http://www.jihadwatch.org/2010/08/fitzgerald-just-one-question-for-the-new-y
ork-times.html

 


Fitzgerald: Just one question for the New York Times


If only those who write for The New York Times, such as Laurie Goodstein,
could understand that they have a responsibility not to credulously accept
such efforts as this <http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3IofpsHOosE>
transparent propaganda video at face-value, but to find out about the
Muslims who actually appear on it, as is done here. Read what The New York
Times reported about this video, under the title "Muslims Make Video to
Rebut Militants
<http://www.nytimes.com/2010/08/01/us/01imams.html?_r=1&ref=us> ." That
title parrots exactly the Muslim line that this is a heartfelt attempt to
"rebut militants" rather than what it in truth is, a video in the main
directed not at Muslims but at non-Muslims. It is an effort to show
non-Muslims that "we, the Muslims in America, are doing the right thing,
taking the right stand, and you'd better take note of this and not question
the efficacy or the omissions in our video, you'd better be more than
satisfied, and stop suspecting us, or else."

If you read Laurie Goodstein's article, you would remain entirely in the
dark about those who took part in it. And since you would not have been
informed about the religiously-sanctioned doctrines of Taqiyya and Kitman,
and you might not be as suspicious as anyone who has either studied Islam
and the (mis)representation of Islam or lived as a non-Muslim citizen of a
Muslim-ruled country, you might not question that report.

But now that Robert Spencer has set out here
<http://www.jihadwatch.org/2010/08/new-york-times-touts-muslim-video-rebutti
ng-militants-and-featuring-rogues-gallery-of-islamic-suprem-print.html> ,
for easy reference, some of the unsavory connections and self-damning
remarks, and examples of blatant lying about the contents of the Qur'an, and
what Islam inculcates. He has set out, even so a reporter for The New York
Times can understand, what the Taqiyya Nine -- Suhaib Webb, and Maher
Hathout, and Ihsan Bagby, and Mohamad Magid, and Zaid Shakir, and Jamal
Badawi, and Hamza Yusuf (who is shown in a photograph, with three prayer
rugs, one already turned Mecca-wards, and a bookshelf full of row upon grim
row of Islamic books) and Yasir Qadhi -- are truly all about.

Now The New York Times has a choice.

It can do a follow-up story, in which the reporter takes the information
about these nine people, listed one by one above, with information about
them, and quotations by them, and that reporter then investigates, studies
the evidence that such remarks were made, that such connections can be made.

And then that reporter should report both what is given by Robert in the
article above, and what those nine figures say to him when asked to explain
those remarks.

Otherwise The New York Times will be guilty of having participated in a
transparent fraud, in what for those who are knowledgeable appears
unambiguously to be a fraudulent and, for the wellbeing of this country, and
its citizens, a dangerous effort.

I do not know, and I hate to think, of how the New York Times covered the
propagandists for Fascists and Nazis in the 1920s and 1930s. Why, no sooner
had Mussolini made his March on Rome, and the Ventennio just started, than a
certain Count Constantini was telling the society ladies of Boston about how
wonderful that splendid fellow and his wonderful Blackshirts were: "Tells
Mussolini's aims and progress; Count Constantini Speaks at the Chilton Club
Italy's leader Has Won Whole Nation's Confidence, He Says." (Boston Daily
Globe. Jan 16, 1923, p. 13)

And of course the Germans could count on such people as Ernst "Putzi"
Hanfstaengl, Harvard Class of 1909, and a member of the Hasty Pudding Club
(both biographical details are important, and would come in handy for
Hanfstaengl, and for Hitler, later on), and others, so well connected to
America's ruling circles at that time. Why, so many were classmates. They
arrived on these shores to spread misinformation about Herr Hitler and his
National Socialist program. And within this country, Fritz Kuhn's Bund was
also doing yeoman's service as it stood up for Hitler and wailed about the
injustices done to Germany which he, Herr Hitler, had protested. And wasn't
it right and proper that the "Sudeteners" (never "the Sudeten Germans")
should be given "self-determination" (the Wilsonian phrase that nowadays has
been distorted and misapplied to the case of the local Arabs, the shock
troops of the Jihad against Israel, who for obvious propaganda purposes --
when such propaganda became necessary after the Arab defeat in the Six-Day
War -- were carefully renamed as "the Palestinian people")?

Now The New York Times has reported, without a scintilla of skepticism,
about this effort to "refute" the "militants." And not a syllable of
Goodstein's sober prose is devoted to actually reporting on any of the views
expressed elsewhere by these nine people who made this video elsewhere -
views about America, about the political and legal institutions of the
Infidel nation-state of America, about Jews and the "myth" of the Holocaust,
or about what they see as the right role, and right goals, for Muslims now
living in this country. There is nothing about the company they keep, or
about their very own heartfelt expressions, made mostly to fellow Muslims,
and mostly earlier, before they realized that they had to go into full
taqiyya-and-kitman mode.

Will the New York Times publish a follow-up account, based on the
information even cats and dogs can now acquire, if they only have a
computer, and a little time?

Many Muslims, and their unthinking supporters, believe that they can
intimidate well-prepared critics of Islam, or of mosques being built hither
and yon, by shrill cries about "freedom of religion" when Islam is, in the
main, quite unlike any other religion. It is a Total Belief-System that in
large part makes political and geopolitical claims, the claims of Allah to
the whole world, that is, the claim or insistence that Islam must everywhere
dominate, and Muslims rule, everywhere.

And if "freedom of religion" is a red herring, so is this absurd cry about
"racism" that is flung about, as if Islam, an ideology, can be compared to a
"race," and Muslims forever be entitled to hide behind that cry of "racism"
even where it so obviously does not apply. There is a "racism," however,
that does apply - and that is the "racist" sense of superiority exhibited by
Muslim Arabs against non-Muslim Arabs. For Islam, despite its universalist
claims, is and has been a vehicle for Arab supremacism, in the ways I have
many times discussed here.

No one should be embarrassed, much less apologetic, for daring to consider
the evidence of his senses - that is, the Jihad news that mounts and mounts,
from all over the world, and especially that which demonstrates the cruel
treatment of non-Muslims by Muslims wherever Muslims rule, save in a handful
of cases where special circumstances have allowed for a taming or
constraining - possibly temporary - of Islam, as in Kazakhstan or Kemalist
Turkey. Nor should we be apologetic about becoming aware of the evidence
provided in books, rather than newspaper dispatches, by the historians of
Islamic conquest: that is, the 1350-year history of the conquest of
non-Muslim lands, and the subsequent subjugation of the autochthonous
non-Muslims. And we should be unapologetic about reading the scholars of
Islam, such as C. Snouck Hurgronje, Joseph Schacht, Arthur Jeffery, and
dozens of others, who wrote before Arab money and influence and other
factors aided the Muslim takeover of many academic departments in the West
having to do with Islam and related studies. And finally, we can read Ayaan
Hirsi Ali, Wafa Sultan, Ibn Warraq, Magdi Allam, Nonie Darwish, and a
growing list of other Defectors from the Army of Islam, whose articulate
works, whose morally and intellectually advanced temoignages, can be
compared with the deceit practiced by those listed as participating in the
Feelgood video that is given such credulous treatment by the New York Times
reporter, and by those who vetted, but did not change, the story about the
"Muslim video."

The West is now imperiled in a way unique in its history, mostly from an
ideological pressure brought from within, and not by military pressure from
without. Not everyone thinks we should simply throw up our hands and wail
"but what can we do?" and "there's nothing to be done." There are those who
are not, sometimes out of a mere want of imagination and intellect, able to
figure out the many things that they could legitimately and rationally do to
preserve (and perhaps even extend) the civilisational legacy they inherited.
But there are also those who wish to protect it from its present-day most
dangerous enemies, those who have not lost their senses, those who refuse to
make burnt offerings of themselves or their children on the Altars of the
Idols of the Age, Tolerance and Diversity - a misapprehended "Tolerance," a
diseased conception of "Diversity." The latter group must regard with alarm
and disgust the irresponsibility of The New York Times.

The irresponsibility of a great part of the media is beginning to alarm,
beginning to disgust. Nine years after the attacks on the World Trade Center
and the Pentagon, and several decades after the slow but steady growth,
seemingly unstoppable, of the Muslim presence in the historic heart of the
West, the countries of western Europe, and after these great and costly and
squandering military-cum-reconstruction efforts first in Iraq and now in
Afghanistan, how much do we in the United States need to rely on The New
York Times. Does anybody, anymore, still "rely" on the New York Times after
the display of its non-coverage of Islam? How often, in the New York Times,
have you seen any intelligent discussion or explanation of what the word
"Sunnah" means? Have you had any inkling of what the Hadith are, or what the
different collections of Hadith are, or how individual Hadith have been
ranked as to presumed "authenticity," or even how the different muhaddithin
are regarded, and why Bukhari and Muslim stand above all the rest? Have you
been informed properly by The New York Times as to what is in the Qur'an
concerning Unbelievers? Have you seen, in the pages of The New York Times,
even a single mention of the murders of Abu Afak and of Asma bint Marwan, or
about what happened at the Khaybar Oasis and why, or about what Muhammad did
when the 600-900 members of the Banu Qurayza, taken prisoner and bound, were
decapitated? Have you ever, even once, in the pages of The New York Times,
read anything about little Aisha, and why virtually the first act of that
learned theologian, the Ayatollah Khomeini, when he came to power, was to
reduce the marriageable age of girls to nine years?

Oh, I could fill up the page and printer, and so could you, with what The
New York Times has, in nearly a decade, chosen not to tell its readers,
willfully refused to enlighten them about -- that is, the ideology and the
practice of Islam. And this is curious, because the best way to convince the
public to support what the New York Times supports - a pullout from Iraq and
Afghanistan - is to make them more aware of what Islam inculcates, what
Islam contains, what Islam means.

It is wrong, it is unjust, it is cruel to its readers, it is dangerous, it
is a dereliction of journalistic duty, for those reporters and editors on
the New York Times, to sanction this deception by their inattention, their
nonchalance amounting to criminal negligence, their unwillingness to dig
just a little bit on such things as the real views behind the for-the-camera
smiles and wiles of those Nine Supernumeraries of Islam who took part in
this video charade, this tableau-vivant of taqiyya-suffused viciousness.
Those reporters and editors are doing what The New York Times, in its
embarrassing history, did in the past to aid and abet propagandists for
totalitarian ideologies - including one of its most famous reporters, Walter
Duranty, who won a Pulitzer for his efforts at hiding the reality of the
famine-ravaged Ukraine.

This time it is not Walter Duranty, doing his best for Joseph Stalin. Nor is
it some suave mustachioed well-tailored Count Constantini talking to
untouchable Brahmin wives at the Chilton Club on Beacon Street. And this
time it isn't Ernst Hanfstaengl telling his old classmates from the Harvard
Class of '09 - perhaps even some fellow members of the Hasty Pudding Club,
with whom good old Putzi may have high-kicked-it in drag for one of those
Hasty Pudding Theatricals -- about how Hitler was merely a useful tool of
Krupp and Thyssen, a tool to beat back the Bolsheviks, and in America they
had nothing to worry about, for the National Socialists just wanted to get
Germany back on its feet, to give it its self-respect. No, this time it is
another Total Belief-System, with many similarities to the totalitarian
ideologies of the previous unappetizing centuries, and another set of
adherents to an ideology that flatly contradicts, in letter and spirit, the
American Constitution and everything else that makes America America.
Adherents who want to make sure we do not find out much about the ideology
of Islam, or about those who work to undermine the legal and political
institutions of this country.

Let's all wait right here -- at this very website, Jihad Watch -- and see if
The New York Times will indeed, under the circumstances, feel it has an
obligation to run another story, a follow-up, where the information
presented above about the nine participants in this video - most of them
well-versed in the arts of taqiyya and kitman - is no longer omitted, but
becomes the very subject of the story.

Perhaps you'd like to make a wager on what The New York Times will do.

So go ahead. Faites vos jeux, mesdames et messieurs. And do it fast, because
any moment now the croupier at this website is going to announce that "les
jeux sont faits."

And les jeux sont faits, for many Americans, in another sense. Yes, for many
of us, when it comes to trying to get people to meet their responsibilities
and report adequately on the contents of Qur'an, Hadith, Sira, and to
analyze truthfully the content of Muslim propaganda and campaigns of Da'wa,
for us les jeux sont faits, which in English means -- the chips are down.

And when those chips are really down in every sense, who will be there to
defend the political and legal institutions of this country, its social
understandings, its art and science and literature, its political freedoms,
and the conditions that make those manmade laws, those political
institutions, that art, that science, that literature, those individual
freedoms, possible? Those conditions could not possibly exist for one minute
under Islam. Who will defend these things, if not those who, even if in some
cases hesitatingly, begrudgingly, not really wanting to find out what they
suspect they will find out, finally decide to learn about the texts, tenets,
attitudes, atmospherics of Islam? And then, too, they must learn also about
all the ways that Muslim propagandists in the West attempt to keep
non-Muslims unaware and thus unwary, confused and thus unable to see things
clearly.

Okay, New York Times. You have one last chance. You didn't do right when it
came to Walter Duranty and the misreporting on the Soviet Union. Your
coverage of the Nazi persecution of the Jews, throughout not only the 1930s,
but right through the war, was laughable, and cruel, and had consequences.
It resulted in many deaths, for there must have been many readers of The New
York Times who, unaware of what was really going on, did not do enough
either to save their own relatives, or to raise holy hell, wherever and
whenever they could, because they relied on The New York Times, and the
Sulzberger family was not about to let its paper be tarred as "too Jewish."
In other words, that family cared more about itself, and its own position,
then it did about reporting the truth. And right now, I suspect, those who
run The New York Times have no desire to let themselves be open to charges
of "racism" or "Islamophobia" or some other such obvious nonsense.
Apparently they lack the wit, they lack the imagination, they lack the
knowledge, to be able to respond appropriately to such charges.

Well, I've had my fill of analyzing or psychoanalyzing those who report for,
those who are columnists for, those who edit for, those who run, those who
own, The New York Times.

I repeat, one last time, the question I asked more than once above: having
published that story about this Muslim propaganda-vehicle video as a
splendid attempt to "rebut militants," will The Times now publish a
follow-up article, one that gives full weight to the information supplied by
Robert Spencer in his article above, about the nine Muslims who appear in
that video, or will it not?

 



[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]



------------------------------------

--------------------------
Want to discuss this topic?  Head on over to our discussion list, 
[email protected].
--------------------------
Brooks Isoldi, editor
[email protected]

http://www.intellnet.org

  Post message: [email protected]
  Subscribe:    [email protected]
  Unsubscribe:  [email protected]


*** FAIR USE NOTICE. This message contains copyrighted material whose use has 
not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. OSINT, as a part of 
The Intelligence Network, is making it available without profit to OSINT 
YahooGroups members who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the 
included information in their efforts to advance the understanding of 
intelligence and law enforcement organizations, their activities, methods, 
techniques, human rights, civil liberties, social justice and other 
intelligence related issues, for non-profit research and educational purposes 
only. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of the copyrighted material 
as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use 
this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' 
you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.
For more information go to:
http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtmlYahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/

<*> Your email settings:
    Individual Email | Traditional

<*> To change settings online go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/join
    (Yahoo! ID required)

<*> To change settings via email:
    [email protected] 
    [email protected]

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
    [email protected]

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
    http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/

Reply via email to