http://tinyurl.com/29vf2gu

Contemporary Jihadism and Remembrance of Bulgaria's Islamic Past - Lessons
from Bistra Tsvetkova 

Wednesday, 13 October 2010 19:24 Andrew Bostom 

 
<http://www.rightsidenews.com/component/option,com_mailto/link,aHR0cDovL3d3d
y5yaWdodHNpZGVuZXdzLmNvbS8yMDEwMTAxMzExODc0L2VkaXRvcmlhbC93b3JsZC1vcGluaW9uL
WFuZC1lZGl0b3JpYWwvY29udGVtcG9yYXJ5LWppaGFkaXNtLWFuZC1yZW1lbWJyYW5jZS1vZi1id
WxnYXJpYXMtaXNsYW1pYy1wYXN0LWxlc3NvbnMtZnJvbS1iaXN0cmEtdHN2ZXRrb3ZhLmh0bWw=/
tmpl,component/> E-mail
<http://www.rightsidenews.com/2010101311874/editorial/world-opinion-and-edit
orial/contemporary-jihadism-and-remembrance-of-bulgarias-islamic-past-lesson
s-from-bistra-tsvetkova/print.html> Print

The first
<http://gatesofvienna.blogspot.com/2010/10/radical-muslims-aim-to-seize-powe
r-in.html>  of two
<http://gatesofvienna.blogspot.com/2010/10/turkish-juggernaut-overshadows-bu
lgaria.html#more>  recent reports by the invaluable Ned May at Gates of
Vienna highlights
<http://gatesofvienna.blogspot.com/2010/10/radical-muslims-aim-to-seize-powe
r-in.html>  the resurgent jihadism in the former Ottoman Muslim colony of
Bulgaria. Given the predictably self-loathing reaction of Bulgaria’s
prototypical Leftist
<http://gatesofvienna.blogspot.com/2010/10/turkish-juggernaut-overshadows-bu
lgaria.html#more>  media, it is well past overdue for such uninformed
ignorami to understand what the yoke of the Sharia inflicted upon their
noble ancestors, invoking Santayana, ad nauseum…

Murad-I_Ottoman_Congueror_of_Sofia_1385_ADBistra Tsvetkova [Cvetkova]
(1926-1982) was a Bulgarian-born scholar who studied in Sofia, Cairo, and
Paris, before obtaining her PhD from Leningrad University in 1972. Her
doctoral thesis analyzed the Ottoman conquest of the Balkans during the
early fifteenth century. Dr. Tesvetkova became a member of the Bulgarian
Academy of Sciences in 1952, and a professor at Sofia University, and
concurrently, director of the Commission on Ottoman-Turkish source
materials, in 1972. The Universite de Strasbourg conferred upon her an
honorary degree in 1981. Tsvetkova’s major work, Les Institutions Ottomanes
en Europe was published in 1978. Not long after a horrific traffic accident,
during which her husband was instantly killed, and she was seriously
injured, Dr. Tsvetkova committed suicide, August 16, 1982.

Here are the conclusions from her Russian essay, which translates,
“Religious and ethnic discrimination in Bulgaria during the period of
Turkish rule,”:

The Ottoman feudal aristocracy purposely encouraged the religious fanaticism
of the Muslims, and the hatred of the Muslims towards the non-Muslim reaya
[raya; “dhimmis”]. By these means the ruling class intended to distract the
Turkish peasantry from the ever-increasing social antagonism within the
state, and to prevent them from recognizing their true class enemies and
originators of their oppression and exploitation.

Ethnic and religious discrimination, inexorably linked with the burdensome
regime of feudal exploitation and political oppression, stalled the
development of the Bulgarian people for centuries. This discrimination,
which doomed the non-Muslim reaya to enduring insults and attacks on their
dignity as human beings, their life, and their personal and familial honor,
also limited religious freedom and threatened coercive Islamization, and
tightened the yoke of Turkish feudal oppression. Yet, over centuries, the
Bulgarian people stubbornly and courageously resisted this regime of
discrimination and oppression, and despite attempts at enforced
assimilation, managed to preserve its national identity and culture.

Tsvetkova’s analysis of the movement to liberate Bulgarians from
Ottoman-imposed dhimmitude, the  so-called haiduk movement [“The Bulgarian
Haiduk Movement in the 15th-18th Centuries" in East Central European Society
and War in the Pre-Revolutionary Eighteenth Century, edited by G.E.
Rothenberg, B.K. Kiraly, and P.F. Sugar, 1982.], included these
observations, from pp. 327-28:

…[T]he haiduk movement and the spontaneous outbursts of the rayah (dhimmi
Christians) were a manifestation of the subjugated Bulgarians’ national
self-awareness as well as their implacable opposition to the system their
oppressors had installed. Even in the scant information in official
documents, the distinctiveness the Bulgarians felt comes through in the
references to their clothing and appearance, both provocative to the Turks.
As one element of Ottoman religious and national discrimination, the
non-Muslim rayah was forbidden to wear bright or striking garments; flouting
this convention would be seen as rebelliousness. Thus the Turks testifying
against the haiduk, Voivode Chavdar of Sopotnica near Bitola, did not fail
to mention that he wore a red cloak and feathers in his cap.

The translation of Tsvetkova’s “Religious and ethnic discrimination in
Bulgaria during the period of Turkish rule,” is presented in full, below:

The consolidation of the Ottoman institutions and authorities in the
Bulgarian territories at the end of the fourteenth century established an
onerous regime of ethnic and religious discrimination towards the conquered
non-Muslim population. This discrimination was accompanied by
ever-increasing manifestations of feudal exploitation and political
oppression. For almost five centuries of the Turkish rule, this regime of
discrimination stalled and stifled development of the Bulgarian people,
depriving it of the opportunity to lead a normal human existence.

The religious intolerance advocated by Islamic scholars, and theories
proclaiming the superiority of the Muslims over the subjugated populace were
adopted and maintained by the Turkish feudal aristocracy. The latter used
the reactionary dogmas of the official Ottoman ideology to throttle class
conflict within the Turkish state, and to distract the Turkish peasants from
the existing acute social antagonisms. Furthermore, religious and ethnic
discrimination was the means by which the Turkish feudal authorities
controlled the population of conquered states.

Throughout the period of Turkish rule in Bulgaria the brutal regime of
discrimination manifested itself daily. This regime particularly intensified
the feudal exploitation of non-Muslim peoples and was reflected in the
differences in the taxation system for the defeated infidels. It must be
said that feudal oppression and exploitation was also suffered by the Muslim
peasants, who were also dependents of the Turkish state and landed nobility.
As opposed to their Turkish counterparts, however, the non-Muslim population
was subject to a multitude of taxes, which the Muslim peasants were not
obliged to pay. For example all non-Muslim men aged between 15 and 75 had to
pay, cizye <http://www.andrewbostom.org/blog/wp-admin/post-new.php#_edn1>
[i], a humiliating poll tax. These taxes underscored the difference between
the subjugated population and their masters and conquerors.

In the Ottoman Empire in general, and in Bulgaria in particular, certain
taxes were collected to a greater extent from the non-Muslim reaya
<http://www.andrewbostom.org/blog/wp-admin/post-new.php#_edn2> [ii], than
the Muslim one. A series of sources state that whilst the Muslim dependent
population had to pay 22 Akce
<http://www.andrewbostom.org/blog/wp-admin/post-new.php#_edn3> [iii] per
farm for resm-i cift, a land tax, the non-Muslim population, and
specifically the Bulgarian reaya, was forced to pay 25 Akce per household
for ispence <http://www.andrewbostom.org/blog/wp-admin/post-new.php#_edn4>
[iv], an identical tax under a different name. The very name ispence
suggests that the Turkish administration was, even in fiscal nomenclature,
trying to emphasise the smaller tax burden of the Muslim population in
comparison to the non-Muslim one. The tax discrimination towards the
non-Muslim, and specifically, the Bulgarian dependent population enabled the
Turkish landed nobility and central financial management institutions to
deprive the non-Muslim reaya not only of the surplus, but also of the
products of its labor necessary for subsistence.

Together with their extensive retinues, members of the Turkish feudal
aristocracy and its fiscal agents would eat out at the houses of Bulgarian
peasants or poor city dwellers, rob them, take their cattle, and consign
them to a life of utter poverty. Hundreds of Turkish documents and
observations made by foreigners attest to the fact that ethnic and religious
discrimination made the already heavy burden of feudal exploitation almost
impossible bear for the Bulgarian people. For example, the traveler H.
Dernschwam, noting the fertility of Bulgarian soil and the industry of the
Bulgarian people, points out that “If the Turks did not rip them off as they
do, they would be a rich people. Where they live alongside Turks, however,
the Bulgarians have nothing”[v]
<http://www.andrewbostom.org/blog/wp-admin/post-new.php#_edn5> . From a
record of a trial of the Sofia kadi from July 21 1550 we discover that
Bulgarian peasants from the village of Gubislav, in the okolia (district) of
Sofia, complained that their sipahi took their tithe in money and not in
kind, took a larger ispence than was lawful, made them work for him for five
days a year, and also to deliver him firewood on their own carts.[vi]
<http://www.andrewbostom.org/blog/wp-admin/post-new.php#_edn6> 

The tax discrimination in the Bulgarian lands that manifested itself in a
variety of forms of fiscal abuse throughout the fifteenth and sixteenth
centuries, became particularly severe from the end of the 1500s as a result
of a continued development of feudal relations. Thus, in his 1595 report for
the Transylvanian landowner Sigismund Bathory, P.Djordjic notes that “the
Christians are oppressed by their extreme poverty, caused by the heavy
taxation and the coercion of the Janissaries and the sipahi who take from
them, the most necessary of their personal possessions”[vii]
<http://www.andrewbostom.org/blog/wp-admin/post-new.php#_edn7> . In his
report to Rudolph II, the Austrian Emperor, P.Djordjic writes that the Turks
dispossess the Christians of Bulgaria of “wine, grain, and anything else
that comes their way… Where before they took 60 Akce from each person when I
was in Bulgaria three years ago, now they take four and five hundred Akce,
and I hear that they are now starting to take 800 and 1000 Akce”[viii]
<http://www.andrewbostom.org/blog/wp-admin/post-new.php#_edn8> . The cizye
tax, which was between 40 and 50 Akce prior to 1582, grew to 700-800 in the
first half of the 17th century[ix]
<http://www.andrewbostom.org/blog/wp-admin/post-new.php#_edn9> .
Furthermore, from 1691 this tax was not collected from a household, but from
each person individually[x]
<http://www.andrewbostom.org/blog/wp-admin/post-new.php#_edn10> . According
to Selaniki, the cizye-paying Bulgarians became subject to a slew of new
taxes: a tax on wine (bedel-I hamr), a surcharge on the new poll tax
(ziyade-I cizye-I cedid) and an additional tax for the ascension of the new
Sultan (ziyade-I culus-I humayun). Together, they added up to 300 Akce
<http://www.andrewbostom.org/blog/wp-admin/post-new.php#_edn11> [xi]. In a
1717 letter, Lady Montague writes that the Turkish Pashas, having traveled
the provinces with a sizeable retinue, and taken whatever they wanted to
satisfy their appetites, then “have the audacity to demand what they call a
“teeth tax” from the poor peasants”. This tax is a compensation for the
blunting of the teeth that may have resulted from consuming the peasants’
produce[xii] <http://www.andrewbostom.org/blog/wp-admin/post-new.php#_edn12>
. The German traveller Niebuhr, who passed through the Bulgarian lands in
1761 tells of the behaviour of the Aga who accompanied him. Niebuhr writes
“Throughout the journey, my Aga and his retinue stayed exclusively at the
houses of the Christians, even if the population of the village was
predominantly Muslim. The poor Christian peasants had to provide sheep and
chickens, in short, all of the foodstuffs, for free, or in return for a very
small payment, if they did not wish to be beaten”[xiii]
<http://www.andrewbostom.org/blog/wp-admin/post-new.php#_edn13> .

In was in the 19th century that the fiscal discrimination towards
non-Christians in Bulgaria, mostly ethnic Bulgarians, reached its peak.
Reports from this are not just exclusively available from Turkish
sources[xiv] <http://www.andrewbostom.org/blog/wp-admin/post-new.php#_edn14>
.  Alot of information on the subject is to be found in the reports of
European ambassadors and travelers and certain Bulgarian sources. We can
find such information in the report made by Alexander Eksarh for the grand
vizier Reshid Pasha. The report says that when the bylykbashi and beglikci
arrived at the villages, they demanded to be given the best houses with the
prettiest and the merriest women. Their horses were to be fed by the owners
twice a day, whilst they themselves would be given banitsa, wine, vodka, and
all kinds of food. Additionally, they demanded that the most beautiful woman
would serve them and “and wait on them, with her arms crossed, whilst they
sat at the table”[xv]
<http://www.andrewbostom.org/blog/wp-admin/post-new.php#_edn15> . In one
appeal to the Russian Emperor, dated September 1850 and signed by over a
thousand people, the facts of severe discrimination against the Bulgarian
people are vividly described. Amongst other tings, the document notes: “We,
the poor, pay the taxes and the harac [poll tax] even for the dead for three
years [after their death]. When the dead man is crossed out from the
official list, the khatib [scribe] takes a ram, and, despite all this, the
village is still obliged to pay. When a Christian dies, a kismet paraci
[burial tax] is taken, and depending on the wealth of the dead man- this can
be 50 Akce from a poor man, and 1000 Akce from a rich man- and besides, his
property is sequestrated. Until the kismet paraci is paid, the Christian is
not allowed to be buried. Even for one Turk we have to cook enough food to
feed five. Yet, if he cannot eat all the food, he feeds it to his hunting
dogs”[xvi] <http://www.andrewbostom.org/blog/wp-admin/post-new.php#_edn16> .
The noteworthy Bulgarian Nayden Gerov, who was then the Russian vice-consul,
describes in detail the abuses of the reaya by the kyrserdar, multezim and
the zaitiah. “When  inspecting a certain district, the bylykbashi, same as
the kyrserdar and their retinues and horses live on the free food provided
by the villagers… Occasionally, they take their friends with them when going
to the village, to party with them, to entertain them at the expense of the
locals.

The villagers take turns to accommodate these spongers, but they are not
always happy with the allocated homes, and they forcefully stay in the best
houses, making the hosts dine them as best they can. For this reason, the
locals avoid building good or comfortable houses.”[xvii]
<http://www.andrewbostom.org/blog/wp-admin/post-new.php#_edn17> 

The heavy tax burden and abuses extended to the Muslims, but they were less
cruel and humiliating than those meted out to the religiously and ethnically
discriminated-against populations of the non-Muslim quarters in towns and
villages.

Ethnic and religious discrimination, with its many humiliating limitations,
cast a terrible shadow over the everyday existence of the Bulgarian people.
The powerless subject was supposed to convey his inferior status with every
gesture, and even his appearance. The disdain and religious intolerance
shown towards him by the Ottoman subjugators was underlined by the insulting
nickname “kafir” (infidel). Karl Marx described very vividly the affront to
the dignity of the non-Muslim population, resulting from the religious
discrimination. Only a Muslim “has the right to carry weapons, and the most
high-placed Christian has to make way for the lowest-placed Muslim”[xviii]
<http://www.andrewbostom.org/blog/wp-admin/post-new.php#_edn18> . According
to the shariah law, followed by the Ottoman feudal aristocracy, the
non-Muslims were not allowed to wear colourful or luxuriant clothes, and
generally to dress like Muslims. These instructions were followed in the
Bulgarian lands.

The following is contained in the order from the Sultan to the Istanbul kadi
dated March 25, 1631: “In accordance with the demands of religion, the
shariah and the law state that the kafirs must be humiliated and insulted
through their clothing and conduct; they should not be allowed to ride on
horseback, wear sable coats or hats, wear European-style or satin clothing,
and their wives should not walk around exhibiting the manners and habits of
the Muslim [women]”[xix]
<http://www.andrewbostom.org/blog/wp-admin/post-new.php#_edn19>  A similar
order was sent to the Istanbul kadi in 1757. It also emphasizes that
Christians and Jews should behave and dress in a way that conveys their
lower social status.[xx]
<http://www.andrewbostom.org/blog/wp-admin/post-new.php#_edn20>  Much later
in 1836-8 the French traveller A. Boue noted that in Turkey “there are still
laws that restrict the luxuriousness of clothes…” He continues “The reaya
<http://www.andrewbostom.org/blog/wp-admin/post-new.php#_edn21> [xxi] makes
way when he runs into a Turk, and even dismounts until the Turk passes him…
The reaya does not greet the Turk first… The Turk takes the greeting as an
insult, since he knows that the Christian hates him, and only greets him
when he is forced to”[xxii]
<http://www.andrewbostom.org/blog/wp-admin/post-new.php#_edn22> . The
Englishman W. Eton wrote in 1798: “The insulting segregation between Muslims
and Jews is such that even the smallest details of clothing have become
subject to restrictions. A Christian may wear only dark clothing and
headwear, shoes made of black leather, and he must paint his house umber or
black”[xxiii]
<http://www.andrewbostom.org/blog/wp-admin/post-new.php#_edn23> .

The discrimination created the conditions for attempts on the lives of
non-Muslims, and also their personal and family honor. Hundreds of documents
from the era of Turkish rule reveal a series of harrowing facts of abuse and
victimisation of the Bulgarian people, perpetrated by the Turkish on the
basis of religious and ethnic discrimination. It is reported that in 1589
the Muslim population of Bitoli complained that the non-Muslims that lived
next to the Mahmoud Celebi Mosque distracted them from their prayers with
“their indecent behaviour”. On the basis of this unsubstantiated allegation
the Turkish authorities ruled that all the Bulgarian dwellings around the
Mosque were to be sold to Muslims, thus removing the “kafirs” from the
vicinity of the mosque[xxiv]
<http://www.andrewbostom.org/blog/wp-admin/post-new.php#_edn24> . Legally,
it was during the Tanzimat, as far back as 1839 that all the citizens of the
Empire were officially guaranteed inviolability of person, property and
dignity, regardless of religious inclination by the Hatti-i Sharif of
Gulhane. In actual fact, the discrimination towards the non-Muslim reaya and
the threat to the non-Muslims’ lives, property and dignity were not removed.
Describing instances of severe discrimination Boue adds “Despite the Hatti-I
Sharif, the Turks continue to oppress the reaya everywhere”.

The complaint of the Bulgarians from the Pleven okolia received by Alexandr
Eksarh, many affronts to the dignity and attempts on the lives of Bulgarians
are detailed. It reads “[The Turks] assaulted and robbed a man from the
village of Petarnitsa… They slaughtered and robbed a family from the city of
Lukovit. Whist travelling around the villages and staying at Bulgarian
houses, the Turks demand chickens, banitsa, baklava, halvah, and girls and
young women to serve them vodka and wine… A  man was stabbed to death in the
village of Deventsi… A man from the city of Teteven was slaughtered and
robbed outside the village of Cherven Breg… Six millers were massacred at
their mills”[xxv]
<http://www.andrewbostom.org/blog/wp-admin/post-new.php#_edn25> . The polish
émigré Michal Czaikowsky (Sadyk Pasha) who converted to Islam, tells of the
misdemeanours of Ibrahim Pasha from the city of Silistra “Ibrahim Pasha, and
his retinue, particularly when he was drunk, entertained themselves by
riding Bulgarians through the streets of Silistra, whipping and spurring
them. He enjoyed this barbaric form of entertainment that he staged it for
all the officials, agas and dervishes that came to pass through
Selistra…”[xxvi]
<http://www.andrewbostom.org/blog/wp-admin/post-new.php#_edn26> 

The Ottoman rulers would not even leave the dead alone. Thus, for example,
one of the documents from 1695 states that the kadis of Vidin did not allow
the Bulgarian population of the city and the okolii under their jurisdiction
to bury their dead until a due was paid. Consequently, the dead often
remained unburied for three or four days.[xxvii]
<http://www.andrewbostom.org/blog/wp-admin/post-new.php#_edn27> 

Heavy restrictions on religious freedoms meant that the Bulgarians were
forbidden from building churches and openly performing religious rituals.
Brought up as fundamentalists, the representatives often acted
disrespectfully towards the Christian churches, often converting them into
Mosques. (for example, the Sofia  churches of St. George and St.
Sofia)[xxviii]
<http://www.andrewbostom.org/blog/wp-admin/post-new.php#_edn28> . The
Turkish authorities officially forbade the construction of large and
beautiful churches, particularly next to mosques. The Christian prayer
houses were not meant to stand out in any way, and were very often built
underground. A range of Turkish documents from various periods of Ottoman
rule show that the Turkish officials ordered the demolition of Christian
churches without hesitation. Thus, one such order from September 30, 1613
the kadis of the Ohrid sanjak are firmly instructed to demolish all churches
built without permission, with the exception of those that were damaged
during the Turkish invasion and later rebuilt in the same way.[xxix]
<http://www.andrewbostom.org/blog/wp-admin/post-new.php#_edn29>  On August
13, 1624 the Plovdiv kadi was ordered to demolish a new church in Stanimake,
of the Asenovgrad okolia as being large and fortified, it could become a
shelter for insurgents[xxx]
<http://www.andrewbostom.org/blog/wp-admin/post-new.php#_edn30> . In a
firman from December 20-29, 1693 the kadi of Balchik and Silistra was
instructed to destroy the rebuilt church in the Kavarna village of the
Balchik District. The church was built in place of another one, which was
also destroyed because it was next to a Turkish mosque.[xxxi]
<http://www.andrewbostom.org/blog/wp-admin/post-new.php#_edn31>  W.Eton also
stresses that “Christians can neither build new churches, nor can they
renovate old ones without [paying] large sums of money”[xxxii]
<http://www.andrewbostom.org/blog/wp-admin/post-new.php#_edn32> . The
victimisation of Christian monks and churchmen was also commonplace in
Bulgaria. So, we discover from a firman to the bey of Kyustendil and the
kadi of Dupnitsa we discover that as far back as 1493, the monks at the
monastery of Rila complained about the behaviour of certain local sipahi and
other officials, who, when visiting the monastery, would demand free food
and wine. “Apart from this, the unwelcome guests ran riot, and committed
various abuses and misdemeanours towards the monks”[xxxiii]
<http://www.andrewbostom.org/blog/wp-admin/post-new.php#_edn33>  A different
firman from the Sultan, dated 1595, to the kadis of Samokov and Dupnitsa we
discover of the murder of two monks from the Azarnovch Monastery[xxxiv]
<http://www.andrewbostom.org/blog/wp-admin/post-new.php#_edn34> . The
communications of Catholic churchmen in Bulgaria also contain a litany of
testaments of abuse by the representatives of the Turkish authorities.[xxxv]
<http://www.andrewbostom.org/blog/wp-admin/post-new.php#_edn35> 

The Bulgarians could not hope for a fair punishment for the criminals, and
could not rely on the intercessions of the Turkish administration. Without a
doubt the Turkish dependents also suffered from the shariah courts, which
safeguarded the mastery and privileges of the Ottoman landed elite. Yet this
court was particularly biased towards the non-Muslims, and often ruled in
favor of Muslims on the basis of no evidence whatsoever. Telling evidence of
this is contained in the copy of a notification of the Vidin kadi (1700).
According to this notification, Omer, a Turk from Vidin, appropriated the
vineyard of a certain Ivan, son of Nikola from the same city. Despite the
evidence provided by Ivan’s witnesses, and despite the fact that Omer had no
way of proving his rights to the ownership of the appropriated vineyard, the
court ruled in favour of the Muslim[xxxvi]
<http://www.andrewbostom.org/blog/wp-admin/post-new.php#_edn36> . The
defencelessness of the non-Muslim reaya before the Turkish courts was picked
up by M.Febure “[The Turks] allow themselves to beat and insult Christians,
who cannot retaliate in the same fashion. If they lose their temper, they
will be severely punished by the courts, as if they have made some sort of
attempt on a life, and as a result they have no choice but to abscond. They
retain a right to appeal to the judge, but in order to have their grievance
settled, and to have the perpetrator punished, they must have a witness, who
is a Turk, the same as the culprit; as Jews and Christians were considered
“infidels”, neither had the right to testify against a Muslim…”[xxxvii]
<http://www.andrewbostom.org/blog/wp-admin/post-new.php#_edn37>  “The Turks
only recognizes the law when dealing with another Turk” reads the Bulgarian
appeal to the Russian Emperor from 1853. “In the Tatar-Pazardzhik district
of the Filipopol diocese alone, 106 Bulgarians were killed in 1852, and not
a single Turk was caught, and yet the murderer of the only Turk killed in
the same period was caught”[xxxviii]
<http://www.andrewbostom.org/blog/wp-admin/post-new.php#_edn38> . In his
1861 report to the Russian ambassador in Istanbul, Nayden Gerov lists a
number of facts demonstrating discrimination towards non-Muslims in the area
of shipbuilding. Summing up the facts Gerov wrote “The old Turkish taxes are
so elastic that, in the words of Turks themselves, they are like wet skin
that will stretch in any direction you try to stretch it… [The Christians’]
testimonies are not accepted in court, as they are non-Muslims”

On the contrary, when faced against the testimonies of two Turks any written
document loses its legal power.Furthermore, any document not supported by a
Turk’s signature does not have any legal power”[xxxix]
<http://www.andrewbostom.org/blog/wp-admin/post-new.php#_edn39> .

This intensive discrimination can also be seen in the many acts of enforced
assimilation, a “Turkification” of the Bulgarian people through the times of
the Turkish occupation. One of the ways of forced assimilation was the
so-called devsirme. Every three, five or seven years, all the healthiest
Christian children were selected and taken to the capital of the Empire,
where they were converted to Islam and given military training. The
janissary corps was formed from these boys. The janissaries were brought up
in the spirit of intransigent intolerance, derision and hatred towards the
non-Muslim peoples[xl]
<http://www.andrewbostom.org/blog/wp-admin/post-new.php#_edn40> .

In one communication to the Eastern congregation, the Catholic Archbishop
Martin Bici describes the forced removal of Christian children to become
janissaries “Last year [1610], a janissary commander, sent by the Sultan,
arrived to collect the children of the Christian peoples. It is a
long-standing tradition [to take these children] to serve him and his sarai.
As a result [the bishop Petur Solinat] went through a great deal of
suffering. The said Bishop of Sofia and the poor Christian people hid their
children in caves, mountains and forests, to keep them in the holy faith,
and to prevent them from falling into the hands of the infidels, and even so
not without further augmenting their poverty.”[xli]
<http://www.andrewbostom.org/blog/wp-admin/post-new.php#_edn41>  In a letter
to the congregation from October 20 1646 the Catholic bishop Fransisc
Soimirovich writes of the same thing “…the Sultan sent out the order to
collect the children. One of the noblemen from his court arrived with two
hundred janissaries that later arrived here, took some Christian boys, and a
large sum of money. They put several Christians in chains demanding that
more children be found. When we saw these horrors, we took our young to the
mountains, where we stayed for a week…”[xlii]
<http://www.andrewbostom.org/blog/wp-admin/post-new.php#_edn42>  In very
rare cases the practice of devsirme was continued into the 18th century. In
this way Ahmed III ordered a thousand Christian children to be recruited
through devsirme in 1703[xliii]
<http://www.andrewbostom.org/blog/wp-admin/post-new.php#_edn43> .

The previously quoted works of Alexander Eksarh it is described how
Bulgarian women were forcibly converted into Islam. When a low-ranking
Turkish official wanted a beautiful Bulgarian woman for a wife, he would
“gather his friends, who would surround the girl’s house, abduct her, take
her to Albania, where she is forced to take up Islam, and finally the
abductor gets to take the woman as a wife”[xliv]
<http://www.andrewbostom.org/blog/wp-admin/post-new.php#_edn44> . One
complaint for the Bulgarians from the Pleven district from the middle of the
19th century, writes that the local Turkish tyrants forcibly take women
away, and make them their wives[xlv]
<http://www.andrewbostom.org/blog/wp-admin/post-new.php#_edn45> . In a
witness testimony from 1876 of one Turk from the village of Chaushkoy
(Tsenovo, Belene okolia) before the Turkish court one such forcible
conversion into Islam is described: two Turks abducted a Bulgarian girl from
Iblanovo (?) to make her convert and marry one of them. According to the
testimony “she was resisting and did not want to become a Muslim”.[xlvi]
<http://www.andrewbostom.org/blog/wp-admin/post-new.php#_edn46> 

The national Bulgarian epos is rich with moving songs praising the
resistance of courageous Bulgarian men and women to being converted to Islam
and isolated from their people. One such example is the song about brave
Balkanji Yovo. Despite the terrible abuses he was subjected to by the
Turkish officials, so that he would agree to the Turkification of his
sister, he fearlessly tells his tormentor “Hey voivoda, I will give my head,
but I will not surrender Yana to Islam” A different song from Macedonia
tells of a girl by the name of Kana, who was thrown into prison for her
refusal to convert to Islam. Distraught about the fate of her daughter, the
girl’s mother comes to the prison and tries to persuade her daughter to
yield to her captors, and to enter Islam to avoid death. Kana responds
angrily to this:

Be silent, mother, fall dumb

Where you stand, be struck blind

How can I sell my faith,

What do I first need to forget?

When her abductors heard these words they subjected her to even greater
tortures. Yet, in the words of the folk singer, the wonderful, resilient
Kana gave away her life, but not her faith.[xlvii]
<http://www.andrewbostom.org/blog/wp-admin/post-new.php#_edn47> 

The Turkish authorities in Bulgarian lands were not averse to attempting
mass Turkification of the citizens of entire villages and districts. One of
the earliest of these attempts goes back to the times of Selim I
(1512-1520). From the anonymous “Tale of the Second Destruction of Bulgaria”
we discover that Bulgaria was ruined by Selim I, and the population in the
areas around Chepino, Dospat, Kochan and Krupnik was Turkified.[xlviii]
<http://www.andrewbostom.org/blog/wp-admin/post-new.php#_edn48> 

Relating to the same period (about 1515-1520) are some interesting facts
contained in one fragment from the tax roll for the villages in the Nevrokop
okolia. This fragment of the tax roll contains a tax inventory of the
villages in this okolia that includes the names of the Muslims and the
non-Muslims, exact information about the number of households, the number of
the unmarried and the widowed, and about the size and types of taxes
collected from them. In one such segment from the village of Baba Vylkan, or
Tilani, that was a part of the Nevrokop okolia, the page 5-b contains a
separate list of the Muslim citizens of this village. Amongst them are a few
names that give cause to a certain well-known kind of speculation. Here are
the names: Bekhadir, son of Georgo; Elias, son of Todor; Yusuf, son of
Georgo; Elias, son of Momchila. In page 7-a listing the Muslims from the
village of Bezretche, which was a part of the Pomest, we read the following
names: Mehmed, son of Istancho (Stancho); Kurd, son of Vylko; Shir Mourad,
son of Rajko; Karagyoz, son of Radi; Hasan, son of Torni. Amongst the
Muslims of the village of Petrovo, in the Nevrokop okolia, we can find on
page 1-b we can find a certain Karagyoz, son of Istano (Stano) in Paparayko,
or Lykavich, we find a Ferrah, son of Istani (Stani); page 5-a from the
village of Isferitina, in the Pomest, there is marked down an Ali, son of
Milko (page 8-a), whilst in Bolotniche, in the Nevrokop, there is a Yusuf,
son of Georgo (page 10-a). These interesting facts give us reason to think
that the above only recently entered Islam. We can infer this from the
Bulgarian names of their fathers, accurately noted down by the registrar.
Considering that these fragments contain not one or two people, but a
substantial proportion of the population of these cities, it is feasible
that these Christians converted to Islam as a result of organised pressure
from the Turkish authorities, which led to the mass Turkification.
Considering that the tax rolls are from between 1515 and 1520, it is
reasonable to link these to the mass Turkification that took place in
Macedonia under Selim I.

Testaments of mass Turkification in the Bulgarian lands become particularly
frequent from the second half of the 17th century. The changes in the
Turkish feudal system, the decline of the Ottoman Empire and the
intensification of feudal exploitation and political oppression resulted in
an upturn in the degree of religious discrimination towards the Bulgarians,
and to more frequent attempts at mass forced assimilation. The Turkification
of the Bulgarians in the Chepintsi Bay, so vividly described by the
clergyman Metodi Draginov from the village of Korova, is also from this era,
or specifically 1657. Draginov writes that the Turkification was accompanied
by atrocious crimes “Some of those who did not convert to Islam were
slaughtered, whilst others escaped to the woods and had their houses burnt
down”[xlix] <http://www.andrewbostom.org/blog/wp-admin/post-new.php#_edn49>
>From one communication of the Karnobat Naib, dated April 20, 1690, we
discover about the Turkification of 30 people from the village of Bin Geran
in the Karnobat okolia. This communication tells us that the dwellers of
this village told the court that their village, which was the vakf of Rakas
Sinan, had a cizye imposed of over 262 hane (literally “houses”, but here a
unit of tax). This was a result of thirty of the villages entering Islam,
and being spared from paying the cizye, whilst the tax burden was
distributed between the remaining Christian villagers. The villagers say
that they cannot pay the cizye on behalf of the converts and ask that it be
reduced.[l] <http://www.andrewbostom.org/blog/wp-admin/post-new.php#_edn50>
In all probability we are also talking about a case of enforced
Turkification, as a result of which, a group of thirty peasants was
converted into Islam. The record of trial of the Vodina kadi from October
25- November tells of similar instances of Turkification of the Bulgarian
population of the city of Vodina. In this document, the Vodina reaya
complains that every Easter, the Muslims run riot on the streets of the
city, catch Christians, abuse them, destroy their dwellings and force them
to convert to Islam.[li]
<http://www.andrewbostom.org/blog/wp-admin/post-new.php#_edn51> 

The Ottoman feudal aristocracy purposely encouraged the religious fanaticism
of the Muslims, and the hatred of the Muslims towards the non-Muslim reaya.
By these means the ruling class intended to distract the Turkish peasantry
from the ever-increasing social antagonism within the state, and to prevent
them from recognising their true class enemies and originators of their
oppression and exploitation.

Ethnic and religious discrimination, inexorably linked with the burdensome
regime of feudal exploitation and political oppression, stalled the
development of the Bulgarian people for centuries. This discrimination,
which doomed the non-Muslim reaya to enduring insults and attacks on their
dignity as human beings, their life, and their personal and familial honor,
also limited religious freedom and threatened coercive Islamization, and
tightened the yoke of Turkish feudal oppression. Yet, over centuries, the
Bulgarian people stubbornly and courageously resisted this regime of
discrimination and oppression, and despite attempts at enforced
assimilation, managed to preserve its national identity and culture.

 



[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]



------------------------------------

--------------------------
Want to discuss this topic?  Head on over to our discussion list, 
[email protected].
--------------------------
Brooks Isoldi, editor
[email protected]

http://www.intellnet.org

  Post message: [email protected]
  Subscribe:    [email protected]
  Unsubscribe:  [email protected]


*** FAIR USE NOTICE. This message contains copyrighted material whose use has 
not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. OSINT, as a part of 
The Intelligence Network, is making it available without profit to OSINT 
YahooGroups members who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the 
included information in their efforts to advance the understanding of 
intelligence and law enforcement organizations, their activities, methods, 
techniques, human rights, civil liberties, social justice and other 
intelligence related issues, for non-profit research and educational purposes 
only. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of the copyrighted material 
as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use 
this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' 
you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.
For more information go to:
http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtmlYahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/

<*> Your email settings:
    Individual Email | Traditional

<*> To change settings online go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/join
    (Yahoo! ID required)

<*> To change settings via email:
    [email protected] 
    [email protected]

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
    [email protected]

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
    http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/

Reply via email to