The Third Choice

Posted By Mark Tapson On September 20, 2010 @ 12:15 am In FrontPage | 2
<http://frontpagemag.com/2010/09/20/the-third-choice/print/#comments_control
s>  Comments

Before it was innocuously renamed Park 51, the Ground Zero mosque
development had been known as the Cordoba House, which proponents claimed
referred to a supposed golden age of multi-faith tolerance under Islamic
rule. What they neglect to mention is that historically, non-Muslims under
Muslim rule have been presented with three choices: conversion to Islam,
death, or the subservient status known as dhimmitude.

A new book sheds light on that little-understood condition and its
contemporary relevance. The
<http://www.amazon.com/Third-Choice-Islam-Dhimmitude-Freedom/dp/0980722306/r
ef=sr_1_1?s=books&ie=UTF8&qid=1284529310&sr=1-1>  Third Choice: Islam,
Dhimmitude and Freedom [1] by Dr. Mark Durie was released in February by
Deror Books and short-listed for Australian Christian Book of the Year. A
former linguistics scholar, Durie is now the Vicar of St. Mary's Anglican
Church, Caulfield in Melbourne, Australia. He writes and speaks extensively
in Australia and internationally about Islam, interfaith dialogue, religious
conflict, and the persecution of religious minorities, especially Christians
living under Sharia law.

I caught up with the author just prior to his recent arrival in Los Angeles
to promote the book.

MT: Dr. Durie, I'd like to begin talking about The Third Choice by asking
what inspired you, as an Anglican priest, to write a study of Islam and
dhimmitude?

MD: I first became interested in Islam when doing linguistic field work in
Aceh, Indonesia, in the early 1980's. The Acehnese people are proud of their
Islamic identity, but despite enjoying countless discussions about religion
with them, I made no attempt to study Islam formally; my whole focus was on
linguistic research. But I couldn't escape learning about jihad
<http://www.discoverthenetworks.org/guideDesc.asp?catid=124&type=issue>
[2], because it played such a large role in the historical consciousness of
the people. An amazingly large number of works of Acehnese literature are
jihad epics. Another aspect of my experience was contact with local
Christians; this is how I came to know of the difficult circumstances of
non-Muslims living in an Islamic society.

When I left academia to become an Anglican minister, around 1998, I thought
I was leaving Islamic jihad well behind me. I had no idea of the depth and
breadth of the global Islamic movement. Then as I watched the burning World
Trade Center towers collapse in the New York morning sunshine, I knew there
was no ideology on this earth other than Islamic jihad which could have
inspired such an attack. It was no surprise when verses from the Koran
reportedly found in the backpacks of the terrorists were exactly the same
verses which had figured so prominently in Acehnese jihad epic poems from
over a century ago.

At that point I knew I had to try to understand Islam properly. So I read
the hadiths, the Koran, and Ibn Ishaq's biography of Muhammad in the months
after 9/11, with the eye of a theologian - I was constantly asking how this
material would form people's spiritual identity.  This exploration made me
deeply troubled. The persona of Muhammad which arose before me from Islam's
primary sources shocked me to my core. I thought, "If this man's life is
supposed to be the best example, we are all in deep trouble."

I went to the Islamic Council offices in Melbourne and bought more books
about Islam. One was Maududi's Let Us be Muslims. This only increased my
concern. After chapters on all the essentials of Islam, such as the pillars
of faith, Maududi concludes the book with a call to jihad. Everything else
in Islam, he said, was but a preparation for toppling governments, taking
power, and establishing Islam in the world. I thought this was an ideal book
for turning a pious young Muslim into a jihad-ready militant.

At that time I began to write and teach on Islam, and I've been going ever
since. I wrote The Third Choice to help people understand Islam from the
ground up, and to know what it really means to depend upon the benevolence
of an Islamic state from the perspective of a dhimmi - a non-Muslim living
under Islamic rule.

MT: How is your book different from other works about the topic by scholars
like Andrew <http://frontpagemag.com../author/andrew-g-bostom/>  Bostom [3]
or Bat Ye'or, who actually wrote your foreword?

MD: Their books are great, and I could not have written The Third Choice
without them. But they are long and academic. Their focus is on specific
historical manifestations of Islam: jihad, dhimmitude and anti-Semitism
<http://www.discoverthenetworks.org/guideDesc.asp?catid=145&type=issue>
[4]. They also include large chunks of primary source material. This is
great for the researcher, but for many readers it is just too much to
digest. Also, their books don't attempt to explain Islam itself as a total
system.  One of my central goals is to make Islam itself clear and
plausible. This is very necessary. Also I approach the subject as a
theologian - I focus on ideology: how it shapes people's worldview, and how
we can find freedom from it. The Third Choice is a one-stop shop for
understanding Islam and the dhimmi condition.

MT: Where and in what ways do you see dhimmitude at work in the West?

MD: Gradually, and in countless ways, the West is accepting that Islam
deserves to be treated differently and preferentially. We are finding it
perfectly normal to make concessions to Islam which would never be made to
other faiths. The "third choice" of my title is the alternative to
conversion to Islam or the sword. This is the choice to give up fighting,
and surrender to Islam, and live as a non-Muslim under Islamic rule. But
there is a price to keeping your head without converting, and this is to
serve Islam and to embrace your own inferiority. 

The two most characteristic psychological traits of the dhimmi are gratitude
and humility. We are seeing both these traits shaping public discourse
around Islam. President Obama, for example, has spoken of the "debt" the
West owes to Islam. This sense of indebtedness is being imparted to our
schoolchildren through Islamicized history textbooks.

The dhimmi syndrome is analogous to that of the battered woman. An abused
woman will often vigorously deny that her husband is doing anything wrong,
even when her life is daily at risk from beatings. She will be schooled by
the violence to be grateful for any small kindness shown to her, and to
insist that he loves her. All the abuse is her own fault. The dhimmi
syndrome causes victims to go to extraordinary lengths to preserve their
worldview of denial.

I respect but deplore the psychological power of this dynamic. Respect,
because these are the strategies of survivors. Deplore, because such
soul-destroying strategies rob people of freedom and bind them into
self-deception. Indeed I was amazed to discover a Moroccan jurist who in his
commentary on Sura 9:29 of the Koran said that the purpose of the dhimmi
system is to "kill the soul" of the non-Muslim, so he will render willingly
everything demanded of him.

MT: What can be done to reverse the trend of surrendering to Islam's
demands? 

MD: The most important thing is to understand Islam, warts and all, without
camouflage, from the ground up, for ourselves. We must make sense of the
theology - or ideology, if you like. We must also insist on reciprocity in
all things. We need to recognize that handing over your worldview and
allowing it to be shaped by an abuser is a terrible loss of freedom, and no
good will come of it. We need to recapture our discourse, and demand that
the word jihad be used where it is appropriate. We need to stop talking in
circumlocutions which conceal and hide the truth. We need to stop protecting
Muslims from being forced to account for their own religion's teachings.

MT: The Ground Zero mosque controversy has amplified accusations against
non-Muslims of Islamophobia, fear and ignorance. Are they legitimate, and
can we put our trust in interfaith dialogue to resolve tensions?

MD: There is this idea floating around that those who are speaking up about
Islamic radicalism must be bigots and therefore they must be ignorant.
Ironically the loudest critics of Islam are usually the ones who have
studied the fundamentals of Islam the most rigorously. Those crying "bigot"
can be the most ignorant, and will come up with absolute howlers, real
nonsense, spoken with a poker face as it were the most serious thing in the
world. They decry accurate and reliable information about Islam as
"Islamophobic facts," just as the Soviet courts used to reject what they
called "calumnious facts."

When non-Muslims go into interfaith dialogue without a good understanding of
Islam, they are severely handicapped. The dialogue can easily be manipulated
to become an exercise in da'wa, or proclaiming Islam. A good example is the
label "Abrahamic faith." This is a Koranic term, and in Islam it stands for
the idea that Abraham was a Muslim. According to the Koran, the faith of
Abraham is Islam. Getting Jews and Christians to speak about "Abrahamic
religions" has been a great coup - it is a manifestation of the Islamization
of our religious discourse.

The problem of dialogue is especially acute if your Muslim counterpart
subscribes to the doctrine of taqiyya, which favors the use of misleading
impressions, or even direct lies. Everyone involved in interfaith dialogue
with Muslims needs to understand that under certain circumstances - for
example, if Muslims feel threatened - giving a misleading impression could
be regarded as a righteous act. Not all Muslims will go down this track, but
for some it is a real option, and there are plenty of clear examples of it
happening all around us. In The Third Choice I give a very clear explanation
of the doctrine of taqiyya, and explain how it arises in Islamic theology,
how it is being taught by Muslims, and how it is being applied today.

MT: A distinction is often made between Islam and Islamism. Do you feel that
it's a valid distinction, and is a reformed Islam possible?

MD: A thorough reading through the hadiths, sira and Koran led me to believe
that reform in the sense of "improvement" is incredibly difficult. In
medieval Christianity, reforming religion meant making it better by going
back to its roots, back to the gospels. The problem is, if you reform Islam
this way, you go back to Muhammad's message and example, and what you get is
Wahhabism and al Qaida
<http://www.discoverthenetworks.org/groupProfile.asp?grpid=6211>  [5].
Reform through reshaping Islam under the influence of external ideas,
derived from non-Islamic sources, is conceivable, but the trend of the past
100 years has been just about all in the other direction.

If you put a young God-fearing Muslim in a room with an Islamic radical and
an Islamic moderate, both trying to win over the young person's soul, the
radical would win again and again. It is because the canon - hadiths, sira
and Koran - are massively stacked in favor of the radical position. Yes,
there are violent passages in the Bible too, but it is an uphill battle to
build a violent theology based on them. With the Koran, building a violent
theology is like rolling balls down a hill. It is a huge uphill struggle
building a "moderate" Islamic theology on the basis of the Islamic canon
alone.

I think some commentators - whose work I respect and admire - speak of
"Islamism" because they don't want to dignify the radical cause by calling
it "Islam." Also, if they name the problem as "Islam," it would seem too
overwhelming. Nevertheless, I agree with Ayaan Hirsi Ali, Wafa Sultan and
other ex-Muslims that the problem of radical Islam is the problem of Islam
itself. The will to dominate is hard-wired into the core texts of Islam, and
this cannot be excised from the heart of these texts without a traumatic
assault on the fundamentals of Islam. So I don't like to speak about
"Islamism." To me it feels like a cop-out.

Often I meet people who want to be informed about Islam but will let their
minds grasp the problem only if the solution is clear. This is hopeless. You
must first live with the problem, even for a long time, before solutions
will come. But I am convinced we will  find solutions to the challenge of
Islam. That is why I wrote The Third Choice - out of conviction that facing
the truth will bring liberty.

  _____  

Article printed from FrontPage Magazine: http://frontpagemag.com

URL to article: http://frontpagemag.com/2010/09/20/the-third-choice/

URLs in this post: 

[1] The Third Choice: Islam, Dhimmitude and Freedom:
http://www.amazon.com/Third-Choice-Islam-Dhimmitude-Freedom/dp/0980722306/re
f=sr_1_1?s=books&ie=UTF8&qid=1284529310&sr=1-1

[2] jihad:
http://www.discoverthenetworks.org/guideDesc.asp?catid=124&type=issue

[3] Andrew Bostom: http://frontpagemag.com../author/andrew-g-bostom/

[4] anti-Semitism:
http://www.discoverthenetworks.org/guideDesc.asp?catid=145&type=issue

[5] al Qaida: http://www.discoverthenetworks.org/groupProfile.asp?grpid=6211

 



[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]



------------------------------------

--------------------------
Want to discuss this topic?  Head on over to our discussion list, 
[email protected].
--------------------------
Brooks Isoldi, editor
[email protected]

http://www.intellnet.org

  Post message: [email protected]
  Subscribe:    [email protected]
  Unsubscribe:  [email protected]


*** FAIR USE NOTICE. This message contains copyrighted material whose use has 
not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. OSINT, as a part of 
The Intelligence Network, is making it available without profit to OSINT 
YahooGroups members who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the 
included information in their efforts to advance the understanding of 
intelligence and law enforcement organizations, their activities, methods, 
techniques, human rights, civil liberties, social justice and other 
intelligence related issues, for non-profit research and educational purposes 
only. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of the copyrighted material 
as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use 
this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' 
you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.
For more information go to:
http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtmlYahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/

<*> Your email settings:
    Individual Email | Traditional

<*> To change settings online go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/join
    (Yahoo! ID required)

<*> To change settings via email:
    [email protected] 
    [email protected]

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
    [email protected]

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
    http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/

Reply via email to