Obama administration's basic hostility to Israel is so salient that no
amount of appeasing on any specific issue will alter its position
Obama and the US-Israel alliance
By Caroline Glick Friday, October 15, 2010
Israel's opposition leaders spent the past week trying to prove their
relevance. On Tuesday, both former prime minister Ehud Olmert and Kadima
leader Tzipi Livni accused Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu of wrecking
Israel's relations with the US. Both Livni and Olmert claimed that Netanyahu
is taking a knife to Israel's most valuable alliance by refusing to bow to
US President Barack Obama's demand that the government extend the ban on
Jewish building in Judea and Samaria for an additional 60 days.
As Olmert put it, "The United States, the great superpower, says: 'You held
a building freeze for 10 months, now extend it by two months.'"
"Sure we are an independent state," Olmert allowed, but then he continued,
"But doesn't reason, a sense of responsibility and foresight, justify giving
two more months?"
Finally, he warned, "We can refuse the efforts by friendly states, but will
we then be able to continue to conduct a relationship of goodwill with them
in the future?"
So as far as Olmert is concerned, if Israel refuses to bow to the Obama
administration's demand that Jewish property rights be abrogated for an
additional two months, the US will be justified in ending its support for
Israel.
Livni accused Netanyahu of sacrificing Israel's relations with the US in
order to placate his coalition partners.
Olmert's and Livni's assaults on Netanyahu made clear that like most of
their colleagues on the Left, they believe that relations between countries
and relations between governments are the same thing. They recognize no
distinction between ties with autocracies like Egypt and Jordan on the one
hand and ties with democracies like the US on the other. In both cases, as
far as the Left is concerned, alliances or conflicts between nations are
determined by the status of relations between political leaders.
Assuming for a moment that Livni and Olmert are right about the nature of
US-Israel ties, does it follow that Netanyahu is wrecking those ties by
defying Obama? Tuesday's State Department press briefing indicates that this
is not the case.
On Tuesday, State Department spokesman P.J. Crowley was asked, "Do you [i.e.
the administration] recognize Israel as a Jewish state and will you try to
convince the Palestinians to recognize it?
As Rick Richman at Commentary's blog noted, Crowley repeatedly tried to
evade answering the question. Reporters were forced to repeat the question
six times before Crowley managed to say, "We recognize that Israel is a - as
it says itself, is a Jewish state, yes."
As for whether or not the administration will try to convince the
Palestinians to recognize the Jewish state, Crowley could not bring himself
to give a simple affirmative answer.
Crowley's refusal to give straight answers to straight questions about US
recognition of Israel as a Jewish state shows that Israel has never faced a
more unfriendly US administration. After all, recognizing Israel as a Jewish
state means recognizing that the Jewish people are a nation, and as a
nation, the Jews have a right to self-determination in our national
homeland. So recognizing Israel as a Jewish state is recognizing Israel's
right to exist.
Crowley's unwillingness to state flat out that the US recognizes Israel as a
Jewish state and expects Israel's supposed Palestinian peace partners to do
so as well means that the Obama administration's basic hostility to Israel
is so salient that no amount of appeasing on any specific issue will alter
its position.
What this means is that if Livni, Olmert and the Left they represent are
correct, and the sole or even major determinant of the strength and quality
of US-Israel relations is views of the US president, then Netanyahu's
actions are irrelevant. Relations with America are doomed no matter what he
does.
LUCKILY FOR Israel, Livni, Olmert and the Left they represent have no idea
what they are talking about. Contrary to what they would have voters
believe, there is a world of difference between how democracies conduct
foreign relations and how autocracies conduct them.
Whereas in places like Egypt, Israel's relations with the country are
completely contingent on the identity of Egypt's leader, in the US, the
president does not determine whether the alliance between Washington and
Jerusalem will remain strong. The American people make that decision. And
the American people have no intention of abandoning their alliance with
Israel.
As a poll released last week makes clear, Americans are far more likely to
ditch leaders they believe are harming the US-Israel alliance than they are
to ditch the alliance. The poll was carried out from October 3-5 by the
non-partisan McLaughlin and Associates survey research group for the
pro-Israel Emergency Committee for Israel. It is the most in-depth poll of
US sentiment towards Israel in recent memory. The poll broke down
respondents by political affiliation, geographical area, religion, race,
age, education level, sex, income level and ideological outlook.
The results were extraordinary.
Some 93.5 percent of Americans believe that the US should be concerned about
Israel's security. Whereas the Obama administration is unconvinced that the
Palestinians need to recognize Israel as a Jewish state, 77% of Americans
believe that they must do so. Only 6% of Americans believe the Palestinians
shouldn't recognize Israel.
And not only do Americans support Israel, they expect their leaders to
support Israel as well.
Some 50.9% of Americans are more likely to vote for a staunchly pro-Israel
candidate, and only 25.2% are less likely to do so. Fifty-three percent of
Americans say they could not vote for an anti- Israel candidate even if they
agreed with the candidate's positions on most other issues.
As for Obama's treatment of Israel, some 42.7% of Americans believe that the
president's Middle East policies harm Israel's security, and only 29.6%
believe that they are improving Israel's security situation. Some 51.6% of
Americans believe that Obama is less friendly towards Israel than his
predecessors have been. Only 35.4% believe that he is as friendly towards
Israel as his predecessors were.
No less noteworthy than the poll's exposure of the massive support Israel
enjoys from the American people is what it tells us about the relative
strength and weakness of that support along the partisan and ideological
divide. As the Emergency Committee for Israel's Chairman Bill Kristol
summarized the poll's findings in The Weekly Standard, 69% of Republicans
are more likely to vote for a pro-Israel candidate, while only 40% of
Democrats are. Furthermore, a mere 15% of Republicans are less likely to
vote for a pro-Israel candidate while 33% of Democrats are less likely to
vote for a candidate who strongly supports Israel.
The Right-Left divide mirrors and amplifies the partisan divide. A majority
of US conservatives are pro-Israel and only 5% of self-described liberals
are pro-Israel.
WITH EVERYONE from Glenn Beck to George Soros predicting a massive
Republican victory in next month's midterm congressional elections, it is
clear that the disparity between Obama's policies and the preferences of the
American people is about to massively constrain Obama's ability to implement
his agenda.
>From Netanyahu's perspective, what this means that if he wishes to maintain
US support for Israel, his best bet is to do exactly the opposite of what
the Left proposes. He should continue to defy Obama and explain to the
American people why Israel cannot accede to the administration's demands.
As the electoral clock runs down it is becoming increasingly clear that it
is Obama and his supporters, not Israel, that will be forced to pay a price
for Obama's Middle East policies. In fact, those most strongly identified
with Obama's anti- Israel positions are already paying a price for their
highly unpopular positions. Take the pro-Palestinian lobby J Street for
instance. If Obama's policies towards Israel were popular, J Street wouldn't
be concerned about The Washington Times' recent exposes about the group.
Those reports revealed that contrary to repeated claims by J Street's
leaders, the virulently anti-Israel George Soros is one of its largest
financial backers. Moreover, again, in spite of the group's denials, J
Street's senior personnel set up meetings with US lawmakers for notoriously
anti-Israel Richard Goldstone. Indeed, J Street's co-founder Daniel Levy
accompanied Goldstone to his meetings on Capitol Hill.
As things stand today, the group that positioned itself as Obama's chief
defender in the American Jewish community is teetering on the verge of
collapse. J Street's credibility is in tatters and the administration that
sought to empower J Street is now distancing itself from the group.
J Street's central contention is that American Jews stand to the left of
pro-Israel groups like AIPAC. By staking out a position to the left of AIPAC
- and in line with the White House's policies - J Street claims it serves as
the true voice of American Jewry. But another recent poll shows that this is
untrue.
A survey of American Jewish opinion published this week by the American
Jewish Committee shows that J Street's agenda is rejected by American Jewry.
Whereas 78% of American Jews voted for Obama in 2008, today a bare majority
of 51% approve of his performance in office. As political analyst Larry
Sabato noted, "A 50% positive rating for a Democratic president among Jews
is, frankly, terrible."
The unprecedented drop in American Jewish support for Obama is directly
related to his hostility towards Israel. Today a mere 49% of American Jews
support his handling of US-Israel relations, while 45% disapprove.
Tellingly, 62% of American Jews approve of Netanyahu's handling of US-Israel
relations and only 27% disapprove.
Democrats supported by J Street - that is Democrats who have supported
Obama's policies towards Israel - are running scared today. The Emergency
Committee for Israel and the Republican Jewish Coalition are running ads
against members of Congress supported by J Street to great effect. In
Pennsylvania, Democratic Senate candidate and J Street ally congressman Joe
Sestak is polling far behind Republican nominee Pat Toomey.
In Chicago, far-left six-term Democratic congresswoman and J Street
sweetheart Jan Schakowsky's approval ratings have fallen below 50%. Her
unabashedly pro-Israel Republican opponent Joel Pollak is making
Schakowsky's record on Israel a pillar of his campaign. For his efforts
Pollak was the recipient of Harvard law professor Alan Dershowitz's first
ever endorsement of a Republican.
Likewise, in New Jersey seven-term Democratic congressman Rush Holt is
facing a tough challenge from Republican Scott Sipprelle. Sipprelle is also
pounding his opponent over his ties to the Obama-aligned J Street.
In Florida, Democratic congressman Ron Klein is expected to lose his
reelection bid against Allen West. Although Klein is Jewish and West is
African-American, West has been running to Klein's right on Israel to great
effect. Klein has also participated in J Street events.
The Israeli Left's failure to recognize what is happening in the US today is
not surprising. After all, the Left has ignored the sentiments of the
Israeli people for years. But as the elected leader of the Jewish state,
Netanyahu should recognize the truth. If he wishes to secure Israel's
alliance with the US, he should do what is best for Israel, not what is best
for Israel's Left.
Originally published in The Jerusalem Post.
CFP Tools
<http://www.facebook.com/sharer.php?u=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.canadafreepress.com%2
Fprintpage.php&t=Canada%20Free%20Press%20-%20Printer%20Friendly%20Version&sr
c=sp> Share34
| More <http://www.addthis.com/bookmark.php?v=250&username=bthom62>
(0)
<http://www.canadafreepress.com/index.php/site/comments/obama-and-the-us-isr
ael-alliance/> Reader Feedback
Subscribe <http://canadafreepress.com/eesystem/index.php/CFP-subscriptions/>
Print <http://www.canadafreepress.com/printpage.php> friendly
Contact
<mailto:[email protected]?subject=dear%20canada%20free%20press>
Us
_____
Caroline Glick
<http://canadafreepress.com/index.php/members/28797/Caroline%20Glick/> Bio
Caroline Glick
<http://www.canadafreepress.com/index.php/members/28797/Caroline%20Glick/>
Most recent columns
Chicago-born Caroline Glick, Center for Security Policy
<http://www.centerforsecuritypolicy.org> , is deputy managing editor of the
Jerusalem Post. A former officer in the Israel Defense Forces, she was a
core member of Israel's negotiating team with the Palestinians and later
served as an assistant policy advisor to the prime minister. During
Operation Iraqi Freedom, the widely-published Glick was an embedded
journalist with the U.S. Army's Third Infantry Division. She was awarded a
distinguished civilian service award from the U.S. Secretary of the Army for
her battlefield reporting.
_____
Printed from: http://canadafreepress.com/index.php/article/28797
[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
------------------------------------
--------------------------
Want to discuss this topic? Head on over to our discussion list,
[email protected].
--------------------------
Brooks Isoldi, editor
[email protected]
http://www.intellnet.org
Post message: [email protected]
Subscribe: [email protected]
Unsubscribe: [email protected]
*** FAIR USE NOTICE. This message contains copyrighted material whose use has
not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. OSINT, as a part of
The Intelligence Network, is making it available without profit to OSINT
YahooGroups members who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the
included information in their efforts to advance the understanding of
intelligence and law enforcement organizations, their activities, methods,
techniques, human rights, civil liberties, social justice and other
intelligence related issues, for non-profit research and educational purposes
only. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of the copyrighted material
as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use
this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,'
you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.
For more information go to:
http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtmlYahoo! Groups Links
<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/
<*> Your email settings:
Individual Email | Traditional
<*> To change settings online go to:
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/join
(Yahoo! ID required)
<*> To change settings via email:
[email protected]
[email protected]
<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
[email protected]
<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/