http://www.mainstreamweekly.net/article388.html
 

Strategic Alliance with the USA in a World of ’Civilisation’-based Alignment


Wednesday 31 October 2007, by
<file:///C:/Program%20Files/Common%20Files/Microsoft%20Shared/Stationery/aut
eur39.html> Kunal Ghosh


The Government of India is in the process of reaching a comprehensive
agreement with the USA on civil cooperation in nuclear power. The Left
parties are opposed to it on the ground that it binds India to America as a
global strategic partner and that has some long term ramifications. They
say: “The nuclear cooperation deal is an integral part of the July 2005
Joint Statement, which has political, economic and strategic aspects. It is
also closely linked to the June 2005 Military Framework Agreement signed
with the United States.” (Left Parties’ Statement 2007) They look at the
deal from their traditional anti-imperialist point of view and they make no
secret that they consider the USA to be the number one neo-imperialist
hegemon that has put on the garb of neo-liberalism. There is some element of
truth in their assessment but I consider it incomplete. There is a
cultural-civilisational-religious-racial dimension to America’s geo-politics
which impinges both directly and indirectly on India’s national interests,
and it is this aspect that all political parties, including the Congress,
Left and BJP, have ignored so far. I shall call it the religio-ethnic
dimension in brief. It has something to do with the national identity of
America and its core allies.

National Identity and Secularism (or Sectarianism) of America

CONTRARY to popular belief, America is a deeply divided society on the basis
of religiosity. The coastal cities of both the east and the west are centres
of non-religious liberalism and are home to the major universities of world
fame. We often tend to judge the USA by the social mores of these
high-profile cities. The majority of people lives in Middle America and is
deeply religious and harbour narrow sectarian outlook. They tend to have
large families and their population is increasing faster. They are
increasingly dominant in national affairs. They are primarily Protestant and
secondarily Catholic. The presence of the third important Christian
denomination, Orthodoxy, is negligibly small. Among the Protestants the
Episcopalians and the Baptists are dominant. Both sprang from the Anglican
Church in different times in history. Traditionally the Baptists have been
more intolerant and devout, some say, fanatical. In contrast, the
Episcopalians have been more tolerant toward other denominations and
religions and have a more liberal-secular outlook, in the mould of the
Church of England. But all that seems to have been changing for last one
generation with the rise of the mid-20th century Evangelism. A very famous
Baptist preacher, Rev Billy Graham, took centre-stage during the 1960s. He
supported the American aggression in Vietnam to the hilt and to the last,
even when it appeared that American withdrawal was inevitable. He was a
family friend of most of the Presidents, such as, Johnson, Nixon etc. of
that era. He was tremendously popular among the Blacks and was a friend of
Martin Luther King, Junior, the legendary Black leader of the civil rights
movement, till they fell out later over the Vietnam war. What is most
important is that he had also a tremendous following among the
Episcopalians. Wikipedia, the web encyclopedia, says: “Billy Graham, is a
career evangelist and an Evangelical. He has been a spiritual adviser to
multiple US Presidents and was number seven on Gallup’s list of admired
people for the 20th century. He is a member of the Southern Baptist
Convention.” The next generation saw the arrival of Pat Robertson, who is
equally popular in America, a member of the closely knit top political
circle. Robertson is a televangelist. He is the founder of numerous
organisations and corporations, including the Christian Broadcasting Network
(CBN), the Christian Coalition, Operation Blessing International Relief and
Development Corpora-tion. He is the host of The 700 Club, a Christian TV
programme airing on channels throughout the United States and on CBN
affiliates worldwide. He is opposed to abortion and gay rights, Robertson is
a supporter of the Republican Party and campaigned unsuccessfully to become
the party’s nominee in the 1988 presidential election. He is a Southern
Baptist and was active as an ordained minister with that denomination for
many years, but holds to a charismatic theology not traditionally common
among Southern Baptists. (Wikipedia 2007) The Middle America has a long
tradition of donating enormously and regularly to church funds, and with the
rise of Evangelism this trend has strengthened. The Evangelical movement has
tremendous money power, which can be easily judged by looking at the number
of their websites, TV channels, publications and worldwide network. The
declared aim of the Evangelical movement is converting the whole world to
their version of Christianity. Their enormous man and money power is active
in North-East India, Africa, Eastern Europe and Latin America. They have
tasted much success in targeting Catholics in Brazilian slums, and that has
become a bone of contention with the Catholic Pope. To summarise, [1] the
American Episcopalians and Baptists have come closer. They seem to be in the
process of a de facto merger. [2] Both have moved away from their
traditional worldview and found a new cause in Evangelism. President George
Bush, Jr., born in an Episcopalian family, is a declared ‘Born Again’
Christian and a supporter of Evangelism. In his book, A Charge To Keep, he
says he was inspired by the Baptist preacher, Rev Billy Graham, who was a
family friend, during one of his visits to Bush family home at Maine and
“this contributed to my decision to commit my heart to Jesus Christ”.

The American Constitution enshrines religious freedom explicitly and
unambiguously, it is well known. What is not well known is that America has
many anti-cult laws on her statutes. A cult is defined as a cohesive social
group devoted to beliefs or practices that the surrounding culture considers
outside the mainstream. Under the cult laws any religious organisation,
outside the pale of traditional Christian denominations, can be sued for
millions of dollars if even one disgruntled or disappointed former disciple
can be found who states that he/she has been taken advantage of. Many
Hindu-Buddhist organisations and secular Yoga exercise groups have been sued
under cult laws. Often an evangelical Christian enters a so-called cult in
the disguise of a disciple only to come out later lifting an accusatory
finger. Organised Christian cult-busting legal groups with dozens of lawyers
and million dollar budgets go around systematically encouraging suits
against Hindu and Buddhist groups. Such groups as the Hare Krishnas
(ISKCON), Transcendental Meditation, the Sikhs under Yogi Bhajan, to name a
few, have faced such suits and sometimes adverse settlements in the
millions. To summarise, [1] what the Constitution gives with the right hand
it takes away with the left, and [2] Evangelist influence is increasing as
America moves more and more toward persecution of beliefs alien to
mainstream Christian denominations.

I have written quite a few articles in the pages of Mainstream on the
Baptist connection of separatism in North-East India. (Ghosh 1999, 2002;
Ghosh and Kumar 2004, 2005a, 2005b) The British during the Raj consciously
used religion as an instrument of politics and facilitated access to
North-East India for American Baptist missionaries and had drafted a plan
(the Coupland plan) for creating a Crown Colony comprising parts of India
and Burma. After independence American missionary funding continued for
Christianisation and secession. The American Government tacitly encouraged
it for punishing non-aligned India, which had refused to join their camp.
Nowadays the funding continues with renewed vigour from an America that is
in the grip of combined Episcopalian-Baptist Evangelism. (See Note 1 for the
American connection.) Many of the separatist organisations of North-East
India are motivated by the political tenets of Christianity and employ
terror tactics such as bombing of civilians and trains, forced conversion of
people in remote hamlets etc. I am tempted to coin a term, namely
Christianism, after the well-known term Islamism. The latter means,
according to Huband (1999), ‘the ideological belief in the requirement to
enact the political tenets of Islam as the basis of political life’. In the
Indian North-East there are groups which believe in creating a Christian
theocratic state as the basis of political life. A few excerpts from the
political manifesto of National Socialist Council of Nagaland are sufficient
to substantiate this point: To us the sovereign existence of our country,
the salvation of our people in socialism with their spiritual salvation in
Christ are eternal and unquestionable. …import of things repugnant to the
taste of a Christian people would be prohibited.

We stand for faith in God and salvation of mankind in Jesus, the Christ,
alone, that is, ‘NAGALAND FOR CHRIST’.

I call such people Christianist and their ideology Christianism. America is
the main support base for Christianist separatists of North-East India.
Returning to the proposed 123-nuclear Agreement, it is apparent that America
expects its Indian ally to refrain from anything that is not in America’s
strategic interest, and it restricts India’s hands in any natural-gas-deal
with Iran. The least the Government of India could have done was to include
a clause for closing funding channels from America to Christianist militants
in North-East India, as a quid pro quo. There is no evidence that India has
even mooted the topic.

Religio-Ethnic Core of America

HUNTINGTON (1996) in his book, Clash of Civilisations and Remaking of World
Order, says that ‘Western Christianity’ is central to America’s
civilisational identity. By Western Christianity he means Protestantism and
Catholicism. He is hypocritically silent on Judaism, whereas in fact Judaism
is integral to American civilisation. The Jews are a minority in America but
they are the most significant minority, distinguished for their control of
banking and finance, and contribution to music, film industry and all forms
of intellectual activities from research in science and technology to
economics, social sciences and liberal arts. Also they are singularly active
and powerful in American politics. They occupy significant posts in both the
mainstream parties in strength which is out of proportion to their number.
>From the inception of Israel in 1948 the American Jewry has been allowed to
hold dual citizenship of Israel and the USA, a privilege not given to any
other group or country. The West European Protestant and Catholic countries,
Canada, Australia and Israel, form the block of kin-civilisation countries
allied with the United States. After the disintegra-tion of Yugoslavia and
the Soviet Union, a few countries of Central Europe, such as, Slovenia,
Croatia, Poland etc. have joined this kin-civilisation group. But there is
an inner core inside this group. This core consists of the English-speaking
White nations and Israel. The security and welfare of the core is paramount
and takes precedence even over the economic interests of America. This fact
our Leftist politicians should do well to pay attention to. The next most
important thing to America is, of course, her global economic interests,
which include relationship with the oil exporting countries, most of whom
happen to be Islamic. Most of these countries are in a dilemma over Israel’s
brutal treatment of Muslim Palestinians and this dilemma is the greatest
influence on American foreign policy and global politics, more than her
neo-imperialist considerations. The central issue to this dilemma and
American response needs a name and I shall call it America-Israel Kinship
factor, in short, AIK factor. The worldwide growing anti-Americanism among
the Muslims is the direct product of the AIK factor.

An Adversary : Who and Why?

NO matter what the Western political leaders profess in public, they
practice something close to what is described in Huntington’s aforementioned
book. They perceive Muslim and Orthodox countries as the ‘other’, a twin
adversary. However, each adversary has to be handled differently. Also,
there is large body of Muslims in today’s world who believe in Pan-Islamism.
To such Muslims America gives a clear signal: “If you attack my core, the
retaliation would be swift and all out.” Such attacks on the USA and Western
Europe will be viewed as terrorism. But similar attacks on Russia, Serbia,
India or Thailand would be viewed as freedom struggle. The secessionist
tendency in Kashmir is almost as old as India’s independence and India has
fought a few wars with Pakistan over Kashmir. The Anglo-American powers have
always sided with Pakistan, overtly or covertly. When the terrorist
insurgency started in Kashmir in the 1980s, this attitude on their part
persisted for next 20 years and only now it seems to be softening. Bosnia,
Kosovo, Chechnya are all cases in point with respect to the US attitude to
the Orthodox. The Orthodox countries need not be accommodated at all,
because America’s economic interests are not tied up in Orthodox countries.
In fact they can be sacrificed to placate the Muslim sentiment and
counter-balance the AIK factor and America has done precisely that with
respect to Serbia and Russia, as I will show later.

At one time America considered the Soviet Union an enemy country because it
was the centre of world communism. On the part of the Communists the idea of
exporting revolutionary ideas and overthrowing capitalism was a mission. The
Cold War grew out of such circumstances. But that is a thing of the past.
The Soviet Union has disintegrated and Eastern Europe has embraced
capitalism and so has China in the garb of the so-called market-socialism.
Why does America still continue with hostile posturing vis-à-vis Russia? It
is because America needs an adversary for a definite reason, for the sake of
maintaining an armament industry which is gargantuan in size, generates
enormous employment and helps the government to spend tax money without
causing inflation. The global arms market is so huge and involves so many
players globally that it would be safe to say that the world capitalist
economy would get into recession if true peace (instead of cold war of one
kind or another) prevails and the armament industry of all countries is
forced to close down. So an adversary is necessary to maintain public
support and the raison d’etre to keep the arms manufacture and defence
research going. In the 1980s President Gorbachev of the erstwhile Soviet
Union had offered a deal for negotiated, calibrated and gradual mutual
disarmament to the United States. The offer was rejected after much
pretensions and negotiations, because the leading capitalist power cannot
create a serious disorder in the global capitalist economy. After the
collapse of the Soviet Union, the new Russia again extended its hand of
friendship to America, and again it was rejected. Now President Putin has
reasserted Russian dominance in whatever remains of her zone of influence in
Eastern Europe and Central Asia. Russia has been forced to re-start the arms
race.

Russia’s Chechnya

CHECHNYA is a republic in the Caucasus mountains in the federal structure of
Russia, inhabited mostly by a Muslim population. The recently arrived
Wahhabism from Saudi Arabia has managed to displace the traditional Sufi
Islam practised in the region to a great extent. (Khan 1999) This has bred
militancy, terrorism and separatism. President Boris Yeltsin tried to come
to terms with Chechen aspirations by granting them autonomy, but that
spurred them on further to export Wahhabism and separatism to neighbouring
Dagestan and Ingushetia by terrorist methods. Finally Russia, led by
President Putin, was forced to crack down and militarily subdued the Chechen
guerrillas. Thereafter sporadic acts of terrorism continue. A few years ago
Chechen terrorists took over a school in Beslan which finally resulted in
confrontation with the security forces and a bloodbath leading to the death
of hundreds of children. The Western powers, led by the Anglo-Americans, had
been pontificating to the Russians right from the beginning of separatism
that they should give independence to Chechnya; the Chechens are fighting
for freedom and self-determination, etc. After the Beslan massacre President
Bush of the USA uttered a homily that Russia should settle politically with
the Chechens and give them freedom. This invited a slap of a statement from
President Putin that America should settle politically with Osama bin Laden
and give him what he wanted. It is to be noted that the Beslan incident came
well after the plane-bombing of the World Trade Centre in New York, USA on
September 11, 2001, and Osama bin Laden was considered the top leader of the
Al-Qaeda that perpetrated this horrific act of terrorism. This incident
shows up the American double-standard with respect to Islamist terrorism and
how America is prepared to placate Muslim sentiment at the cost of Orthodox
Russia.

Serbia’s Kosovo

SERBIA, the heartland of the erstwhile Yugoslav Federation, Orthodox by
religion, had been traditionally held in high regard by the West. During
World War II the Serbs stood up to Hitler. In contrast, a major section of
the Croats, the Catholic inhabitants of Croatia, another republic of the
federation, collaborated with the Nazis and massacred the Serb Orthodox
minority in Croatia under the guidance of a Catholic clergyman. The Nazis
took advantage of the traditional hatred between Catholics and the Orthodox
in that part of the world. Later during the 1950s Yugoslavia, defended by a
predominantly Serbian Army, defied the Soviet dictator, Stalin. It continued
to defy the dictates of a domineering Soviet Union till the time of
Brezhnev. Politically Yugoslavia since World War II had been non-aligned in
spite of being ruled by Communists and endeared herself to the Western
powers. Led by Tito she always pursued a policy of mixed economy and not
“command economy” as the rest of the communist bloc. Basic freedoms, such as
freedom of expression and travel, were respected. All in all Serbia had
earned goodwill and prestige from the Western nations.

In the next phase of history after the break-up of the Soviet Union and
Yugoslavia, Serbia’s contribution to the defeat of Fascism and building of
democracy was forgotten in no time at all. In the civil war that followed
the disintegration of Yugoslavia, the West supported Catholic Croatia along
the Serbia-Croatia border. There was ethnic cleansing committed by both
sides. The evidence against Croatia was suppressed by the machinations of a
NATO intervention force. Vanita Singh (1992), who lived in Yugoslavia at
that time, has given an excellent impartial record of these events. But the
worse was yet to come. In the Bosnian theatre of the war it was a triangular
struggle among Muslims, Catholic Croats and Orthodox Serbs. Again all three
committed war crimes, but it was only the Serbs who were held guilty. Their
leaders, Karadzic and Milosevic, were demonised by the West. Europe for the
first time saw infusion of Mujahideen warriors from non-European Muslim
countries fighting on the side of Bosnian Muslims led by Izetbegovic. The
NATO imposed a settlement on Bosnia. And then Kosovo, a southern province of
Serbia, went up in flames.

Kosovo has an interesting history. Slavs entered the Balkans in 6th to 7th
century AD. By 1190 Kosovo had become the administrative and cultural centre
of the medieval Serbian state ruled by the powerful Nemanjic dynasty. This
dynasty lasted 200 years and still today Kosovo is known by Serbians as “Old
Serbia”. In the Middle Ages the Balkans were occupied by the Ottoman Turks
and they imposed discriminatory laws against the Christian population
leading to large scale conversion to Islam. Both Albania and present-day
Kosovo had Christian and Muslim populations and there were continual strife
and see-saw struggle between Christian Serbs and Muslim Albanians/Kosovars.
During the Nazi occupation of World War II, the Serbs resisted and the
Albanian/Kosovar Muslims collaborated; thousands of Kosovo Serbs were
expelled by armed Albanian groups, notably the Vulnetari militia. It is
still not known exactly how many fell victim to this, but Serbian estimates
put the figures at 10,000-40,000 killed with 70,000-100,000 expelled. Kosovo
was on its way to becoming an Albania- dominated province.

There is resurgence in Islamic militancy all over the world and Bosnia and
Kosovo are no exceptions. As stated before, the Israeli-Palestinian conflict
and America-Israel Kinship (AIK) factor are primarily responsible for this.
But Huntington (1996) thinks otherwise and says, ( p.116, Chapter 5:
Economics, Demography and the Challenger Civilisations), While the rise of
East Asia has been fuelled by spectacular rates of economic growth, the
resurgence of Islam has been fuelled by equally spectacular rates of
population growth. Population expansion in Islamic countries, particularly
in the Balkans, North Africa and Central Asia has been significantly greater
than that in the neighbouring countries and in the world generally.

He backs up his statement with impressive and latest birth rate data. The
demographic factor may have skewed the politics of both Bosnia and Kosovo to
some extent. There have been consistent reports of Albanians (mostly Muslim)
pouring across the mountainous border into more prosperous Yugoslavia (that
is, into Kosovo) from a Stalinist Albania throughout the latter half of the
20th century.

The rest of the history is brief. When the Bosnian civil war came to an end,
the NATO intervention there emboldened Albanians in Kosovo and they started
ethnic cleansing of the minority Orthodox Serbs. President Slobodan
Milosevic strengthened the presence of the Serbian Army and security forces
many fold to maintain law and order and protect the Serbs. This caused an
exodus of Albanian Muslims. The NATO bombed Serbia proper for three months
and into the Stone Age by destroying all power houses, utility network, road
bridges and important public buildings. Serbia was forced to withdraw all
security forces and the bombings came to an end on June 10, 1999. The
Albanians moved back, some of the resident Serbs escaped and since then
Kosovo has demanded secession from Serbia. This demand is backed by the
NATO. Right now the NATO and Russian forces are present in Kosovo to protect
the remaining Serb minority who live in enclaves. When Kosovo gains
independence, what would happen to them? Everyone knows that they would have
to escape. To me secession of Kosovo does not seem morally justified and I
perceive a close parallel with India’s Kashmir, except that there never was
an exodus of Muslims from Kashmir, although the Hindu exodus of 1989-90 has
not been reversed so far. If Kosovo secedes with NATO assistance, would
Kashmir be the next target of the Western powers led by America? The track
record of America does not inspire confidence. She has to counterbalance the
AIK factor continually to placate the Muslim world.

India’s Strategic Interest in Central Asia

INDIA has her sole overseas military facility at the Ayni air base, 15 km
from Tajikistan’s capital Dushanbe, under the 2002 bilateral defence
agreement with Tajikistan. The refurbishment of the Ayni military base, for
around $1.77 million (about Rs 7 crores), was completed earlier this year
nearly 24 months behind schedule by the Indian Border Roads Organisation.
India is likely to be evicted from its sole, albeit fledgling, overseas
military facility under pressure from Russia, which has considerable
influence with Tajikistan and is concerned over New Delhi’s burgeoning ties
with Washington.

There are other developments in Central Asia. In order to check the entry of
a freshly aggressive NATO on the one hand and Islamism on the other, a
Collective Security Treaty Organisation (CSTO) was loosely formed in 1992 in
Tashkhent. Later some other countries joined it and the Treaty came into
force formally on April 20, 1994. The signatories are Russia, Armenia,
Kazakhstan, Kyrghyzstan, Tajikistan, Uzbekistan, Azerbaijan, Georgia and
Belarus. The Treaty reaffirmed the desire of all the participating states to
abstain from the use or threat of force. The signatories wouldn’t be able to
join other military alliances, while an aggression against one signatory
would be perceived as an aggression against all.

China is not a member of the CSTO and is the key country in the Shanghai
Cooperation Organisation (SCO). Such a name has been chosen deliberately to
keep India out. India cannot possibly join the SCO for the same reason as
why she cannot join a hypothetical Rawalpindi Coopera-tion Treaty. Names
matter. India can, however, seek an ‘observer’ status in the SCO, which is
notably not a military alliance. China’s relationship with India is not
going to change much in the near future and China would maintain an
aggressive posture by claiming Arunachal, and military thrusts and jabs
along the border. But India need not be unnecessarily perturbed since we
have adequate strength and China would never engage on this side of the
Himalayan ridge line. China may have superior strength in ICBMs and nuclear
arms, but infantry engagement across a mountain is another matter. She
remembers what happened when she sent her Army into Vietnam during the
1980s. Skirmishes along the North-Eastern border would continue and India
must keep a vigil, take local action, lodge a protest when appropriate but
not get perturbed. China would continue to arm Pakistan and give it nuclear
and missile technology to keep India tied down on her western borders. All
this is because of Dalai Lama and Buddhism, both having an Indian
connection. Chinese Communists consider Buddhism a competing
religion/ideology and a threat, and persecute any organised Buddhist
activity in mainland China, such as Falun Gong. (Ghosh 2002b) They just
about tolerate organised Lama Buddhism in Tibet but have circumscribed it to
a great extent. India must make a realistic assessment of any international
situation and should neither whip up nor get carried away by emotions. India
must come to terms with China’s phenomenal economic and military rise. It is
completely unnecessary to even think of a containment of China. How does it
matter to us if China becomes a superpower? Our priorities should be
security along the border and economic development. It would be sheer
stupidity to think that America can help us contain China, even if she wants
to. China has close economic ties with the USA, become the hub of production
of consumer goods for thousands of major US companies, holds 900 billion
dollars worth of US treasury bonds, and helps maintain the world dollar
standard. It means that China subsidises the American consumer and America
is ‘indebted’ to China.

Russia is drawing closer to China in the face of the hostile Western
posturing, and the SCO and CSTO—which have some overlapping membership—may
soon sign a protocol of cooperation. (Bhadra-kumar 2007) Is time running out
for India in Central Asia?

Russia has always been a reliable friend to India, whereas America’s record
is mixed. What would be our standing in Central Asia after the 123-nuclear
Agreement with the USA goes through? Can we not acquire nuclear fuel and
technology from a resurgent Russia? The USA backtracked from a signed
agreement on the Bokaro steel plant in the 1960s. Internationally it has
withdrawn from many treaties when its national interests so demanded. The
Kyoto Protocol on climate change, Comprehensive Test Ban Treaty (CTBT) and
Strategic Arms Limitation Treaty (SALT) are examples. There is already the
Hyde Act, and a future President may interpret this Act to his convenience
and withdraw from the 123-nuclear Agreement with India. Conclusions

DURING the Cold War era Russia was Communist and India non-aligned. British
imperialism had ended and given place to Anglo-American neo-colonialism.
India as a non-aligned country wanted friendship with all, but was viewed
with suspicion by the Western powers. They struck a pro-Pakistan posture and
tacitly encouraged Kashmir’s secession. In North-East India they facilitated
Baptist-inspired separatism. Notably, religion was used as an instrument of
politics in both arenas to trouble India. Russia, as the prime component of
communist Soviet Union, stood by India in all confrontations with Pakistan,
was the largest supplier of military hardware and helped India to
industrialise, whereas America backed off from a signed agreement to build a
single steel plant.

Now the world paradigm has changed. The conflicts are no longer
ideology-based but civilisation-based, as per Huntington (1996), and the
most important ingredient of a civilisation is its religion. In this era
what is the probability that America would retract from fomenting trouble in
the North-East by reining in funding from the Baptists? It is pretty much
nil, in my opinion. America herself is in the grip of Evangelist fervour as
Baptists and Episcopalians are gradually merging, and support of the
Christianist militants of the North-East will likely gain momentum. America,
in this mood, cannot be a reliable strategic partner. In addition America
has to appease the Muslim world in all other theatres except in the
Arab-Israeli conflict of West Asia. She has conveniently picked Orthodox
Christianity as the adversary and has encouraged Islamist separatists in
Kosovo and Chechnya, and bombed Serbia to Stone Age, in order to neutralise
the effect of the AIK factor. For a long time America had categorised
Islamist terrorism in Kashmir as freedom struggle, and only recently has
resiled from that stand. When Afghanistan’s and North-West Pakistan’s
Taliban militancy becomes somewhat pacified, America will likely revert back
to her original Kashmir posture again, to reward (and perhaps stabilise)
Pakistan for her cooperation in the Afghan frontier.

Our foreign policy seems ill-advised and short- sighted. We seem to be
putting all our eggs in the American basket. We may have limited joint naval
exercises with America but should not enter into any military or strategic
pact or understanding with her. However, we should join the CSTO, retain our
military base and presence in Tajikistan and influence events in
Afghanistan. If China can have close economic ties with the USA, hold
billions of dollars worth of US treasury bonds and help maintain the world
dollar standard on one hand, and cosy up to the CSTO on the other, why
cannot India continue her traditional friendship with Russia and at the same
time have a working relationship with the USA? What the government is
proposing right now is an extremely close strategic tie-up with America to
the detriment of our relationship with Russia. In the end it is a question
of finesse in conducting foreign policy. We should learn from Pakistan;
observe how it acquires nuclear power with the help of China, carries on
ambivalently with the Taliban and yet milks her relationship with the USA to
the last drop. In contrast, our foreign policy is offending our traditional
and reliable friend, Russia, by a ham-handed one-sided approach. The
government must rethink and change direction. What I have tried to show is
that, under the present geo-political circumstances, Orthodox-majority
secular Russia is a natural and reliable ally of Hindu-majority secular
India. The Orthodox, unlike the Protestant and Catholic, do not have a
proselytising mission to convert the rest of the world to their faith, and
religion matters in today’s world.

 



[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]



--------------------------
Want to discuss this topic?  Head on over to our discussion list, [EMAIL 
PROTECTED]
--------------------------
Brooks Isoldi, editor
[EMAIL PROTECTED]

http://www.intellnet.org

  Post message: [email protected]
  Subscribe:    [EMAIL PROTECTED]
  Unsubscribe:  [EMAIL PROTECTED]


*** FAIR USE NOTICE. This message contains copyrighted material whose use has 
not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. OSINT, as a part of 
The Intelligence Network, is making it available without profit to OSINT 
YahooGroups members who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the 
included information in their efforts to advance the understanding of 
intelligence and law enforcement organizations, their activities, methods, 
techniques, human rights, civil liberties, social justice and other 
intelligence related issues, for non-profit research and educational purposes 
only. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of the copyrighted material 
as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use 
this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' 
you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.
For more information go to:
http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtml 
Yahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/

<*> Your email settings:
    Individual Email | Traditional

<*> To change settings online go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/join
    (Yahoo! ID required)

<*> To change settings via email:
    mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] 
    mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
    [EMAIL PROTECTED]

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
    http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/
 

Reply via email to