The Left's Converging Political Misjudgments: Communism and Radical Islam

Posted By Paul Hollander On February 28, 2011 

The fall of Mubarak in a country where the Muslim Brotherhood is the
strongest and best organized political movement raises the possibility of an
eventual outcome similar to that in Iran that followed the overthrow of the
Shah in 1979. At the same time, we should remind ourselves that history need
not repeat itself: Egypt is not Iran and the Egyptian military may prevent
the rise to power of the Brotherhood. But in the event that it comes to
power, there is little reason to imagine that it would usher in a system
more open, enlightened and liberal than that of Mubarak. Far more likely, it
would resemble the repressive theocracy of Iran. While the actual historical
and political developments in these two countries may diverge, the
similarities between perceptions on the Left of these two historical events,
and the part played by political Islam, are already quite pronounced.

Why do people on the Left, and especially intellectuals - often motivated by
high ideals and good intentions - so often make poor political judgments,
especially about the adversaries of the United States? It is of course
always difficult to generalize about entities such as intellectuals. There
are no opinion surveys addressed to "intellectuals" as such, hence, we only
learn about the attitudes and beliefs of the more prominent among them who
have the opportunity and inclination to express themselves in writing or in
the mass media.

To be sure, there are surveys of the political attitudes of various
professions, including professors, which include a high proportion of
intellectuals in the humanities and social sciences. These surveys make
clear that most American academics are left of center: "Democrats typically
outnumber Republicans at elite universities by at least six to one among the
general faculty and by higher ratios in the humanities and social sciences."
A recent study of academic social psychologists found a total lack of
diversity in their political views and found them to constitute a
"tribal-moral community united by sacred values." [1] Of course, these
attitudes are just as prevalent in departments of English, sociology,
anthropology, history and political science as among social psychologists.

The global rise of Islamic radicalism, loosely paralleled by the global
decline of communism, provides a new occasion to ponder the political
judgments of those on the Left, including many intellectuals. Their
observations about Islamic radicalism suggest parallels between their
disposition towards the two important political-ideological currents of our
times: communism and political Islam. This is not to say that these two sets
of attitudes have been the same, but there are some notable similarities as
well as differences spelled out below.

By the time of the fall of the Soviet Union, not many American leftist
intellectuals were enamored of the Soviet system (or those modeled after
it), with the exception of Cuba and, for a shorter period, Nicaragua.
Venezuela under Chavez has become a new destination for a smaller group of
supporters. One of them, Eva Golinger, became a resident supporter and
cheerleader for Chavez, describing herself as "a soldier of this revolution.
I would do whatever asked of me for this country." As the New York Times put
it, "Her zeal invokes earlier waves of political pilgrims in Latin America
from rich countries like the volunteers who cut Cuban sugar cane in the
1960s or the Sandalistas. who flocked to Nicaragua in the 1980s." Ms.
Golinger has  expressed warmth and sympathy toward Ahmadinejad of Iran and
Lukashenko of Belarus. She considered the latter a socialist country, not a
dictatorship, "where people seemed really into their communal work and stuff
like that." [2]

But even if many members of the Left no longer admired these systems, the
attitudes which gave rise to their sympathy and support in the first place
were by no means gone. These attitudes were deeply rooted in a highly
critical disposition toward American society, disdain for capitalism and
commerce, ignorance about "actually existing" communist states, as well as a
propensity to chronic moral indignation. [3]

While militant Islamic movements and theocratic Iran shared the
anti-American disposition of communist states, their anti-Americanism has
been far more intense and irrational than the communist variety due to its
religious inspiration. A strong aversion to modernity has further added to
hostility to the United States, correctly seen as a major embodiment of
modernity. In turn, Islamic movements came to be viewed with a degree of
sympathy by numerous American intellectuals and those on the Left, who were
convinced of the worthlessness of their own society, and were irresistibly
drawn to "the enemies of their enemy."

It has not been easy, sometimes impossible, to project upon these movements
the attributes which earlier attracted many American and other Western
intellectuals to communist systems. Unlike the movements and political
systems inspired by Marxism, Islamic movements and beliefs are not
universalistic, they are openly and demonstratively intolerant and uphold
traditional religious beliefs that are alien to secular, leftist Western
intellectuals. Islamic societies permeated by Islamic tradition oppress
women, hate and mistreat homosexuals, and are beholden to a wide range of
rigid religious beliefs and practices, including corporal punishments such
as stoning, amputation and beheading. Such attitudes and policies are
difficult to accept for progressive leftists who believe in the equality of
women and in the rights of people of different sexual orientation and are
opposed to capital and corporal punishment. These attributes of Islamic
movements and societies have given a pause to some on the Left, but many
others have managed to ignore these blemishes, or ascribe them to an
authentic cultural heritage that is to be treated with toleration.

In addition to their intense hostility to the United States (greatly
appreciated by the native social critics) Islamic movements and the one
existing theocratic Islamic state (Iran) also partake of the allure of the
Third World. Upon the latter, many Western intellectuals have, for some
time, projected their longings and hopes following their partial
disillusionment with communist states. [4]  The imaginary virtues of the
Third World included, above all, a presumed freedom from the corruptions of
Western capitalist societies and a corresponding authenticity associated
with its traditional, pre-modern aspects. The Third World has received
further moral credit from leftist intellectuals and their followers on
account of its victimization (real or imaginary) by predatory Western
capitalism.

Even a highly oppressive theocracy such as the one established in Iran
earned the sympathy and support of prominent American intellectuals such as
Richard Falk (of Princeton University) who in 1979 thought that Ayatollah
Khomeini was "defamed" by the American news media and believed that he
created "a new model of popular revolution based, for the most part, on
non-violent tactics;" in his view, Iran was going to "provide us with a
desperately needed model of human governance." [5] Ramsey Clark, an
especially embittered critic of U.S. foreign policy and American society,
rushed to France in 1979 to meet Ayatollah Khomeni and in the same year also
visited Iran to show solidarity with the new regime. In 1986, following the
U.S. bombings of LIbya, Clark traveled to Libya once more to show his
solidarity to a government hostile to the United States. Clark also
volunteered his legal services to the bombers of the American embassies in
Kenya and Tanzania, and to Saddam Hussein, among other groups and
individuals hostile to the United States. [6] Michel Foucault, the famous
French philosopher, was similarly supportive of the Iranian theocracy,
observing that Ayatollah Khomeini reflected "the perfectly unified will" of
the Iranian people, among other enthusiastic comments. [7]

Somewhat unexpectedly in the wake of 9/11, many of these feelings and
attitudes found new expression. Numerous Western intellectuals on the Left
used the occasion to aver that the attack was well deserved, and its root
causes were to be found in the American mistreatment of Islamic countries
and populations and in the exploitative practices of global capitalism
headquartered in the United States. As Christopher Hitchens put it, "jihad
[became] an understandable reaction to Muslim grievances" and even "a
supposed socialist-feminist [Naomi Klein] [was] offering swooning support to
theocratic fascists." [8] Jean Baudrillard and Norman Mailer relished the
symbolic punishment meted out in the destruction of the towers of the World
Trade Center, symbols of global capitalism.

In May 8, 2006, Noam Chomsky visited Lebanon, meeting Hezbollah leaders and
providing them with welcome moral support and political legitimacy. He also
expressed strong support (on both Lebanese and Hezbollah television) for
Hezbollah keeping its weapons - a position directly contradicting the UN
Resolution No. 1559 that called for its disarming. [9] Norman Finkelstein -
whose detestation of Israel rivals that of Chomsky, offered at an
"Islamophobia" conference in Istanbul his sympathetic understanding of
Holocaust denial in the Muslim world and argued that it is used to
"demonize" Muslims. He was far less disturbed by these denials than by the
alleged "demonization." Since his parents were Holocaust survivors, he did
not deny it. Like Chomsky (his role model) he readily equated the Holocaust
and Nazism with the misdeeds of the United States. [10] Lynne Stewart, the
radical lawyer represented (and admired) Sheikh Omar Abdul Rahman, who as
convicted in 2005 (in spite of Stewart's efforts) in the 1993 bombing of the
World Trade Center. Subsequently, Stewart was convicted and sentenced to
jail for supporting Rahman's organization in 2006. She has been an admirer
not only of Muslim fundamentalists but also of Mao, Castro and Ho Chi Minh.
[11]

Other notable leftist sympathizers with radical Islam include George
Galloway, (former Labor member of the British Parliament), Naomi Klein, and
the late Edward Said. Ian Buruma and Timothy Garton Ash are distinguished by
their shared scorn for Ayaan Hirshi Ali, the Somali-born critic of Islam and
former member of the Dutch parliament, who has been subject to numerous
death threats. By contrast, they both think well of Tariq Ramadan, the well
known Western spokesman of Islamist causes who pretends to be a moderate
when addressing Western academic audiences. In his Murder in Amsterdam,
Buruma postulated a moral equivalence between alleged Dutch racism and
Muslim fundamentalism.

As to the recent responses to the potential rise in power of the Muslim
Brotherhood in Egypt, Bruce Riedel of the Brookings Institute in an op-ed
advised "Don't Fear Egypt's Muslim Brotherhood" and Shadi Hamid (also of
Brookings) wrote that "Westerners should not lose sleep over the
Brotherhood's inclusion. A pragmatic organization at its core." [12]

While not even the most bitterly alienated American leftists can easily
glorify or fully justify the traditional, repressive and less than fully
rational aspects of Islamic political culture (including Sharia law), a
number of similarities may be found between their attitudes toward communist
systems and those toward radical, political Islam. The appreciation of
anti-Americanism and a broader anti-Westernism are not the only
similarities. Many Western leftists and especially intellectuals among them
have found the collectivism of both communist systems and of Islam appealing
given their yearning for community and their rejection of capitalistic
competitiveness, as well as their apprehensions about social isolation in
Western capitalist societies. They also find attractive the apparent sense
of purpose permeating both communist and Islamic societies and movements.
The most alienated among American and other Western intellectuals are also
drawn to the fundamentalist Islamic rejection of modernity: they too reject
many aspects of modernity, namely popular culture, consumerism, moral
relativism and assorted social pathologies such as crime, alcoholism and
drug addiction.

Authenticity, the unity of word and deed (or theory and practice), is also
highly prized by leftist Western intellectuals and their followers and they
find a great deal of it among militant Islamic radicals. Indisputably,
suicide bombers act out their beliefs, they unite theory and practice, as
communist revolutionaries used to a long time ago.

Nonetheless, Western leftist views of the relationship between theory and
practice are not consistent, neither as regards communist systems of the
past nor the religious-fundamentalist Islamic movements of the present.
During the Cold War, leftist peace activists, as well as numerous academic
specialists, used to argue that the Soviet Union was not a serious threat
because its policies (including those flagrantly aggressive) were largely
defensive and not motivated by ideology (by Marxism-Leninism). The West
could "do business" with the Soviet Union (and other communist systems)
because it no longer pursued a militant, messianic, expansionist policy and
because theory ceased to matter, as Soviet leaders became increasingly
pragmatic. They further suggested that peaceful coexistence was possible
provided the West make a serious attempt to understand the grievances and
insecurities of communist leaders - a view strikingly similar to current
exhortations to engage Islamic movements and their leaders in a dialogue. 

There is a further, striking similarity between the past dismissal of
ideology as a force in the conduct of communist systems and the current
denials that Islamic religious values and beliefs play a part in Islamic
violence although suicide bombers regularly affirm their unshakeable belief
in the generous other-wordly rewards that await them. They are confident
that putting to death a sufficient number of American, British, Israeli,
Indonesian, Iraqi or Spanish infidels - men, women, children and the old,
will usher in a better world.

  _____  

  _____  

As in the old days, the Left insists that a better, non-judgmental approach
will mollify Islamic extremists and radicals - as was hoped to be the case
in regard to Communist leaders and ideologues. They believe that adopting
conciliatory attitudes and policies will lead to peace, goodwill and
rational discourse. It is difficult for critics of the United States and
Western values to attribute irrationality to the enemies of their countries
and social systems.

Ready attribution of moral equivalence is another similarity between
attitudes toward communist systems and radical Islam. As may be recalled,
during the Cold War, and especially following the 1960s, it was widely held
by leftist intellectuals in the United States (and elsewhere) that there was
little to choose between American or Soviet imperialism, between the two
corrupt and oppressive super powers. More recently, American and Israeli
policies have been equated with, and held responsible for, the violence of
Islamic terrorists, who, in this perspective, had no choice but to engage in
their campaigns of destruction and violence to draw attention to their
grievances.

In the final analysis, it is difficult to quantify the similarities between
the two sets of attitudes and misperceptions discussed above. The leftist
support for communist systems and ideologies probably greatly exceeded
present day sympathy for radical Islam in the same circles. Communist
systems - their ideology, slogans, and promises - were easier to idealize
than present day Islamic fanaticism, dogmatic rigidity and murderous
intolerance. What has been similar is the misperception and wishful
misjudgment of both political entities because they meet certain needs and
allowed leftist intellectuals to project upon them attributes they valued
and could not find in their own society. Most importantly, they have been
seen in a favorable light because they shared the hostility toward Western
societies and traditions which has animated many leftist intellectuals for
several generations.

Paul Hollander is professor emeritus of sociology at the University of
Massachusetts, Amherst and associate of the Davis Center for Russian and
Eurasian Studies at Harvard University. He is the author or editor of
fourteen books, including Political Pilgrims. 

Notes:

[1]. John Tierney: "Social Scientist Sees Bias Within," New York Times,
February  8, 2011.

[2] Simon Romero: "In Venezuela, an American Has the President's Ear," New
York Times, February 5, 2011]

[3] Tom Wolfe proposed  that indignation was an essential quality of the
intellectual "that elevated him to a plateau of moral superiority." ["In the
Land of the  Rococo Marxists," Hooking Up, New York, 2000, p.117.]

[4] Of course some Third World countries have also been communist and
therefore all the more appealing, i.e. Cuba, China (under Mao), Vietnam,
Nicaragua and others.

[5] Falk quoted in  New York Times, February 19, 1979.

[6] Http:/www.  DiscovertheNewtworks.org/individualProfile.asp?indid=781 

[7] Wesley Young: "The Philosopher and the Ayatollah," Boston Globe, June
12, 2005. See also James Miller: The Passion of Michel  Foucault, Cambridge,
MA  2000.

[8] Hitchens in Slate, September 7, 2004.

[9] Zachary Hughes in CAMERA (Committee for Accuracy in Middle East
Reporting) , July 20, 2006.

[10] Finkelstein: "Islamophobia and Holocaust Denial" see his  "official
website" December 1, 2007.

[11] DiscovertheNetworks.Org cited,  indid=861; see also George Packer on
Lynne Stewart  in New York Times Magazine, September 22, 2002.

[12] Quoted in David Flynn: "Brookings and the Brotherhood" Frontpage,
February 19, 2011.

  _____  

Article printed from FrontPage Magazine: http://frontpagemag.com

URL to article:
http://frontpagemag.com/2011/02/28/the-lefts-converging-political-misjudgmen
ts-communism-and-radical-islam/

 



[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]



------------------------------------

--------------------------
Want to discuss this topic?  Head on over to our discussion list, 
[email protected].
--------------------------
Brooks Isoldi, editor
[email protected]

http://www.intellnet.org

  Post message: [email protected]
  Subscribe:    [email protected]
  Unsubscribe:  [email protected]


*** FAIR USE NOTICE. This message contains copyrighted material whose use has 
not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. OSINT, as a part of 
The Intelligence Network, is making it available without profit to OSINT 
YahooGroups members who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the 
included information in their efforts to advance the understanding of 
intelligence and law enforcement organizations, their activities, methods, 
techniques, human rights, civil liberties, social justice and other 
intelligence related issues, for non-profit research and educational purposes 
only. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of the copyrighted material 
as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use 
this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' 
you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.
For more information go to:
http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtmlYahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/

<*> Your email settings:
    Individual Email | Traditional

<*> To change settings online go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/join
    (Yahoo! ID required)

<*> To change settings via email:
    [email protected] 
    [email protected]

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
    [email protected]

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
    http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/

Reply via email to