Explaining anti-Semitism (and Israel) to progressive Europeans

October 17, 2010 in  <http://cifwatch.com/category/uncategorized/>
Uncategorized | Tags:  <http://en.wordpress.com/tag/antisemitism/>
Antisemitism,  <http://en.wordpress.com/tag/comment-is-free/> Comment is
Free,  <http://en.wordpress.com/tag/guardian/> Guardian,
<http://en.wordpress.com/tag/europe/> Europe | by
<http://cifwatch.com/author/cweleventhauthor/> Adam Levick

 
<http://commentisfreewatch.files.wordpress.com/2010/10/antisemitism_european
1.jpg> 

I was sitting in Cafe Aroma with my new French friends, a young couple I met
while on a tour in Jerusalem, having a really enjoyable conversation - the
kind you often have on vacation, especially long vacations where you're more
likely to throw your usual social caution to the wind.  It's the kind of
liberation you feel as the result of being by so far from everything and
everyone you've ever known.  It allows you take greater risks and throw your
normal social caution to the wind. Though I'm not technically on vacation,
making Aliyah (6000 miles away from the place I called home for most of my
life) has definitely made me more prone to the mood I was in while
backpacking across Europe in my 20s - the sense of unlimited possibilities.

I think the three of us ended up talking for over 2 hours, a conversation
which revolved around many things, but politics and religion took up most of
our time - which seemed quite natural given their obvious erudition and
genuine curiousness. My new friends genuinely seemed to have more questions
(about Judaism, Israel, the U.S.) than answers, assumptions, or specific
opinions - all of which made them quite pleasant interlocutors.

My friends were not Jewish, not evangelical Christians or religious in any
sense, and not in any way connected to the Jewish state in the usual way.
They were simply visiting Israel out of curiousness.  They were secular
Europeans on vacation - the kind of visitors most countries take for granted
but, in Israel, is at least a bit more unusual.  Indeed, their background
made me think through my answers a bit longer than I normally would have. I
felt that - especially when the conversation touched on the
Israeli-Palestinian Conflict, Zionism, and, American Jewry - I was,
simultaneously representing my identities as an American, a new Israeli, and
a Jew more broadly.

I must admit, my answer to the question, "why did you move to Israel" is a
bit different when posed by a non-Jew, both in the broader discourse I
engage in, as well as in the specific language I use. How many non-Jews, for
instance, know what the word "Aliyah" means? To what degree do I need to
defend/explain the Israeli Right of Return? Even the word, "Zionist", for
instance, tragically, often has negative connotations for many in the
non-Jewish progressive community - which made me wonder if much of what I
was going to say would be lost in (political) translation.

Further, while conversing with my new friends I was trying hard to take them
and their questions at face value, and not put them in the pre-assigned
category of progressive Europeans (of the Guardian reading variety) who are
hostile towards Israel - and, indeed, there was nothing even remotely
indicating they held such views. And, in fact, I found their erudition quite
refreshing.  Even though they may not be overly informed on the topic of
modern Zionism, their education and open-mindedness allowed them absorb what
I was saying with a broad understanding of the political, cultural, and
religious themes I was exploring. They were truly European in the very best
sense of the word. However, though their English was excellent, and I don't
think they missed much of what I was saying, there is, when discussing
complex matters with non-native English speakers, always the fear that some
of the nuance of the words and phrases you use may get lost or even slightly
misinterpreted.

The most interesting part of our conversation was when my new friend asked
me - during the course of the talk which touched on issues of perceived
Jewish power in the U.S. - to provide any insight I had over the broad
phenomena of anti-Semitism. "Why do you think it occurs", was what he was
wondering.

Boy, there's a topic!!! (And, sure, I realize that some of my friends would
likely ask, "G-d, why couldn't you have kept the conversation a bit lighter?
There's so much to discuss that isn't so controversial and emotional.art,
music, sports, or Croissants!"  But, what can I say, these conversations
seem to follow me.  I, after all, took on this job with CiF Watch for a good
reason.)

Anti-Semitism - what historian Robert Wistrich has referred to as the
world's
<http://www.amazon.com/Antisemitism-Longest-Robert-Solomon-Wistrich/dp/08052
10148> longest hatred - is an issue which has shaped much of my professional
and intellectual life, and one which I have spent a lot of time
contemplating, as well as reading and writing about. There were so many
angles I could have tackled the subject from, as anti-Semitism has gone
through different stages over the years, and varies widely depending on the
part of the world where this phenomena took place. For instance, early
Christian anti-Judaic polemics - predicated largely by Jews' rejection of
Christ, and the related charge that Jews were responsible, as a group, for
the death of Christ (deicide) - dates back to the first or second century
CE, and certainly is/was quite a different creature than 20th century
secular incarnations, such as the racially based anti-Semitism of the Nazis.
And, the modern "progressive" anti-Semitism has some correlation to classic
anti-Semitism, but, in many other respects, varies widely from that dynamic.

However, there were two themes which I thought worth commenting on, having
decided to speak broadly on what I believe to be at the root of much (but,
obviously not all) of the modern manifestation of anti-Semitism. The first
one pertains to the reaction of many non-Jews to a very particularistic
Jewish identity in a world increasingly under the influence of post-identity
politics (which, for the sake of brevity, I didn't explore), and the other,
which I chose to elaborate on, was the reaction to the perception of Jewish
power in the world.

Put simply, I explained - and as I touched on in my CW post about
<http://cifwatch.com/2010/07/16/tisha-bav-and-jewish-power/> Tisha B'Av and
Jewish power - classic anti-Semitism (such as the Jewish conspiracy posited
in The Protocols of the Elders of Zion) was predicated upon the fear of Jews
(Judeophobia, as such) as aliens, different, the other who can't be trusted
and who, it was supposed, meets in secret with other Jews with some
malicious intent, so that anything undesirable, economic or political could
be projected upon the them. In the Middle Ages, Jews, to use but one
example, were accused of being behind the Black Plague.

Today, however, while such wildly conspiratorial narratives pertaining to
the Jews, sadly, still have currency in many parts of the world, by and
large, such views have lost credibility in most of the West, and has instead
morphed into a general fear of Jews insofar as they - who have achieved a
good deal of economic and educational success - are perceived to posses
power which is, in this view, disproportionate to their numbers. Indeed, a
<http://bostonreview.net/BR34.3/malhotra_margalit.php> poll taken during the
height of the economic downturn in the U.S., in 2008, indicated that 25% of
Americans (including 1/3 of those identifying as Democrats) believed that
Jews, as a group, were primarily responsible for the downturn. Jews are no
longer accused in polite circles of "poisoning the wells", but, as
representing in the eyes of many, the ruling class and perceived to be the
group who has benefitted most by the capitalist system, they could be
associated with other modern social and economic miseries which, even for
the well-educated, often defy simple explanations.

This perception of Jews as wielding a disproportionate degree of power and
influence in the world can also be found in critiques suggesting that Jews
exercise too much power over the course of our nation's foreign policy. The
book by Stephen Walt and John Mearsheimer, Israel Lobby and U.S. Foreign
Policy - which argues that many of America's deleterious foreign policy
decisions (such as their support for Israel, as well as the decision, in
2003, to go to war with Iraq)  was only made possible as a result of the
disproportionate influence of the organized Jewish community - is the
intellectual ground zero of such a narrative.  (The Guardian's
<http://cifwatch.com/2010/08/12/jonathan-steele-promotes-%E2%80%98the-big-li
e%E2%80%99/> Jonathan Steele published an essay in August advancing this
ugly narrative of the corrosive effects of organized Jewry on the American
body politic.)

This is obviously a much longer discussion, but, I think that our modern
political culture has come to almost fetishize powerlessness, and, indeed,
much of our discourse seems to almost lionize those perceived to be victims.
It's as if the status of being perceived to be an "underdog" is assumed, a
priori, to carry with it a positive moral dimension - a position which often
allows political actors in the world arena perceived to be weak to get a
sort of moral get-out-of-jail-free card.  Thus, denied the moral agency (the
responsibility for one's moral actions) that we assign to all other
political actors, we can't possibly ask as much from them as we do their
stronger competitor? (Hamas may have an openly anti-Semitic founding
charter, and be at its core, a totally reactionary political movement, but,
it is often argued, at least implicitly, "who are we to condemn their use of
civilians as human shields in their war with Israel"? "What can we expect
from them"? "Look how much stronger the Israeli military is than those
"rag-tag" fighters in Gaza".)

And, as Jews in the West have shown that a historically oppressed minority
can indeed overcome their oppression and succeed and prosper, they are,
tragically, now often on the wrong side of this political paradigm. For,
taking this politics of victimhood to its natural end, if the weakest
members of society are weak for no reason other than the machinations of a
system which oppresses them, then the inverse would naturally be true -
those who benefit most from this same society must invariably reap these
benefits by some nefarious undertakings or at least owing to some inherent
systemic injustice. Much of modern anti-Semitism (and, to some degree,
anti-Zionism), I argued, is only one component within a broader Western
political current which, at its core, is about our perception of the
relationship between power, personal (and group) responsibility, and
success.  Modern Jewry, and the state of Israel - in their example of a
historically oppressed minority who (through their own grit and
determination) overcame their weakness and victimhood and now generally
thrive (socially and economically) both as a people and as a nation - runs
counter to the post-colonial paradigm which often lay at the core of
"progressive" politics.  Many truly seem to resent the Jews for having
emerged from their immemorial weakness - the mission "assigned" to them
since the first diaspora - to achieve, by any standard, to a degree
immensely disproportional to their numbers.  Once seen as powerless (the
wretched of the earth), Jews are now accused of being arrogant, domineering,
and immensely powerful.

I don't know if I necessarily converted my new friends to my view, but they
did genuinely seem interested in what I said, and seemed open-minded to my
explanations.

CiF Watch can only hope that the ideologically dogmatic essayists  (and
their readers) who often display a seemingly reflexive enmity towards Israel
and their Jewish supporters - a dynamic this blog is dedicated to exposing -
will one day be equally as open-minded in their analyses, a bit more
self-critical, and tread more carefully on rhetorical ground that has been
claimed in the service of such a historically lethal hatred.  I don't think
this is too much to ask of a powerful European media enterprise claiming
such an elite "progressive" pedigree.



[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]



------------------------------------

--------------------------
Want to discuss this topic?  Head on over to our discussion list, 
[email protected].
--------------------------
Brooks Isoldi, editor
[email protected]

http://www.intellnet.org

  Post message: [email protected]
  Subscribe:    [email protected]
  Unsubscribe:  [email protected]


*** FAIR USE NOTICE. This message contains copyrighted material whose use has 
not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. OSINT, as a part of 
The Intelligence Network, is making it available without profit to OSINT 
YahooGroups members who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the 
included information in their efforts to advance the understanding of 
intelligence and law enforcement organizations, their activities, methods, 
techniques, human rights, civil liberties, social justice and other 
intelligence related issues, for non-profit research and educational purposes 
only. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of the copyrighted material 
as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use 
this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' 
you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.
For more information go to:
http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtmlYahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/

<*> Your email settings:
    Individual Email | Traditional

<*> To change settings online go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/join
    (Yahoo! ID required)

<*> To change settings via email:
    [email protected] 
    [email protected]

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
    [email protected]

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
    http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/

Reply via email to