http://tinyurl.com/2f6p8a8

 


Arizona, Borderlands and U.S.-Mexican Relations


August 3, 2010 | 0856 GMT 


 
<http://www.stratfor.com/print/168405?utm_source=GWeekly&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=100803&utm_content=readmore&elq=9665d59c64df47bca2e1b3ec02787aac>
 PRINTPRINT

Text Resize:

                        

 <javascript:void(0);> http://w.sharethis.com/chicklets/facebook.gif 
<javascript:void(0);> http://w.sharethis.com/chicklets/twitter.gif 
<javascript:void(0);> http://w.sharethis.com/chicklets/sharethis.gifShareThis

 <http://www.stratfor.com/weekly/friedman_on_geopolitics?fn=8716749536> 



 <http://www.stratfor.com/weekly/friedman_on_geopolitics?fn=8716749536> 
Geopolitics, Nationalism and Dual Citizenship

 

By George Friedman

Arizona’s new law on illegal immigration went into effect last week, albeit 
severely limited by a federal court ruling. The U.S. Supreme Court undoubtedly 
will settle the matter, which may also trigger federal regulations. However 
that turns out, the entire issue cannot simply be seen as an internal American 
legal matter. More broadly, it forms part of the relations between the United 
States and Mexico, two sovereign nation-states whose internal dynamics and 
interests are leading them into an era of increasing tension. Arizona and the 
entire immigration issue have to be viewed in this broader context.

Until the Mexican-American War, it was not clear whether the dominant power in 
North America would have its capital in Washington 
<http://www.stratfor.com/analysis/net_assessment_united_states?fn=4716840596>  
or Mexico 
<http://www.stratfor.com/analysis/20091112_geopolitics_mexico_mountain_fortress_besieged?fn=5816840576>
  City. Mexico was the older society with a substantially larger military. The 
United States, having been founded east of the Appalachian Mountains, had been 
a weak and vulnerable country. At its founding, it lacked strategic depth and 
adequate north-south transportation routes. The ability of one colony to 
support another in the event of war was limited. More important, the United 
States had the most vulnerable of economies: It was heavily dependent on 
maritime exports and lacked a navy able to protect its sea-lanes against more 
powerful European powers like England and Spain. The War of 1812 showed the 
deep weakness of the United States. By contrast, Mexico had greater strategic 
depth and less dependence on exports.


The Centrality of New Orleans


The American 
<http://www.stratfor.com/geopolitical_diary/20090701_geopolitical_diary_americas_indivisible_imperatives?fn=1016840543>
  solution to this strategic weakness was to expand the United States west of 
the Appalachians, first into the Northwest Territory ceded to the United States 
by the United Kingdom and then into the Louisiana Purchase, which Thomas 
Jefferson ordered bought from France. These two territories gave the United 
States both strategic depth and a new economic foundation. The regions could 
support agriculture that produced more than the farmers could consume. Using 
the Ohio-Missouri-Mississippi river system, products could be shipped south to 
New Orleans. New Orleans was the farthest point south to which flat-bottomed 
barges from the north could go, and the farthest inland that oceangoing ships 
could travel. New Orleans became the single most strategic point in North 
America. Whoever controlled it controlled the agricultural system developing 
between the Appalachians and the Rockies. During the War of 1812, the British 
tried to seize New Orleans, but forces led by Andrew Jackson defeated them in a 
battle fought after the war itself was completed.

Jackson understood the 
<http://www.stratfor.com/new_orleans_geopolitical_prize?fn=2516840535>  
importance of New Orleans to the United States. He also understood that the 
main threat to New Orleans came from Mexico. The U.S.-Mexican border then stood 
on the Sabine River, which divides today’s Texas from Louisiana. It was about 
200 miles from that border to New Orleans and, at its narrowest point, a little 
more than 100 miles from the Sabine to the Mississippi.

Mexico therefore represented a fundamental threat to the United States. In 
response, Jackson authorized a covert operation under Sam Houston to foment an 
uprising among American settlers in the Mexican department of Texas with the 
aim of pushing Mexico farther west. With its larger army, a Mexican thrust to 
the Mississippi was not impossible — nor something the Mexicans would 
necessarily avoid, as the rising United States threatened Mexican national 
security.

Mexico’s 
<http://www.stratfor.com/weekly/20100405_mexico_and_failed_state_revisited?fn=3116840515>
  strategic problem was the geography south of the Rio Grande (known in Mexico 
as the Rio Bravo). This territory consisted of desert and mountains. Settling 
this area with large populations was impossible. Moving through it was 
difficult. As a result, Texas was very lightly settled with Mexicans, prompting 
Mexico initially to encourage Americans to settle there. Once a rising was 
fomented among the Americans, it took time and enormous effort to send a 
Mexican army into Texas. When it arrived, it was weary from the journey and 
short of supplies. The insurgents were defeated at the Alamo and Goliad, but as 
the Mexicans pushed their line east toward the Mississippi, they were defeated 
at San Jacinto, near present-day Houston. 

The creation of an independent Texas served American interests, relieving the 
threat to New Orleans and weakening Mexico. The final blow was delivered under 
President James K. Polk during the Mexican-American War, which (after the 
Gadsden Purchase) resulted in the modern U.S.-Mexican border. That war severely 
weakened both the Mexican army and Mexico City, which spent roughly the rest of 
the century stabilizing Mexico’s original political order. 


A Temporary Resolution


The U.S. defeat of Mexico settled the issue of the relative power of Mexico and 
the United States but did not permanently resolve the region’s status; that 
remained a matter of national power and will. The United States had the same 
problem with much of the Southwest (aside from California) that Mexico had: It 
was a relatively unattractive place economically, given that so much of it was 
inhospitable. The region experienced chronic labor shortages, relatively minor 
at first but accelerating over time. The acquisition of relatively 
<http://www.stratfor.com/geopolitical_diary_immigration_debate?fn=5816840529>  
low-cost labor became one of the drivers of the region’s economy, and the 
nearest available labor pool was Mexico. An accelerating population movement 
out of Mexico and into the territory the United States seized from Mexico 
paralleled the region’s accelerating economic growth. 

The United States and Mexico both saw this as mutually beneficial. From the 
American point of view, there was a perpetual shortage of low-cost, low-end 
labor in the region. From the Mexican point of view, Mexico had a population 
surplus that the Mexican economy could not readily metabolize. The inclination 
of the United States to pull labor north was thus matched by the inclination of 
Mexico to push that labor north. 

The Mexican government built its social policy around the idea of exporting 
surplus labor — and as important, using remittances from immigrants to 
stabilize the Mexican economy. The U.S. government, however, wanted an outcome 
that was illegal under U.S. law. At times, the federal government made 
exceptions to the law. When it lacked the political ability to change the law, 
the United States put limits on the resources needed to enforce the law. The 
rest of the country didn’t notice this process while the former Mexican 
borderlands benefited from it economically. There were costs to the United 
States in this immigrant movement, in health care, education and other areas, 
but business interests saw these as minor costs while Washington saw them as 
costs to be borne by the states.

Three fault lines emerged in United States on the topic. One was between the 
business classes, which benefited directly from the flow of immigrants and 
could shift the cost of immigration to other social sectors, and those who did 
not enjoy those benefits. The second lay between the federal government, which 
saw the costs as trivial, and the states, which saw them as intensifying over 
time. And third, there were tensions between Mexican-American citizens and 
other American citizens over the question of illegal migrants. This inherently 
divisive, potentially explosive mix intensified as the process continued.


Borderlands and the Geopolitics of Immigration


Underlying this political process was a geopolitical one. Immigration in any 
country is destabilizing. Immigrants have destabilized the United States ever 
since the Scots-Irish changed American culture, taking political power and 
frightening prior settlers. The same immigrants were indispensible to economic 
growth. Social and cultural instability proved a low price to pay for the 
acquisition of new labor. 

That equation ultimately also works in the case of Mexican 
<http://www.stratfor.com/borderlands_and_immigrants?fn=4416840542>  migrants, 
but there is a fundamental difference. When the Irish or the Poles or the South 
Asians came to the United States, they were physically isolated from their 
homelands. The Irish might have wanted Roman Catholic schools, but in the end, 
they had no choice but to assimilate into the dominant culture. The retention 
of cultural hangovers did not retard basic cultural assimilation, given that 
they were far from home and surrounded by other, very different, groups. 

This is the case for Mexican-Americans in Chicago or Alaska, whether citizens, 
permanent residents or illegal immigrants. In such locales, they form a 
substantial but ultimately isolated group, surrounded by other, larger groups 
and generally integrated into the society and economy. Success requires that 
subsequent generations follow the path of prior immigrants and integrate. This 
is not the case, however, for Mexicans moving into the borderlands conquered by 
the United States just as it is not the case in other borderlands around the 
world. Immigrant populations in this region are not physically separated from 
their homeland, but rather can be seen as culturally extending their homeland 
northward — in this case not into alien territory, but into historically 
Mexican lands. 

This is no different from what takes place in borderlands 
<http://www.stratfor.com/analysis/20100526_slovakia_hungary_spat_over_citizenship?fn=2016840533>
  the world over. The political border moves because of war. Members of an 
alien population suddenly become citizens of a new country. Sometimes, massive 
waves of immigrants from the group that originally controlled the territory 
politically move there, undertaking new citizenship or refusing to do so. The 
cultural status of the borderland shifts between waves of ethnic cleansing and 
population movement. Politics and economics mix, sometimes peacefully and 
sometimes explosively.

The Mexican-American War established the political boundary between the two 
countries. Economic forces on both sides of the border have encouraged both 
legal and illegal immigration north into the borderland — the area occupied by 
the United States. The cultural character of the borderland is shifting as the 
economic and demographic process accelerates. The political border stays were 
it is while the cultural border moves northward. 

The underlying fear of those opposing this process is not economic (although it 
is frequently expressed that way), but much deeper: It is the fear that the 
massive population movement will ultimately reverse the military outcome of the 
1830s and 1840s, returning the region to Mexico culturally or even politically. 
Such borderland conflicts rage throughout the world. The fear is that it will 
rage here. 

The problem is that Mexicans are not seen in the traditional context of 
immigration to the United States. As I have said, some see them as extending 
their homeland into the United States, rather than as leaving their homeland 
and coming to the United States. Moreover, by treating illegal immigration as 
an acceptable mode of immigration, a sense of helplessness is created, a 
feeling that the prior order of society was being profoundly and illegally 
changed. And finally, when those who express these concerns are demonized, they 
become radicalized. The tension between Washington and Arizona — between those 
who benefit from the migration and those who don’t — and the tension between 
Mexican-Americans who are legal residents and citizens of the United States and 
support illegal immigration and non-Mexicans who oppose illegal immigration 
creates a potentially explosive situation. 

Centuries ago, Scots moved to Northern Ireland after the English conquered it. 
The 
<http://www.stratfor.com/analysis/20100129_northern_ireland_devolution_power_and_potential_violence?fn=6516840598>
  question of Northern Ireland, a borderland, was never quite settled. 
Similarly, Albanians moved to now-independent 
<http://www.stratfor.com/analysis/20100722_kosovo_consequences_icj_opinion?fn=4116840581>
  Kosovo, where tensions remain high. The world is filled with borderlands 
where political and cultural borders don’t coincide and where one group wants 
to change the political border that another group sees as sacred.

Migration to the United States is a normal process. Migration into the 
borderlands from Mexico is not. The land was seized from Mexico by force, 
territory now experiencing a massive national movement — legal and illegal — 
changing the cultural character of the region. It should come as no surprise 
that this is destabilizing the region, as instability naturally flows from such 
forces.

Jewish 
<http://www.stratfor.com/analysis/geopolitics_israel_biblical_and_modern?fn=5716840518>
  migration to modern-day Israel represents a worst-case scenario for 
borderlands. An absence of stable political agreements undergirding this 
movement characterized this process. One of the characteristics of the 
Israeli-Palestinian 
<http://www.stratfor.com/analysis/20090113_geopolitics_palestinians?fn=9816840531>
  conflict is mutual demonization. In the case of Arizona, demonization between 
the two sides also runs deep. The portrayal of supporters of Arizona’s new law 
as racist and the characterization of critics of that law as un-American is 
neither new nor promising. It is the way things would sound in a situation 
likely to get out of hand.

Ultimately, this is not about the Arizona question. It is about the 
relationship between Mexico and the United States on a range of issues, 
immigration merely being one of them. The problem as I see it is that the 
immigration issue is being treated as an internal debate among Americans when 
it is really about reaching an understanding with Mexico. Immigration has been 
treated as a subnational issue involving individuals. It is in fact a 
geopolitical issue between two nation-states. Over the past decades, Washington 
has tried to avoid turning immigration into an international matter, portraying 
it rather as an American law enforcement issue. In my view, it cannot be 
contained in that box any longer.

 

Reprinting or republication of this report on websites is authorized by 
prominently displaying the following sentence at the beginning or end of the 
report, including the hyperlink to STRATFOR:

"This report is republished with permission of STRATFOR 
<http://www.stratfor.com/> "



Read more:  
<http://www.stratfor.com/weekly/20100802_arizona_borderlands_and_us_mexican_relations?utm_source=GWeekly&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=100803&utm_content=readmore&elq=9665d59c64df47bca2e1b3ec02787aac#ixzz0vXe0MAYo>
 Arizona, Borderlands and U.S.-Mexican Relations | STRATFOR 

 



[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]



------------------------------------

--------------------------
Want to discuss this topic?  Head on over to our discussion list, 
[email protected].
--------------------------
Brooks Isoldi, editor
[email protected]

http://www.intellnet.org

  Post message: [email protected]
  Subscribe:    [email protected]
  Unsubscribe:  [email protected]


*** FAIR USE NOTICE. This message contains copyrighted material whose use has 
not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. OSINT, as a part of 
The Intelligence Network, is making it available without profit to OSINT 
YahooGroups members who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the 
included information in their efforts to advance the understanding of 
intelligence and law enforcement organizations, their activities, methods, 
techniques, human rights, civil liberties, social justice and other 
intelligence related issues, for non-profit research and educational purposes 
only. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of the copyrighted material 
as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use 
this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' 
you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.
For more information go to:
http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtmlYahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/

<*> Your email settings:
    Individual Email | Traditional

<*> To change settings online go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/join
    (Yahoo! ID required)

<*> To change settings via email:
    [email protected] 
    [email protected]

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
    [email protected]

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
    http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/

Reply via email to