http://www.jewishworldreview.com/0111/glick012811.php3

 

Jan. 28, 2011 / 23 Shevat, 5771 

The pragmatic fantasy 

By Caroline B. Glick 

        




        
                

 

 

 

http://www.JewishWorldReview.com | Today the Egyptian regime faces its
gravest threat since Anwar Sadat's assassination thirty years ago. As
protesters take to the street for the third day in a row demanding the
overthrow of 82-year old President Hosni Mubarak, it is worth considering
the possible alternatives to his regime. 

Thursday afternoon, Egyptian presidential hopeful Mohammed ElBaradei, the
former head of the UN's International Atomic Energy Agency returned to Egypt
from Vienna to participate in anti-regime demonstrations. As IAEA head,
Elbaradei shielded Iran's nuclear weapons program from the Security Council.
He repeatedly ignored evidence indicating that Iran's nuclear program was a
military program rather than a civilian energy program. When the evidence
became too glaring to ignore, Elbaradei continued to lobby against
significant UN Security Council sanctions or other actions against Iran and
obscenely equated Israel's purported nuclear program to Iran's. 

His actions won him the support of the Iranian regime which he continues to
defend. Just last week he dismissed the threat of a nuclear armed Iran
telling the Austrian News Agency, "There's a lot of hype in this debate,"
and asserting that the discredited 2007 US National Intelligence Estimate
that claimed Iran abandoned its nuclear weapons program in 2003 remains
accurate. 

Elbaradei's support for the Iranian ayatollahs is matched by his support for
the Muslim Brotherhood. This group, which forms the largest and best
organized opposition movement to the Mubarak regime is the progenitor of
Hamas and al Qaida. It seeks Egypt's transformation into an Islamic regime
that will stand at the forefront of the global jihad. In recent years, the
Muslim Brotherhood has been increasingly drawn into the Iranian nexus along
with Hamas. Muslim Brotherhood attorneys represented Hizbullah terrorists
arrested in Egypt in 2009 for plotting to conduct spectacular attacks aimed
at destroying the regime. 

Elbaradei has been a strong champion of the Muslim Brotherhood. Just this
week he gave an interview to Der Spiegel defending the jihadist movement. As
he put it, "We should stop demonizing the Muslim Brotherhood. .[T]hey have
not committed any acts of violence in five decades. They too want change. If
we want democracy and freedom, we have to include them instead of
marginalizing them." The Muslim Brotherhood for its part has backed
Elbaradei's political aspirations. On Thursday it announced it would
demonstrate at ElBaradei's side the next day. 


Then there is the Kifaya movement. The group sprang onto the international
radar screen in 2004 when it demanded open presidential elections and called
on Mubarak not to run for a fifth term. As a group of intellectuals claiming
to support liberal, democratic norms, Kifaya has been upheld as a model of
what the future of Egypt could look like if liberal forces are given the
freedom to lead. 

But Kifaya's roots and basic ideology are not liberal. They are anti-Semitic
and anti-American. Kifaya was formed as a protest movement against Israel
with the start of the Palestinian terror war in 2000. It gained force in
March 2003 when it organized massive protests against the US-led invasion of
Iraq. In 2006 its campaign to get a million Egyptians to sign a petition
demanding the abrogation of Egypt's peace treaty with Israel received
international attention. 

Many knowledgeable Egypt-watchers argued this week that the protesters have
no chance of bringing down the Mubarak regime. Unlike this month's overthrow
of Tunisia's despot Zine El Abidine Ben Ali, they say there is little chance
that the Egyptian military will abandon Mubarak. 

But the same observers are quick to note that whoever Mubarak selects to
succeed him will not be the beneficiary of such strong support from Egypt's
security state. And as the plight of Egypt's overwhelmingly impoverished
citizenry becomes ever more acute, the regime will become increasingly
unstable. Indeed, its overthrow is as close to a certainty as you can get in
international affairs. 

And as we now see, all of its possible secular and Islamist successors
either reject outright Egypt's peace treaty with Israel or will owe their
political power to the support of those who reject the peace with the Jewish
state. So whether the Egyptian regime falls next week or next year or five
years from now, the peace treaty is doomed. 

Since the start of Israel's peace process with Egypt in 1977, supporters of
peace with the Arabs have always fallen into two groups: the idealists and
the pragmatists. 

Led by Shimon Peres, the idealists have argued that the reason the Arabs
refuse to accept Israel is because Israel took "their" land in the 1967 Six
Day War. Never mind that the war was a consequence of Arab aggression or
that it was simply a continuation of the Arab bid to destroy the Jewish
state which officially began with Israel's formal establishment in 1948. As
the idealists see things, if Israel just gives up all the land it won in
that war, the Arabs will be appeased and accept Israel as a friend and
natural member of the Middle East' family of nations. 

Peres was so enamored with this view that he authored The New Middle East
and promised that once all the land was given away, Israel would join the
Arab League. Given the absurdity of their claims, the idealists were never
able to garner mass support for their positions. If it had just been up to
them, Israel would never have gotten on the peace train. But lucky for the
idealists, they have been able to rely on the unwavering support of the
unromantic pragmatists to implement their program. 

Unlike the starry-eyed idealists, the so-called pragmatists have no
delusions that the Arabs are motivated by anything other than hatred for
Israel, or that their hatred is likely to end in the foreseeable future. But
still, they argue, Israel needs to surrender. 

It is the "Arab Street's" overwhelming animosity towards Israel that causes
the pragmatists to argue that Israel's best play is to cut deals with Arab
dictators who rule with an iron fist. Since Israel and the Arab despots
share a fear of the Arab masses, the pragmatists claim that Israel should
give up all the land it took control over as a payoff to the regimes, who in
exchange will sign peace treaties with it. 

This was the logic that brought Israel to surrender the strategically
priceless Sinai Peninsula to Egypt in exchange for the Camp David accord
that will not survive Mubarak. 

And of course, giving up the Sinai wasn't the only sacrifice Israel made for
that nearly defunct document. Israel also gave up its regional monopoly on
US military platforms. Israel agreed that in exchange for signing the deal,
the US would begin providing massive military aid to Egypt. Indeed, it
agreed to link US aid to Israel with US aid to Egypt. 

Owing to that US aid, the Egyptian military today makes the military Israel
barely defeated in 1973 look like a gang of cavemen. Egypt has nearly 300
F-16s. Its main battle tank is the M1A1 which it produces in Egypt. Its navy
is largest in the region. Its army is twice the size of the IDF. Its air
defense force constitutes a massive threat to the IAF. 

And of course, the ballistic missiles and chemical weapons it has purchased
from the likes of North Korea and China give it a significant stand-off mass
destruction capability. Despite its strength, due to the depth of popular
Arab hatred of Israel and Jews, the Egyptian regime was weakened by its
peace treaty. Partially in a bid to placate its opponents and partially in a
bid to check Israeli power, Egypt has been the undisputed leader of the
political war against Israel raging at international arenas throughout the
world. So too, Mubarak has permitted and even encouraged massive
anti-Semitism throughout Egyptian society. 

With this balance sheet at the end of the "era of peace," between Israel and
Egypt, it is far from clear that Israel was right to sign the deal in the
first place. In light of the relative longevity of the regime it probably
made sense to have made some deal with Egypt. But it is clear that the price
Israel paid was outrageously inflated and unwise. 

In contrast to the Egyptian regime, as the popular outcry following Al
Jazeera's publication of the Palestinian negotiations documents this week
shows, the Fatah-run Palestinian Authority is as weak as can be. Yitzhak
Rabin, the godfather of the pragmatist camp famously argued that Yassir
Arafat and Fatah would handle the Israel-hating Palestinian Street, "without
the Supreme Court and B'Tselem." 

That is, he argued that it made sense to surrender massive amounts of
strategically critical land to a terrorist organization because Arafat and
his associates would repress their people with an iron fist, unfettered by
the rule of law and Palestinian human rights organizations. 

And yet, the fact of the matter is that Arafat commanded the terror war
against Israel that began in 2000 and transformed Palestinian society into a
jihadist society that popularly elected Hamas to lead it. 

The leaked Palestinian documents don't tell us much we didn't already know
about the nature of negotiations between Israel and Fatah. The Palestinians
demanded that the baseline of talks assume that all the disputed territories
actually belong to them. And for no particular reason, Tzipi Livni and Ehud
Olmert agreed to these historically unjustified terms of reference. 

While this was well known, in publishing the documents, Al Jazeera has still
made two important contributions to the public debate. First, the PA's
panicked reaction to the documents exposes the ridiculousness of the notion
that the likes of Mahmoud Abbas, Saeb Erekat and Salam Fayyad are viable
partners for peace. 

Not only do they lack the power to maintain a peace deal with Israel. They
lack to power to sign a peace deal with Israel. All they can do is talk -
far away from the cameras - about hypothetical, marginal concessions in a
peace that will never, ever be achieved. The notion that Israel should pay
any price for a deal with these nobodies is completely ridiculous. 

The Al Jazeera papers also expose Livni's foolishness. Just as she failed to
recognize the inherent weakness of the Lebanese state when she championed UN
Security Council Resolution 1701 which called for the Hizbullah-dominated
Lebanese army to deploy to the border with Israel at the end of the 2006
war, so Livni failed to understand the significance of the inherent weakness
of Fatah as she negotiated away Gush Etzion and Har Homa. 

And she didn't need Al Jazeera's campaign against the PA to understand that
she was speaking to people who represent no one. That basic fact was already
proven with Hamas's victory in the 2006 elections. 

The truths exposed by the convulsive events of the past month make it
abundantly clear that Israel lives in a horrible neighborhood. It is a
neighborhood where popular democracy means war against Israel. 

In this neck of the woods, it is not pragmatic to surrender. It is crazy. 

 

 



[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]



------------------------------------

--------------------------
Want to discuss this topic?  Head on over to our discussion list, 
[email protected].
--------------------------
Brooks Isoldi, editor
[email protected]

http://www.intellnet.org

  Post message: [email protected]
  Subscribe:    [email protected]
  Unsubscribe:  [email protected]


*** FAIR USE NOTICE. This message contains copyrighted material whose use has 
not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. OSINT, as a part of 
The Intelligence Network, is making it available without profit to OSINT 
YahooGroups members who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the 
included information in their efforts to advance the understanding of 
intelligence and law enforcement organizations, their activities, methods, 
techniques, human rights, civil liberties, social justice and other 
intelligence related issues, for non-profit research and educational purposes 
only. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of the copyrighted material 
as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use 
this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' 
you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.
For more information go to:
http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtmlYahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/

<*> Your email settings:
    Individual Email | Traditional

<*> To change settings online go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/join
    (Yahoo! ID required)

<*> To change settings via email:
    [email protected] 
    [email protected]

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
    [email protected]

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
    http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/

Reply via email to