http://www.jewishworldreview.com/0111/glick011811.php3

 

Jan. 18, 2011 

Tunisia's lessons for Washington 

by Caroline B. Glick 

 


Tunisian president's regime was not the only thing destroyed. The two main
foundations of 'expert' Western analysis of the Mideast have also been
undone 

If at the height of the anti-government protests in Tunisia last week,
Israel and the Palestinians had signed a final peace deal, would the
protesters have packed up their placards and gone home? 

Of course not.

So what does it tell us the nature of US Middle East policy that at the
height of the anti-regime protests in Tunisia, the White House was consumed
with the question of how to jump start the mordant peace process between the
Palestinians and Israel? 

According to Politico, as the first popular revolution in modern Arab
history was in full swing, last week the White House organized two "task
forces" to produce "new ideas" for getting the Palestinians to agree to sit
down with Israeli negotiators. The first task force is comprised of former
Clinton and Bush national security advisers Sandy Berger and Stephen Hadley.

The second is led by former US ambassador to Israel under the Clinton
administration Martin Indyk.

And as these experts were getting in gear, US President Barak Obama
dispatched his advisor and former Middle East peace envoy under the Bush 1,
Clinton and Bush 2 administrations Dennis Ross to Israel to meet with
Israeli and Palestinian leaders to ask them to put out "new ideas."
Amazingly, none of these task forces or meetings has come up with anything
new.

Again, according to Politico, these task forces and consultations generated
three possible moves for the Obama White House. First, it can put more
pressure on Israel by announcing US support for a "peace plan" that would
require Israel to surrender its capital city and defensible borders.

Second, the US can pressure Israel by seeking to destabilize Prime Minister
Binyamin Netanyahu's government.

And third, the US can pressure Israel by pumping still more money into the
coffers of the unelected Palestinian government and so raise expectations
that the US supports the unelected Palestinian government's plan to declare
independence without agreeing to live at peace with Israel.

So much for new ideas. 

http://www.jewishworldreview.com/../cols2/dingbat.gif

 

THEN THERE is the unfolding drama in Lebanon. It is hard to think of a
greater slap on the face than the one Hizbullah and Syria delivered to Obama
last Wednesday. Hizbullah brought down Lebanese Prime Minister Saad Hariri's
government with the open and active support of Syria while Obama was meeting
with Hariri in the Oval Office.

And how did Obama respond to this slap in the face? By dispatching
Ambassador Robert Ford to Damascus to take up his new post as the first US
ambassador in Syria since Syria and Hizbullah colluded to assassinate
Hariri's father, former Lebanese prime minister Rafik Hariri six years ago.

Reality is crashing in on the Obama administration. But rather than face the
challenges presented by reality, the Obama administration is burying its
head in the sand. And it is burying it head in the sand with the firm
support of the inbred US foreign policy elite.


The overthrow of Tunisian President Zine El Abedine Ben Ali last Friday is a
watershed event in the Arab world. It is far too early to even venture a
guess about how Tunisia will look a year from now. But it is not too early
to understand that Ben Ali's regime was not the only thing destroyed last
Friday. The two main foundations of "expert" Western analysis of the Middle
East have also been undone.

The first foundation of what has passed as Western wisdom about the region
is that the only that thing that motivates the proverbial "Arab street" to
act is hatred of Israel.

For nearly a generation, successive US administrations have based their
Middle East policies on the collective wisdom of the likes of Ross, Hadley,
Berger, Indyk, George Mitchell, Dan Kurtzer, and Tony Blair. And for nearly
a generation, these wise men have argued that Arab reform, democracy, human
rights, women's rights, minority rights, religious freedom, economic
development and the rule of law can only be addressed after a peace treaty
is signed between Israel and the Palestinians. In their "expert" view, Arab
autocrats and their repressed subjects alike are so upset by the plight of
the Palestinians that they can't be bothered with their own lives.

Tunisia's revolution exposes this "wisdom," as complete and utter piffle.
Like people everywhere, what most interests Arabs is their own standard of
living, their relative freedom or lack thereof, and their prospects for the
future.

Mohammed Bouazizi, the 26-year-old Tunisian college graduate who set himself
on fire last month after regime security forces destroyed his unlicensed
produce cart did not act as he did because of Israel.

The Egyptian man who set himself on fire in Cairo on Monday outside the
Egyptian parliament, and the Algerian man who set himself on fire in Tebessa
on Sunday, did not choose to self-immolate in the public square because of
their concern for the Palestinians. So too, the anti-regime demonstrators in
Jordan are not demonstrating because there is no Palestinian state west of
the Jordan River.

The Tunisian revolution demonstrates that "Arab unity" and commitment to
"Palestinian rights," is little more than a sop for Western "experts."

The chief concern of Arab dictators is not Israel, but the prolongation of
their grip on power. From their perspective, one of the keys to maintaining
their iron grip on power is neutralizing US support for freedom.

By arguing that Israel is the root cause of all Arab pathologies, Arab
despots put the US on the defensive. Having to defend its support for the
hated Jews, the US feels less comfortable criticizing the dictators for
their repression of their own people. And without the Americans breathing
down their backs, Arab dictators can sleep more or less easily. Since Europe
doesn't mind that they trample human rights, only the US constitutes a
threat to the legitimacy of these Arab autocrats' iron fisted repression of
their people.

And this brings us to the second fallacious foundation of "expert" Western
analysis of the Middle East destroyed by the recent events in Tunisia. That
foundation is the belief that it is possible and desirable to build a stable
alliance structure on the back of dictatorships.

Tunisia's revolution exposed two basic truths about relationships with
dictatorships. First, they cannot outlast the regime. Since dictators
represent no one but themselves, when the dictator leaves the scene, no one
will feel bound by his decisions.

The second fundamental truth exposed by Ben Ali's overthrow is that all
power is fleeting. Ben Ali's day came last Friday. The day of his Arab
despot brethren will also arrive. And when they are overthrown, their
alliances will be overthrown with them. To a significant degree, the Obama
administration's failure to understand the chronic instability of
dictatorships explains its obsession with appeasing Syrian dictator Bashar
Assad. Because the US wrongly assumes that Assad's regime is inherently
stable, it misunderstands Assad's rationale for preferring Iran and
Hizbullah to the US.

Assad is a member of the Alawite minority community. He fears his people not
only because he represses them through state terror, but because given his
Alawite identity, most Syrians do not view him as one of them.

As dictators and murderers themselves, Iran's ayatollahs and Hizbullah's
terror masters support Assad's regime in a way that the US never could, even
if it wished to. Indeed, as Assad sees things, given the nature of his
regime, there is no chance that an alliance with the US would do anything
but weaken his regime's grip on power.

US attempts to build relations with Assad tell this dictator two seemingly
contradictory things at the same time. First they signal to him that his
alliance with Iran and Hizbullah strengthen his regional stature. Without
those alliances, the US would not be interested in appeasing him.

Second, due to the chronic instability of his tyrannical terror state, and
his consequent utter fear of democracy, Assad views American attempts to
draw him into the Western alliance as bids to overthrow his regime. The more
the likes of Obama and Clinton seek to draw him in, the more convinced he
will become that they are in league with Israel to bring him down. 

http://www.jewishworldreview.com/../cols2/dingbat.gif

 

ON THE face of it, the Tunisian revolution vindicates former president
George W. Bush's policy of pushing democratization of the Arab world. As
Bush recognized in the aftermath of the 9/11 attacks, the US is poorly
served by relying on dictators who maintain their power on the backs of
their people.

Bush got into trouble however by seeing a straight line between the problem
and his chosen solution of elections. As the Hamas victory in the
Palestinian Authority and the Muslim Brotherhood's victories in Egypt's
parliamentary elections on the one hand, and the undermining of pro- Western
democratically elected governments in Lebanon, Afghanistan and Iraq on the
other hand made clear, elections are not the solution to authoritarianism.

The Tunisian revolution provides several lessons for US policymakers. First,
by reminding us of the inherent frailty of alliances with dictatorships,
Tunisia demonstrates the strategic imperative of a strong Israel. As the
only stable democracy in the region, Israel is the US's only reliable ally
in the Middle East. A strong, secure Israel is the only permanent guarantor
of US strategic interests in the Middle East.

Second, the US should proceed with great caution as it considers its ties
with the Arab world. All bets must be hedged. This means that the US must
maintain close ties with as many regimes as possible so that none are viewed
as irreplaceable.

Saudi Arabia has to be balanced with Iraq, and support for a new regime in
Iran. Support for Egypt needs to be balanced with close relations with South
Sudan, and other North African states.

As for engendering democratic alternatives, the US must ensure that it does
not make any promises it has no intention of keeping. The current tragedy in
Lebanon is a blow to US prestige because Washington broke its promise to
stand by the March 14 movement against Hizbullah.

At the same time, the US should fund and publicly support liberal democratic
movements when those emerge. It should also fund less liberal democratic
movements when they emerge. So too, given the strength of Islamist media,
the US should make judicious use of its Arabic-language media outlets to
sell its own message of liberal democracy to the Arab world.

Tunisia's revolution is an extraordinary event. And like other extraordinary
events, its repercussions are being felt far beyond its borders.
Unfortunately, the behavior of the Obama administration signals that it is
unwilling to acknowledge the importance of what is happening.

If the Obama administration persists in ignoring the fundamental truths
exposed by the popular overthrow of Tunisia's dictator, it will not simply
marginalize US power in the Middle East. It will imperil US interests in the
Middle East.

 

 



[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]



------------------------------------

--------------------------
Want to discuss this topic?  Head on over to our discussion list, 
[email protected].
--------------------------
Brooks Isoldi, editor
[email protected]

http://www.intellnet.org

  Post message: [email protected]
  Subscribe:    [email protected]
  Unsubscribe:  [email protected]


*** FAIR USE NOTICE. This message contains copyrighted material whose use has 
not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. OSINT, as a part of 
The Intelligence Network, is making it available without profit to OSINT 
YahooGroups members who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the 
included information in their efforts to advance the understanding of 
intelligence and law enforcement organizations, their activities, methods, 
techniques, human rights, civil liberties, social justice and other 
intelligence related issues, for non-profit research and educational purposes 
only. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of the copyrighted material 
as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use 
this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' 
you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.
For more information go to:
http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtmlYahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/

<*> Your email settings:
    Individual Email | Traditional

<*> To change settings online go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/join
    (Yahoo! ID required)

<*> To change settings via email:
    [email protected] 
    [email protected]

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
    [email protected]

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
    http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/

Reply via email to