http://www.nytimes.com/2011/01/18/nyregion/18defense.html?_r=1
<http://www.nytimes.com/2011/01/18/nyregion/18defense.html?_r=1&partner=rss&;
emc=rss> &partner=rss&emc=rss

 

January 17, 2011


Ghailani’s Lawyers Detail Terror Defense Strategy


By BENJAMIN WEISER
<http://topics.nytimes.com/top/reference/timestopics/people/w/benjamin_weise
r/index.html?inline=nyt-per> 


The jury had been deliberating over four days in the trial of Ahmed Khalfan
Ghailani
<http://www.nytimes.com/2010/11/18/nyregion/18ghailani.html?_r=1&scp=1&sq=Gh
ailani&st=cse>  when it sent a note to the judge, asking how much the
defendant needed to know about Al Qaeda
<http://topics.nytimes.com/top/reference/timestopics/organizations/a/al_qaed
a/index.html?inline=nyt-org> ’s conspiracies to bomb and kill in order to be
convicted. 

To the defense lawyers, the issue of what their client knew was pivotal, as
they had been arguing that Mr. Ghailani — the first former Guantánamo
detainee tried in a civilian court — was duped into assisting in the 1998
conspiracy to bomb two American Embassies in East Africa. 

“This is it right here,” one lawyer, Steve Zissou, wrote in an e-mail to the
rest of the defense team, about two hours after the federal jury in
Manhattan concluded deliberations for the day on Nov. 16. “The entire case
rests on this charge. Everybody please think and dream about this all night
and let’s be ready tomorrow.” 

The next morning, the judge gave the jury a new instruction, including key
language sought by the defense. Late that afternoon, Mr. Ghailani was
acquitted of more than 280 counts of murder and conspiracy, while being
convicted of just one count of conspiracy to destroy government buildings
and property. The jury also found that his conduct had directly caused the
death of a person, which meant that he could receive life imprisonment when
he is sentenced next Tuesday. 

The jury has not explained how it reached that decision, and with conjecture
that the verdict reflected a compromise by a sharply divided panel, no one
knows what the jurors had believed about Mr. Ghailani’s guilt or innocence. 

Still, the verdict was a surprising counterpoint to the overwhelming number
of convictions in similar terrorism trials in the United States, and has
deepened the debate over the use of civilian courts for terrorism detainees.


Prosecutors declined to comment for this article. But they made clear in a
filing on Friday that they believed evidence showed that Mr. Ghailani, 36,
was a knowing participant in the plot, and that in convicting him of
destroying property — and finding that his conduct caused death — the jury
rejected the characterization of him as an innocent dupe. 

Prosecutors are seeking life imprisonment, the same term he would have faced
had he been convicted of every count. Such an outcome could make the
acquittals seem a hollow victory; indeed, his lawyers say their reaction has
been tempered by that prospect. 

But the lawyers said they felt the verdict validated their strategy of
portraying Mr. Ghailani as an unwitting pawn in the Qaeda conspiracy. 

“It would be impossible, I would think, for a jury to have found ‘not
guilty’ on all of those counts if they had not accepted our defense that he
did not know and that he was used,” Peter E. Quijano, the lead defense
counsel, said. “It’s as simple as that.” 

In their first extensive interviews since the verdict, Mr. Ghailani’s
lawyers provided a rare look inside a terrorism trial, albeit a one-sided
view. They discussed how their strategy evolved as their relationship with
their client developed. Some provided copies of e-mails they exchanged in
the final hours of the case, as they pushed back against the government’s
response to the jury’s last question. They also described the pendulum of
emotions as they reassessed their initial assumption that the jury was
overwhelmingly against them. 

What Jury Wasn’t Told 

The challenges for the defense were formidable. 

The prosecutors had described Mr. Ghailani as an integral member of the
Qaeda cell that carried out the bombings that killed 224 people in Nairobi,
Kenya, and Dar es Salaam, Tanzania — “Al Qaeda’s most spectacular attack to
that point on America,” a prosecutor, Harry Chernoff, said in his closing
argument. 

Mr. Ghailani, he added, had “the blood of hundreds on his hands.” 

But some of the most potentially damaging evidence against Mr. Ghailani was
never heard by the jury. 

On the eve of the trial, the judge, Lewis A. Kaplan
<http://topics.nytimes.com/top/reference/timestopics/people/k/lewis_a_kaplan
/index.html?inline=nyt-per>  of Federal District Court, ruled that the
government could not use an important witness, Hussein Abebe, who
prosecutors said had sold Mr. Ghailani the TNT that was used to blow up the
embassy in Dar es Salaam; he was barred because the government had learned
about him through coerced interrogation
<http://topics.nytimes.com/top/reference/timestopics/organizations/c/central
_intelligence_agency/cia_interrogations/index.html?inline=nyt-classifier>
of Mr. Ghailani while he was in the custody of the Central Intelligence
Agency
<http://topics.nytimes.com/top/reference/timestopics/organizations/c/central
_intelligence_agency/index.html?inline=nyt-org> . 

The government also did not introduce statements Mr. Ghailani made before he
was brought into the civilian system, even though prosecutors said they
amounted to a confession. For example, he said a plotter had told him of the
plans to attack the embassy in Tanzania “about a week before it was bombed,”
a statement Mr. Ghailani has conceded making voluntarily, prosecutors said.
The jury also never heard allegations that during Mr. Ghailani’s six years
as a fugitive, he trained with Al Qaeda in Afghanistan and worked as a
bodyguard for Osama bin Laden
<http://topics.nytimes.com/top/reference/timestopics/people/b/osama_bin_lade
n/index.html?inline=nyt-per> . 

Instead, prosecutors concentrated on the events leading to the embassy
bombings. They charged that Mr. Ghailani helped to buy the truck that
carried the bomb that blew up the embassy in Dar es Salaam, as well as gas
tanks that were placed inside the truck to magnify the blast. They said he
stored a detonator in his residence and used a false passport to flee along
with other operatives. “This is Al Qaeda,” Mr. Chernoff told the jury,
pointing at the defendant. “This is a terrorist. This is a killer.” 

The defense team included six lawyers, among them two trial veterans: Mr.
Quijano, a death penalty specialist who was initially appointed when the
government was still considering capital punishment in the case, and Mr.
Zissou, whose focus included forensics
<http://topics.nytimes.com/top/reference/timestopics/subjects/f/forensic_sci
ence/index.html?inline=nyt-classifier>  and searches in the case. 

Mr. Quijano said that the dupe strategy evolved after hundreds of hours of
jailhouse meetings that the lawyers, particularly Anna N. Sideris, an
associate in his office, held with Mr. Ghailani. “Developing trust with the
client was huge in this case,” Ms. Sideris said, “because we needed him to
open up and just talk to us, so we could learn his story — which was our
defense.” 

The story that emerged was that Mr. Ghailani had been one of hundreds of
enterprising young men who frequented Dar es Salaam’s busy marketplace area,
Kariakoo, running errands and hustling for deals, hoping to earn commissions
and tips. 

Mr. Quijano, Ms. Sideris and a third lawyer, Michael K. Bachrach, traveled
to Tanzania, where they met with Mr. Ghailani’s family, interviewed
potential government witnesses and visited Kariakoo, where Mr. Quijano said
he could imagine his client as a young man — he was 24 at the time of the
attacks — making purchases and doing tasks for friends without asking
questions. 

After the trip, Mr. Quijano said, “His story was so much more believable to
us in a way that we could portray it to a jury.” 

The defense also consulted closely with two military lawyers who had
represented Mr. Ghailani at Guantánamo, and who had concluded that he had
been duped. “That was also going to be our defense in Guantánamo,” one
lawyer, Marine Col. Jeffrey P. Colwell, recalled. 

Mr. Ghailani’s physical appearance bolstered the portrait the defense hoped
to offer to jurors: he was short, with a youthful, almost boyish face. “I
mean, he doesn’t look like Al Qaeda,” Mr. Quijano said. “He doesn’t look
like somebody who’d blow up an embassy. He looks like somebody you’d want to
take home with you.” 

Strip-Search Trauma 

But as the trial approached, Mr. Ghailani had been refusing to attend
hearings, saying he did not want to undergo the required strip-searches on
every trip to court. His lawyers were concerned about his potential absence.
“How’s it going to look,” Ms. Sideris recalled thinking, “if there’s an
empty chair?” 

Moreover, until Judge Kaplan barred Mr. Abebe’s testimony, Mr. Quijano was
considering asking Mr. Ghailani to testify on his own behalf to rebut the
witness — an impossibility if he were not in court. (Mr. Ghailani has said
he thought the TNT was to be used for mining and other legitimate purposes.)


A psychologist, Katherine A. Porterfield, who earlier evaluated Mr. Ghailani
for the defense, had determined that the strip-searches set off
post-traumatic stress disorder linked to his harsh treatment by the C.I.A. 

The lawyers pleaded with him to come to court, and ultimately, Mr. Ghailani
agreed to attend the trial after Dr. Porterfield helped reduce his anxiety. 

In court, Mr. Ghailani typically appeared relaxed and engaged as he sat with
his lawyers. And in closing arguments, Mr. Quijano spoke at length about the
naïve “child of Kariakoo” who had innocently assisted others. “Ahmed did not
know,” he said repeatedly. 

Mr. Quijano said that as the jury began its deliberations, he felt
confident, but his mood changed when a juror wrote to the judge on Monday,
Nov. 15, the third day of deliberations, claiming that she was alone and
“secure” in her views, but that she was being attacked by other jurors. 

“My conclusion it not going to change,” she wrote in broken English, asking
that she be excused or replaced. 

The note offered no hint as to her actual position, but the lawyers said
they had to assume she was the only juror holding out for acquittal, and
that the rest of the jury, apparently by an 11-to-1 vote, supported
conviction. 

Mr. Quijano said he was “beyond despondent.” 

“I couldn’t believe with those facts, I’d lost 11 that quickly,” he said. 

A new strategy arose: to make sure that Judge Kaplan did not remove the
holdout juror, and to protect her from being pressured into changing her
vote. The lawyers’ best hope appeared to be for a mistrial. “We certainly
are not consenting to any kind of replacement at this time,” Mr. Quijano
told the judge. 

Judge Kaplan called in the jurors and reminded them that they could change
their position if they were convinced it was erroneous, but that they were
not bound to surrender their “honest convictions” solely because of other
jurors’ views. 

At lunchtime, Mr. Quijano, Ms. Sideris and Dr. Porterfield walked to the
nearby Whiskey Tavern on Baxter Street. The lawyers each downed a bloody
mary with their meals and discussed the possibility that a note announcing a
guilty verdict would be waiting. 

‘Longest Afternoon’ 

At one point, Dr. Porterfield offered some supportive analysis. “A juror who
would send such a forceful and strong letter was not going to change her
opinion,” she recalled telling the two lawyers. “She will never flip.” 

After lunch, Mr. Zissou asked for an immediate mistrial, suggesting an
apparent deadlock. The defense wanted the request in before another note
arrived. Judge Kaplan denied the request. 

It was the “longest afternoon,” Mr. Quijano recalled. But with continued
silence from the jury through the next morning, Mr. Quijano said he began to
consider whether they had misread the note — perhaps the vote was not 11 to
1, or the jury was split over some lesser issue. 

But Mr. Quijano, who, like many lawyers, said he had his own rituals and
superstitions — he always tries to work in his Scottish terrier, Watson,
when giving a closing argument (“About the only living creature who will
live with me,” he told the Ghailani jury) — hesitated to overanalyze the
situation. “You don’t mess with the trial gods,” he explained, adding that
if something has worked, keep doing it. So, he dragged Ms. Sideris and Dr.
Porterfield back to lunch at the Whiskey Tavern: same booth, same waitress
and same meals — a cheddar burger for him, chicken fingers for Ms. Sideris
and a taco salad for Dr. Porterfield. 

Lunch was not as somber this time, and Dr. Porterfield recalled that they
discussed a startling proposition: What if the jury was split 11-to-1 in
favor of acquittal? What if they were protecting the wrong juror? 

It was around 3 p.m. when the jury’s note arrived, asking about the level of
knowledge Mr. Ghailani needed to have in order to be convicted. 

But muddying the issue a bit, the note asked about “conscious avoidance,” or
willful blindness. The jury wanted to know whether Mr. Ghailani could be
convicted if he had suspected that something illegal was under way, but had
buried his head in the sand to avoid knowing the full story. 

If that were the case, the note asked, did he need to know the plot’s
specific objectives, as charged in the indictment, like bombing embassies or
killing Americans? Or was it enough to say that he knew something unlawful
was going on? 

It was the kind of convoluted, paradoxical question upon which verdicts can
turn, Mr. Zissou said. 

There was an intense discussion outside the jury’s presence. A prosecutor
argued that Mr. Ghailani needed only to know there was “some illegal
purpose” to his activity, even if he had kept himself in the dark about its
ultimate ends. Mr. Zissou argued for a higher degree of knowledge — Mr.
Ghailani had to have known the ultimate aims of the charged conspiracies —
which would seemingly be harder for the government to prove. 

Late that afternoon, Judge Kaplan proposed an instruction that he said he
would deliver the next morning. It included language the defense had sought,
requiring the higher level of knowledge. It was “not enough,” the judge had
written, for Mr. Ghailani to have known only that “some crime” would be
committed; he had to know the specific objectives of the conspiracies. 

‘Lock This Down’ 

That evening, Mr. Zissou sent out his urgent e-mail, declaring that the case
rested on this instruction. He says he wanted to fend off any government
attempt to weaken the judge’s version. The point of the e-mail was “to make
sure we lock this down,” he says. 

Within an hour, around 8:15 p.m., prosecutors had a new proposal for the
judge, asking again for an instruction requiring the lower level of
knowledge. 

The government’s letter prompted a flurry of messages among the defense
lawyers; some consulted law partners, and even a former moot court
instructor at Albany Law School. Mr. Bachrach wrote to his colleagues that
the government’s newest version was “directly inconsistent” with Judge
Kaplan’s proposal. Mr. Bachrach told Mr. Zissou he would draft a response in
the morning, “once I have fresh eyes.” 

Ideas flowed through the night. Around 5:30 a.m., Mr. Bachrach began
drafting a three-page letter to Judge Kaplan, calling the government’s
proposal “a nonstarter” and asking that it be “rejected in its entirety.” 

At 7:10 a.m., Mr. Zissou wrote to him, asking, “How is the thinking cap?” 

“Going good,” Mr. Bachrach responded. “Should have a draft for you in the
next few minutes.” The letter was sent to court just after 8 a.m. on Nov.
17. 

When the judge read the instruction to the jury that morning, he largely
included the language the defense had wanted. 

With the jury still deliberating at lunchtime, Mr. Quijano and his two
colleagues returned again to the Whiskey Tavern, taking the same booth, and
again ordering the same meals and drinks. 

Later that day, told that a verdict note had arrived, Mr. Quijano, Ms.
Sideris and Dr. Porterfield met with Mr. Ghailani in the cellblock. Mr.
Quijano recalled that as he prepared his client for the worst, Mr. Ghailani
said he felt optimistic. 

In court, Mr. Ghailani sat in his usual place between Ms. Sideris and Mr.
Bachrach, holding each of their hands as the jury foreman announced the
results. 

Looking back, Mr. Bachrach said Mr. Ghailani felt vindicated at being
acquitted of murder, and was happy “a jury could see through the politics of
this case and view him fairly.” 

And despite knowing he still faces a steep sentence next Tuesday, “he knows
that he’s only getting that sentence after a fair trial, and in the end,
that’s what he wanted, a fair trial.” 

 



[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]



------------------------------------

--------------------------
Want to discuss this topic?  Head on over to our discussion list, 
[email protected].
--------------------------
Brooks Isoldi, editor
[email protected]

http://www.intellnet.org

  Post message: [email protected]
  Subscribe:    [email protected]
  Unsubscribe:  [email protected]


*** FAIR USE NOTICE. This message contains copyrighted material whose use has 
not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. OSINT, as a part of 
The Intelligence Network, is making it available without profit to OSINT 
YahooGroups members who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the 
included information in their efforts to advance the understanding of 
intelligence and law enforcement organizations, their activities, methods, 
techniques, human rights, civil liberties, social justice and other 
intelligence related issues, for non-profit research and educational purposes 
only. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of the copyrighted material 
as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use 
this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' 
you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.
For more information go to:
http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtmlYahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/

<*> Your email settings:
    Individual Email | Traditional

<*> To change settings online go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/join
    (Yahoo! ID required)

<*> To change settings via email:
    [email protected] 
    [email protected]

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
    [email protected]

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
    http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/

Reply via email to