' “Declinism” is in the air, but some of us apocalyptic types are way beyond
that. The United States is facing nothing so amiable and genteel as
Continental-style “decline,” but something more like sliding off a cliff.
"-Mark Steyn

 

 

 <http://www.newcriterion.com/articles.cfm/Dependence-Day-6753>
http://www.newcriterion.com/articles.cfm/Dependence-Day-6753



January 2011

Dependence Day

by Mark Steyn <http://www.newcriterion.com/author.cfm?authorid=18> 

On the erosion of personal liberty.

Burke

was right!

 <http://www.newcriterion.com/donate.cfm> Support The 
New Criterion 

If I am pessimistic about the future of liberty, it is because I am
pessimistic about the strength of the English-speaking nations, which have,
in profound ways, surrendered to forces at odds with their inheritance.
“Declinism” is in the air, but some of us apocalyptic types are way beyond
that. The United States is facing nothing so amiable and genteel as
Continental-style “decline,” but something more like sliding off a cliff.

In the days when I used to write for Fleet Street, a lot of readers and
several of my editors accused me of being anti-British. I’m not. I’m
extremely pro-British and, for that very reason, the present state of the
United Kingdom is bound to cause distress. So, before I get to the bad
stuff, let me just lay out the good. Insofar as the world functions at all,
it’s due to the Britannic inheritance. Three-sevenths of the G7 economies
are nations of British descent. Two-fifths of the permanent members of the
U.N. Security Council are—and, by the way, it should be three-fifths: The
rap against the Security Council is that it’s the Second World War victory
parade preserved in aspic, but, if it were, Canada would have a greater
claim to be there than either France or China. The reason Canada isn’t is
because a third Anglosphere nation and a second realm of King George VI
would have made too obvious a truth usually left unstated—that the
Anglosphere was the all but lone defender of civilization and of liberty. In
broader geopolitical terms, the key regional powers in almost every corner
of the globe are British-derived—from Australia to South Africa to
India—and, even among the lesser players, as a general rule you’re better
off for having been exposed to British rule than not: Why is Haiti Haiti and
Barbados Barbados?

And of course the pre-eminent power of the age derives its political
character from eighteenth-century British subjects who took English ideas a
little further than the mother country was willing to go. In his 
sequel to Churchill’s great work, The History of the English-Speaking
Peoples, Andrew Roberts writes:

Just as we do not today differentiate between the Roman Republic and the
imperial period of the Julio-Claudians when we think of the Roman Empire, so
in the future no-one will bother to make a distinction between the British
Empire–led and the American Republic–led periods of English-speaking
dominance between the late-eighteenth and the twenty-first centuries. It
will be recognized that in the majestic sweep of history they had so much in
common—and enough that separated them from everyone else—that they ought to
be regarded as a single historical entity, which only scholars and pedants
will try to describe separately.

If you step back for a moment, this seems obvious. There is a distinction
between the “English-speaking peoples” and the rest of “the West,” and at
key moments in human history that distinction has proved critical.

Continental Europe has given us plenty of nice paintings and agreeable
symphonies, French wine and Italian actresses and whatnot, but, for all our
fetishization of multiculturalism, you can’t help noticing that when it
comes to the notion of a political West—one with a sustained commitment to
liberty and democracy—the historical record looks a lot more unicultural
and, indeed (given that most of these liberal democracies other than America
share the same head of state), uniregal. The entire political class of
Portugal, Spain, and Greece spent their childhoods living under
dictatorships. So did Jacques Chirac and Angela Merkel. We forget how rare
on this earth is peaceful constitutional evolution, and rarer still outside
the Anglosphere.

Decline starts with the money. It always does. As Jonathan Swift put it:

A baited banker thus desponds,
>From his own hand foresees his fall,
They have his soul, who have his bonds;
’Tis like the writing on the wall.

Today the people who have America’s bonds are not the people one would wish
to have one’s soul. As Madhav Nalapat has suggested, Beijing believes a
half-millennium Western interregnum is about to come to an end, and the
world will return to Chinese dominance. I think they’re wrong on the latter,
but right on the former. Within a decade, the United States will be spending
more of the federal budget on its interest payments than on its military.

According to the cbo’s 2010 long-term budget outlook, by 2020 the U.S.
government will be paying between 15 and 20 percent of its revenues in debt
interest—whereas defense spending will be down to between 14 and 16 percent.
America will be spending more on debt interest than China, Britain, France,
Russia, Japan, Germany, Saudi Arabia, India, Italy, South Korea, Brazil,
Canada, Australia, Spain, Turkey, and Israel spend on their militaries
combined. The superpower will have advanced from a nation of aircraft
carriers to a nation of debt carriers.

What does that mean? In 2009, the United States spent about $665 billion on
its military, the Chinese about $99 billion. If Beijing continues to buy
American debt at the rate it has in recent years, then within a half-decade
or so U.S. interest payments on that debt will be covering the entire cost
of the Chinese military. This year, the Pentagon issued an alarming report
to Congress on Beijing’s massive military build-up, including new missiles,
upgraded bombers, and an aircraft-carrier R&D program intended to challenge
American dominance in the Pacific. What the report didn’t mention is who’s
paying for it. Answer: Mr. and Mrs. America.

Within the next five years, the People’s Liberation Army, which is the
largest employer on the planet, bigger even than the U.S. Department of
Community-Organizer Grant Applications, will be entirely funded by U.S.
taxpayers. When they take Taiwan, suburban families in Connecticut and small
businesses in Idaho will have paid for it. The existential questions for
America loom now, not decades hence. What we face is not merely the decline
and fall of a powerful nation but the collapse of the highly specific
cultural tradition that built the modern world. It starts with the money—it
always does. But the money is only the symptom. We wouldn’t be this broke if
we hadn’t squandered our inheritance in a more profound sense.

Britain’s decline also began with the money. The U.S. “Lend-Lease” program
to the United Kingdom ended with the war in September 1946. London paid off
the final installment of its debt in December 2006, and the Economic
Secretary, Ed Balls, sent with the check a faintly surreal accompanying note
thanking Washington for its support during the war. They have our soul who
have our bonds: Britain and the world were more fortunate in who had
London’s bonds than America is seventy years later. For that reason, in
terms of global order, the transition from Britannia ruling the waves to the
American era, from the old lion to its transatlantic progeny, was one of the
smoothest transfers of power in history—so smooth that most of us aren’t
quite sure when it took place. Andrew Roberts likes to pinpoint it to the
middle of 1943: One month, the British had more men under arms than the
Americans; the next month, the Americans had more men under arms than the
British.

The baton of global leadership had been passed. And, if it didn’t seem that
way at the time, that’s because it was as near a seamless transition as
could be devised—although it was hardly “devised” at all, at least not by
London. Yet we live with the benefits of that transition to this day. To
take a minor but not inconsequential example, one of the critical links in
the post-9/11 Afghan campaign was the British Indian Ocean Territory. As its
name would suggest, it’s a British dependency, but it has a U.S. military
base—just one of many pinpricks on the map where the Royal Navy’s Pax
Britannica evolved into Washington’s Pax Americana with nary a thought: From
U.S. naval bases in Bermuda to the Anzus alliance down under to Norad in
Cheyenne Mountain, London’s military ties with its empire were assumed,
effortlessly, by the United States, and life and global order went on.

One of my favorite lines from the Declaration of Independence never made it
into the final text. They were Thomas Jefferson’s parting words to his
fellow British subjects across the ocean: “We might have been a free and
great people together.” But in the end, when it mattered, they were a free
and great people together. Britain was eclipsed by its transatlantic
offspring, by a nation with the same language, the same legal inheritance,
and the same commitment to liberty.

It’s not likely to go that way next time round. And “next time round” is
already under way. We are coming to the end of a two-century Anglosphere
dominance, and of a world whose order and prosperity many people think of as
part of a broad, general trend but which, in fact, derive from a very
particular cultural inheritance and may well not survive it. To point out
how English the world is is, of course, a frightfully un-English thing to
do. No true Englishman would ever do such a ghastly and vulgar thing. You
need some sinister rootless colonial oik like me to do it. But there’s a
difference between genial self-effacement and contempt for one’s own
inheritance.

Not so long ago, Geert Wilders, the Dutch parliamentarian and soi-disant
Islamophobe, flew into London and promptly got shipped back to the
Netherlands as a threat to public order. After the British Government had
reconsidered its stupidity, he was permitted to return and give his speech
at the House of Lords—and, as foreigners often do, he quoted Winston
Churchill, under the touchingly naive assumption that this would endear him
to the natives. Whereas, of course, to almost all members of Britain’s
governing elite, quoting Churchill approvingly only confirms that you’re an
extremist lunatic. I had the honor a couple of years back of visiting
President Bush in the White House and seeing the bust of Churchill on
display in the Oval Office. When Barack Obama moved in, he ordered
Churchill’s bust be removed and returned to the British. Its present
whereabouts are unclear. But, given what Sir Winston had to say about Islam
in his book on the Sudanese campaign, the bust was almost certainly arrested
at Heathrow and deported as a threat to public order.

Somewhere along the way a quintessentially British sense of self-deprecation
curdled into a psychologically unhealthy self-loathing. A typical
foot-of-the-page news item from The Daily Telegraph:

A leading college at Cambridge University has renamed its controversial
colonial-themed Empire Ball after accusations that it was “distasteful.” The
£136-a-head Emmanuel College ball was advertised as a celebration of “the
Victorian commonwealth and all of its decadences. 

 Students were urged to “party like it’s 1899” and organisers promised a
trip through the Indian Raj, Australia, the West Indies, and 19th century
Hong Kong.

But anti-fascist groups said the theme was “distasteful and insensitive”
because of the British Empire’s historical association with slavery,
repression and exploitation.

The Empire Ball Committee, led by presidents Richard Hilton and Jenny Unwin,
has announced the word “empire” will be removed from all promotional
material.

The way things are going in Britain, it would make more sense to remove the
word “balls.”

It’s interesting to learn that “anti-fascism” now means attacking the
British Empire, which stood alone against fascism in that critical year
between the fall of France and Germany’s invasion of Russia. And it’s even
sadder to have to point out the most obvious fatuity in those “anti-fascist
groups” litany of evil—“the British Empire’s association with slavery.” The
British Empire’s principal association with slavery is that it abolished it.
Before William Wilberforce, the British Parliament, and the brave men of the
Royal Navy took up the issue, slavery was an institution regarded by all
cultures around the planet as as permanent a feature of life as the earth
and sky. Britain expunged it from most of the globe.

It is pathetic but unsurprising how ignorant all these brave “anti-fascists”
are. But there is a lesson here not just for Britain but for the rest of us,
too: When a society loses its memory, it descends inevitably into dementia.
As I always try to tell my American neighbors, national decline is at least
partly psychological—and therefore what matters is accepting the psychology
of decline. Thus, Hayek’s greatest insight in The Road to Serfdom, which he
wrote with an immigrant’s eye on the Britain of 1944:

There is one aspect of the change in moral values brought about by the
advance of collectivism which at the present time provides special food for
thought. It is that the virtues which are held less and less in esteem and
which consequently become rarer are precisely those on which the British
people justly prided themselves and in which they were generally agreed to
excel. 

 The virtues possessed by Anglo-Saxons in a higher degree than most other
people, excepting only a few of the smaller nations, like the Swiss and the
Dutch, were independence and self-reliance, individual initiative and local
responsibility, the successful reliance on voluntary activity,
noninterference with one’s neighbor and tolerance of the different and
queer, respect for custom and tradition, and a healthy suspicion of power
and authority.

Within little more than half a century, almost every item on the list had
been abandoned, from “independence and self-reliance” (some 40 percent of
Britons receive state handouts) to “a healthy suspicion of power and 
authority”—the reflex response now to almost any passing inconvenience is to
demand the government “do something.” American exceptionalism would have to
be awfully exceptional to suffer a similar expansion of government without a
similar descent, in enough of the citizenry, into chronic dependency.

What happened? Britain, in John Foster Dulles’s famous postwar assessment,
had lost an empire but not yet found a role. Actually, Britain didn’t so
much “lose” the Empire: it evolved peacefully into the modern Commonwealth,
which is more agreeable than the way these things usually go. Nor is it
clear that modern Britain wants a role, of any kind. Rather than losing an
empire, it seems to have lost its point.

This has consequences. To go back to Cambridge University’s now non-imperial
Empire Ball, if the cream of British education so willingly prostrates
itself before ahistorical balderdash, what then of the school system’s more
typical charges? In cutting off two generations of students from their
cultural inheritance, the British state has engaged in what we will one day
come to see as a form of child abuse, one that puts a huge question mark
over the future. Why be surprised that legions of British Muslims sign up
for the Taliban? These are young men who went to school in Luton and West
Bromwich and learned nothing of their country of nominal citizenship other
than that it’s responsible for racism, imperialism, colonialism, and all the
other bad -isms of the world. If that’s all you knew of Britain, why would
you feel any allegiance to Queen and country? And what if you don’t have
Islam to turn to? The transformation of the British people is, in its own
malign way, a remarkable achievement. Raised in schools that teach them
nothing, they nevertheless pick up the gist of the matter, which is that
their society is a racket founded on various historical injustices. The
virtues Hayek admired? Ha! Strictly for suckers.

When William Beveridge laid out his blueprint for the modern British welfare
state in 1942, his goal was the “abolition of want,” to be accomplished by
“cooperation between the State and the individual.” In attempting to
insulate the citizenry from the vicissitudes of fate, Sir William succeeded
beyond his wildest dreams: Want has been all but abolished. Today, fewer and
fewer Britons want to work, want to marry, want to raise children, want to
lead a life of any purpose or dignity. Churchill called his book The History
of the English-Speaking Peoples—not the English-Speaking Nations. The
extraordinary role played by those nations in the creation and maintenance
of the modern world derived from their human capital.

What happens when, as a matter of state policy, you debauch your human
capital? The United Kingdom has the highest drug use in Europe, the highest
incidence of sexually transmitted disease, the highest number of single
mothers; marriage is all but defunct, except for toffs, upscale gays, and
Muslims. For Americans, the quickest way to understand modern Britain is to
look at what lbj’s Great Society did to the black family and imagine it
applied to the general population. One-fifth of British children are raised
in homes in which no adult works. Just under 900,000 people have been off
sick for over a decade, claiming “sick benefits,” week in, week out, for ten
years and counting. “Indolence,” as Machiavelli understood, is the greatest
enemy of a free society, but rarely has any state embraced this oldest
temptation as literally as Britain. There is almost nothing you can’t get
the government to pay for.

Plucked at random from The Daily Mail: A man of twenty-one with learning
disabilities has been granted taxpayers’ money to fly to Amsterdam and have
sex with a prostitute. Why not? His social worker says sex is a “human
right” and that his client, being a virgin, is entitled to the support of
the state in claiming said right. Fortunately, a £520 million program was
set up by Her Majesty’s Government to “empower those with disabilities.”
“He’s planning to do more than just have his end away,” explained the social
worker.

“The girls in Amsterdam are far more protected than those on U.K. streets.
Let him have some fun—I’d want to. Wouldn’t you prefer that we can control
this, guide him, educate him, support him to understand the process and
ultimately end up satisfying his needs in a secure, licensed place where his
happiness and growth as a person is the most important thing? Refusing to
offer him this service would be a violation of his human rights.”

And so a Dutch prostitute is able to boast that among her clients is the
British Government. Talk about outsourcing: given the reputation of English
womanhood, you’d have thought this would be the one job that wouldn’t have
to be shipped overseas. But, as Dutch hookers no doubt say, lie back and
think of England—and the check they’ll be mailing you.

After Big Government, after global retreat, after the loss of liberty, there
is only remorseless civic disintegration. The statistics speak for
themselves. The number of indictable offences per thousand people was 2.4 in
1900, climbed gradually to 9.7 in 1954, and then rocketed to 109.4 by 1992.
And that official increase understates the reality: Many crimes have been
decriminalized (shoplifting, for example), and most crime goes unreported,
and most reported crime goes uninvestigated, and most investigated crime
goes unsolved, and almost all solved crime merits derisory punishment. Yet
the law-breaking is merely a symptom of a larger rupture. At a gathering
like this one, John O’Sullivan, recalling his own hometown, said that when
his grandmother ran a pub in the Liverpool docklands in the years around the
First World War, there was only one occasion when someone swore in her
presence. And he subsequently apologized.

“The past is a foreign country: they do things differently there.” But
viewed from 2010 England the day before yesterday is an alternative
universe—or a lost civilization. Last year, the “Secretary of State for
Children” (both an Orwellian and Huxleyite office) announced that 20,000
“problem families” would be put under twenty-four-hour cctv supervision in
their homes. As the Daily Express reported, “They will be monitored to
ensure that children attend school, go to bed on time and eat proper meals.”
Orwell’s government “telescreen” in every home is close to being a reality,
although even he would have dismissed as too obviously absurd a nanny state
that literally polices your bedtime.

For its worshippers, Big Government becomes a kind of religion: the state as
church. After the London Tube bombings, Gordon Brown began mulling over the
creation of what he called a “British equivalent of the U.S. Fourth of
July,” a new national holiday to bolster British identity. The Labour Party
think-tank, the Fabian Society, proposed that the new “British Day” should
be July 5th, the day the National Health Service was created. Because the
essence of contemporary British identity is waiting two years for a hip
operation. A national holiday every July 5th: They can call it Dependence
Day.

Does the fate of the other senior Anglophone power hold broader lessons for
the United States? It’s not so hard to picture a paternalist technocrat of
the Michael Bloomberg school covering New York in cctv ostensibly for
terrorism but also to monitor your transfats. Permanence is the illusion of
every age. But you cannot wage a sustained ideological assault on your own
civilization without profound consequence. Without serious course
correction, we will see the end of the Anglo-American era, and the eclipse
of the powers that built the modern world. Even as America’s spendaholic
government outspends not only America’s ability to pay for itself but, by
some measures, the world’s; even as it follows Britain into the dank pit of
transgenerational dependency, a failed education system, and unsustainable
entitlements; even as it makes less and less and mortgages its future to its
rivals for cheap Chinese trinkets, most Americans assume that simply because
they’re American they will be insulated from the consequences. There, too,
are lessons from the old country. Cecil Rhodes distilled the assumptions of
generations when he said that to be born a British subject was to win first
prize in the lottery of life. On the eve of the Great War, in his play
Heartbreak House, Bernard Shaw turned the thought around to taunt a British
ruling class too smug and self-absorbed to see what was coming. “Do you
think,” he wrote, “the laws of God will be suspended in favor of England
because you were born in it?”

In our time, to be born a citizen of the United States is to win first prize
in the lottery of life, and, as Britons did, too many Americans assume it
will always be so. Do you think the laws of God will be suspended in favor
of America because you were born in it? Great convulsions lie ahead, and at
the end of it we may be in a post-Anglosphere world.

 



[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]



------------------------------------

--------------------------
Want to discuss this topic?  Head on over to our discussion list, 
[email protected].
--------------------------
Brooks Isoldi, editor
[email protected]

http://www.intellnet.org

  Post message: [email protected]
  Subscribe:    [email protected]
  Unsubscribe:  [email protected]


*** FAIR USE NOTICE. This message contains copyrighted material whose use has 
not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. OSINT, as a part of 
The Intelligence Network, is making it available without profit to OSINT 
YahooGroups members who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the 
included information in their efforts to advance the understanding of 
intelligence and law enforcement organizations, their activities, methods, 
techniques, human rights, civil liberties, social justice and other 
intelligence related issues, for non-profit research and educational purposes 
only. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of the copyrighted material 
as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use 
this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' 
you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.
For more information go to:
http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtmlYahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/

<*> Your email settings:
    Individual Email | Traditional

<*> To change settings online go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/join
    (Yahoo! ID required)

<*> To change settings via email:
    [email protected] 
    [email protected]

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
    [email protected]

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
    http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/

Reply via email to