The Mackenzie Newsletter

PO Box 338, Adelaide Station   Toronto, Ontario   M5C-2J4    Tel:
(416)-686-4063

E-Mail:  [email protected]  Web:  Mackenzieinstitute.com

2010
#79




Table of Contents

On Shooting the Wounded
On Activism and Bullying
4

Notes From 20 Years Ago
8

Alexander Mackenzie’s Library
9

Voices of Freedom
10

 

 

On Shooting the Wounded

In October 2008, Captain Robert Semrau of the Royal Canadian Regiment was
commanding a ‘mentoring team’ of four Canadian soldiers operating with a
company of Afghan National Army troops engaged in fighting Taliban
insurgents in Helmand Province. Taliban insurgents opened fire on this force
and were engaged by a supporting US Apache gunship.  The Taliban promptly
withdrew, leaving one of their gunmen dead and one severely wounded.

The Afghan Army troops did not treat the wounded Talib who had one leg
shredded off, a foot severed and may have also been wounded in the torso.
Instead they apparently kicked and insulted him and then moved on.  This put
the Canadians in a dilemma. 

Following the textbook on modern ethical warfare, one would immediately halt
the Afghan troops, treat the badly wounded prisoner (apparently dying in
great pain), call for a medical evacuation and only then continue with the
mission.  Textbook solutions are one thing; reality on the ground is
something else. The Afghan Army troops obviously showed no interest in the
well-being of the badly wounded Talib.  The Taliban themselves have shown
little respect for any laws of war.  The Afghan National Army is a poor army
with few resources and may not have had a means of evacuating a wounded
prisoner in time to save him: The sweep for the enemy had to continue and
such things must be done promptly before the foe escapes to fight again. 

Moreover, for the Afghan soldiers, the fate of the wounded Taliban was in
the hands of Allah… ‘Inshallah’ (literally: ‘As God wills’).  If he lived or
died was in God’s hands and the Afghan troops moved on untroubled by the
prisoner’s wounds or future.

Captain Semrau had to balance resources, time, the rules and the mission
and, as a foreign expert attached to the Afghan Army, his credibility with
these rough men fighting a vicious enemy.  Evidently, this badly wounded
Talib would not even survive long enough to reach effective treatment.  So
which was the right action:  To prolong the Talib’s pain to no purpose and
lose the enemy’s trail or to end his suffering and continue the pursuit?

>From what we know so far, Captain Semrau decided to fire two bullets into
the wounded Talib and end his suffering.  

This irritated the Afghan government troops. Who was this non-Muslim
foreigner to decide the fate of the wounded prisoner in lieu of God?  But
the complexities of Afghanistan casualty management are not the issue for
Captain Semrau or or the Court Martial that confronts him.  Here the one
real question is did he or did he not commit either manslaughter or second
degree murder?

Strangely, while the central act of war is homicide and there is no end to
histories, commentaries and studies of almost every facet of war, the
shelves of material are slender when it comes to issues like this. It is
something veterans seldom talk about.

That war is homicide is a point needing no debate.  War revolves around
killing people, but in a manner that most of us sanction in one way or
another.  

We have laws, rules, customs and unwritten practices to outline what forms
of homicide are acceptable during warfare yet there is a substantial gray
area between some of the absolutes.  It is acceptable for a soldier to kill
an enemy who is shooting at him.  It is unacceptable to execute unarmed
prisoners in a safe area in the rear of battle. The gray areas lie between
shading from light to dark according to circumstances and situations.  The
customs and unwritten practices of combatants remain an ambiguous and
largely unexplored territory although they go far towards defining what is
permissible for men in battle.

Lawyers and civil servants who are far removed from the miasma of fear,
fatigue and fury on a battlefield can try to regulate men’s behaviour in
battle. This would be pretty much like virgin children writing an
instruction book on advanced sexual technique.  Some attempts are best left
unmade and unenforceable laws should never be written.

One of the many gray areas of battlefield conduct concerns the killing of
horribly wounded personnel whether those of the enemy or your own.

Imagine, if you will, what to do if confronted by a man blasted out of the
hatch of a tank, with nothing remaining of him below the waist except for a
few tatters of flesh. As he is also badly burned by flaming propellant, he
is not likely to bleed to death for three or four minutes during which the
shock might wear off, letting him become aware of the full horrifying extent
of his injuries before he dies.   What is merciful and what is cruel under
these circumstances?

One metaphor we use about dying dates back to Homer’s epic on ancient Greek
warfare.  When he described somebody “biting the dust” it was usually in the
paroxysms of their death throes… and it wasn’t a metaphor.

Actually, mercy killing is extremely common in warfare. At field hospitals.
Physicians and medical staff would (and still do) practice Triage.  This is
the practice where, when resources are overwhelmed, patients are swiftly
sorted into those who will probably recover without immediate care, those
who will probably die even with immediate care, and those who will recover
only if given prompt attention.  Those who will probably die even with
immediate care are heavily dosed with morphine and put off to the side to
quietly expire.   Triage, effectively, is mercy killing by medical
professionals that remains a practice which almost all military medical
units resort to when necessary.  

Nor is it just military medics who resort to triage.  Canadians might want
to look up the regulations and rules for resort to triage in all of our
hospitals.  It is widely recognized that triage might be particularly common
in rural hospitals when confronted with mass casualties from an event such
as a major auto crash.  Regulations and legislation are in place to protect
Canadian physicians who have to make such choices in particular
circumstances.

The more conventional view of battlefield mercy killing can be guessed at
from anecdotes.  As an infantryman in the Rhineland offensive in February
1945, this writer’s uncle was involved in such a dilemma with a German
fallshirmjaeger.  Another veteran once told me of a night in Holland where a
badly wounded enemy soldier was alternatively screaming and wailing for his
mother in the deadly ground between two fiercely held positions until a
Canadian medic crept out to him with a knife.   Barry Broadfoot’s Six War
Years contains an anecdote of a Canadian slitting the throat of a badly
wounded soldier in a dark night between the lines in Italy without checking
which uniform he wore.

The full horrors of battle are seldom ever described by veterans except in
the vaguest terms; but there are exceptions.   Raleigh Trevelyn, a British
Guards officer at Anzio, once recounted seeing the puddle of human fat
pooled underneath a knocked out Sherman rendered from its crew by the slow
fire inside their tank.  He was willing to tell of this horror, but was more
guarded about something else.  One of his diary entries following the tank
anecdote said: “Yesterday evening there was something on a stretcher that
was the worse sight I have ever seen at this bridgehead… and it was still
alive.”  Years later, the casual reader might wonder, but who would really
want to know?

There are many memoirs written by combat veterans and some of them are very
frank indeed.  Eugene Sledge’s “With the Old Breed on Pelelieu and Okinawa”
recounts ghastly episodes of the battles in which he participated as a US
Marine in 1944-1945.  Being covered with maggots after slipping downhill on
a slope coated with decaying bodies is but one of these episodes. For defeat
and despair, one could consult Guy Sajer’s account of his three years as a
German soldier on the Russian Front in “The Forgotten Soldier.”  Canadians
would do well to look at Blackburn’s ‘Guns’ trilogy or Farley Mowat’s
account of his mental breakdown outside Ortona in “And No Birds Sang.” 

Sledge only indirectly refers (twice) to mercy killing.  In this case, it
concerned shooting burning Japanese who had just come screaming out of a
bunker after a flamethrower hit them, and dispatching wounded Japanese who
was still alive when one Marine started pulling out his gold teeth.   Sajer,
who mentions the casual murder of Russian prisoners, pulled back from
helping his horribly wounded friend, Ernst.  However, he does state ‘We shot
a great many men to put them out of their misery, although mercy killings
were strictly forbidden. Neither Blackburn nor Mowat mention mercy killing
at all.

In 35 years of asking informed questions from combat veterans (starting with
men who had been in the Trenches in the First World War) the matter of mercy
killing was never voluntarily raised.  A few conceded that they knew of
episodes involving badly wounded foes.  Only one veteran, a British soldier
from 1917-18, mentioned a sergeant who ‘took care of’ a man in his platoon
who had three bullets through the guts, an inevitable and painfully slow
death sentence in the days before antibiotics.   Another heard wounded mates
imploring their officer to shoot them.  

Another veteran of the Falklands War once described the dilemma of his
fighting patrol which had just killed a number of Argentines, excepting one
disembowelled by a grenade.  The wounded Argentine was dying slowly and
painfully.  The British troops couldn’t carry him away, didn’t dare to use
their slender stock of morphine on him, and his howling was drawing other
Argentines.  So a knife was used to ease the situation.

One Vietnam veteran recounted a common occurrence – men who are hit in the
legs or abdomen often check (or ask a mate to check) to see if their
genitals are still there.   One man who had his torn away begged to be shot
then and there, and a comrade provided this service.

Although many veterans simply won’t discuss this issue with those who have
never been in combat, there are some accounts of regret from soldiers in
many armies who killed their own badly wounded or those of the enemy and
regrets from those who did not.  The morality of every incident is
disputable, because the circumstances are always different, but the choices
are always the same absolutes.  This aspect of warfare is seldom discussed.
It happens and veterans keep their judgments to themselves; some remain
untroubled by their choices, some are haunted by them.

Captain Semrau was charged with second degree murder for killing the wounded
Talib and has been involved in a court martial.  These charges never should
have been laid.

The only people who can properly judge Captain Semrau are his true peers –
veterans of combat and perhaps medical doctors who have had to triage
patients in the sure knowledge some wouldn’t survive.  The only person who
can truly condemn or reprieve him is himself.

 

On Activism and Bullying

By way of a personal introduction, the author was a child in a Canadian Air
Force family and spent much of his childhood as the perpetual newcomer (the
family moved five times in seven years). His parents normally chose to live
off-base which inevitably meant – for their sons – having to negotiate with
a whole new school almost every year.  This also inevitably meant having to
confront a new suite of bullies and finding one’s place in a new pecking
order every time.  Life lessons were learned.

There are two constants in society; there are always people intent on
reforming others (they are usually but not invariably ‘liberal’).  Then
there are those intent on not being reformed by others who are most often
comfortable in the ‘conservative’ camp.   Both labels are not entirely
accurate.

There are three ways of looking at this perpetual struggle.  Sometimes,
change is vital, good and necessary and it is quite possible to find both
camps engaged in creative tension over ways and means.  Liberals like
William Wilberforce may have led the charge against the institution of
slavery but in the end it was ,conservatives like the Duke of Wellington,
who drove that charge home.  

Sometimes, there are people who drive change as a reaction to personal
tragedy.  In these encounters, the usual labels do not apply and might be
reversed in some situations.   Victims of violent crime, who often push to
tighten up the justice system, find themselves opposed at every turn.  On
the other hand, in the early 1980s, Mothers Against Drunk Driving (MADD)
achieved very rapid success in eliminating society’s then widespread
tolerance of drinking and driving.

The third aspect is less welcome.   There are people who, by their very
nature and upbringing, feel compelled to change others and they lock in
conflict with people who do not want to be changed.  Let’s call the first
camp activists and resist the temptation to call the second camp ‘targets’.

Sometimes, the activist’s goals are praiseworthy, but their ultimate motives
are questionable.

In terrorism, the ultimate “root cause” is the terrorist’s own interior
psychological make-up which generates a desire to appear heroic, to refine
one’s self image or to cause harm.  He or she then shops around for an
ideology that permits and shapes their violence.  It would seem some
activists share a similar predilection.

 

There are many activists for particular causes whose main impetus appears to
be ideological.  Members of Communist Parties, for example, have a long
history of creating activist campaigns or infiltrating existing groups and
turning them to the advantage of their party.  “Entryism” was the Trotskyite
name for this tactic and one example is the use Socialist Action made of
their memberships in Canada’s New Democratic Party over the years.  Many
Canadian Communists and Trotskyites had no clear personal interest in such
diverse issues as day care or prison reform but they saw an opportunity to
advance a wider agenda. 

Ideologues can be bullies – particularly when they sense things are going
their way – but this is not inevitable or universal.  It is, however,
usually a prudent practice to keep them from attaining political power.
Some people can be trusted with the keys to the liquor cabinet and others
cannot.

However, there is a very close connection between the psychology of bullying
and one particularly common form of activism.   One of the most common forms
of schoolyard or societal bullying is the enforcement of conformity or at
least those notions of conformity as understood by the bully/activist.

As first personally observed in the many schoolyards of the 1960s, bullies
often defend what they think is the social order.  One particular nemesis
believed it was his duty to keep those he regarded as strange or weird away
from the ‘cool’ kids whose ranks the bully desperately believed would open
to him for his exertions in their defence.  If he did not undertake this
duty, he himself might descend in status to be among what he thought were
lesser beings.

The same sort of drive would explain the Klu Klux Klan in Mississippi and
Alabama some 50 years ago. In a small rural Southern town, there were three
general layers of status:  the wealthy educated whites, the not so educated
or well-off whites and the blacks.  The KKK largely came from the middle
band and consisted mainly of men who felt, at that often unconscious level
where our ‘political’ thinking really begins, that their status would be
endangered if the Blacks squirmed out from underfoot.  They also hoped that
their efforts on behalf of the status quo would be rewarded.

A lot of bigotry can be explained thusly.  The same model would not seem
unfamiliar to Eastern European Jews under Czarist rule.  This may partly
explain the bewilderment the Holocaust caused, being racism from a largely
unexpected source. Polish and Ukrainian Jews knew what Cossacks and some of
their neighbours could be like but the Germans were supposed to be cultured.
Catholics in Ulster faced the same from working class Protestants, and so
on.

The bully is often an instrument of conformity- an enforcer who feels that
his (or her) efforts will improve their own lot provided that they are
merciless to the non-conformists.  There is nothing new here. In some ways,
the above has been the plot device for dozens of bad movies about youthful
rebellion by misfits ever since ‘Animal House’ (in which, it should be
pointed out, the bullies had their victory in the end). 

Many dictatorial regimes have also learned one tool of governance is to give
petty authority to those eager to exercise it.  It turns them into
supporters of the regime and its most zealous defenders.  It is an old
phenomenon but perhaps the best contemporary example can be seen in
Venezuela where Hugo Chavez has created a large political militia of his
lower class supporters.  It is a safe prediction that these supporters will
poison Venezuelan politics for decades after Chavez is gone.  This is an old
phenomenon.

For that matter, dictatorial regimes that become police states rely on
bullying conformists to inform on their neighbours.  The German Gestapo
actually had very few officers engaged in domestic security but they relied
on streams of denunciations and reports filed by hundreds of thousands of
ordinary Germans determined to prove their worth and orthodoxy.  Soviet
authorities relied on the same system.

For that matter, cast an observing eye on a collection of police officers.
Some are outstanding human beings, strong and compassionate, motivated by an
impulse of service to the community.  Some are professional; policing is a
job and they will perform it as best as they can.  There are a few, however,
who are attracted to police service by the prospect of the authority they
will gain, and who will abuse it when they think they can get away with it.


This simple observation should really be no surprise.  Hegel pointed out in
his “Philosophy of History” that the real driving force in history is the
individual’s constant striving for status and influence.  Those with less
are often eager for more; those with more are eager to defend it. Give
people who have had no authority some of their own to exercise and the
results should be entirely predictable.

Modern Western urban society is far more complex than that of – oh, 1950s
rural Mississippi – or the average suburban schoolyard. 

Some of the more pernicious developments in our society involve the
development of what could be called post-modernist liberalism or the
appearance of an ideological elite in what had been, some 50 years, ago an
increasingly egalitarian society. Those who hold to the credo of classic
Western Liberalism are now hopelessly out-of date ‘Neo-Cons’ while the
former partisans of that belief have been supplanted by a managerial elite
that believes in the benevolence of the state (when in the proper hands of
course) and support the states ability to intrude into every facet of our
lives for our own good.

The late Christopher Lasch was a prescient observer of major trends in the
Western World and his last book (published posthumously in 1995 – The Revolt
of the Elites and the Betrayal of Democracy) warned of the directions this
trend would lead to and the following 15 years certainly give abundant
reason to trust his warning.  A governing/managerial culture has emerged
based on contemporary liberal elites who view the public as being too
ignorant to be consulted about the business of governance.  Lasch did point
out that the depreciation of the rigors of the education system over the
last few decades was no accident and supports the assumption of this
culture.

The hatchet-toting Carrie Nation of the 19th Century Temperance movement
would have approved: the ability of the state to do good to society seems
limitless.   Those of us who wish to be left alone are on the ropes and
being slugged silly.    

What might be helpful for the punch-drunk citizen who is being knocked
endlessly about is to remember some things about bullying and how to resist
it successfully.

The modern activist bully has a whole range of issues to work on and
numerous targets to engage.

Gun control is one classic situation.  People who own guns and enjoy using
them are obviously not in tune with the modern state and therefore can be
safely harassed by any mechanism the activist bully can enable.   Even if
every new proposal in the US and Canada by every level of government to
restrict the right of firearms ownership is defeated, the activists keep
trying.  Gun-owners haven’t learned their lesson yet.

The Christian Churches are out of lockstep with the temper of the times and
must also be punished accordingly.  In the new spirit of Multiculturalism,
of course, not all religions are safe to persecute but every attempt to
demean those whacky Baptists and evangelicals must be good, and every
misdeed by Catholic Clergy over the past 50 years must be exploited as fully
as possible.  In the meantime, in the name of “Separation of Church and
State” (whatever that means), every public expression of Christianity must
be curtailed.  No more crèches at Christmas... oops, during the Holiday
season… no more crosses on hilltops, and so on.

The sheep-like way in which smokers caved in to the new Zeitgeist is
especially disheartening.   Admittedly, most of us don’t miss the blue haze
that used to fill our restaurants and bars and smoking is an unhealthy
habit.  But the attempts to regulate smokers in their homes, their cars and
in every aspect of their lives need to be opposed.  Where are the
‘Smoke-ins’ and the signs of opposition?  It has also been interesting to
watch the boundless zealousness of those opposed to smoking, who now seek
laws that intrude into the homes and automobiles of smokers.

There are things that truly irritate a bully.  When a target refuses to be
timorous or remains dignified in the face of indignity, it can be
infuriating.  One can almost imagine the though process:  “How dare he
ignore me, doesn’t he know his place?”  This then leads to the almost
entirely unconscious though that attends it:  “If he doesn’t know his place,
who will know mine?”  Admittedly, this might not be the best defence with
physical bullying unless one is prepared to endure the consequences or at
least fight a losing battle like a cornered wolverine.

When Christ preached that the best response to an insult was to turn the
other cheek, one might well wonder if this was the intended result.   If it
was, then perhaps it was best that Christ didn’t specify exactly what cheek
one should turn…   What might be called the “St. Bernard” tactic is often a
good response to bullying by snobbery and insult; if one is being snubbed,
act like a big gentle St. Bernard dog and give them more of you to love and
be sure to – metaphorically -- shed hair and drool on the furniture while at
it.

Bullies really don’t like being mocked and one should remember that some
inner sense of insecurity constitutes a significant part of their
motivation.  Never pass up a chance to deride an activist and take advantage
of the fact that few have a sense of humour.  It is, however, important to
remember that some do… particularly some of the ideologues of the Radical
Left.   As Sun Tzu cautioned 2,500 years ago, know your enemy and yourself
before launching an attack.

When separating the activist bully who seeks authority and status, from the
genuine activist with a cause, consider the following:

The person with a real cause is not seeking status or financial reward; this
is not true of the activist who turns their issue into a profession.

The person with a real cause is prepared to discuss matters, and may
sometimes change their message.  The activist bully will use the opportunity
to hector opponents and will not budge.

When meeting policy makers and senior officials, the person with a real
cause is often unsure of how to act and may not be comfortable.  The
activist bully is delighted to be in the room and pleased when in the
proximity of power.

For the modern citizen, particularly those who are normally inclined not be
pushed around, there can only be one rational result:   Become as contrary
as possible.  The more your religion is snubbed, the more you should openly
practice it.  If owning firearms or eating red meat is frowned upon, then
your path is clear.  If some books are deemed too difficult or old fashioned
to be safe for children, buy them for as many children as you can. 

Encourage critical thinking… and embrace rational rebellion.  It drives the
bullies nuts and if one is properly prepared for it, driving bullies nuts is
enormous fun and should be engaged in whenever possible.  It is the best way
to drive them into permanent retreat.   So whenever one encounters bullying,
it should be automatic to turn the other cheek… the one that requires you to
loosen your belt before presenting it.

 

Notes From 20 Years Ago

The Mackenzie Institute has been around since 1986, and has been engaged in
desk-top publishing since 1990.  With a history like this, it seems useful
to occasionally dust off old columns and re-examine them.  Have our
observations and conclusions stood the test of time?

In the Spring newsletter of 1990, Maurice Tugwell wrote a long essay on
recent developments as they pertained to the Institute’s professional
interests.  Excerpts follow:

“Supreme excellence” in warfare was defined twenty-five centuries ago by the
Chinese military philosopher Sun Tzu as “breaking the enemy’s resistance
without fighting.”  In practice, all conflict is a mixture of persuasion and
compulsion, of psychological and physical actions. Sun Tzu placed emphasis
on the former, because the cost to the attacker was less and the prize was
likely to be captured intact.

The alternative of force and persuasion – terror and propaganda – is
particularly important to the revolutionary if only because he starts out at
a grave disadvantage in terms of legitimacy, power and resources.  Always,
where the revolutionary challenge is serious, politics dominates and force
is merely a means to the political end. Thus, ideas are fundamental.

Religious militants, fanatical ideologues, frustrated nationalists,
minorities with legitimate grievances and other movements or countries
convinced by “righteous causes” may use such revolutionary methods to
redress disparities within their own regimes or with the developed nations.
Inevitably, it is the open society that is vulnerable.  Lenin, Stalin and
Hitler understood this well, as do their successors.

In Italy in the 1930s, Antonio Gramsci, a Marxist, brought the ideological
aspect of revolutionary warfare up-to-date and his tactics are widely used
by radicals today.

Terrorism

While the incidence of terrorism may be declining, its lethality is
increasing.  Terrorism seems to be changing from its 1970s and ‘80s form as
violent theatre designed to catch headlines and direct attention to some
cause, to being low-intensity warfare based on attrition.  Our responses
have not kept pace.  

While the ideological/nationalist/religious motive for terrorism remains
important in some movements, mercenary motives are uppermost in others.
This is the case in much Middle Eastern hostage-taking, and it is
particularly so in drug-related terrorism.  Cruel though the “idealistic”
terrorist can be, there are usually limits to his or her atrocities imposed
by a need to justify acts within the philosophical framework and thus retain
the support of true believers.  For the mercenary, such restrictions do not
apply.  For many years it has been the conventional wisdom that terrorism
can contribute effectively to a wider revolutionary strategy but, unaided,
is incapable of winning more than minor concessions.  In Colombia, some
observers have forecast a national surrender to the terrorism of the drug
lords.  Would this be a freak event or a trend-setter?

 

Revolution

… democracy has won a series of stunning bloodless victories over
totalitarian communist regimes in Central and Eastern Europe.  Gramsci’s
techniques have worked perfectly, but in the opposite direction to that
intended by their author.

… we are assured by Ed Broadbent, Douglas Roche and many others that the
Cold War is over.  Two years ago, such luminaries would doubtless have
denied that there was such a war outside the imaginations of “Cold
Warriors”.  The “Death of Communism” is another popular phrase.  Questions:
if the Cold War is over, presumably it has been won by the West.  Who are we
to thank for this:  Effete intellectuals and peace-at-any-price disarmers
who confronted by nuclear blackmail, counselled appeasement; or the Cold
Warriors who faced reality and responded rationally?  But perhaps the Cold
War has not been won, simply suspended or concealed.  In that case, how can
we talk of the death of communism?

Sun Tzu would caution us against the comfortable illusion that winning
battles is the same thing as winning a war.

Propaganda

Only when we are aware of our delusions, explained French philosopher
Jacques Ellul, will we experience the beginning of genuine freedom.  To gain
awareness, we must step back and examine the means of deception and covert
influence.

Propaganda and its half-brother, deception, are hard subjects, because
knowing where truth ends and lies begin is always difficult and sometimes
impossible.  However, because political warfare, terrorism and revolution
rely on propaganda, the topic must be addressed.  As a rule, analysis
proceeds through case studies, which yield patterns and organizations.  From
such examples, working hypotheses emerge.  Little can be proved with the
degree of accuracy we have come to expect in a scientific age, but awareness
can nevertheless be developed, and with it the promise of greater freedom.  

 

Alexander Mackenzie’s Library

Some things never change…

The first ‘go-to’ book in drafting the original National Post column on the
Semrau court martial was Richard Holmes’ Acts of War: the Behaviours of Men
in Battle (The Free Press, New York, 1985).  Holmes was already that
wonderful combination of soldier and scholar. He has since finished his
service as a Brigadier in the British Territorial Army and is a
well-published professor of history. His more recent books betray an
incredible mix of empathy, logic and detailed knowledge all wedded to an
excellent prose, so a return to one of his older books was a chance to
re-meet the younger author. It is a worthwhile meeting.

Acts of War is a survey of the literature of men in combat, drawing heavily
on historical books from Ancient Greece to the more recently published
memoirs of survivors of combat from sundry Middle Eastern wars and Vietnam.
It is a lengthy, comprehensive and blunt survey of every aspect of human
motivation and behaviour in combat.  Every section is strongly supported by
abundant anecdotes from accounts of combatants, sometimes drawing on 3,000
years of experience. 

Holmes arrives at one inevitable conclusion: Human nature does not change
and men will fight as they always have when the situation arises.  The 25
years that have passed since the book was published give us even less reason
to doubt its findings.

You Mean They Really do Hate us?

It is nine years after 9/11 and Western bewilderment about Islam is still
far too common.  Reflexive comments from too many of our leaders suggest
they believe that potential violence from their own citizens in reaction to
Islamic pressure is a greater problem than the risk of terrorism and that
somehow there are moderate Muslims and a moderate strain of Islam that we
can deal with.  Walid Phares stepped up to the plate to explain things again
in his book The War of Ideas (Palgrave MacMillan, New York, 2007).  

There is a fundamental debate between Western traditions and those of the
Islamic World but Phares describes it as a one-sided battle. The West’s best
ideals are not being engaged and its ability to export the fruits of its
democratic traditions is severely constrained, usually by its own choices.
Against this, the Arab World’s disinterest in Western ideals and democracy
is already strongly entrenched, but the Jihad movements’ utter rejection of
them is buttressed by its ready resort to the technology and techniques of
Western communications.  Moreover, resorting to those tools and practices is
forcing the West on the defensive.

Phares pleads with us to be far more intellectually assertive and ruthless.
We can keep our best traditions while being mercilessly blunt to the agents
of the Jihad movement here… why tolerate the Muslim Brotherhood and the
Dawa?  It does no good to us or to Muslims anywhere to let them engage us on
an equal footing.   Such common sense is rare.


Voices of Freedom


“Force is only justifiable in extremes; when we have the upper hand, justice
is preferable.”

- Napoleon Bonaparte, Political Aphorisms

 

“Regulations are all very well for drill but in the hour of danger they are
no more use… You must learn to think.”

- Ferdinand Foch

 

“Education is what survives when what has been learned has been forgotten.”

- B.F. Skinner, New Scientist, May 1964

 

And from the You-Said-Sister Department:

“No one would remember the Good Samaritan if he’d only had good intentions.
He had money as well.”

- Margaret Thatcher, Television interview, January 1986.

 

The Mackenzie Institute

 

The Institute was formed in 1986 to provide research and comment on such
diverse subjects as terrorism, organized crime, political extremism,
propaganda, conflict and other such matters.  It does not shy away from
controversy.

 

The Institute holds to the proposition that our democratic institutions need
to be defended and enhanced. It works to do what it can to protect the
stability of Canadian society.

 

Those who support its purposes are invited to become Friends of the
Institute, and those who contribute $60 (or more) to it, receive its
publications for the next twelve months.  

 

The Mackenzie Institute

PO Box 338, Adelaide Station

Toronto, Ontario

M5C-2J4

Tel: 416-686-4063

 

[email protected]

www.mackenzieinstitute.com

 



[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]



------------------------------------

--------------------------
Want to discuss this topic?  Head on over to our discussion list, 
[email protected].
--------------------------
Brooks Isoldi, editor
[email protected]

http://www.intellnet.org

  Post message: [email protected]
  Subscribe:    [email protected]
  Unsubscribe:  [email protected]


*** FAIR USE NOTICE. This message contains copyrighted material whose use has 
not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. OSINT, as a part of 
The Intelligence Network, is making it available without profit to OSINT 
YahooGroups members who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the 
included information in their efforts to advance the understanding of 
intelligence and law enforcement organizations, their activities, methods, 
techniques, human rights, civil liberties, social justice and other 
intelligence related issues, for non-profit research and educational purposes 
only. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of the copyrighted material 
as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use 
this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' 
you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.
For more information go to:
http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtmlYahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/

<*> Your email settings:
    Individual Email | Traditional

<*> To change settings online go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/join
    (Yahoo! ID required)

<*> To change settings via email:
    [email protected] 
    [email protected]

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
    [email protected]

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
    http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/

Reply via email to