http://www.newswithviews.com/Timothy/baldwin152.htm
IDENTIFYING FREEDOM'S PROBLEMS
PART 1
By Timothy N. Baldwin, JD.
October 13, 2010
NewsWithViews.com
Those who would classify themselves as the enemies of tyranny and advocates
of freedom have offered-and for quite some time-many reasons why the United
States are in the condition they are in. These reasons need to be reduced to
their principle and need to be studied in terms of both society and
government phenomenon before real remedies can be applied to the problems
caused by the reasons. The reasons can be summarized into three main
statements. The problem with the United States:
(1) is not with the United States Constitution ("USC") but with the people
of America;
(2) is not with the USC but with government rulers; and
(3) is with the USC, regardless of the people or rulers.
It is admitted that the complexity of this subject cannot be fully dealt
with in a short article as this, but perhaps the content herein will aspire
more people to truly identify the real causes of our plight so that an
enlightenment of the mind will produce freedom, happiness and peace in all
of the societies in America. To that end, I will take the proposed reasons
in order.
(1) The problem with the United States is not with the USC but with the
people of America.
I find this position to be at best partially correct.
(a) Subjective Perspective of the 'People's Problem'
It is easily admitted and provable that a large number of Americans
(increasingly) do not possess the characters and virtues required to
self-government and limited government, from a subjective perspective. That
is, individual Americans do not possess the required attributes of a
responsible citizen towards fellow man and government, ranging from his lack
of education,[1] <http://www.newswithviews.com/Timothy/baldwin152.htm#_ftn1>
his disingenuous attitude towards politics and his laziness to study and get
involved in preserving freedom. However, laying the blame solely on the
people is a serious mistake. While it is absolutely true that constitutions
do not enforce themselves and thus "it must be the people's fault," it is
equally true that for every cause there is an effect. Thus, where a
constitution is created in such a way as to cause directly or indirectly
certain effects, it is correct to place at least some blame on the cause,
especially where the cause's effects are foreseeable.
The USC has been in effect since 1787. Since then, thousands of federal
politicians have been elected, federal court cases rendered and discussed
and Congressional bills passed and executed throughout generations of
American society. Since then, unrelenting constitutional debates have filled
thousands of volumes and millions of pages to discuss the "true" extent of
the federal government's power by some of the most intelligent and studied
men of history-including men who not only helped draft the USC but also
contributed to declaring the colonies free and independent states in 1776.
These political events have taken place in front of millions of virtuous,
admirable and freedom-loving Americans of every generation. Still, the
effect of the constitutional process blares before our eyes. Thus, it cannot
be true that the problems in society and government are completely
attributable to the people alone.
The result of this 200-plus year constitutional process has produced a
federal government, operation, rule of law and system of what many are
claiming suddenly to be anti-constitutional, as if the federal power and
authority being asserted is somehow new in its origin and basis. Using the
logic and ideology of founders like Alexander Hamilton, Charles Pinckney,
Governor Morris and the like, the federal government is simply exercising
its legitimate, supreme-law-of-the-land authority with plenary power to
implement any and all laws it deems necessary and proper in pursuance of
their powers to provide for the general welfare of the nation of one
body-politic-the American people at large. It is this same logic that the
U.S. Supreme Court has used since 1788 to confirm this same plenary power of
the federal government to pass and execute laws, subject only to their
review as the final arbiter and determiner of the USC.
This 200-plus year application of the USC has proven itself to be very
detrimental to the rights, powers and sovereignty of the State
bodies-politic, not the least offense of which was displayed from 1861-1865.
But even before that time, all three branches of the federal government
slowly but surely claimed powers in the authority of and in pursuance of the
USC that were once held by the states, the U.S. Supreme Court justices
upholding their laws time and time again. This is the nature of humans and
government-especially big government:
"[W]e overlook the changes that insensibly happen by a long train of steps
that are but slightly marked. It would be rendering nations an important
service to show from history how many states have thus entirely changed
their nature, and lost their original constitution."[2]
<http://www.newswithviews.com/Timothy/baldwin152.htm#_ftn2>
If it took over 200 years to reach this point, how much longer would it take
to restore freedom to its 1787 condition when nature works in favor of an
expanding and encroaching government and not in favor of the rights of
individuals and societies?-especially given the position that the problem
with America is the people, not the USC. For as Thomas Jefferson observed,
"[t]he natural progress of things is for liberty to yield and government to
gain ground."[3] <http://www.newswithviews.com/Timothy/baldwin152.htm#_ftn3>
Even if the "original constitution" were proposed to preserve the
sovereignty of the states, virtually any and all resistance displayed by
state governments to protect their sovereignty has been struck down as being
contrary to the national, one-American-body-politic principles of the USC by
the federal government. In essence, state sovereignty is whatever the U.S.
Supreme Court has deemed it to be. Unfortunately, the states have complied
with and submitted to this constitutional interpretation and have largely
done so (with few exceptions) throughout America's history-and for the past
century and more, mostly by accepting federal handouts each year. Their
hands are extended, and while the money is put in one hand, the chains are
shackled around the other.
For more than 100 years, the entire federal government, under both Republic
and Democratic leadership, has declared to the American people and to the
world that it has the power to regulate virtually any matter whatsoever
through its tax and commerce power. During this time, America's "greatest
generation" (the World War II generation) existed and consented to such a
constitutional proclamation, handing down to their posterity the
consequences of such a constitutional application. It was this generation
that consented to Franklin D. Roosevelt's "New Deal" wherein the federal
government's role extended to regulate the smallest of private industry and
consented to the U.S. Supreme Court's decisions, such as Wickard v. Filburn,
317 U.S. 111 (1942), upholding Congress' power to regulate what and how much
crops a private farmer could grow for his personal use. Matters have only
gotten exponentially worse since then, creating more resentment, frustration
and anger in the hearts and minds of the people who long for freedom yet
never find it in the system created by the USC, or at least the people who
have controlled it.
And if the USC has been supposedly raped (as opposed to being pursued) for
as long as it has and the cause of the same is the people of America, why
has there not been an effort to separate from the societies causing the
generation-after-generation demise? After all, if this is true, "show
respect to liberty and your power will increase daily,"[4]
<http://www.newswithviews.com/Timothy/baldwin152.htm#_ftn4> then the power
which has increased daily since 1787 proves that the people and rulers do
not respect liberty but rather respect statism and big government. Still,
this statism and big government has come by way of the USC in its organic
form.
"The worst of all abuses is to pay an apparent obedience to the laws, only
in order to actually break them with security. For in this case the best
laws soon become the most pernicious; and it would be a hundred times better
that they should not exist."[5]
<http://www.newswithviews.com/Timothy/baldwin152.htm#_ftn5>
Problems being perceived as "new" today are actually manifestations of
principles which have been analyzed, accepted and applied for over two
hundred years through constitutional process. While some may argue that the
laws being passed today do not reflect what the "founders intended," they
would be competing against a philosophy developed for many generations and
have to unravel a ball of yarn that has been not only tied into knots but
also glued into place. Trying to argue what the "founders intended" would
prove most ineffectual-especially on a national scale-considering the
differing and opposing views held by the founders and ratifying States, not
to mention societies' views of the founding generation today.
What is clear to many is that freedom will not be restored by trying to go
backwards, but by moving forward on principles found in God's natural and
revealed laws. Is this not what the founding generation did? Were the
founding fathers abandoning their forefathers when they seceded from the
British Constitution or were they pursuing and perpetuating their honorable
sacrifice? In 1776, the conditions were ripe for revolution. In 2010, those
conditions are no less ripe:
"[L]iberty may begin as an internal power, an internal power to reflect upon
the past (to see what might have been different in it) and upon the future
(to see alternative courses of possible action). And liberty may also depend
upon an internal power to choose (both to repent of some things in the past
and to select and choose a new course in the future). But to flourish and
break into blossom, liberty needs the sunny warmth of culture and ideas and
the nourishing rain of favorable institutions of politics and economics. The
inner power to act freely and the hunger to exercise liberty may be
universal, but the cultural and institutional ecology of liberty may for
millennia be unfavorable to its exercise. These interior powers may
therefore slumber in the patience of evolution, until conditions are right.
The blossoming of liberty has in fact required many centuries to unfold.
Only two centuries ago, the Americans of 1776 and 1789 were poignantly aware
of their own uneasy originality. They rejoiced at casting their very first
votes as a free people."[6]
<http://www.newswithviews.com/Timothy/baldwin152.htm#_ftn6>
Federal courts have in very large part not relied upon what some call the
"original intent" but rather have relied upon the construction of the words
of the USC; for as was observed by John Jacques Rousseau, "The power of the
laws depends still more on their own wisdom than on the severity of their
administrators."[7]
<http://www.newswithviews.com/Timothy/baldwin152.htm#_ftn7> Consequently,
the federal government's power has been and would be today considered by
many constitutional scholars as being sound and legitimate given those
factors of constitutional interpretation and application.
Given the hundreds of millions of Americans who have overseen the
constitutional process in America since 1787; the 200-plus year political
process within the three branches of the federal government which have put
flesh on and put into practice the "experiment" of the USC proposed in 1787;
the intense debate and involvement which America's "greatest generation[s]"
and even founding generation existing after 1787 concerning the federal
government's constitutional powers; and the thousands of repeated
confirmation of constitutional federal plenary power, there could hardly be
a legitimate argument made that the political and governmental problems in
America today lie solely with the people and do not lie at all with the USC.
Otherwise, what effect does a constitution really have when it can be
completely destroyed by the simple fact that the people are not capable of
governing themselves? If a constitution is wholly inadequate for an immoral
and irreligious people, then what good is binding yourself to a society and
union that creates the unenforceability of the constitution you claim must
protect your freedom? One would think that a better way to secure freedom
would be first to do what Alexander Hamilton suggested in times of tyranny:
"The people should resolve to RECALL ALL THE POWERS they have heretofore
parted with out of their own hands, and to DIVIDE THEMSELVES INTO AS MANY
STATES [8] <http://www.newswithviews.com/Timothy/baldwin152.htm#_ftn8> AS
THERE ARE COUNTIES, in order that they may be able to manage their own
concerns in person."[9]
<http://www.newswithviews.com/Timothy/baldwin152.htm#_ftn9>
Secondly, all citizens of the state must endeavor to possess the qualities
of self-government, -responsibility and morality, not just write some words
on a piece of paper, call it a constitution and hope that it will govern
people who cannot govern themselves.
"There can be no patriotism without liberty, no liberty without virtue, no
virtue without citizens; create citizens, and you have everything you need;
without them, you will have nothing but debased slaves, from the rulers of
the State downwards. To form citizens is not the work of a day; and in order
to have men it is necessary to educate them when they are children."[10]
<http://www.newswithviews.com/Timothy/baldwin152.htm#_ftn10>
A constitution will only follow the philosophy of the people and will never
have the effect of limiting government where the people do not possess
self-governing characteristics. From the looks of it, the condition
prevalent is not changing anytime soon, which is largely thus:
"The unequal distribution of inhabitants over the territory, when men are
crowded together in one place, while other places are depopulated; the
encouragement of the arts that minister to luxury and of purely industrial
arts at the expense of useful and laborious crafts; the sacrifice of
agriculture to commerce; the necessitation of the tax-farmer by the
mal-administration of the funds of the State; and in short, venality pushed
to such an extreme that even public esteem is reckoned at a cash value, and
virtue rated at a market price: these are the most obvious causes of
opulence and of poverty, of public interest, of mutual hatred among
citizens, of indifference to the common cause, of the corruption of the
people, and of the weakening of all the springs of government. Such are the
evils, which are with difficulty cured."[11]
<http://www.newswithviews.com/Timothy/baldwin152.htm#_ftn11>
At least, the answer lies in a spiritual and mental enlightenment of
individuals who compose the several societies in America. It was only for
the reason that the American people were capable of self-government that the
USC-ratifying generation believed the experiment of the USC could possibly
be successful. The gamble of the experiment was made on that presumption.
However, those presumptive facts no longer exist. It is for this same reason
that for freedom to be restored in American societies, much more will be
needed than "voting the bums out" in Washington D.C.-a futile, ineffectual
and fruitless exercise. Instead, individuals composing the several societies
in America must apply the formulas of freedom in their own society. For part
two click below.
Footnotes:
1. Education is used in the political and philosophical sense and
application.
2. Emer De Vatel, The Law of Nations, Book 1, Sec. 30.
3. Thomas Jefferson and John P. Foley, ed., The Jeffersonian Cyclopedia, A
Comprehensive Collection of the Views of Thomas Jefferson, (New York and
London: Funk & Wagnalls Co., 1900), 387.
4. Jean Jacques Rousseau, A Discourse on Political Economy, from Great Books
of the Western World, Ed., Robert M. Hutchins, Trns. G.D. H. Cole, (Chicago,
IL, Encyclopedia Britannica, Inc., 1952, originally published 1755), 375.
5. Rousseau, A Discourse on Political Economy, 372.
6. Michael Novak, The Universal Hunger For Liberty, Why the Clash of
Civilizations Is Not Inevitable, (New York, NY, Basic Books, 2004), xv-xvi.
7. Rousseau, A Discourse On Political Economy, 371.
8. "State, in which all the individuals being well known to one another,
neither the secret machinations of vice, nor the modesty of virtue should be
able to escape the notice and judgment of the public; and in which the
pleasant custom of seeing and knowing one another should make the love of
country rather a love of the citizens than of its soil." John Jacques
Rousseau, A DISCOURSE ON A SUBJECT PROPOSED BY THE ACADEMY OF DIJON: WHAT IS
THE ORIGIN OF INEQUALITY AMONG MEN, AND IS IT AUTHORISED BY NATURAL LAW?,
from Great Books of the Western World, Ed., Robert M. Hutchins, Trns. G.D.
H. Cole, (Chicago, IL, Encyclopedia Britannica, Inc., 1952, originally
published 1755), 323.
9, Alexander Hamilton, Federalist Paper 26 (emphasis added).
10, Rousseau, A Discourse on Political Economy, 375.
11, Rousseau, A Discourse on Political Economy, 375.
Timothy N. Baldwin is an attorney from Pensacola, FL. He received his
bachelor of arts degree at the University of West Florida in 2001 and
received his Juris Doctorate degree from Cumberland School of Law at Samford
University in 2004. Baldwin was a Prosecutor in the 1st District of Florida
from 2004 to 2006. In 2006, he started his own law practice, where he
created specialized legal services entirely for property management
companies.
Like his father, Chuck Baldwin <http://www.chuckbaldwinlive.com/> , Timothy
Baldwin is an astute articulator of cutting-edge political ideas, which he
posts on his website, www.libertydefenseleague.com
<http://libertydefenseleague.com/liberty/> and speaks about in various
public forum. Baldwin is the author of Freedom For A Change
<http://libertydefenseleague.com/freedom-for-a-change/buy-from-the-author/>
, in which he expounds the fundamental principles of freedom believed by
America's forefathers and gives inspiring and intelligent application of
those principles to America's current political and cultural standing.
Baldwin believes that the times require all freedom-loving Americans to
educate, invigorate and activate the principles of freedom within the STATES
of America for ourselves and our posterity.
Web site: LibertyDefenseLeague <http://libertydefenseleague.com/liberty/>
[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
------------------------------------
--------------------------
Want to discuss this topic? Head on over to our discussion list,
[email protected].
--------------------------
Brooks Isoldi, editor
[email protected]
http://www.intellnet.org
Post message: [email protected]
Subscribe: [email protected]
Unsubscribe: [email protected]
*** FAIR USE NOTICE. This message contains copyrighted material whose use has
not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. OSINT, as a part of
The Intelligence Network, is making it available without profit to OSINT
YahooGroups members who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the
included information in their efforts to advance the understanding of
intelligence and law enforcement organizations, their activities, methods,
techniques, human rights, civil liberties, social justice and other
intelligence related issues, for non-profit research and educational purposes
only. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of the copyrighted material
as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use
this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,'
you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.
For more information go to:
http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtmlYahoo! Groups Links
<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/
<*> Your email settings:
Individual Email | Traditional
<*> To change settings online go to:
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/join
(Yahoo! ID required)
<*> To change settings via email:
[email protected]
[email protected]
<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
[email protected]
<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/