The Closing of the Muslim Mind

Posted By Jamie Glazov On October 18, 2010 

Frontpage Interview’s guest today is Robert R. Reilly, a senior fellow at
the American Foreign Policy Council who has written for the Wall Street
Journal, the Washington Post, Reader’s Digest, and National Review, among
many other publications. A member of the board of the Middle East Media
Research Institute and a former director of the Voice of America, he has
taught at the National Defense University, served in the White House and the
Office of the Secretary of Defense. His latest book is The
<http://www.amazon.com/Closing-Muslim-Mind-Intellectual-Islamist/dp/19338599
11/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1275401584&sr=8-1>  Closing of the Muslim
[1]
<http://www.amazon.com/Closing-Muslim-Mind-Intellectual-Islamist/dp/19338599
11/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1275401584&sr=8-1>  Mind: How Intellectual
Suicide Created the Modern Islamist Crisis [1], just been published by ISI
Press.

FP: Robert R. Reilly, welcome to Frontpage Interview.

Let’s begin with what inspired you to write The Closing of the Muslim Mind.

Reilly: Several things.  Professionally, I was working in the “war of ideas”
area both at the Voice of America and then at the Defense Department.  One
cannot fight a war of ideas unless one understands the ideas one is at war
with.  Our 9/11 attackers justified themselves in terms of their Muslim
faith.  Therefore, I was ineluctably led into a deep study of Islamic
theology and into an examination of what constitutes justice in Islam.

I was also intrigued by Bernard Lewis’ work, which so effectively laid out
“what went wrong” in the Islamic world without exactly telling us “why” it
went wrong.  I began searching for the answer. 

FP: What is the main argument of your book and how is your book original?

Reilly: I did not find the answer to my question in any one place, or I
would not have written the book.  I discovered bits and pieces here and
there.  I put them together into what I hope is a coherent answer to the
question of “why it went wrong?” I wrote the book for myself and for any
others who are intrigued by the same question as to how this once great
culture so totally collapsed in on itself and became so frustrated that it
bred these Islamist terrorists.

My general thesis is that Islamism is a spiritual pathology based on a
deformed theology that has produced a dysfunctional culture.  I know this is
a mouthful, and I take some 200 pages to explain it.  In short, the source
of the problem is a profound misconception as to who God is.

FP: Tell us about the Islamic conception of God and how it closes the human
mind.

Reilly: First, I must be careful in saying that I speak only of Sunni Islam,
which is by far the majority expression of the faith.  Within Sunni Islam, I
speak of the Ash‘arite school of theology, which is the majority view within
Sunni Islam, especially so in the Middle East.  I focus on this because the
Arab world is dominant in Islam for the obvious reasons that Mohammed was an
Arab and that the Quran, thought to be the literal word of God, is in
Arabic.  As most Muslims accept the Quran as having existed co-eternally
with God, this means that Arabic is God’s language.

The answer to your question completely hinges on God’s relationship to
reason in Sunni Islam.   Is God reason, or logos, as the Greeks would say?
If God himself is reason, then it is hard to close the mind because one
would then be closing oneself to God.  This, in fact, was the view of the
first fully-developed theological school in Islam, the Mu‘tazilites. The
Mu‘tazalites asserted the primacy of reason, and that one’s first duty is to
engage in reason and, through it, to come to know God. They held that reason
is a gift from God given to come to know Him through the order of his
creation.   All men have this gift, not only Muslims.  Therefore, they were
disposed to accept Greek philosophy and the moral truths it contained.

However, the school of theology that arose to oppose the Mu’tazilites, the
Ash‘arites, held the opposite. Unfortunately, by the end of the ninth
century, they prevailed and became the formative influence in Sunni Islam.
For the Ash‘arites, God is not reason, but pure will and absolute power.  He
is not bound by anything, including his own word.  Since God is pure will,
He has no reasons for his acts.  Thus what He does cannot be understood by
man.   One of the things that God does is create the world, which also
cannot be understood.

To protect their notion of God’s omnipotence, the Ash‘arites denied cause
and effect in the natural world.  For God to be omnipotent, nothing else can
be so much as potent.  Therefore, fire does not burn cotton; God does.
Gravity does not make the rock fall; God does.  God is the direct cause of
everything and there are no secondary causes.  To say otherwise is blasphemy
– comparing something to the incomparable God.  Everything therefore becomes
the equivalent of a miracle. By their very nature, miracles cannot be
understood.  Without causality in the natural order, anything can come of
anything, and nothing necessarily follows.  The world becomes
incomprehensible because it is without a continuing narrative of cause and
effect.

Within our Western tradition, Albert Einstein once remarked that “the most
incomprehensible thing about the universe is that it is comprehensible.”
Thomas Aquinas put it another way. He said that we can understand the world
because it was first “thought” by God.  The universe is the product of
creative reason.  That is why it is comprehensible. The Ash‘arite rejoinder
to Einstein’s statement would be that “the most comprehensible thing about
the world is that it is incomprehensible.”  It must be incomprehensible
because it is the direct consequence of God’s action, of his will, not of
his reason.

Man can only understand that God has given him rules to obey in his
revelation.  As a consequence of its character, this revelation must be
blindly obeyed.  It is not given to be understood or questioned, but to be
complied with.  Put reason aside and submit.  This is how the Sunni Muslim
mind closed.  It undercut reason and its ability to know reality.
Philosophy was forbidden.  To protect its notion of God, it made reality
unknowable.  This had devastating consequences.

FP: Share some statistics and facts with us to illuminate the earthly
incarnations of the closed Muslim mind. In other words, paint for us the
dysfunctional culture of Islam today. 

Reilly: Well, there are tons of statistics put out by the UN Arab Human
Development reports, all written by Arab scholars, by the way.  In brief,
but for sub-Saharan Africa, the 300 million people in the Arab world would
be at the bottom of every measure of human progress – education, literacy,
health care, productivity, GDP, patents, etc.  Original scientific research
is essentially dead.  The effort of science is to discover nature’s laws.
The teaching that these laws do not, in fact, exist (for theological
reasons) is an obvious discouragement to the scientific enterprise.

  _____  

  _____  

Also, it is very revealing that Spain translates almost as many books in a
single year as the Arab world has translated in the last thousand years.
What would Caliph al-Ma’mun, who created the House of Wisdom in Baghdad in
830 A.D. to translate books, think of the state of the Arabic world today?
He would be appalled.

Sometime anecdotes tell as much or more than the statistics, especially
about the effects of the denial of secondary causality on even the most
practical aspects of daily life.  For instance, former British Islamist Ed
Husain relates that “Hizb ut-Tahrir [an organization dedicated to the
restoration of the caliphate] believed that all natural events were acts of
God (though in some actions man could exercise free will), hence insurance
polices were haram . . . Hizb members could not insure their cars.”
Likewise, the use of seatbelts is considered presumptuous.  If one’s
allotted time has arrived, the seatbelt is superfluous.  If it has not, it
is unnecessary.  One must realize that the phrase “in shâ Allah [God
willing]” is not simply a polite social convention, but a theological
doctrine.

Those involved in training Middle Eastern military forces have encountered a
lackadaisical attitude to weapon maintenance and sharp-shooting.  If God
wants the bullet to hit the target, it will and, if He does not, it will
not.  It has little to do with human agency or skills obtained by discipline
and practice.  As the Qur’anic verse states: “When you shot it was not you
who shot but God.” (8:17)

A Kurdish acquaintance told me that he went on the Hajj with a devout friend
who was very much taken by the Ash’arite teaching of God as the only cause.
At the Ka’ba under the hot Saudi sun, his friend touched the black stone,
which was cool.  See, he said, this is God’s direct miraculous action; how
else could this stone be so cool in this heat?  My Kurdish acquaintance
looked around until he found stairs descending to a refrigeration unit.  He
then took his friend down to see it, and explained to him, “This is why the
stone is cool.”  His friend’s reaction to this lesson was outrage.  Rational
knowledge was a threat to his religious certainty.  The refrigeration unit,
a product of rational knowledge, was an assault on his theology.

FP: Why is the West, aside from some few and brave thinkers, so blind in
confronting the Islamist crisis?

Reilly: Self-delusion is one problem and ignorance is another.  Many in the
secular West find it hard to believe that anyone takes religion seriously
anymore.  Since they have lost their faith, they don’t have the ability to
comprehend the terms of faith in anyone else’s life.   In fact, their
incomprehension, their obliviousness to the sacred, is one of the things
that inflames Islam against the West.

We are essentially facing a theological problem and a profound spiritual
disorder.  People ignorant of theology are unable to recognize the nature of
the problem.  They want to create another economic development program in
the Middle East, as if that will solve it.  This is delusional and a total
waste.  The problem needs to be addressed at the level at which it exists,
not by sociologists or psychiatrists.

FP: What hope is there that some kind of “moderate” Islam can ever emerge?

Reilly: I suppose you could say that there is always hope where there is
prayer.  So we had better start praying.

At the end of the nineteenth and the beginning of the twentieth century
there was far more intellectual ferment for reconciling Islam and modern
science, for finding ways to adopt the best of the West to the Muslim world.
These efforts largely failed.  Things are now likely to get worse, not
better.

The intellectual impetus in the Muslim world is not with those who see the
need to reopen the foreclosed questions from the ninth century as to who God
is and what his relationship to reason is.  (There are such Muslim thinkers
but they get no support from us.)  It is with those who wish to return to
the seventh century and replicate the feats of the Companions of the Prophet
in creating the greatest empire the world had seen up to that point.  The
worse things get in the Muslim world, the more support these jihadists
receive because they provide an explanation and a program that can be easily
understood by those who deeply feel the grievances and humiliation of their
situation.

It is not inevitable that the Islamists should succeed, except in the
absence of any strategy to counter them.  Muslim leaders like the former
president of Indonesia, the late Abdurrahman Wahid, the spiritual head of
the largest Muslim organization in the world, Nahdlatul Ulama, have called
for a counter-strategy that would include offering “a compelling alternative
vision of Islam, one that banishes the fanatical ideology of hatred to the
darkness from which it emerged.”  Wahid advocated a partnership with the
non-Muslim world in a massively resourced effort to uphold human dignity,
freedom of conscience, religious freedom, and the benefits of modernity
before the juggernaut of Islamist ideology swamps the Muslim world. It was a
compelling summons. It has yet to be answered.

There is another way to state this at its heart.  The Arab Muslim world
reached its apogee when it was at its most Hellenized, i.e. under the
influence of Greek philosophy.  It then underwent a process of
dehellenization, a divorce from reason and the extirpation of philosophy.
Its path to recovery must be in these same terms – a rehellenization, a
restoration of the status or reason and a return to philosophy.  Is that
possible?  As a twentieth century Moroccan Muslim thinker put it, either the
future of Islam will be Aristotelian, or it will not be.

I think the general theme is how a deformed theology produced a
dysfunctional culture.

FP: Robert R. Reilly, thank you for joining Frontpage Interview.

  _____  

Article printed from FrontPage Magazine: http://frontpagemag.com

URL to article:
http://frontpagemag.com/2010/10/18/the-closing-of-the-muslim-mind/

URLs in this post: 

[1] The Closing of the Muslim:
http://www.amazon.com/Closing-Muslim-Mind-Intellectual-Islamist/dp/193385991
1/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1275401584&sr=8-1

 



[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]



------------------------------------

--------------------------
Want to discuss this topic?  Head on over to our discussion list, 
[email protected].
--------------------------
Brooks Isoldi, editor
[email protected]

http://www.intellnet.org

  Post message: [email protected]
  Subscribe:    [email protected]
  Unsubscribe:  [email protected]


*** FAIR USE NOTICE. This message contains copyrighted material whose use has 
not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. OSINT, as a part of 
The Intelligence Network, is making it available without profit to OSINT 
YahooGroups members who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the 
included information in their efforts to advance the understanding of 
intelligence and law enforcement organizations, their activities, methods, 
techniques, human rights, civil liberties, social justice and other 
intelligence related issues, for non-profit research and educational purposes 
only. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of the copyrighted material 
as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use 
this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' 
you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.
For more information go to:
http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtmlYahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/

<*> Your email settings:
    Individual Email | Traditional

<*> To change settings online go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/join
    (Yahoo! ID required)

<*> To change settings via email:
    [email protected] 
    [email protected]

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
    [email protected]

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
    http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/

Reply via email to