http://gcn.com/Articles/2011/01/17/Security-trends-2011.aspx?s=gcndaily_1801
11
<http://gcn.com/Articles/2011/01/17/Security-trends-2011.aspx?s=gcndaily_180
111&p=1> &p=1

 

5 cyber threats to watch out for this year

(Plus a couple of bright spots)

*       By William Jackson
<http://gcn.com/forms/emailtoauthor.aspx?AuthorItem=%7bC4126F0C-6B16-4232-98
5C-93F86A33A188%7d&ArticleItem=%7bE30F72F6-69C1-4667-8C60-BCF079ED0DCA%7d> 
*       Jan 12, 2011

Threats in cyberspace don't disappear; we can probably expect all of the
headaches from 2010 to remain with us in 2011. But some security pros have
identified a handful of problems that have raised their heads in the last
year or so that they believe will be the major trends in the coming year.

They range from the personal, such as the proliferation of mobile and
consumer devices that continue to make their way into the work place, to the
global, such as cyber war and politically motivated espionage. In general,
malware is becoming more sophisticated, criminals more professional, the
target environment richer, and the stakes higher.

  _____  

Related stories:

How Google attacks changed the security game
<http://gcn.com/articles/2010/09/06/interview-george-kurtz-mcafee-google-att
acks.aspx> 

 
<http://gcn.com/articles/2010/12/23/cybereye-stuxnet-high-profile-mystery.as
px> Stuxnet story is high-profile but still out of reach

  _____  

But although security pros again find themselves playing catch up in areas
where functionality has outstripped security, there are some glimmers of
hope. Law enforcement might be getting better and the cloud might even
improve security. Here are some predictions of what to expect in 2011. 

1. Supply chain security

Vulnerabilities traditionally have been flaws in software discovered by
researchers - either white hat or black - and then exploited. But who's to
say a vulnerability has to be a flaw? Why can't it be something planted on
purpose?

"Software security has increased quite a bit, and it's getting tougher to
find mistakes," said Hugh Thompson, chief security strategist at People
Security, a software security company. "What's the next step? Putting it
there yourself."

A recent study by the Enterprise Strategy Group, commissioned by Microsoft
and Hewlett-Packard, found that many organizations in the critical
infrastructure sectors were unprepared to ensure that the supply chains on
which they depended for IT resources were trustworthy. The study concluded
that supply chain security should be a high priority for the foreseeable
future.

Vulnerabilities introduced through the supply chain can be particularly
dangerous because they can be purpose-built to attack a specific target and
can easily avoid detection by code scanners used to detect vulnerabilities.

"Building vulnerabilities to avoid code scanners is not that hard because
scanners are built typically to look for mistakes, not intentional things
that have been hidden," Thompson said. 

The Open Group, a government and industry consortium promoting
standards-based interoperability, announced in December the formation of the
Trusted Technology Forum to identify best practices for securing a global
technology supply chain. In addition to private-sector heavyweights such as
IBM, Cisco Systems and Microsoft, founding members of the task force include
NASA and the Defense Department.

"We've defined a trusted technology provider framework based on existing
open standards and best practices," said Andras Szakal, IBM distinguished
engineer and Open Group board member. The task force is identifying
practical programs that are grounded in reality and are already used by
organizations with mature supply chain security, he said.

The Protecting Cyberspace as a National Asset bill (S.3480), which failed to
make it out of the last Congress, included procurement reforms that would
promote cyber supply chain security.

As cybersecurity legislation that did not make it through the last Congress
is reintroduced in the current session, several bills are likely to include
provisions for ensuring the integrity of supply chains on which government
IT systems depend.

2. Consumerization of IT

Computers long ago passed from being strictly business machines to consumer
commodities, but the pace of innovation and the disappearance of the line
between the home (or the coffee shop) and the workplace further opens an
enterprise to threats.

"The trend is to bring more and more unmanaged devices into the network,"
said Uri Rivner, head of new technologies, identity protection and
verification at RSA, the security division of EMC. "That is going to create
a huge challenge. This increases the attack surface." 

Not only is the attack surface growing, but the value of consumer devices as
targets is growing as well, said Unisys CIO Patricia Titus. "2009 and 2010
were the USB years," she said. "The next year, we're going to see consumer
devices skyrocketing. I think we're going to see a significant increase in
attacks targeting consumer devices, using them to gain access to corporate
resources."

It's a matter of supply and demand, Titus said. When Microsoft owned the
market for consumer software, Microsoft was the hackers' target of choice
and the public's whipping boy. With the development of increasingly powerful
non-PC platforms that can be used in the workplace, the attackers are
following.

There is not yet enough forensic analysis available to say how common
malware is for personal devices such as laptops, tablets and smart phones,
Titus said. Tracking their use and their security status is difficult
because they often are not managed as part of the enterprise. But as they
become Internet-enabled and support multiple applications, "we are seeing a
steady increase in the amount of data consumption," she said.

Data consumption for some users has risen to more than 30G a day. And with
organizations now relying on Facebook, YouTube and Twitter as well as the
Web and internal databases for mission-critical activities, not all of those
bytes are personal. "The more you use the devices, the more value they have"
for attackers, Titus said.

As is so often the case, the tools that are making their way into the
enterprise were not built with security in mind. Security is evolving,
particularly for the more mature technologies such as Microsoft Windows CE
and BlackBerry devices. But too often, available security tools are not
being used. Devices are not protected by personal firewalls and antivirus
software, and communications are not secured by encryption and VPNs.

This puts the onus on administrators to enforce policies on which devices
can and can't be connected to the network and to manage those devices that
are allowed. "The perimeter is blurred, but it is not gone," Titus said.
"That is a decision that has to be made based on the risk."

Because of the difficulty of managing personal devices being used for work,
educating users is more important than ever. Education can empower users so
that they benefit from the convenience and increased productivity of these
new tools without opening new security holes.

Government organizations have one advantage in adapting to these new tools,
Titus said. "They have a tool we don't have in industry, and that is the
authority to dictate policy and enforce compliance." Many agency system
administrators might argue that point. 

3. Mobile devices

Closely tied to the issue of consumerization is mobility, because so many of
the new consumer devices coming into the workplace and connecting with the
enterprise are mobile devices such as smart phones.

"We've been saying for five years now that next year will be the year of
cellular telephone malware," said Kevin Haley, director of product
management for Symantec. But the devices finally are reaching critical mass,
both in the number of them in the workplace and in functionality. In 2011,
"we are going to see it," he said. 

Haley said two types of threats have emerged for mobile devices. GPS
trackers, disguised as a game or other application, are a form of geospyware
using a device's Global Positioning System functionality to follow the
device's location. Used legitimately, trackers can deliver targeted
advertising or other information. Surreptitiously, it could be used for
stalking. Another type of malware uses the devices as a platform for sending
text messages or making phone calls, driving up bills for connections to an
unscrupulous service.

"We're seeing a number of these happening," particularly in China so far,
Haley said.

Now, many phones are still not easy to attack. But with increased computing
power and multiple types of connections, they will become more attractive
targets, said RSA's Rivner. "There is going to be a tremendous growth in
mobile Trojans over the next year," he predicted.

One bright spot is that downloadable applications often are controlled and
vetted by the device's vendors, "so it's a little bit better," Rivner said.
But with increased attention from hackers, holes will be found. "We will see
more of these issues in 2011."

"With the beginning of malware, we're seeing the beginning of security
solutions for smart phones," Haley said. Symantec has several such
offerings, he said, although "they are not widely used at this point."

Because static defenses will be targeted and evaded by attackers,
"flexibility and intelligence are key," in defending smart phones, Rivner
said.

4. Targeted, political attacks

"We will see more cyber espionage and, potentially, cyber sabotage," Haley
said.

Cyber espionage is not new, but 2010 saw two high-profile examples of
sophisticated, specifically targeted attacks with the Google hack revealed
in January and the discovery of Stuxnet six months later. 

The Google attacks targeted that company and about 150 other organizations
in an apparent effort to gain sensitive, high-value information. China is
suspected of being behind the attack. The Stuxnet worm, which remains
something of a mystery, apparently targeted industrial controls at a uranium
enrichment facility in Iran but also spread around the globe. 

Those attacks are distinguished by the amount of effort that went into
making them stealthy and difficult to get rid of, and they are members of an
emerging class named advanced persistent threats, or APTs. "We are going to
see more of these APTs," Rivner said.

Rather than being broadcast, ATPs often depend on social engineering -
enticing people to click on a link - to hit their targets, making them more
difficult to defend against. 

"The most striking thing about these sophisticated attacks is that, unlike
the last three years, the network wasn't the immediate target," Rivner said.
"That is no longer needed." By compromising a human through social
engineering for delivery of malware, "you're already inside the network."

Targeted attacks make the coveted zero-day vulnerability more valuable.
Attackers who want to slip into a system and sit quietly while gathering
data, may well be willing to pay more for these vulnerabilities than
security researchers who create patches for them. 

Both the Google and Stuxnet malware exploited multiple zero-day
vulnerabilities. "With a targeted attack, you don't want to be discovered,"
Haley said. "You've only got one chance to get it right."

Identifying the motive for these attacks is difficult. Are they politically
motivated? "We don't know, of course," Haley said. "We can guess, but we
really don't know."
 
What we do know is that there are people, organizations or nations out there
with the resources and the motivation to invest a lot of time and effort
into crafting attacks that can slip past defenses to hit high-value targets.
There is no reason to believe nations will not take advantage of them.

5. Cyber war

With the issue of politically motivated attacks comes the issue of cyber
war. The United States has recognized cyberspace as a new virtual theater of
war, along with land, water, air and space. Now security leaders have to
decide what cyber war is and how to fight it.

Not only is cyberspace new, it also is not a physical domain, and things
happen quickly there and at a distance. This makes it difficult to tell who
is attacking you or what exactly is being attacked, which makes it difficult
to respond in a timely manner without hurting your friends as well as, or
instead of, your enemies.

"It's a difficult issue to grasp for policy makers," People Security's
Thompson said. "We're making policy decisions in an environment where we
don't know what the situation will be in six months."

Thompson, who also is the program committee chairman for the RSA security
conference, said the operational aspects of cyber war were a big issue at
RSA's European conference in late 2010 and that it will be a major topic at
the U.S. conference coming up in San Francisco in February.

The ability to do forensics investigations to identify the source and nature
of attacks is improving, but it still is not quick enough to allow nuanced
responses in real time, and there are no bright lines between warfare,
criminal activity, political or industrial espionage, or garden-variety
hacking.

On the other hand, military conflicts since the end of the Cold War have
become more like those evolving in cyberspace. The enemies are not
necessarily nations using traditional military organizations. Political
borders no longer define battlefields, and it is difficult to distinguish
between enemies and allies, victims and attackers. Perhaps most confusing,
we don't know how to tell when a war is over and who has won it.

Protocols for waging war in cyberspace will be informed by the lessons we
have learned fighting terrorism and ideologies in the real world and vice
versa.

On the bright side ... 

"It's not all doom and gloom," RSA's Rivner said.

Although cybersecurity often requires running as fast as possible just to
stay in the same place, there are occasional signs of progress.

Justice is neither swift nor sure in the civil and criminal court systems,
but legal action is emerging as a practical weapon against hackers and
spammers. 

Operation Bot Roast, an FBI program to track down and prosecute bot herders,
has resulted in a number of arrests and convictions in the past several
years. And in October, feds arrested more than 30 people for their alleged
involvement in the Zeus botnet that was used to steal millions of dollars
from bank accounts, part of a larger crackdown that had been going on since
the summer. There were similar arrests in the United Kingdom.

In February 2009, Microsoft offered a $250,000 reward for information
leading to the arrest and conviction of those behind the creation and
distribution of the Conficker worm. This year, a U.S. District Court judge
for the Eastern District of Virginia has recommended that ownership of 276
Internet domains used by the Waledac botnet be turned over to Microsoft,
which would effectively cut off the botnet's command and control network.

These actions will not by themselves stop cyber criminals, who have shown
themselves to be resourceful and resilient in the face of the best efforts
against them. But legal consequences can effectively raise the stakes of
engaging in online crime, which until now has been a low-cost, low-risk and
high-return endeavor. Fortinet, a vendor of network security appliances,
predicts that in 2011, there will be greater international collaboration to
shut down the bad guys through the courts.

Finally, the move to cloud and virtual environments might have positive
effects. They won't come automatically, but as the proper use of the new
environments is understood, security and the control of data will be better
understood and addressed, Rivner said.
 
"Visibility and control are so important to security, and it is becoming
more and more difficult" to achieve them in the traditional enterprise, he
said. More unmanaged devices are creeping into enterprises, and even managed
devices are becoming harder to protect.

"If you have the right cloud infrastructure, you can have better visibility
and manage things better," Rivner said. "But it will take planning and
policies."

About the Author

William Jackson is a senior writer for GCN and the author of the CyberEye
<http://gcn.com/articles/list/cybereye.aspx>  column. 



 



[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]



------------------------------------

--------------------------
Want to discuss this topic?  Head on over to our discussion list, 
[email protected].
--------------------------
Brooks Isoldi, editor
[email protected]

http://www.intellnet.org

  Post message: [email protected]
  Subscribe:    [email protected]
  Unsubscribe:  [email protected]


*** FAIR USE NOTICE. This message contains copyrighted material whose use has 
not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. OSINT, as a part of 
The Intelligence Network, is making it available without profit to OSINT 
YahooGroups members who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the 
included information in their efforts to advance the understanding of 
intelligence and law enforcement organizations, their activities, methods, 
techniques, human rights, civil liberties, social justice and other 
intelligence related issues, for non-profit research and educational purposes 
only. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of the copyrighted material 
as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use 
this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' 
you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.
For more information go to:
http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtmlYahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/

<*> Your email settings:
    Individual Email | Traditional

<*> To change settings online go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/join
    (Yahoo! ID required)

<*> To change settings via email:
    [email protected] 
    [email protected]

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
    [email protected]

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
    http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/

Reply via email to