attorney general's charges, NXIVM spokesman Phil Robertson
noted that Raniere had never admitted any wrongdoing, and also that he
suspected the whole investigation was a conspiracy engineered by Wal-Mart,
which felt threatened by Consumer Buyline's low discount prices. "It's just
a brilliant idea to save people money, and I think the pinch was felt in
Arkansas, and Wal-Mart felt the pinch, and they said, 'Let's collapse this
guy.' " 


Raniere has done considerably better with NXIVM. Originally dubbed Executive
Success Programs, the company offers Ayn Rand–ian seminars on personal
growth and achieving business goals. But critics say that the exhaustive,
10-hour sessions are designed to break down students' personalities and
isolate them from family and friends, until they're dependent on NXIVM for
their self-esteem and willing to pay good money to get it. NXIVM devotees
include some of the richest people in America and Mexico, such as two heirs
to the Bronfman/Seagram's fortune, Black Entertainment Television co-founder
Sheila Johnson, and the children of former Mexican presidents Carlos Salinas
and Vicente Fox. 

  _____  


No one has complained about NXIVM more tirelessly than Rick Ross, a New
Jersey–based "cult deprogrammer" who has spent years compiling information
on predatory cults around the country. Ross says he first heard of NXIVM in
late 2002, when a family called to complain that their son had gotten
involved with a strange new group and had recruited their daughters for the
seminars as well. A private eye dug up the pyramid-scheme accusations
against Raniere's earlier venture, and one of the daughters gave notes from
her NXIVM seminars to Ross, who forwarded them to a few psychiatrists. John
Hochman, a UCLA behavioral-psychiatry professor, concluded that NXIVM's
curriculum employed classic group mind-control techniques: long seminar
hours, isolation from friends and family, redefining English words to fit
the ambitions of group leaders, paramilitary rituals (Raniere's followers
are forced to wear sashes displaying their rank and to address him as
"Vanguard"), and daily contact with group leaders "framed as personal
growth." 


"They claimed that they had a 'breakthrough technology,' " Ross says. "What
they really have, in my opinion, is just another large group-awareness
training program, very similar to [the personal-growth cult] Landmark
Education, with certain aspects that are almost verbatim from the teachings
of Scientology." 


NXIVM's Robertson replies that Ross merely paid Hochman a fee to write the
analysis he wanted. "Hochman was paid by Ross or others to create a report,"
he said. "So he's compromised. It's not a scholarly report; he was paid to
come up with a certain production." As for Ross, Robertson claims that he's
just a "thug" who incites fear of cults in innocent people to make a buck.
"Ross is paid to create cults. That is to say, the more cults, the more
opportunities he has to make money deprogramming people. . . . The man's a
criminal—in my opinion, anyway." 


Armed with this report, Ross lured his clients' son to a Florida vacation
resort and tried to talk him into leaving NXIVM; however, the son refused
and later moved to Raniere's Albany headquarters. But the rest of the family
got out, and Ross published Hochman's report, along with everything else he
could find on NXIVM, on his website. NXIVM's leaders promptly sued him for
copyright infringement; the lawsuits and countersuits are stuck in federal
court to this day. As part of NXIVM's legal strategy, Juval Aviv was
allegedly given a new assignment in 2004: take on Ross as a special project.




  _____  

Around November 2004, according to a lawsuit that Ross filed against NXIVM,
an Interfor representative called and asked him if he wouldn't mind speaking
to a gentleman named Juval Aviv. "He told me that a very old friend of his,
an old and dear friend—not just a client, but someone that was a personal
friend—had a daughter in NXIVM and wanted to do an intervention to deprogram
her," Ross said in a later interview. "And he repeatedly said that the
mother was very wealthy, the family was very wealthy—as if to impress me, I
suppose, or get my interest." 


Ross agreed to meet the mother and Aviv at Interfor's office on Madison
Avenue. Later that month, Ross walked into the lobby and met Aviv for the
first time. "I couldn't help but notice that his hand was sweaty when he
shook my hand," Ross recalled. "And I thought that he was very nervous. And
he seemed—how do I put it?—an oily creature." The two men allegedly sat in a
conference room with Interfor attorney Anna Moody and a distraught woman who
called herself Susan Zuckerman, but who, Ross claims he would later
discover, was really a professional actress. 


"She tells me she's very worried about her daughter," Ross says. "That her
daughter is brainwashed, that she's in NXIVM, that she's sold family
heirlooms to pay for courses. That her husband is sick over it, that he had
to go to pawnshops in Manhattan and find these things and buy them back.
That they've had terrible arguments over this, that she's very worried and
doesn't know what to do." According to Ross's lawsuit, Moody asked him what
he knew about NXIVM. As a tape machine recorded the conversation, Ross spent
at least an hour explaining what he'd discovered about the group, Raniere,
and the psychological effects of the "seminars." 


After speaking with Zuckerman, the allegedly grieving mother, Ross agreed to
conduct an intervention, but added that he wouldn't have anything to do with
physical restraint. The daughter, he insisted, would be free to leave at any
time. "Aviv walks me to the elevator, even rides the elevator down to the
lobby with me," Ross later recounted. "And then he gushed to me that there
would be other cases that we could work on, and that there would be other
cults that he would like to go after, and so on. I thought, 'Man, this guy
is really nervous.' And he just seemed to go overboard, and he was really
solicitous." 


In April 2005, according to the lawsuit, Ross returned for a second meeting.
In a discussion about how such an intervention would work, Ross advised the
people assembled that because NXIVM leaders had a habit of constantly
interrupting the deprogramming with phone calls and e-mails, it was best to
have it take place somewhere isolated. Someone at the meeting suggested a
cruise ship in the Caribbean. Ross would later recall that the more the
cruise-ship notion was floated, the more excited Aviv and Moody became. They
even paid him a $2,500 retainer. But then Ross warned Moody that, as an
ethical principle, he would never be alone in the room with the daughter;
someone she trusted—her mother, or family friend Aviv—would always have to
be present. Ross claims that Moody appeared crestfallen at the news. A few
weeks later, an Interfor representative telephoned Ross and called the whole
thing off. 

  _____  


Meanwhile, NXIVM's consultant, Joseph O'Hara, was growing more and more
disturbed at what Aviv and Raniere were planning for Ross. O'Hara ultimately
stopped working for NXIVM, and now the company is suing him as well.
According to records found in this lawsuit, Interfor faxed O'Hara a
"confidential document" on November 23, 2004. The report was, in fact, a
dossier that Aviv and Interfor had prepared on Rick Ross, detailing every
piece of dirt they could find on him. "Ross' past criminal record,
psychiatric history, and financial bankruptcy leaves him extremely
vulnerable if all the source information so far indicated checks out," the
report read. 


Interfor tallied every damaging item its investigators could find: Ross saw
a shrink as a teenager and was once diagnosed as "hyperkinetic child"; he
was arrested for vandalism when he was 10; after a deprogramming incident
went bad, he was sued for kidnapping and declared bankruptcy. (Ross had
tried to help a woman get her son out of a church that Ross considered a
Bible-based cult, but the son, who was over 18, claimed that he'd been held
against his will. Oddly, it was the Church of Scientology—which had no
relation to the son's church—that encouraged him to file the suit against
Ross and paid all of his legal costs. That famous case had bizarre
repercussions: Eventually, the Church of Scientology won control of the Cult
Awareness Network, its longtime enemy, through this case.) But the Ross
dossier went much deeper than that. Interfor had also accessed Ross's
personal checking account, recorded his financial assets, and even listed
all the checks he had written in October 2004—right down to the check number
and the amount. In addition, Interfor had obtained Ross's telephone records
and listed phone calls that he had made from 2002 to 2004. "Some of the
material in the report appeared to me to be illegally obtained," O'Hara said
in a later interview. (Interfor representative Stephen Braswell refused to
discuss this report or anything related to Rick Ross and NXIVM.) 


The very next day, an alarmed O'Hara penned a note and hand-delivered it to
Keith Raniere. "At least some of the information that is contained therein
could not have been obtained legally," O'Hara wrote, according to court
records. "I was not aware that this review would involve any illegal and
potentially criminal activities. . . . It is imperative that you . . .
immediately direct Interfor to cease and desist any such activities. . . .
This specifically includes, but is not limited to, the 'Sting Operation'
that Keith has proposed having Interfor undertake with respect to Mr. Ross."
In January 2005, O'Hara quit his job with NXIVM and took boxes of documents
with him. A few months later, he gave Interfor's report on Ross to Chet
Hardin, a reporter for the Albany alternative newsweekly Metroland. Mere
months after his bizarre encounter with Aviv, Ross got a phone call from
Hardin, who told him that Interfor had compiled a secret profile of him,
complete with his private financial information and phone records. "I
thought Chet was nuts," Ross says. "Hardin said to me, 'Well, would you just
go pull a statement? Just pull your statement. . . . I went through it with
him, and [he] had all kinds of information that was detailed down to the
penny—deposits, check numbers, everything.' " 


When Ross later called O'Hara, he realized that Interfor had been working
for NXIVM all along. Suddenly, it all started to make sense. There was never
any Susan Zuckerman, never any daughter she wanted freed from NXIVM's
clutches. Aviv, Ross would later claim in a $1 million lawsuit, was just
setting him up for something. Those hour-long recorded conversations with
Interfor's lawyer were just fishing expeditions to find out what Ross had on
the company. The whole time that Aviv was pretending to be a kindly old man
looking out for his friend's daughter, he was allegedly snooping through
Ross's private life, looking for anything that could hurt him. 


But what was that cruise all about? Why were they so excited to get him
alone in the middle of the Caribbean? According to O'Hara, a young, female
NXIVM leader named Kristin Keeffe was supposed to play the role of the
daughter. When O'Hara asked what Keeffe planned to do with Ross out on that
big boat, she allegedly replied, "We're going to convert him." In the end,
no one will probably ever know how Raniere's alleged "sting operation" would
end. 


According to NXIVM spokesman Robertson, company leaders were appalled to
learn what Aviv was up to. Robertson also claimed that O'Hara is a corrupt
lawyer who is sure to be eventually disbarred and accused him of embezzling
$250,000 in NXIVM funds. O'Hara cryptically replied that the matter is the
subject of litigation, and that the lawsuit is on the eve of being settled
amicably. 


Robertson says that NXIVM was barely in contact with Aviv, whom O'Hara hired
on its behalf for entirely legal investigations. "We knew nothing here about
a sting," he said. "We had no participation in any sting. We found out about
it afterward. What we saw was, a corrupt attorney hires a corrupt private
investigator. . . . We certainly didn't—and would not—authorize illegal
activities. That was his doing, and I understand that's his nature. He's
pretty much a loose cannon." 


When asked if he regretted hiring Aviv, Robertson replied: "How can you not
regret hiring the guy who would pad his hours, he'd fabricate, he'd create
stories that he couldn't document, and behind your back he creates fantastic
programs like, uh, we later found out he was going to do some kind of insane
sting kind of deal. . . . We're certainly not responsible, nor do we condone
this type of activity. Aviv did it, there seems to be no doubt. How he did,
I don't know. I heard that he was rummaging through garbage." 

  _____  


Ross's battle with NXIVM has received publicity elsewhere, but in the course
of researching Aviv's past and his involvement with Raniere, the Voice
learned that this wasn't the only time the corporate spy was asked to pursue
one of Raniere's detractors. 


Toni Natalie was just a mom with a 10th-grade education, and all she wanted
to do was leave Raniere behind her. But according to her and O'Hara, Aviv
was hired to go after her as well. 


Natalie first met Raniere when he was running Consumers Buyline. She and her
husband had sold a bumper crop of commissions, and Raniere allegedly invited
them up to Albany for an awards ceremony. According to Natalie, Raniere
became attracted to her, offered her intensive counseling to help her quit
smoking, and promptly manipulated her into breaking up her marriage. "Before
I knew it, he had me convinced that my husband was cheating on me and was
having an affair with my nanny," Natalie recalls. "It was all a lie . . .
the next thing I knew, I was divorced and living in Albany." 


Natalie claims that she secretly dated Raniere for a while, but she became
unnerved by all the women he kept around him, as well as his odd promises
that she would bear his child and that this child would save the world. "So
I tried to break it off with him," she says. That's when the stalking
started. Raniere's followers, Natalie says, "broke into my house; they would
come and ring the doorbell at all hours of the day or night. They would tell
me that I had to come with them, that he was dying, that if I didn't stay
with him, he was going to die. . . . They tortured me—I got down to, I don't
know, a hundred pounds." 


After six months of this, Natalie says she returned to Raniere and dated him
until 1999, when she tried to leave him again and open a restaurant in
Rochester. And once again, she claims, the torment resumed. "When I finally
did leave, they would break into my house and flip pictures upside down,
they'd unmake my bed, steal clothes out of my closet. . . . They stole my
mail, they shut off my phone, they shut off my electricity. They called me
up and asked me if I knew where my son was. . . . They used to stand in
front of the restaurant for hours, telling my waitresses, 'You don't
understand, she has to come back—she's the chosen one!' " 


Eventually, Natalie says, the hounding faded away, and she set out to
rebuild her life. But last summer, Joseph O'Hara contacted Natalie and faxed
her a document that might, he said, be of interest to her. The document,
which Natalie provided to the Voice, was a January 14, 2005, invoice from
Interfor to O'Hara, in which Aviv and his associates agreed to follow
Natalie, spy on her in her house, and dig into her financial records.
"Interfor will conduct a discreet, confidential investigation on Toni
Natalie," the invoice read. "Interfor will monitor the current activities of
Ms. Natalie at her house and certain other residences as discussed. . . .
Interfor will conduct an asset investigation of Toni Natalie focusing on
current holdings as well as possible fraudulent activity (i.e., using her
dead aunt's credit cards)." O'Hara confirms that he sent the invoice to
Natalie. 


Only now, Natalie says, has she been able to discuss this ordeal in detail.
"They're scary, scary people," she says of NXIVM. "I can talk about it now,
but up until three years ago, I was a babbling idiot. . . . You have no
idea. If a door slammed, I'd be stuck on the top of the ceiling." 


Asked about Natalie's allegations, NXIVM spokesman Robertson says that Aviv
was merely retained to investigate whether Natalie committed fraud when she
filed for bankruptcy in 1999. "I couldn't tell you what Aviv did with this
Natalie woman, except that he was certainly not authorized by us to do
anything other than to find out if she's committing fraud," he says. As for
her claims that Raniere and his associates stalked and terrorized her,
Robertson replies that Natalie is a deranged felon who embezzled a fortune
and defrauded numerous banks. 


"She is a habitual thief, and she's a criminal," Robertson says. (The Voice,
however, could turn up no evidence that Natalie has ever been charged with a
crime.) "She's psychologically damaged. The woman is—she's a classic kind of
person who likes to pretend fear where she's really the victimizer. . . .
It's ridiculous to suggest, as Toni has, that she was harassed." 


Then, after denying that Natalie had been the subject of harassment,
Robertson e-mailed the Voice an obsessively detailed 25-page report on her
compiled by NXIVM associate Kristin Keeffe (the same woman who was supposed
to be on the ship in the Caribbean with Ross), which was the result of an
investigation into every aspect of her life—including her family, her
husband, and the restaurant chain they operate—with 47 endnotes, including
references to credit-card statements and lease invoices. Keeffe's report
accuses Natalie of no fewer than 260 counts of bank fraud, racketeering, and
money laundering. Somehow, Robertson expected that this report—almost
frightening in its level of detail—would prove that Raniere has put his
involvement with Natalie behind him. 


In 2003, when Raniere levelled these same charges against Natalie at her
bankruptcy hearing, Judge Robert Littlefield found the claims to be utterly
unsubstantiated. He dismissed the report, saying: "This matter smacks of a
jilted fellow's attempt at revenge or retaliation against his former
girlfriend." 


O'Hara, Ross, Aviv, and NXIVM are all still suing each other, and the cases
don't seem likely to be resolved any time soon. Natalie fought Raniere over
a bankruptcy proceeding for years; now, she said, she just wants it all to
go away. 


In the years since his adventures with NXIVM, Aviv has done very well for
himself, snagging contracts with Hollinger and other Fortune 500 companies.
Fox News, CNN, and other national news outlets still call and ask his
counsel on the latest turn in international affairs. None of them seem to
have done much to vet his credentials. Audrey Pass, a booker on Fox 5 News
(which regularly interviews Aviv on the air), insists that the station has a
proper procedure for researching the backgrounds of their expert
guests—however, she adds, "I'm not going to discuss what those procedures
are." CNN spokeswoman Edie Emery also promised that the network's background
checks are thorough. "Based on the information that he provided at the
time," she says, "we vetted him." 


Meanwhile, people like investigative reporter Steven Emerson and former CIA
official Vincent Cannistraro shake their heads in disbelief. Despite all the
accusations of fraud, manipulation, plagiarism, and invasion of privacy over
all these years, the gravy train just keeps rolling for Juval Aviv. 

 
<file:///C:/generic/show_print.php?id=78154&page=&issue=0743&printcde=MzU3OT
U2MjIzMw==&refpage=L2FkbWluL2VkaXQvZWRpdC5waHA/JmNhc2U9dXBkYXRlJnNlY3Rpb249J
mlkPTc4MTU0Jmlzc3VlPTA3NDMmbXNnPQ==/7>  

 



[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]



--------------------------
Want to discuss this topic?  Head on over to our discussion list, [EMAIL 
PROTECTED]
--------------------------
Brooks Isoldi, editor
[EMAIL PROTECTED]

http://www.intellnet.org

  Post message: [email protected]
  Subscribe:    [EMAIL PROTECTED]
  Unsubscribe:  [EMAIL PROTECTED]


*** FAIR USE NOTICE. This message contains copyrighted material whose use has 
not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. OSINT, as a part of 
The Intelligence Network, is making it available without profit to OSINT 
YahooGroups members who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the 
included information in their efforts to advance the understanding of 
intelligence and law enforcement organizations, their activities, methods, 
techniques, human rights, civil liberties, social justice and other 
intelligence related issues, for non-profit research and educational purposes 
only. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of the copyrighted material 
as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use 
this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' 
you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.
For more information go to:
http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtml 
Yahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/

<*> Your email settings:
    Individual Email | Traditional

<*> To change settings online go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/join
    (Yahoo! ID required)

<*> To change settings via email:
    mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] 
    mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
    [EMAIL PROTECTED]

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
    http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/
 

Reply via email to