_____  

 
<http://feedproxy.google.com/~r/FromNyToIsraelSultanRevealsTheStoriesBehindT
heNews/~3/5AsgCaCl1xA/koran-says-what.html?utm_source=feedburner&utm_medium=
email> The Koran Says What

Posted: 16 Oct 2010 07:27 PM PDT

 
<http://1.bp.blogspot.com/_mveHL3n_4ME/TLpe7_QIkTI/AAAAAAAAED8/UnAy0v8Po5c/s
1600/koran-cartoon.GIF> At The Atlantic, J.J. Goldberg produced one of the
more misguided addenda to the New York Times' Bash Pamela Geller week, by
manufacturing a
<http://www.theatlantic.com/international/archive/2010/10/reuel-gerecht-on-p
amela-gellers-foul-anti-muslim-ideology/64478/>  thin narrative, and then
addressing it rather than Geller's actual arguments. And then forwarding it
to Gerecht, who isn't familiar with Geller. This practice of creating
"strawmen", of arguing against what critics of Islam are supposedly saying,
than what they are actually saying, has become a notoriously common tool for
the liberal media, which censors even cartoons that don't feature Mohammed,
and is certainly eager to censor arguments that do.

The attack typically rephrases the arguments in a tone somewhere between
mocking and ominous, at once undermining the argument by ridiculing it and
associating it with Anti-Semitism, particularly ridiculous as Geller is
Jewish, and Islam is undeniably Anti-Semitic.

In a recent New York Times interview, the blogger Pamela Geller leveled many
serious charges against Islam; she stated that Muslims curse Jews and
Christians during their five-times-a-day prayer; that the only good Muslim
is a secular Muslim; and most perniciously, she said that the Qur'an has
never been properly translated, insinuating that it contains dark secrets
about Muslims and their religious responsibilities.


There's a huge reach from, "it was never properly translated" to "it
contains dark secrets." I feel the Torah has never been properly translated
either. That doesn't mean it contains dark secrets. It means it's never been
properly translated. I can say the same thing about many novels in languages
which don't share much common linguistic ancestry with English.

Wafa Sultan, who was raised an Arab Muslim, has said the same thing. As
Gerecht himself points out, plenty of Koran translations do show that Islam
is hostile to non-Muslims. There are some PC Koran translations, but the
most popular ones used by Muslims are non-PC. The diversity of translations
used by Muslims shows there isn't necessarily an ideal translation. Because
in some cases there isn't even full agreement on what the Koran means.
Stating that there should be an ideal translation means that Muslims and
non-Muslims who don't know Arabic should know what the Koran says and
doesn't say. 

But J.J. Goldberg makes it his thesis that Geller claimed that the Koran
contains "dark secrets." Now I don't claim to read her mind, but this is the
quote, Goldberg is working off.

Now I also believe that a true translation, an accurate translation of the
Koran, is really not available in English, according to many of the Islamic
scholars that I've spoken to. That's deeply troubling. And I don't think
that many westernized Muslims know when they pray five times a day that
they're cursing Christians and Jews five times a day. I don't think they
know that.



I don't claim to be able to read Geller's mind, but her reference was most
likely to, the opening of the Koran, "Show us the straight path, the path of
those whom Thou hast favored; not the (path) of those who earn thine anger
nor of those who go astray." 

This is generally thought to mean Jews as being the ones who earned Allah's
anger, and Christians being the ones who have gone astray.
<http://www.jihadwatch.org/2007/06/blogging-the-quran-sura-1-the-opening.htm
l> Robert Spencer has gone into some detail on the subject here. The
question here is less about literal translation and more about commonly
understood references. Some translations of the Koran do add these words for
clarification. Some maintain the original language. 

 
<http://1.bp.blogspot.com/_mveHL3n_4ME/TLpe4ofT6OI/AAAAAAAAED0/SZgGnmSWrnU/s
1600/political-cartoon.gif> 

But this is less about dark secrets, than it is about clarity. No one needs
to argue the meaning of this verse in particular, to show that Islam
commands Muslims to conquer and rule over non-Muslims. And Muslims who are
familiar with the Koran, learn contextual meanings, rather than just the
exact meaning of words. They are taught what the phrase means, rather than
just being given a dictionary. This is not unusual with most religious works
in most of the major religions. Any Westernized Muslims who do not know that
the reference is to Jews and Christians, are either the product of a
non-mainstream Islamic education, or no Islamic education whatsoever. 

While one need not point to this verse to find that the Koran is hostile to
Jews and Christians. The centrality of it however is what makes it so vital
in Muslim religious life.

Gerecht has the unenviable task of making sense of J.J. Goldberg's
speculations about what Geller said (rather than Goldberg emailing and
asking her) and I have the unenviable task of making sense of that whole
mess. A mess that has less to do with the Koran, than it does with silencing
straightforward criticism of Islam, to only allow criticism of Islamic
extremism. 

Late in the piece, Gerecht makes the arguable claim that Muslims don't think
about Jews and Christians when they pray and don't need to hate Jews and
Christians to be Muslims.

And about Muslim prayer: I certainly have no perfect way of knowing what
Muslims think when they pray, but I really do think they know what they're
doing. If westernized Muslims are facing the Almighty, they know what's in
their hearts. Devout Muslims need not hate Jews and Christians to worship
the Creator.


While Jews and Christians are not the focus of Muslim prayers, neither are
they absent from them as bad examples, as has already been shown above. This
is another strawman that substitutes one argument for another. Islam is
based on Allah's rejection of Jews and Christians, and the Koranic claim
that Jews and Christians rejected Mohammed. The separate existence of Jews
and Christians is in Muslim eyes a testament to their heresy or unbelief.
For if they truly believed, they would be Muslims.  

Can devout Muslims not hate Jews or Christians? Only if we define devout
differently than Mohammed, who Gerecht admits hated both.

But from a technical standpoint, devout Muslims need not hate Jews and
Christians. They're just commanded not to befriend them, and to subjugate
and kill them. But if they can do so with no more emotion than machines,
perhaps Mohammed would still approve. This is hardly much of a defense
though. It is no comfort that your murderers did not hate you personally,
but were only acting on orders from their holy book. 

Reuel Gerecht is correct that Muslims are more than just physical
embodiments of the Koran, but nor can you casually talk about Muslims,
without acknowledging that they strive to live by the Koran as an ideal.
Muslims are human beings who feel the same things we do. But so were the
followers of National Socialism or the guards in the watchtowers of Soviet
Gulags. There were, for example, Nazis who killed Jews, but also saved some
of them. That the same man who oversaw mass murder, might save a child,
tells us that people are complex. But it is no denial of what Nazism is, or
what Nazis did, or even what this man in particular did. 

 
<http://1.bp.blogspot.com/_mveHL3n_4ME/TLpe6KQ1PeI/AAAAAAAAED4/5lOQQ3Lw8sk/s
1600/HuffakerKoran.gif> 

This is what makes the casual and easy liberal reductionism of statements
such as "Christians and Jews and atheists are much more than the sum of
their parts...So, too, are Muslims" into a license for dismissing facts, in
favor of some generic sense of human unity. 

Human beings are indeed more than the sum of their parts. But they are still
mostly defined by one part or another. By culture, nationality, creed and
faith. We cannot ignore those by arguing that we are all the same. We are
the same, but that just means that we all have good and evil inside us. That
we strive to do what we think is good, by the lights of our ideals. And that
to understand who we are, we must look at what those ideals say. A good
Muslim is fundamentally different than a good Christian, Jew, Buddhist,
Hindu or atheist. Trial after trial of terrorists who quote devoutly from
the Koran testify to that. 

Being Muslim is a choice. Geller has argued that Muslims in the West should
be fully informed of what that choice entails. There is no serious
counterargument to be made in that regard. Nor can there be. To ignore that
is to perpetuate terror. Because the unexamined Koran is a ticking time
bomb. And it's a bomb that we're sitting on.



 
<http://feeds.feedburner.com/~ff/FromNyToIsraelSultanRevealsTheStoriesBehind
TheNews?a=5AsgCaCl1xA:wXdWcTI0pfk:yIl2AUoC8zA>
<http://feeds.feedburner.com/~ff/FromNyToIsraelSultanRevealsTheStoriesBehind
TheNews?a=5AsgCaCl1xA:wXdWcTI0pfk:I9og5sOYxJI>
<http://feeds.feedburner.com/~ff/FromNyToIsraelSultanRevealsTheStoriesBehind
TheNews?a=5AsgCaCl1xA:wXdWcTI0pfk:63t7Ie-LG7Y>
<http://feeds.feedburner.com/~ff/FromNyToIsraelSultanRevealsTheStoriesBehind
TheNews?a=5AsgCaCl1xA:wXdWcTI0pfk:F7zBnMyn0Lo>
<http://feeds.feedburner.com/~ff/FromNyToIsraelSultanRevealsTheStoriesBehind
TheNews?a=5AsgCaCl1xA:wXdWcTI0pfk:7Q72WNTAKBA>
<http://feeds.feedburner.com/~ff/FromNyToIsraelSultanRevealsTheStoriesBehind
TheNews?a=5AsgCaCl1xA:wXdWcTI0pfk:V_sGLiPBpWU>
<http://feeds.feedburner.com/~ff/FromNyToIsraelSultanRevealsTheStoriesBehind
TheNews?a=5AsgCaCl1xA:wXdWcTI0pfk:UT3xtbGYFzA>
<http://feeds.feedburner.com/~ff/FromNyToIsraelSultanRevealsTheStoriesBehind
TheNews?a=5AsgCaCl1xA:wXdWcTI0pfk:gIN9vFwOqvQ>
<http://feeds.feedburner.com/~ff/FromNyToIsraelSultanRevealsTheStoriesBehind
TheNews?a=5AsgCaCl1xA:wXdWcTI0pfk:4cEx4HpKnUU>
<http://feeds.feedburner.com/~ff/FromNyToIsraelSultanRevealsTheStoriesBehind
TheNews?a=5AsgCaCl1xA:wXdWcTI0pfk:cGdyc7Q-1BI>
<http://feeds.feedburner.com/~ff/FromNyToIsraelSultanRevealsTheStoriesBehind
TheNews?a=5AsgCaCl1xA:wXdWcTI0pfk:qj6IDK7rITs> 



 

        
Email delivery powered by Google

        

 



[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]



------------------------------------

--------------------------
Want to discuss this topic?  Head on over to our discussion list, 
[email protected].
--------------------------
Brooks Isoldi, editor
[email protected]

http://www.intellnet.org

  Post message: [email protected]
  Subscribe:    [email protected]
  Unsubscribe:  [email protected]


*** FAIR USE NOTICE. This message contains copyrighted material whose use has 
not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. OSINT, as a part of 
The Intelligence Network, is making it available without profit to OSINT 
YahooGroups members who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the 
included information in their efforts to advance the understanding of 
intelligence and law enforcement organizations, their activities, methods, 
techniques, human rights, civil liberties, social justice and other 
intelligence related issues, for non-profit research and educational purposes 
only. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of the copyrighted material 
as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use 
this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' 
you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.
For more information go to:
http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtmlYahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/

<*> Your email settings:
    Individual Email | Traditional

<*> To change settings online go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/join
    (Yahoo! ID required)

<*> To change settings via email:
    [email protected] 
    [email protected]

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
    [email protected]

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
    http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/

Reply via email to