Wishful thinking, but it really doesn't matter.
 
B
 
 

Was Bin Laden's last video faked? 
Video analysts debate whether al-Qaida doctored the video
By Robert Windrem and Victor Limjoco
Updated: 3:01 p.m. PT Oct 29, 2007


When al-Qaida's media arm released its first Osama Bin Laden video in nearly
three years, most of the media attention was focused on Bin Laden's beard.
It appeared either dyed - or perhaps even pasted on. He was ridiculed and a
variety of theories were offered to explain it.

But now, there is a running debate among video analysts about whether
al-Qaida faked the video altogether -that rather than being new, the
September 7 message may have been something recorded at the same time as his
last video in October 2004 (and then released with new audio).

The point of departure for the debate is something not noted at the time:
that of the 25 minutes of video tape, only three and a half minutes, were
moving video. The rest was covered by a still image or a frozen still.
Moreover, the still covered the only time references on the 25 minute of
tape- references to political developments in Iraq, Britain and France. This
lead to the suspicion that the video is not new, but disguised to appear as
new.

A senior U.S. intelligence official says they believe the message is
authentic, adding "it remains our view that the September 7 Bin Laden video
is, in fact, new. interesting but not compelling."

The leading proponent of the theory is a computer scientist and
self-described hacker Dr. Neal Krawetz of Colorado. Krawetz, who makes his
living a computer security consultant, tells NBC News in interviews and
e-mails that the similarities between the October 29, 2004 tape and the
September 7, 2007 tape are too great to be coincidental.


"Here is Bin Laden in the same clothing, same studio, same studio setup, and
same desk THREE YEARS LATER," wrote Krawetz in his blog, hackerfactor.org,
and in an interview with NBC News. "In fact, his stack of papers that he
reads are moved between the exact same stacks. If you overlay the 2007 video
with the 2004 video, his face has not changed in three years -- only his
beard is darker."  

What's his theory on the beard color?  "The contrast on the picture has been
adjusted." He notes it's not the just the beard that is darker.  Bin Laden's
eye sockets are darker as well.  Krawetz does not think that the beard color
has been digitally manipulated however. According to his e-mail: "As far as
my tools can detect, there has been no image manipulation of the Bin Laden
portion of the image beyond contrast adjustment. His beard really does
appear to be that color." 

"What are the chances of nothing changing (except his beard) in three years?
Virtually zero. The clips appear to have been recorded three years ago,"
adds Krawetz.

Krawetz does not believe that al-Qaida used the exact same video it did in
2004. Instead, he suspects that al-Qaida had recorded much more video than
it released in 2004. There may have even been two sittings. "The main thing
I am getting at:  I am not saying that they are the same recording," he
said.  "I believe they recorded a speech, changed a little, and then
recorded some more.  (Under this same theory, they may have done it many
times and AQ just has not released other videos yet)."

"I am saying the two videos were likely made either on the same day or
within days of each other."

There are indeed slight differences but Krawetz says they are easily
explained.

"The 'graybeard' (video) had the yellow tunic unzipped (unbuttoned?) while
'blackbeard' is zipped up at the bottom. This actually makes sense under the
theory that these are two different recordings taking on the same day (or
within the same few days)," Krawetz wrote in an e-mail.

For Krawetz, Bin Laden's clothing says a lot. "If you were on the run
through mountains on foot, would you be carrying around unnecessary
clothing? No. You would only take the essentials. A fancy shirt and yellow
(tunic) are not essential for mountain life on the run. If, in the future,
you find that you need a nice shirt and sweater, you would get new ones!"

Hany Farid, a digital forensics researcher at Dartmouth College, did his own
analysis of the videos for NBC News and disagrees with Krawetz.  He suggests
that while there are "quirky" aspects to the video, he doesn't think there
is a clear case that the two videos were made at the same time and are
certainly not the same video used twice.

"I think it's extremely unlikely these are actually the same video," says
Farid. "I know that there's people out there who are saying that it's
probably a copy, but I think in what we have seen so far, that is probably
not the case. There are just too many differences between the videos, both
at the visual level and at sort of a mathematical level."

"We haven't done a complete analysis, but our initial analysis says that
this is probably just simply one long video that has been edited down,"
referring to the 2007 video.  

And Farid does agree with Krawetz that there has been no digital
manipulation of Bin Laden's beard color, but has no explanation for it.    

"There has been a lot of talk about that, and the answer is no, we did not
find any manipulation there." Said Farid, "From a purely digital forensics
point of view, we don't have any problem with that part of video."

The key for Farid is not the beard, but the audio. There would be audio
differences if they were recorded at different points in time, and Farid
says his analysis didn't detect that.

"In our initial investigation, it seems that the acoustic background that we
hear is actually consistent throughout the tape, so it doesn't sound like it
actually was spliced together from different audio recordings."

Farid does admit without intelligence information, there are things he does
not understand. 

"The 2007 video that just was released is a little quirky," he said. "You
see the video start for few minutes- he's talking, he's moving a little bit
and then the video freezes, you see a still frame for a good 10, 15 minutes.
He moves again a little bit, and then it's a still frame." 

"It has been argued that the only time there are mentions of current events
are during still frames, when Bin Laden is not actually moving. To suggest
that he is perhaps dead - and this video is actually a fake- I don't think
that you can necessarily draw that conclusion from the video. I suspect that
there are simpler arguments, like when you're editing video, you often have
to make cuts and breaks. Or they could have had only one shot at the shoot."



Mo Chen consults and participates in digital forensics research at
Binghamton University in New York. He says the discussion is technically
limited by the bad quality of the 2004 video and he is unwilling to support
either side in the debate.  

"If we only look at the videos, it's possible that 2007 video is captured
from before the 2004 videos.  Our problem right now is that the 2004 Bin
Laden video quality is too poor. So this limits our research," said Chen. 

Chen adds that the lack of any clear "fingerprint" from a digital camera on
the video is a major problem. He agrees that this may not be accidental.


"There might be due to the technical reason, but it is true that it might be
intentional- [that] they don't want people to find any trace [of the
'fingerprint'] from the videos." 

The CIA will not say what it thinks about the possibility, but a senior U.S.
intelligence official tells NBC News the U.S. believes the tape is new. He
would not discuss the reasons why intelligence analysts feel that way.
Another even more senior intelligence official dismissed the possibility
that that beard is fake, but would not discuss the reason for the darkened
beard.  

Despite the debate over the most recent Bin Laden video, there is no debate
among private analysts or intelligence officials about the increasing use of
digital editing, in some cases sophisticated editing in the videos released
by al-Qaida. 

Krawetz said there is no evidence of video editing on the scale seen in the
videos of his deputy Ayman al Zawahiri.  

Krawetz noted in one recent video, Zawahiri was featured in what appeared to
be a library, complete with a desk, a banner, a bookshelf and even a toy
cannon mounted on the bookshelf.  


All of it, Krawetz said, was created digitally using software like 3DStudio.
Even the lettering on the banner was added separately.  The software permits
the creation of wire frame images that can be inserted over a green screen.

"They use multiple overlays," said Krawetz. "I suspect they have a portable
green screen or black fabric they use for the shoot, then edit the video
with multiple overlays," all of which can be seen in a forensic analysis of
the video.  

"You can tell the number of times it was layered and the order in which the
layers were added," Krawetz added. And a close examination can even
determine whether the "green screen" has wrinkles in it. Krawetz said he has
noticed the same wrinkle in several Zawahiri videos.

None of the software they use is particularly expensive, says Krawetz. The
most basic software, from Adobe or Microsoft, can yield the required
effects. (Evan Kohlmann, the NBC News counter terrorism analyst, says most
of the software is probably pirated, that every major jihadi site has a
download section filled with software from companies as big as Microsoft or
Adobe.) Nor is the editing time-consuming, especially since digital editing
is now so common in al-Qaida videos. 

Why the subterfuge? Some of it may just be for production value. making what
would be a boring background more interesting. But in the case of Bin Laden
and Zawahiri, showing them in stable office-like locations has propaganda
value. They're not living in caves or even mud huts, but comfortably, in
well-appointed surroundings. 

URL: http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/21530470/

  _____  

MSN Privacy <http://mobile.msn.com/device/en-us/privacy.aspx>  . Legal
<http://mobile.msn.com/device/en-us/terms.aspx> 
C 2007 MSNBC.com 
(F)AIR USE NOTICE: All original content and/or articles and graphics in this
message are copyrighted, unless specifically noted otherwise. All rights to
these copyrighted items are reserved. Articles and graphics have been placed
within for educational and discussion purposes only, in compliance with
"Fair Use" criteria established in Section 107 of the Copyright Act of 1976.
The principle of "Fair Use" was established as law by Section 107 of The
Copyright Act of 1976. "Fair Use" legally eliminates the need to obtain
permission or pay royalties for the use of previously copyrighted materials
if the purposes of display include "criticism, comment, news reporting,
teaching, scholarship, and research." Section 107 establishes four criteria
for determining whether the use of a work in any particular case qualifies
as a "fair use". A work used does not necessarily have to satisfy all four
criteria to qualify as an instance of "fair use". Rather, "fair use" is
determined by the overall extent to which the cited work does or does not
substantially satisfy the criteria in their totality. If you wish to use
copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you
must obtain permission from the copyright owner. For more information go to:
http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtml 

THIS DOCUMENT MAY CONTAIN COPYRIGHTED MATERIAL. COPYING AND DISSEMINATION IS
PROHIBITED WITHOUT PERMISSION OF THE COPYRIGHT OWNERS.

 


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]



--------------------------
Want to discuss this topic?  Head on over to our discussion list, [EMAIL 
PROTECTED]
--------------------------
Brooks Isoldi, editor
[EMAIL PROTECTED]

http://www.intellnet.org

  Post message: [email protected]
  Subscribe:    [EMAIL PROTECTED]
  Unsubscribe:  [EMAIL PROTECTED]


*** FAIR USE NOTICE. This message contains copyrighted material whose use has 
not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. OSINT, as a part of 
The Intelligence Network, is making it available without profit to OSINT 
YahooGroups members who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the 
included information in their efforts to advance the understanding of 
intelligence and law enforcement organizations, their activities, methods, 
techniques, human rights, civil liberties, social justice and other 
intelligence related issues, for non-profit research and educational purposes 
only. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of the copyrighted material 
as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use 
this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' 
you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.
For more information go to:
http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtml 
Yahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/

<*> Your email settings:
    Individual Email | Traditional

<*> To change settings online go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/join
    (Yahoo! ID required)

<*> To change settings via email:
    mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] 
    mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
    [EMAIL PROTECTED]

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
    http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/
 

Reply via email to