Fred Reed is ignorant.

 

B

 

Hi

 

You mis-spelled the subject line.  It was supposed to read, "Non-sober
thoughts on Afghanistan".  I can tell by the way the article was written
that Fred was drinking a bit too much that day.  I have been reading Fred's
work since the 1980's when he wrote for the Washington Times (where he
actually did some pretty good coverage of military topics).  I don't know
exactly why he "retired" and went to Mexico, but it wouldn't surprise me if
it had to do with excessive alcohol consumption and the price of cheap
liquor in Mexico.

 

First things first.  Fred says:

"Perhaps they are right, and I have underestimated the knowledge and
attention span of the citizenry. I hate to admit it, but, well, truth is
truth. With respect to the wars against Islam, I tend to think in military
terms, and then write (I confess) in vague generalities. This may appear to
be condescension to Sean Hannity's viewers. If I have done them wrong, I
apologize."

 

Thank you for the well-deserved apology.  I accept on behalf of the millions
of Tea Party activists who are more knowledgeable and reasonable than Fred.

 

Just a few facts to illustrate the problems with Fred in his current state:

 

1.  The mention of the Mk. 48 ADCAP missile with the
"enemy-creating-larger-than-Hellfire-warhead left me puzzled because I
follow military topics fairly closely, though I do not claim to be an
expert, yet I could not remember any such missile.  So I looked it up in a
few open-source military sites and found the "Mk. 48 ADCAP torpedo" (not
"missile) that has recently been tested and deployed.  Although this TORPEDO
does in fact have a much larger warhead than a Hellfire missile (as fired
from helicopters, planes, and UAV's), 650 lbs. vs. 38 pounds, I'll be damned
if I can figure out how they are going to transport those 5,000 ton
submarines over the mountains into Afghanistan or Pakistan.  I also doubt
that most Taliban/AQ members live in housboats.  Also, the TORPEDO weighs
almost 2 tons (vs. 108 lbs for an AGM-114 Hellfire MISSILE), so it could not
be launched from any existing helicopter or UAV.  Seems like some pretty
large errors to me.  Naturally, if someone has some concrete info on the
supposed Mk.48 ADCAP missile, I would be happy to examine the material to
improve my own knowledge.

 

2.  There is in fact a somewhat more advanced missile (JAGM) that is due to
replace the Hellfire when inventory runs out, but aside from being a MISSILE
that doesn't require a giant submarine to be present for launch, it is
almost an exact match for the Hellfire, in terms of length (76 inches),
diameter (7 inches), weight (108 lbs.), and warhead weight (about 40 lbs.).
This similarity in size and weight is only logical, since it is intended to
be carried and fired from the same launch rails on the same vehicles as the
older Hellfire missile.  Since most Moslems are already angry with the
infidels (you and me and everyone not "them"), it seems rather implausible
that this more advanced, but similar warhead-size missile, is going to give
that extra boost to their madness.  Unless the Taliban has bred a new
generation of wound ballistics experts who can make minute distinctions
between Hellfire fragments and JAGM fragments.  Ummm, sure.

 

3.  Fred also mentions the "workhorse" AH-78 Commanche helicopter....which
does not now, nor has it ever existed.  Our Army isn't even up to ANY AH
(attack helicopter) with a 78 model number.  There WAS a prototype AH-66
Comanche (correct spelling, not Fred's) helicopter that was tested and found
to offer less capability than the commonplace AH-64 Apache helicopters, thus
making it redundant and too expensive.  Exit stage left.

 

4.  Fred fantasizes that the U.S. is going to give the Afghans 6 of our
(presumably) AH-64D helicopters with a "highly classified" radar that would
inevitably be in the hands of the Chinese within a week.  Now, Fred should
know better than that, since he covered military features for the Washington
Times for approximately a decade.  I'm sure he has heard of "export
versions" of some of our high tech products, which have NOT had the highest
tech goodies installed.  We even do that with countries that we consider
"semi-reliable-allies" like Saudi Arabia.  I see little reason to assume
that the "highly classified radar" would be included in the Afghan
helicopters.  In fact, they might not even get the "D" model with the old
radar, but only the AH-64A model with NO radar.  Just for reference, not all
of our helicopters are the D model with radar.  It just isn't necessary for
many missions, and it is expensive.

 

5.  This is the last topic I have time to address today.  Fred also mentions
the Iranian ' AK 16"-54 ' rifle being supplied to the Afghans, with its
apparently much deadlier, longer barrel, and "which fires a heavier and
therefore longer-ranged bullet".  Surely something we should greatly fear,
right?  Ooops, a few problems arise.  First, open source materials show no
such model, although there is an AKM light machine gun with a longer barrel,
but it's not any more accurate than a normal AK.  Second, a longer-ranged
bullet does not do you much good in an inaccurate rifle, which describes
almost all AK variants.  And long range shooting is a rare skill, possessed
by very, very few Taliban/AQ.  If your bullet will easily travel 2 miles,
but you can't hit anything beyond 200 yards, you are just kidding yourself
if you think this makes you a battlefield superman, or even a competentman.
Third, considering that there are millions of AK-47's and AK-47M's floating
around every battlefield and 3rd world nation on earth, available for the
equivalent price of a goat or 5 chickens, the idea that Iran's supply of
AK's to the Taliban will make any noticeable difference is just insane.  SVD
more to Fred's taste? Jousting at windmills, anyone?

 

I feel sorry for Fred, actually.  He used to be such a good source of info.

 

R.

 

 

  


Sober Thoughts on Afghanistan
by Fred Reed

I get a certain amount of email saying that I am arrogant and dismissive of
the intelligence and political knowledge of certain groups, most notably Tea
Partyers and the audience of Fox News, but also of the American public in
general. Supposedly I talk to them as if they were ignorant when in fact, I
am told, they are not. Some critics have compared me to Mencken with his
disdain for the Booboisie.

Perhaps they are right, and I have underestimated the knowledge and
attention span of the citizenry. I hate to admit it, but, well, truth is
truth. With respect to the wars against Islam, I tend to think in military
terms, and then write (I confess) in vague generalities. This may appear to
be condescension to Sean Hannity's viewers. If I have done them wrong, I
apologize.

All right. Let me try to discuss the wars intelligently, not giving
ideological solutions but just stating the problems from the standpoint of
those who actually have to fight and manage the wars.

(1) The American command wants to run raids across the Afghan border into
Pakistan and Tajikistan to attack Al Qaeda guerrillas who currently enjoy
safe havens in those countries. This is needed, say officers, to save
American lives. But in Islamabad, Benazir Bhutto's Falafel Party - she was
assassinated, but the party lives on, as intensely nationalistic as ever -
says it wants the Pakistani Army to fire on American troops if they "invade"
the country.

What now? While the Falafelists are not in power, they are strong in the
military. Fighting very nearly broke out during a US helicopter raid against
Herat in the Federated Tribal Territories. Do we pursue Al Qaeda at the
possible cost of war with the Paki Army? Tough choice.

(2) We are all familiar with the Predator and Raptor drones used to target
Al Qaeda suspects in Pakistan and Afghanistan. The Pentagon wants to replace
the Hellfire missiles fired currently by the drones with the new Mk 48 ADCAP
("Advanced Capability") missile which, while much more accurate, also has a
larger blast radius - meaning that more civilians will be killed. Is it
worth it, given the anger aroused among civilian populations by the extra
deaths? This is the kind of question that commanders on the ground must
decide.

(3) Then there is the difficult question of cultivation of opium poppies.
When the Taliban took over following the withdrawal of the Russians from
Afghanistan in 1989, they forced farmers into the production of the drug,
thus making the rural population dependent on the (small) profits the
extremists allowed them. The Americans of course want to eliminate the
poppies, but this would do nothing to win the hearts and minds of the
growers. (What are the farmers doing to do? Grow potatoes instead? College
kids won't pay $500 an ounce for sin-semilla spuds.)

So what does the military do about towns like Hecuba and Priam, in Sulawese
Province on the southern border with Iran, which are transshipment points
for drugs crossing Iran en route to European markets? Eliminate them, and
lose the population? Or allow the traffic to continue in order to further
the war effort? The present solution, if so it is, is to uneasily ignore the
question.

Somebody has to make a decision. And it will be denounced in the press as
wrong, either way.

(4) Apart from Black Hawk troop-carrying helicopters, the workhorse chopper
of the war has been the AH-78 Commanche gunship, now equipped with the BQQ-6
submillimeter-wave radar for detecting the movement of metal armaments
(e.g., rifles) at night. The radar is highly classified.

The State Department wants to transfer six of the craft to the Afghan "air
force" (actually a few helicopters) to show faith in the Karzai government.
The Pentagon says the technology would be in Taliban, and thus Chinese,
hands within a week. Worth it? Somebody has to decide, and both answers are
wrong.

The (accidental) damage to the Al Aqsa mosque in Kandahar by a drone strike
aroused fury among the militant Sufi tribesmen of the region. These have a
tradition of almost constant war, dating back to the rule of Peshmurga I,
and of Sufi control over the silk trade through the Khyber Pass to
Rawalpindi and on to Bukitinggi.

Again, it's hearts-and-minds versus military objectives. If you restrict
bombing near mosques, you give Al Qaeda safe havens. If you damage (or, as
some have proposed, even deliberately bomb) mosques, you infuriate the
locals and, so say some commentators, produce recruits to Al Qaeda and the
Taliban. A? Or B?

(5) Iran. According to Infantry Weapons and Light Armor, the bible of the
military small-arms world, Iran is making available to the insurgents the AK
16"-54 (the NATO designation of the long-barreled Iranian knock-off of the
AK47, which fires a heavier and therefore longer-ranged bullet). This has
long been known.

More worrisome, some of the explosives used recently in roadside bombs show
the chemical signature of manufacture at the Iranian arms complex at
Bucephalus. These substances, used in shaped charges, can penetrate the side
armor on M1 tanks. Tehran wants a stable environment for Bucephalis, since
it derives considerable revenue from arms sales, and thus might stop
shipping explosives under American pressure. So far it hasn't.

Should the US bomb the plant, widening the war? Or, instead, accept the
additional losses in Afghanistan to avoid stretching forces already spread
thin? Not an easy question.

(6) Then there is the tricky matter of Hamid Karzai, the Afghan president in
Kabul. The US knows he is corrupt, but has to pretend that he isn't. Such
fictions are part of diplomacy. NATO would like to replace him if it could
dig up a suitable candidate - Ahmad Shah Massoud is mentioned, though he is
said to be good for splashy photo-ops and not much else. Another suggestion
is Yusuf Sala al-Din, but despite his lack of recent political activity he
is suspected of hostility to what bin Laden calls "Crusaders," meaning
European invaders of Islamic lands. Who, then? What it comes to is that
Afghanistan is not brimming over with democratically-minded leaders.

Anyway, how to get rid of Karzai? He could die in a car accident, but that
would be a tad obvious even for the CIA.

(7) Finally another, seemingly minor, instance of what many see as the
military's lack of concern for the feelings of Afghans: General Stanley
McCrystal, before being fired by Obama, flew to the town of Augea in Helmand
Province - in a Lockheed C-130 Hercules cargo plane. The Herc is designed
for unimproved or nonexistent runways, which explains the choice - but it
terrified the herds of the villagers, which stampeded into the countryside.
Then McCrystal, walking through the town, said audibly that Augea was "full
of shit." True in a sense: any town relying on donkeys for transportation
will fit the description. But the village headmaster knew enough English to
understand the slur. Net result: another several hundred Afghans who don't
like the US.

Solution?

Enough. My point is that "the devil is in the details." It is fine to
denounce Islamofascism. Yet, while I do not doubt that the foregoing matters
are understood by the better minds on Fox News, for example Bill O'Reilly
and Saraa Palin, their viewers may have trouble distinguishing truth from
fiction. I have not meant to talk down to them, and neither should the folk
at Fox.

www.fredoneverything.com <http://www.fredoneverything.com/>  





[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]



------------------------------------

--------------------------
Want to discuss this topic?  Head on over to our discussion list, 
[email protected].
--------------------------
Brooks Isoldi, editor
[email protected]

http://www.intellnet.org

  Post message: [email protected]
  Subscribe:    [email protected]
  Unsubscribe:  [email protected]


*** FAIR USE NOTICE. This message contains copyrighted material whose use has 
not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. OSINT, as a part of 
The Intelligence Network, is making it available without profit to OSINT 
YahooGroups members who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the 
included information in their efforts to advance the understanding of 
intelligence and law enforcement organizations, their activities, methods, 
techniques, human rights, civil liberties, social justice and other 
intelligence related issues, for non-profit research and educational purposes 
only. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of the copyrighted material 
as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use 
this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' 
you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.
For more information go to:
http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtmlYahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/

<*> Your email settings:
    Individual Email | Traditional

<*> To change settings online go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/join
    (Yahoo! ID required)

<*> To change settings via email:
    [email protected] 
    [email protected]

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
    [email protected]

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
    http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/

Reply via email to