Sharia in a First Amendment Society

Posted By William Kilpatrick On July 30, 2010 @ 12:05 am In FrontPage | 22
<http://frontpagemag.com/2010/07/30/sharia-in-a-first-amendment-society-2/pr
int/#comments_controls>  Comments

Steve Chapman, a columnist for the Chicago Tribune, has a piece in Human
Events criticizing Sarah Palin for her opposition to building a mosque at
Ground Zero. His argument seems to be that in guaranteeing freedom of
religion, the First Amendment guarantees that all religions be treated
identically. Therefore, argues Chapman, if you would allow evangelical
Christians to build a church near Ground Zero, you must allow Muslims to
build their mosque and community center—otherwise you are guilty of
employing a double standard.

But the double standard only applies if you are dealing with two equivalent
individuals or groups. You’re not guilty of using a double standard if you
give the keys to your car to your sixteen-year-old child but not to your
six-year-old. Likewise, if you support your own children but refuse to
support your neighbor’s children, no one will accuse you of employing a
double standard. In both these examples the two groupings are similar in
many ways (your children, your neighbor’s children) but are different in
crucial ways.

One way to avoid the double standard in regard to Islam is simply to declare
that Islam is a political ideology, not a religion, and therefore not
protected by the freedom of religion clause. For example, Geert Wilders has
claimed that “Islam is not a religion” but a totalitarian ideology and
therefore “the right to religious freedom should not apply to Islam.”
Moorthy Muthuswamy takes a similar tack in his book Defeating Political
Islam. Islam, he maintains, is basically a political ideology. Likewise,
Gregory Davis, the author of Religion of Peace? Islam’s War Against the
World argues that we need to reorient our thinking about Islam: “The first
task of the West must be to reclassify Islam as a political system with
religious aspects, rather than a religion with political aspects.” “How do
you solve a problem like Sharia?” asks Mark Steyn in a playful paraphrase of
the Broadway song. The simple answer is you reclassify Islam as a political
organization.

But for hundreds of years Islam has been thought of as a religion—one of the
world’s “great” religions according to most history books. While it’s
undoubtedly true that many Islamic leaders cynically use religion as a cover
for political ambitions, it’s also certainly true that many Muslims feel
that in practicing Islam they are being obedient to God’s commands. For this
and a number of other reasons it would be difficult to make a case that
Islam is not in any sense a religion.

If Islam is treated as a religion and is therefore protected by the free
exercise clause, what then? The First Amendment has never been interpreted
to give people the freedom to do whatever they want just as long as they do
it in the name of religion. In the late 19th century, Congress outlawed the
Mormon practice of polygamy, and when the Mormons appealed the law, the
Supreme Court upheld the ban. The Congress did, in fact, prohibit the free
exercise of one particular Mormon custom. Congress would certainly also have
the power to prohibit the free exercise of many Islamic customs, laws, and
obligations that are in flagrant violation of federal laws. Crimes such as
polygamy, underage marriages, stoning and whippings, honor killings and the
murder of apostates are covered by existing laws. But there are other, more
ambiguous areas where the free exercise of Islam might be curtailed for
reasons of security. Should the wearing of the burqa be banned? Should
mosques and Muslim schools be monitored for seditious activities? Should
Friday sermons be pre-approved by government officials?

There are two main problems here. One problem is that there so many
questionable aspects to Islamic teachings that mosques, madrassas and
Islamic centers would require extensive, round-the-clock monitoring and
supervision. This, in turn, would generate innumerable protests and civil
rights lawsuits, and, most probably, increased media sympathy for Islam.
Handled the wrong way, a tough crackdown could backfire and end up helping
rather than hindering the spread of Islam.

The other problem is that such an approach sets up a slippery slope for
restricting the religious freedoms of Jews, Christians, Buddhists and
others. Any attempt to ban the burqa will elicit demands that nuns be
forbidden to wear habits. Likewise, it will be argued that if Muslims can’t
wear distinctive garb, Christians shouldn’t be allowed to wear crosses, and
Jews shouldn’t be allowed to display the Star of David. And if you’re going
to monitor mosques and madrassas for un-American activities, why not monitor
churches, homeschools and Christian schools, as well? Granting the
government sweeping supervisory powers over Islam might provide it with just
the leverage it needs to haul Pastor Jones off to jail the next time he says
the wrong thing about gay marriage.

It shouldn’t work that way, of course: people ought to be able to make
distinctions. It ought to be obvious that Christianity poses far less of a
threat to our society than does Islam. But thanks to thirty years of
multicultural indoctrination, many Americans have succumbed to the notion
that all groups no matter how different, must be treated the same. Thus
Steve Chapman observes that even if Islam were “inherently violent and
totalitarian” it would still merit the full protection of the First
Amendment. 

I’m not so sure about that. If the main goal of a religion is the
subjugation of all other religions and governments, along with the
establishment of a totalitarian legal system, then it seems legitimate to
restrict the free exercise of that religion. Whether Islam is a political
ideology or a hybrid of religion and political ideology may not matter for
practical purposes. If it is a religion that aims to impose a system of laws
that will end freedom of religion and freedom of speech, it seems to
disqualify itself from protection by the First Amendment. Moreover, one of
the main purposes of the First Amendment is to prohibit the government from
establishing a state religion. But the main purpose of Islam is precisely to
establish itself as the state religion. In other words, the First Amendment
is un-Islamic. Islam’s raison d´etre is to be the established religion in
every nation.

Lawrence Auster has made the argument that because Islam is fundamentally
different from other religions it shouldn’t be covered by the First
Amendment. He writes, “…I believe that it is possible that Islam’s First
Amendment protections can be removed, through a law or constitutional
amendment stating that Islam is both a religion AND a tyrannical political
movement, and that as such Islam should not be considered a religion under
the First Amendment.”

Auster admits that this is a radical proposal, but argues that Islam is sui
generis and must not be treated as though it were a religion like all other
religions. He also makes the case that such legislation because it would be
Islam specific would avoid the slippery slope problem whereby increased
regulation of Islam would lead to increased regulation of Christianity and
Judaism:

Note that such a change in the First Amendment would have no effect on the
First Amendment, except insofar as Islam is concerned. So there’s no
slippery slope that can be invoked here. No other religions are threatened
by this, only Islam.

Auster concedes that, given the current political and social climate, the
passage of such a law is highly unlikely, but that it’s worth talking about
it if only in order to get people to realize that in Islam we are faced with
a unique threat that can’t be fully understood—let alone addressed—within
our existing legal and mental frameworks.

Whether or not it’s feasible or even advisable to go the route of a
constitutional amendment, it does seem that we need to radically revise our
thinking about Islam. With all the hype about change and adaptability, a
good many Americans are still clinging to obsolete notions about the nature
of Islam. The consensus thinking—that Islam is a religion of peace and
brotherhood just like other religions—is as out of date as bell bottoms.
It’s difficult to recall any time in our history when the nation’s
leadership was so obstinately wedded to such an outmoded and dangerous set
of ideas. So, yes, it’s time for a change. It’s time to change course, and
start asking how to stop the Islamization of America.

How do you solve a problem like Sharia in a First Amendment society? The
answers are far from clear. But here are some of the questions we should be
asking:

*       Can the religious part of Islam be separated from the political
program? Or are they inextricably bound together?

*       What was the framers intent? Did they mean to extend the free
exercise clause to religions that are “inherently violent and totalitarian”
as Steve Chapman suggests? The framers and founders wrote frequently about
the benefits of religion to society, but it seems fairly certain that the
beneficial religion they had in mind was Christianity.

*       Does our society owe something to the Judeo-Christian religious
tradition that it doesn’t owe to Islam? If the Judeo-Christian tradition has
made a lopsided contribution to our society isn’t it only fair to
acknowledge that? Is it wise to demand that all religious traditions be
treated in exactly the same way? Recent experience suggests that the easiest
way for governments to treat all religions equally is to equally suppress
all expressions of faith in the public square—all, that is, except the
worship of the state.

*       Is it desirable to maintain a strict neutrality between the religion
on which your civilization is founded and the religion which aims to
dismantle it?

Liberals like to say that the framers could not have foreseen the many ways
in which our society would develop—with the implication that if they could
have foreseen they would have written the constitution to conform to the
liberal agenda of the moment. Let’s take it as a given that the framers
didn’t foresee the destruction of the twin towers on 9/11/2001, nor did they
foresee that Muslims would soon after ask to build a mosque at Ground Zero.
Were the framers alive today would they insist that the First Amendment
guarantees the right to build that mosque on that site? Would they have
countenanced the erection of a statue of King George on the site of the
Boston Massacre? It seems safe to assume that in both instances the answer
would be “no.” The framers were men of principle, but they were also men of
common sense. They knew they lived in a society, not an abstraction. And
they realized that the preservation of their principles depended very much
on the preservation of a certain type of society, and also on the
preservation and encouragement of a certain religious heritage.

William Kilpatrick’s articles have appeared in FrontPage Magazine, First
Things, National Catholic Register, Catholic World Report, World, Jihad
Watch, and Investor’s Business Daily.

  _____  

Article printed from FrontPage Magazine: http://frontpagemag.com

URL to article:
http://frontpagemag.com/2010/07/30/sharia-in-a-first-amendment-society-2/

 



[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]



------------------------------------

--------------------------
Want to discuss this topic?  Head on over to our discussion list, 
[email protected].
--------------------------
Brooks Isoldi, editor
[email protected]

http://www.intellnet.org

  Post message: [email protected]
  Subscribe:    [email protected]
  Unsubscribe:  [email protected]


*** FAIR USE NOTICE. This message contains copyrighted material whose use has 
not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. OSINT, as a part of 
The Intelligence Network, is making it available without profit to OSINT 
YahooGroups members who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the 
included information in their efforts to advance the understanding of 
intelligence and law enforcement organizations, their activities, methods, 
techniques, human rights, civil liberties, social justice and other 
intelligence related issues, for non-profit research and educational purposes 
only. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of the copyrighted material 
as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use 
this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' 
you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.
For more information go to:
http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtmlYahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/

<*> Your email settings:
    Individual Email | Traditional

<*> To change settings online go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/join
    (Yahoo! ID required)

<*> To change settings via email:
    [email protected] 
    [email protected]

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
    [email protected]

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
    http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/

Reply via email to