http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2010-10-25/u-s-treasury-shielding-of-citigroup
-with-deletions-make-foia-meaningless.html

 

Treasury Shields Citigroup as Deletions Undercut Disclosure

By Bob Ivry - Oct 25, 2010 6:09 PM ET 

*        
*       Tweet
<http://twitter.com/home?status=http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2010-10-25/u-s
-treasury-shielding-of-citigroup-with-deletions-make-foia-meaningless.html>
(222)
*       LinkedIn 
*       Share
<http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2010-10-25/u-s-treasury-shielding-of-citigrou
p-with-deletions-make-foia-meaningless.html#share>  

*       Business
<http://bx.businessweek.com/api/add-article-to-bx.tn?url=http://www.bloomber
g.com/news/2010-10-25/u-s-treasury-shielding-of-citigroup-with-deletions-mak
e-foia-meaningless.html>  Exchange
*       Buzz up!
*       Digg

*       Print
<http://www.bloomberg.com/news/print/2010-10-25/u-s-treasury-shielding-of-ci
tigroup-with-deletions-make-foia-meaningless.html>  
*       Email
<mailto:?body=Treasury%2520Shields%2520Citigroup%2520as%2520Deletions%2520Un
dercut%2520Disclosure%0A%0Ahttp%3A%2F%2Fwww.bloomberg.com%2Fnews%2F2010-10-2
5%2Fu-s-treasury-shielding-of-citigroup-with-deletions-make-foia-meaningless
.html&subject=Bloomberg%20news%3A%20Treasury%2520Shields%2520Citigroup%2520a
s%2520Deletions%2520Undercut%2520Disclosure>  

Treasury Shielding Citigroup 

A Citi logo appears on a flag flying outside the Citigroup Inc. headquarters
in New York. Photographer: Daniel Acker/Bloomberg 

Treasury Shields Citigroup as FOIA Made Meaningless 

 

 <http://www.bloomberg.com/video/63975218/> Play Video

Oct. 25 (Bloomberg) -- The late Bloomberg News reporter Mark Pittman asked
the U.S. Treasury in January 2009 to identify $301 billion of securities
owned by Citigroup Inc. that the government had agreed to guarantee. He made
the request under the federal Freedom of Information Act on the grounds that
taxpayers ought to know how their money was being used. More than 20 months
later, after saying at least five times that a response was imminent,
Treasury officials responded with 560 pages of printed-out e-mails, none of
which Pittman requested. Bloomberg's Suzanne O'Halloran reports. (Source:
Bloomberg) 

Louisiana State University Finance Professor Joseph Mason 

Finance professor at the Ourso College of Business at Louisiana State
University Joseph Mason, seen here, said more openness concerning the causes
of the crisis and the government's response would help the economy recover.
Photographer: Chris Keane/Bloomberg 

The late Bloomberg News reporter Mark Pittman
<http://search.bloomberg.com/search?q=Mark%20Pittman&site=wnews&client=wnews
&proxystylesheet=wnews&output=xml_no_dtd&ie=UTF-8&oe=UTF-8&filter=p&getfield
s=wnnis&sort=date:D:S:d1&partialfields=-wnnis:NOAVSYND&lr=-lang_ja>  asked
the U.S. Treasury in January 2009 to identify $301 billion of securities
owned by Citigroup <http://www.ustreas.gov/press/releases/hp1287.htm>  Inc.
that the government had agreed to guarantee
<http://www.ustreas.gov/press/releases/hp1356.htm> . He made the request on
the grounds that taxpayers ought to know how their money was being used. 

More than 20 months later, after saying at least five times that a response
was imminent, Treasury officials responded with 560 pages of printed-out
e-mails -- none of which Pittman requested. They were so heavily redacted
that most of what's left are everyday messages such as "Did you just try to
call me?" and "Monday will be a busy day!" 

None of the documents answers Pittman's request for "records sufficient to
show the names of the relevant securities" or the dates and terms of the
guarantees. Even so, the U.S. government considers the collection of e-mails
a partial response to an official request under the federal Freedom of
<http://www.justice.gov/oip/>  Information Act, or FOIA. The Justice
Department in July cited
<http://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/2010/July/10-ag-872.html>  an increase in
such responses as evidence that "more information is being released" under
the law. 

President Barack Obama
<http://search.bloomberg.com/search?q=Barack%20Obama&site=wnews&client=wnews
&proxystylesheet=wnews&output=xml_no_dtd&ie=UTF-8&oe=UTF-8&filter=p&getfield
s=wnnis&sort=date:D:S:d1&partialfields=-wnnis:NOAVSYND&lr=-lang_ja>  vowed
to usher in a new era of open government. On Jan. 21, 2009, the day after
his inauguration and a week before Pittman submitted his FOIA request, Obama
directed
<http://www.whitehouse.gov/the_press_office/FreedomofInformationAct/>
agencies to "adopt a presumption in favor of disclosure, in order to renew
their commitment to the principles embodied in FOIA." 

Limits of Transparency 

The saga of Pittman's request shows that the promise of transparency has its
limits when it comes to the government's intervention in the financial
industry, which at its peak reached $12.8 trillion in commitments. From the
2008 Bear Stearns Cos. rescue to the Federal Reserve's policy of
quantitative easing in 2010, the Obama administration has delayed
disclosures and defended its right to secrecy in court, said Tom Fitton
<http://search.bloomberg.com/search?q=Tom%20Fitton&site=wnews&client=wnews&p
roxystylesheet=wnews&output=xml_no_dtd&ie=UTF-8&oe=UTF-8&filter=p&getfields=
wnnis&sort=date:D:S:d1&partialfields=-wnnis:NOAVSYND&lr=-lang_ja> ,
president of Judicial Watch Inc. <http://www.judicialwatch.org/> , which
describes itself as a conservative foundation. 

"This is an unprecedented crisis for open government," said Fitton, whose
Washington-based organization says it sued the Bush administration 48 times
over disclosure issues. "When it comes to the bank bailout, the Obama
administration has made a decision to err on the side of secrecy." 

The Justice Department, which oversees disclosure for the executive branch,
is "working specifically to encourage agencies to be as transparent as
possible and release as much as possible," said Melanie Ann Pustay
<http://search.bloomberg.com/search?q=Melanie%20Ann%20Pustay&site=wnews&clie
nt=wnews&proxystylesheet=wnews&output=xml_no_dtd&ie=UTF-8&oe=UTF-8&filter=p&
getfields=wnnis&sort=date:D:S:d1&partialfields=-wnnis:NOAVSYND&lr=-lang_ja>
, director of the department's Office of Information Policy. "We view our
efforts as an ongoing process." 

Openness Aids Recovery 

More openness concerning the causes of the crisis and the government's
response would help the economy recover, said Joseph Mason
<http://search.bloomberg.com/search?q=Joseph%20Mason&site=wnews&client=wnews
&proxystylesheet=wnews&output=xml_no_dtd&ie=UTF-8&oe=UTF-8&filter=p&getfield
s=wnnis&sort=date:D:S:d1&partialfields=-wnnis:NOAVSYND&lr=-lang_ja> , a
finance professor at the Ourso College of Business at Louisiana State
University in Baton Rouge. 

"Investors who don't have information are investors who refuse to place
funds in markets," Mason said. "If we want investment and economic growth to
resume, we want to be forthright about what happened. The longer we keep
investors in the dark, the longer that low economic growth will persist." 

The public has a particular interest in transparency regarding the
government's unprecedented intervention in capital markets because of its
sheer size, said U.S. Representative Darrell Issa
<http://search.bloomberg.com/search?q=Darrell%20Issa&site=wnews&client=wnews
&proxystylesheet=wnews&output=xml_no_dtd&ie=UTF-8&oe=UTF-8&filter=p&getfield
s=wnnis&sort=date:D:S:d1&partialfields=-wnnis:NOAVSYND&lr=-lang_ja>  of
California, the ranking Republican on the Committee on Oversight and
Government Reform. He called the Obama administration "woefully inadequate"
at fulfilling its promise of transparency. 

Right to Know 

"At a time when the role of government and more specifically the Treasury
Department, through bailouts and stimulus, is responsible for administering
trillions of dollars, there couldn't be a more important time to uphold the
American people's right to know," Issa said in an e-mail. 

On Jan. 28, 2009, Pittman asked Treasury officials for details related to
guarantees the agency had provided on securities held by Citigroup, American
International Group Inc. and Bank
<http://www.bloomberg.com/apps/quote?ticker=BAC:US>  of America Corp. Among
other things, he asked for any contracts with outside firms hired to
calculate the assets' values. 

In its response, Treasury said AIG
<http://www.bloomberg.com/apps/quote?ticker=AIG:US>  didn't participate in
its Asset Guarantee Program. Likewise, despite some negotiations, the
government and Charlotte, North Carolina-based Bank of America "never
entered into a definitive agreement," the response said. 

Citigroup's Largest Shareholder 

That left Citigroup, in which the U.S. government was the largest
<http://www.bloomberg.com/apps/quote?ticker=C:US>  shareholder as of Oct. 1,
according to regulatory filings. Taxpayers' stake, 12.4 percent, was three
times the second-largest investor's. 

In the 560 pages of e-mails exchanged in the last two months of 2008 and
January 2009, Treasury employees and their colleagues at the Federal Reserve
Bank of New York discuss with attorneys the department's $20 billion
investment in New York- based Citigroup and the $301 billion in guarantees.
Both followed an initial $25 billion investment in Citigroup through the
Troubled Asset Relief Program in October 2008. 

The Treasury Department also released 169 pages that included a "Securities
Purchase Agreement" between the bank, the agency and the Federal Deposit
Insurance Corp. The document had previously been disclosed in a Jan. 16,
2009, Citigroup regulatory <http://www.bloomberg.com/apps/quote?ticker=C:US>
filing -- almost two weeks before Pittman sent his request. 

Exemptions Cited 

The department held back 866 more pages, saying each was exempt from
disclosure on one of four grounds: trade secrets, personnel rules and
practices, memos <http://www.justice.gov/oip/exemption5.htm>  subject to
attorney-client privilege and violations of personal privacy. 

Treasury also cited the trade-secrets exemption in responding to a separate,
similar FOIA request by Bloomberg News for details about Citigroup's
segregated bad assets. In that response, 73 of 104 pages were completely
blacked out except for headings. Only six pages -- the cover, contents, a
boilerplate list of legal disclosures and a paragraph titled "FOIA Request
for Confidential Treatment" -- were free of redactions. 

The department's reply to Pittman's request will count statistically as a
"partial response," in government reports, said Hugh Gilmore, Treasury's
FOIA public liaison. The response "adhered to the rules, regulations, U.S.
attorney general guidance
<http://www.justice.gov/ag/foia-memo-march2009.pdf>  and relevant case law
that govern FOIA," Steven Adamske
<http://search.bloomberg.com/search?q=Steven%20Adamske&site=wnews&client=wne
ws&proxystylesheet=wnews&output=xml_no_dtd&ie=UTF-8&oe=UTF-8&filter=p&getfie
lds=wnnis&sort=date:D:S:d1&partialfields=-wnnis:NOAVSYND&lr=-lang_ja> , a
Treasury spokesman, said in an e-mail. 

Right of Appeal 

People who aren't satisfied with federal agencies' responses under FOIA can
appeal to them first, and then file civil lawsuits in U.S. District Court to
try to force more disclosure. 

Bloomberg LP, the parent company of Bloomberg News, sued the Fed over
another Pittman FOIA request that sought the names of banks that took
emergency loans from the central bank. The company has prevailed in U.S.
District Court and on appeal. The Fed, which has not released the
information, has until tomorrow to decide whether to ask the U.S. Supreme
Court to consider the case. 

Like the Treasury Department, the central bank cited the exemption for trade
secrets, known as exemption 4, in withholding details about borrowers. Its
lawyers argued that disclosing the banks' identities would put the
institutions at a competitive disadvantage and make them less likely to seek
emergency loans in the future. 

In an Aug. 24, 2009, ruling, Chief U.S. District Judge Loretta A. Preska
<http://search.bloomberg.com/search?q=Loretta%20A.%20Preska&site=wnews&clien
t=wnews&proxystylesheet=wnews&output=xml_no_dtd&ie=UTF-8&oe=UTF-8&filter=p&g
etfields=wnnis&sort=date:D:S:d1&partialfields=-wnnis:NOAVSYND&lr=-lang_ja>
in Manhattan disagreed. 

'An Inherent Risk' 

"The risk of looking weak to competitors and shareholders is an inherent
risk of market participation; information tending to increase that risk does
not make the information privileged or confidential," Preska wrote. The Fed
"would seemingly sweep within the scope of Exemption 4 all information about
borrowers that anyone throughout the entire marketplace might consider to be
negative. The exemption cannot withstand such inflation." 

Pittman's request for the Treasury Department records spent months in limbo,
according to discussions with the agency's employees. He had waited about 10
months for a response when he died on Nov. 25, 2009. Shortly afterward,
Michael Galleher, an attorney working on contract for the Treasury
Department, called Bloomberg News, asking where he could send the responsive
documents. Attempts to return Galleher's call failed; he couldn't be found
at the agency. 

A December call to Gilmore, the FOIA liaison, was returned by Daneisha
White, a FOIA officer, who suggested calling Michael C. Bell, the FOIA
manager in the Office of Financial Stability
<http://www.financialstability.gov/> . Bell referred questions back to
Gilmore. 

Meanwhile, that month, Citigroup repaid $20 billion of its bailout money and
terminated the asset guarantees. 

Searching for Records 

Gilmore called back in January, saying Galleher had left the agency at the
end of 2009. He and his colleagues would search for Pittman's FOIA
documents, he said, because they weren't sure where they were. 

In April came a call from Galleher. He said that he had returned to work at
Treasury's FOIA office, that he had the relevant documents for Pittman's
request and that he would send them that week. 

"I need to clear the old requests," he said. 

The office where Gilmore works, which has the equivalent of 26 fulltime
employees, handled 890 FOIA requests in fiscal 2009, according to Treasury's
annual FOIA report
<http://www.ustreas.gov/foia/reports/2009%20FOIA%20Annual%20Report%20DOJ%20C
hanges%201%200-%20FINAL.pdf>  to the attorney general. It had 1,766 requests
pending at year's end. 

Government bureaucracies often aren't staffed enough to respond adequately
to requests for public records, said Lucy Dalglish
<http://search.bloomberg.com/search?q=Lucy%20Dalglish&site=wnews&client=wnew
s&proxystylesheet=wnews&output=xml_no_dtd&ie=UTF-8&oe=UTF-8&filter=p&getfiel
ds=wnnis&sort=date:D:S:d1&partialfields=-wnnis:NOAVSYND&lr=-lang_ja> ,
executive director of the Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press in
Arlington, Virginia. In addition, she said, they're simply not motivated to
disclose. 

'Disappointed? Yeah' 

"Agencies get in far more trouble for releasing information than they do for
not," she said. "Am I disappointed in the Obama administration? Yeah." 

In May, Galleher reported that he would have something to send soon. He said
the same thing in June, and then in July. Part of the holdup was caused by
the governmentwide practice of giving private companies a chance to object
to the disclosure of requested documents, he said. Doing so ensures that
companies continue to cooperate with the executive branch by providing
records without fear they'll be made public without review, said Pustay of
the Justice Department. 

Neither Citigroup nor the Treasury Department would discuss which
redactions, if any, the bank sought on Pittman's request. Shannon Bell
<http://search.bloomberg.com/search?q=Shannon%20Bell&site=wnews&client=wnews
&proxystylesheet=wnews&output=xml_no_dtd&ie=UTF-8&oe=UTF-8&filter=p&getfield
s=wnnis&sort=date:D:S:d1&partialfields=-wnnis:NOAVSYND&lr=-lang_ja> , a
spokeswoman for the bank, declined to comment. 

"We have no obligation to explain how much of Citi's recommendations we
accepted and in what ways we decided to differ," Adamske, the Treasury
spokesman, said in an e-mail. 

Second-guessing the government's response to the financial crisis is not
useful, said Wilbur Ross
<http://search.bloomberg.com/search?q=Wilbur%20Ross&site=wnews&client=wnews&;
proxystylesheet=wnews&output=xml_no_dtd&ie=UTF-8&oe=UTF-8&filter=p&getfields
=wnnis&sort=date:D:S:d1&partialfields=-wnnis:NOAVSYND&lr=-lang_ja> , the New
York billionaire who runs the private-equity firm WL Ross & Co. 

"As far as I can tell, there is no evidence of any impure motivation in
connection with any of the big decisions," Ross said in an e-mail. "To me
that is the issue, not whether you or I would have come to the same
conclusion." 

 



[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]



------------------------------------

--------------------------
Want to discuss this topic?  Head on over to our discussion list, 
[email protected].
--------------------------
Brooks Isoldi, editor
[email protected]

http://www.intellnet.org

  Post message: [email protected]
  Subscribe:    [email protected]
  Unsubscribe:  [email protected]


*** FAIR USE NOTICE. This message contains copyrighted material whose use has 
not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. OSINT, as a part of 
The Intelligence Network, is making it available without profit to OSINT 
YahooGroups members who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the 
included information in their efforts to advance the understanding of 
intelligence and law enforcement organizations, their activities, methods, 
techniques, human rights, civil liberties, social justice and other 
intelligence related issues, for non-profit research and educational purposes 
only. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of the copyrighted material 
as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use 
this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' 
you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.
For more information go to:
http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtmlYahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/

<*> Your email settings:
    Individual Email | Traditional

<*> To change settings online go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/join
    (Yahoo! ID required)

<*> To change settings via email:
    [email protected] 
    [email protected]

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
    [email protected]

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
    http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/

Reply via email to