http://blogs.buffalonews.com/live/2011/01/the-trial-of-muzzammil-hassan-day-
7.html


The trial of Muzzammil Hassan: Day 7


Jan 27, 2011 10:26:18 AM / Comment
<http://comments.buffalonews.com/?headline=The%20trial%20of%20Muzzammil%20Ha
ssan%3A%20Day%207&blogId=6a00d83451b85a69e20148c8081935970c&pubDate=2011-01-
27&url=http%3A//blogs.buffalonews.com/live/2011/01/the-trial-of-muzzammil-ha
ssan-day-7.html&author=Buffalo%20News%20Live> 

BUFFALO -- The prosecution rested its case Wednesday in the murder trial of
of Muzzammil "Mo" Hassan in Erie County Court. The defense is supposed to
begin to present its case this morning.

Hassan, 46, is accused of stabbing and beheading his wife, Aasiya Zubair
Hassan, at an Orchard Park television station on Feb. 12, 2009.

Judge Thomas P. Franczyk has allowed Hassan to represent himself.

The News will follow developments in today's court proceedings below:

3:28 p.m. Hassan has spent more than an hour testifying to events and
conversations that he said took place in just one month, August 2006. He
said he told Aasiya late that month that the couple should devote more time
to rebuilding their relationship.

He told the court there is a word, "zidh," in their language that means
essentially "selfish demands." Hassan said that in their conversations, now
that they were talking again, he would chide Aasiya about her "zidhs," and
he said he begged her to help him try to repair the marriage and to set
aside her recently resurrected demands to visit Pakistan again. 

3:21 p.m. Hassan continues to testify about his deteriorating marriage and
his efforts to save it while running into prosecutorial objections whenever
he tries to reveal what someone else has told him. 

He said he told Aasiya she won't be able to change until she takes
responsibility for her abusive behavior. 

In later summer 2006, at one point, Aasiya stopped talking to Hassan on the
advice of her lawyer, and she said future interactions would have to go
through her lawyer.

Hassan said he told her that her treatment of him and her refusal to
communicate directly with him "was killing me."

He said he continued to try to give her examples of her abusive behavior,
examples that she denied to him, such as when he claims she picked up a
bottle of prescription medication and threw it across their room.

Hassan said he contacted the author of "Verbally Abusive Relationships,"
telling her that he was in just such an abusive relationship and asking for
any advice she had. He said the author called him back, but when Hassan
attempted to testify to what she told him, prosecutors again objected and
the judge again sustained the objection and struck his statement from the
record.

3:14 p.m. Court has resumed following a five minute recess.

Lawyers, law students and notable elected officials have been stopping by
the court to watch parts of the Hassan trial. State Supreme Court Justice
Timothy J. Drury has listened to some of Hassan's testimony this afternoon.

3:02 p.m. Hassan is still on the stand and his testimony continues to try to
portray him as the victim of an abusive relationship. He said that he
repeatedly tried to convince his late wife not to use inflammatory words
against him, to disagree with him reasonably and to do a better job of
trying to understand where he's coming from. 

Any time there was any argument, Aasiya had to win, Hassan said. "There was
always a win-lose," he said.

He said he talked to her about developing an attitude that would allow them
to make decisions that lead to both of them winning.

He also said he shared with Aasiya an article on angry outbursts, people who
have explosive tempers, and another article about people who make unilateral
instead of joint decisions. Hassan testified that Aasiya never included him
in her decision-making.

He said at one point he told her she had married "a broken man," one who has
fears and vulnerabilities that she uses against him, and her personal
attacks were breaking him down.

2:51 p.m. Hassan has begun to testify in more detail to the abuse he claims
he suffered at the hands of his late wife.

He said Aasiya would push him, grab him, slap him and grab his hair, and he
testified he didn't go a single week from this time until the end of their
marriage where he wasn't physically assaulted by Aasiya.

"Granted, I'm bigger and a guy, so I can walk away . but it just leaves you
shaking in terms of what's going on," Hassan said.

He tried to testify that Aasiya apologized in an e-mail the day after one of
their blow-ups, but prosecutor Colleen Curtin Gable again objected to his
reference to an e-mail that hasn't been entered into evidence.

Stymied, again, Hassan simply said that Aasiya apologized to him the next
day, using her nickname for him, "King Kong."

2:43 p.m. Hassan now is trying to introduce into evidence his travel
itineraries for various trips that, he contends, show that he was out of
town on certain dates when allegations were made that he was abusive to his
wife.

In response to another objection from prosecutors, Franczyk said Hassan
cannot testify to the authenticity of the Travelocity documents because he
does not work for Travelocity, so he cannot introduce the documents as
evidence but he can refer to them to refresh his memory.

Whenever Hassan refers to an e-mail, prosecutor Colleen Curtin Gable objects
and legal advisor Jeremy Schwartz tries to guide Hassan away from
potentially objectionable testimony.

Hassan said he told Aasiya that her "threat" to walk away from the marriage,
with their children, and return to Pakistan will "destroy a lot of lives."

"Every time she would play that card, I would cave in," Hassan testified,
arguing that he felt controlled and not loved.

2:36 p.m. Hassan has been stymied in his efforts to introduce into evidence,
or read from, e-mails he said had been sent between himself and Aasiya. Each
time he tries to read from an e-mail, prosecutor Colleen Curtin Gable has
objected and Franczyk has sustained her objection. Hassan has paused for
five or 10 seconds at a time at some points before continuing his testimony.
He frequently huddles with Jeremy Schwartz, his legal advisor who sits next
to Hassan at the witness stand, before speaking. 

Even though Aasiya had an earlier abortion, according to Hassan, when she
became pregnant another time she did not want to have another abortion.
Hassan said he did not want another child, but Aasiya was insistent in
changing her mind. She called him more names, and inflicted him to more
"attacks," and said he could just pay for child support to provide for the
new baby, according to Hassan's testimony.

"I'm a flexible person, but it was just pound, pound, pound, pound," Hassan
said, adding that he felt he had no control over his life.

2:28 p.m. Hassan continued detailing the escalating disagreements he said he
had with Aasiya, and the judge agreed with prosecutor Colleen Curtin Gable
that Hassan's purported e-mail conversations with Aasiya have not been
authenticated.

Hassan told jurors that, beginning in 2006, he bought a bed and put it in
the basement and said he slept down there at least 20 different times in the
years to come, as well as another 20 times when he spent time at
extended-stay hotels. 

He said Aasiya became pregnant in 2006 and, that August, because she was
starting the MBA program and didn't want to have another child, she decided
"on her own" to have an abortion, according to Hassan.

Hassan said he began saving e-mails between himself and Aasiya around this
time, and he told the jury that the e-mails would back up what he testifying
about.

Hassan began reading from an e-mail dated Aug. 5, 2006. This email was
marked for evidence, but not entered into evidence, so Curtin Gable objected
to Hassan's reading of the e-mail.

Shown the e-mail, Curtin Gable said she objected to the introduction of the
e-mail for several reasons, first that she had no way of knowing whether
this e-mail is authentic.

Franczyk said he would not allow Hassan to read from a document that is not
in evidence because the e-mail, and presumably others Hassan wishes to
introduce, were not authenticated by an employee from his Internet provider.
Franczyk said Hassan would be able to talk about conversations he had with
Aasiya, and to refer to the e-mails, without reading them, to refresh his
memory.

2:18 p.m. Finally, she agreed to seek counseling, Hassan said as he
continued his testimony. He continues to speak to the jury in a narrative,
conversational form with no questions from Jeremy Schwartz, his legal
advisor, or anyone else.

He said the couple made up at this point, and he moved back home from the
hotel. Then, she changed her mind and said she didn't want to go back to
counseling.

"I felt slighted," Hassan said, but he was already back home and didn't
decide to move out again.

Aasiya did not like the snow and the cold weather here. She said she would
prefer to move to Dallas, and felt in addition to the better weather that
she would have better job prospects there. 

She said, 'There were no cranes in Buffalo,'" Hassan recalled. 

Hassan said this was a source of arguments because Hassan didn't want to
have to move his oldest children out of Western New York and their schools.

He said both of the children wanted to stay in Western New York, and he told
this to Aasiya. He said she "exploded" at this news, and complained about
being stuck "in this horrible place" for about three minutes non-stop.

Hassan said Aasiya consistently complained that he and the children were
holding her back.

 Bridges TV had 25 employees at this point and Hassan said he didn't want to
leave them high and dry with a move to Dallas.

Hassan said Aasiya's arguments escalated to hitting Hassan, slamming doors
as well as the continued yelling at him and calling him names.

2:10 p.m. The audience of spectators in the courtroom is slightly smaller
for the afternoon session. There continues to be a relatively heavy presence
of court officers who sit behind and to the side of Hassan as he sits at the
stand.

Hassan is resuming his testimony. He said in 2005 he continued talking to
Aasiya about changing her behavior and trying to emphasize to her how much
he was hurt by her words and her temper. He also again unsuccessfully sought
to convince her to seek counseling.

"It felt as if I was hitting a thick stone wall. I couldn't get heard at
all," Hassan said.

In March or April 2006, for the first time, he said he moved out of the
house to the Clarion Hotel, within a mile or two of their Hamburg home.

12:53 p.m. Jeremy Schwartz, formerly Hassan's lawyer and now serving a more
limited role as Hassan's legal advisor, told reporters after court broke for
lunch that Hassan's testimony to his state of mind during his marriage to
Aasiya is relevant to his defense.

He declined to say whether he had advised Hassan to take the stand in his
own defense and he would not comment on where Hassan will be going with his
testimony.

When asked whether Hassan would be able to produce a witness, Schwartz said,
"We are speaking to witnesses now. The timing is difficult. I anticipate we
may have witnesses tomorrow." 

He said much of the 1,000 pieces of evidence that Hassan hopes to introduce
are documents such as e-mails that may be presented this afternoon and that
support Hassan's contentions in his testimony.

Another reporter asked whether Schwartz believed members of the jury would
buy the idea that the marital arguments and disagreements he testified to
could possibly justify killing Aasiya. Schwartz replied, "There are a lot of
other things to come."

12:31 p.m. Hassan has begun to use the term "abuse" to describe his
treatment at the hands of Aasiya.

He said he read a book with the title, "Verbally Abusive Relationships," by
Patrticia Evans, a book Hassan said he began to read. He said he found it
enlightening and said it gave him validation.

He said up to that point most of the abuse he suffered was emotional, so it
was hard for people to know he was a victim of abuse. He said it was hard
for other people to see Aasiya's abuse of Hassan because most of what she
said was said in their bedroom, behind closed doors.

The judge has sent the jury out of the courtroom and the trial has recessed
for a lunch break and will resume at 2 p.m.

12:26 p.m. Hassan is continuing his testimony. In 2005, on a trip to Dallas
to see his family, Hassan said members of his family saw Aasiya's
"explosive" temper. Prosecutor Colleen Curtin Gable objected when Hassan
tried to talk about what his mother saw and said. Hassan said he didn't know
what to do in response to Aasiya's temper and its effect on their marriage.

Hassan jumped back in time to talk about his children and his desire to have
his two children from his first marriage and his two children with Aasiya to
live together. November 2004, his two oldest children moved in with Hassan
and Aasiya.

By this point he is working full time at Bridges TV. He said Aasiya had had
a boat while living in Pakistan and she began to request that they buy one
in America. Hassan said he didn't think this was wise because they were just
starting the business and the oldest children soon would begin college. This
prompted her to unfavorably compare their lifestyle in Western New York to
her lifestyle in Pakistan.

He said she also had a gun in Pakistan, and when they would drive by a
shooting range on Maple Road in Amherst she would bring up buying a gun.
Hassan said he is not comfortable having a gun. He said the only time he had
fired a gun was when he went through "FBI training," a statement that drew
curious looks in among members of the courtroom audience. This might have
been a reference to a civilian training program that the FBI offers.

At this point, Hassan said he suggested that Aasiya go through counseling to
get a handle on her temper and her bouts of pouting. He said she angrily
dismissed this suggestion.

12:15 p.m. Hassan began his testimony this morning because he was not able
to present any other witnesses at this time.

Today's second session began with the judge saying he would continue to bar
audio-visual recording of the trial but he would allow still photography.
This decision is limited to Hassan's testimony and photographers are barred
from taking pictures of members of the jury.

The jury is not yet back in court but is being brought back into the room.

12:02 p.m. "It's like if Aasiya felt hurt, she had to hurt you," Hassan
said. He said she would call him a lot of "unkind names." 

Hassan said another argument developed because she wanted to bring their
children with her to Pakistan. He said he was concerned about their safety
and didn't mind if she went alone. This prompted her to yell at him and try
to belittle him, Hassan testified.

"You're nobody; you're nothing. You're just a sperm donor," Aasiya said to
Hassan, according to Hassan.

The judge has called for a five-minute recess.

11:58 a.m. Hassan again is trying to portray Aasiya as someone with a temper
and very particular tastes who always insisted on getting her way. "When she
goes off it's like machine gun bullets," Hassan testified.

In Buffalo, she always had to go to Kebab & Curry, a Pakistani restaurant.
"We couldn't go to other restaurants," he said. In contrast, Hassan said he
was the more laid-back person in the marriage and said he generally gave
into Aasiya's demands.

However, he said he remained physically attracted to her and he said their
working relationship was better. Hassan said he viewed Aasiya as an equal
business partner and he praised her intelligence and business acumen.

The first time Aasiya mentioned divorce, Hassan said, followed an incident
when Aasiya chastised her husband for not carrying up their suitcases while
they were on a trip. He did not say what year this happened.

11:50 a.m. Hassan said the couple continued to clash over her demand to
travel to Pakistan every year, and her desire to work outside the home when
he believed he made enough money that she could stay at home. He said she
first became "physical" with him when he said he wouldn't buy her a horse to
ride. He said he didn't think much of that at the time.

After she came back from a trip to Pakistan, she got pregnant and the
demands for a horse went away. In another point of contention, Aasiya said
she wanted their children to go to a private school, while Hassan wanted
them to go to a public school. He said, in this case and others, when she
would make a demand she would get emotionally attached to the demand.

He said the idea for a TV station devoted to Muslim interests, one that
could build bridges between the Muslim and non-Muslim communities, came when
the couple heard anti-Muslim talk on the radio while they were in their car.

Hassan said they were able to raise $6 million or $7 million in seed capital
for the network, and that's when he left his job at M&T Bank to focus full
time on Bridges TV.

11:42 a.m. Hassan appears to be trying to show the jury that Aasiya can be
stubborn and insistent and can display flashes of a temper if she doesn't
get her way.

Aasiya finally got a visa, so she was able to join Hassan in Western New
York. She had worked as an architect, but Hassan said Aasiya didn't find any
good work opportunities here in that field. So, she went to work for a 7-11.

Hassan said her family has a business background, and she expressed interest
in running her own business or corporate franchise. They looked at several,
including Tim Hortons, before deciding to operate a 7-11 franchise.

In 2001, Hassan said, Aasiya said she wanted to go back to Pakistan to see
her family again. Hassan said financially this was difficult, following the
wedding expenses they had. Hassan said she kept insisting she had to go.

On a visit to Toronto to see a friend, Hassan said, Aasiya got out of their
car when it was stopped at a red light. Aasiya told him she wouldn't go to
the friend's dinner until Hassan bought her a ticket to travel to Pakistan.
Hassan said their argument on the street corner lasted half an hour before
Hassan went back to his car and called his mother for guidance. Aasiya then
got back into the car and went to the dinner, though she was in a foul mood
that night. Eventually, Hassan relented and bought Aasiya a ticket to
Pakistan.

11:33 a.m. Hassan continues to speak casually and evenly as he gives his
testimony to the jury. He is talking more about the beginning of his
marriage to Aasiya.

He said he was grateful that Aasiya was accepting of his children from his
first marriage. He described the process he went through to try to get a
tourist visa for Aasiya so that the couple could travel to Canada at some
point. He told the jury that she became very upset at him and abruptly left
the Internet cafe where they were using a computer. He said this incident
gave him the idea that she had difficulty verbalizing her feelings,
especially if she is upset.

He said because this was her first marriage, and his third, he decided they
would do whatever she wanted. They were spending the beginning of their
honeymoon in the north of Pakistan. Hassan said he felt he was more at
Aasiya's mercy and that she was making more of the decisions about what they
did on the honeymoon and which hotels they used.

But he said he didn't mind too much because he brought more "baggage" to the
marriage than she did. Aasiya said she wanted to be alone on the honeymoon
with Hassan, and he said she didn't want to see his father or his children,
which hurt him.

11:25 a.m. Hassan is continuing his narrative testimony. He is not asking
himself questions and Schwartz, his attorney who is serving more as a legal
advisor, is not asking him questions or otherwise speaking.

Hassan said he took medication for depression, and began reading books on
the causes of depression. After reading one book, and at the advice of a
counselor he was seeing, he went to a 12-step program for alcoholics. He
said he did this not because he was an alcoholic, or because alcohol had
caused the break-up of his marriage, but because he wanted to gain some
insights into the 12-step program and how it could help him.

At the same time, when Hassan was doing an internship at Eastman Kodak and
his two children were attending Sunday School in Rochester, he entered into
an arranged marriage. "In hindsight it was a bit silly," Hassan said, and he
believed the marriage was not a good fit for him. It was also at this time
that he left Rochester to take the job at M&T Bank. He said he got an order
of protection because the family of his second wife was pressuring him.
Curtin Gable objected to this statement. The judge sustained the objection.
Hassan filed for divorce from his second wife in 1998.

In 2000 he met Aasiya, online. He said they developed an online courtship
and by October 2000 he went to Pakistan to marry Aasiya. 

11:13 a.m. Franczyk is giving the jury instructions related to Hassan's
testimony in the trial. He is instructing them not to draw any conclusions
based on his decision to testify at trial, while he represents himself.
Court officers have placed a second chair near the witness stand for
Schwartz so that the attorney can advise the defendant.

Hassan has been sworn in. He is talking to the jury. He referred to the
killing of Aasiya as the "tragedy" of Feb. 12. "It is a very complex story."
He is speaking slowly and explaining that he has never run afoul of the law.
Curtin Gable objected to this statement, and her objection was sustained.
Hassan paused for a few seconds.

"I felt all I wanted to do was someone to hear my side of the story." He
said his side of the story of the couple's 10-year marriage hasn't been
heard. His testimony is beginning as a personal statement.

He gave the jury some background on his personal history. He is talking
about his father, and his family, saying they lived in Pakistan for the
first 15 years of his life. He said he went to a British school in Pakistan
and said he was a good student but he wasn't good at sports such as cricket
because he was on the heavy side.

He said he went to the University of Rochester on a scholarship and earned a
bachelor's degree in chemical engineering. After his bachelor's degree, he
went to work for Proctor & Gamble. After that company, he went back to
school for his MBA from the University of Rochester, which he finished in
1996. Then he worked at M&T Bank, where he served as a vice president before
leaving the bank in 2004 to work at Bridges TV full time.

On the personal level, in college, he met his first wife and soon got
married, in 1984, when he was 20. They separated in 1994. They had two
children, his oldest children, who both testified at the trial and are
estranged from their father now.

 

The break-up was difficult for him and he said he was hospitalized at a
mental institution in Connecticut for several weeks.

11 a.m. Prosecutor Colleen Curtin Gable said she and District Attorney Frank
A. Sedita III were served subpoenas at 9:55 a.m. directing them to appear in
court Friday. She said they will be moving to quash the subpoenas.

Prosecutor Paul Bonanno asked for a list of all the evidence Hassan intends
to introduce. Franczyk asked Hassan if he has such a list. Hassan said he
has the materials, but not the list. Franczyk said such a list would be
helpful to provide.

Prosecutors are asking for any discoverable material related to the
witnesses Hassan intends to call. Hassan said he may not be able to provide
it. The jury is now being called into the courtroom, one hour after the
scheduled start of the trial.

10:43 a.m. Franczyk is asking a court officer to explain the delay to
members of the jury by informing them that court personnel are marking
exhibits for use as evidence. The judge's law clerk is assisting the court
clerk in this task.

Hassan is representing himself in the trial but he huddles with Schwartz
frequently, seeking his advice or legal opinion on matters.

10:38 a.m. Hassan now is asking about the logistics of his testimony. He has
asked Franczyk whether his attorney, Jeremy Schwartz, will be able to sit or
stand close to him while he is on the stand. The judge said Schwartz would
be able to be near him while Hassan is on the stand.

"I am not going to let you question yourself on the stand. I think that's
absurd," Franczyk said to Hassan.

Franczyk is warning Hassan not to testify to statements or evidence that is
not admissible at trial.  "You can testify to facts. You can testify to
things you know through personal knowledge," the judge said. The judge added
that evidence he plans to introduce during his testimony should be premarked
as evidence, though Franczyk worries how much extra time this will take.

Hassan told Franczyk he may have as many as 1,000 items of evidence to mark,
a statement that drew a gasp from members of the audience in the courtroom.
Franczyk wondered what the jury would do in the interim.

"Your honor, I thought this is where the whole truth comes out," Hassan
said.

The judge said a trial is not an effort to discover some abstract truth. It
is held to see whether the prosecution can prove its case, and then it is up
to members of the jury to decide the defendant's guilt or innocence.
Franczyk, the prosecutor and the defense, along with court personnel,
continue to discuss how the trial will proceed.

10:28 a.m. Hassan's attorney and Hassan are discussing housekeeping issues
and admissible evidence with Franczyk. The jury is not yet in the courtroom,
and Franczyk has just admonished Hassan for making jurors wait this long
outside the courtroom.

"I don't know anything about the legal process. Sorry, your honor," Hassan
said.

10:24 a.m. The trial of Hassan has started. A line of about 30 members of
the public waited outside the courtroom to grab one of the coveted seats for
the high-profile trial. Only 10 were allowed into court.

Read News Staff Reporter Sandra Tan's account of Wednesday's court
proceedings in  <http://www.buffalonews.com/city/article324904.ece> "I have
not done anything to hurt you since Sunday, since I saw my mistake."

See The News' entire coverage of the Hassan case at the Mo Hassan topics
page <http://www.buffalonews.com/topics/mo-hassan/> .

 



[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]



------------------------------------

--------------------------
Want to discuss this topic?  Head on over to our discussion list, 
[email protected].
--------------------------
Brooks Isoldi, editor
[email protected]

http://www.intellnet.org

  Post message: [email protected]
  Subscribe:    [email protected]
  Unsubscribe:  [email protected]


*** FAIR USE NOTICE. This message contains copyrighted material whose use has 
not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. OSINT, as a part of 
The Intelligence Network, is making it available without profit to OSINT 
YahooGroups members who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the 
included information in their efforts to advance the understanding of 
intelligence and law enforcement organizations, their activities, methods, 
techniques, human rights, civil liberties, social justice and other 
intelligence related issues, for non-profit research and educational purposes 
only. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of the copyrighted material 
as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use 
this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' 
you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.
For more information go to:
http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtmlYahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/

<*> Your email settings:
    Individual Email | Traditional

<*> To change settings online go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/join
    (Yahoo! ID required)

<*> To change settings via email:
    [email protected] 
    [email protected]

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
    [email protected]

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
    http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/

Reply via email to