http://www.familysecuritymatters.org/publications/id.8843/pub_detail.asp

 

February 28, 2011


An Interview with Michael B. Mukasey


Read what former AG Mike Mukasey thinks is "deeply disturbing" about AG Eric
Holder's Justice Department.

 <http://www.familysecuritymatters.org/authors/id.67/author_detail.asp> Ruth
King


Print This <javascript:%20printVersion()>  E-mail This
<javascript:%20emailVersion()>  



 <javascript:void(0);> http://www.familysecuritymatters.org/images/share.png


ShareThis <javascript:void(0);> 

 

Comments (7)
<http://www.familysecuritymatters.org/publications/comments.asp?id=8843> 

http://www.familysecuritymatters.org/imgLib/20110227_MBMukasey1.jpg

 

Michael B. Mukasey served as the 81st Attorney General of the United States
from November 2007 to January 2009. He oversaw all activities of the Justice
Department, and advised on critical issues of domestic and international
law.

 

He was eminently well suited for the role, following an illustrious career
in law. Judge Mukasey began his career in private practice after graduating
from Yale Law School in 1967, where he was a member of the board of editors
of the Yale Law Journal. He served as an Assistant U.S. Attorney for the
Southern District of New York, in the Criminal Division, from 1972 to 1976,
and as chief of that office's official corruption unit in 1975-1976.

 

>From 1976 until 1987, when President Reagan nominated him to the bench, he
practiced at Patterson, Belknap, Webb &Tyler, where he litigated cases in
state, federal and arbitral tribunals.

 

>From 1988 to 2006, he served as a district judge in the United States
District Court for the Southern District of New York, becoming chief judge
in 2000.  While on the bench, he handled numerous cases, including the trial
of Omar Abdel Rahman, the so-called "blind sheikh," and nine co-defendants,
convicted of a wide-ranging conspiracy that included the 1993 bombing of the
World Trade Center and a later plot to blow up New York landmarks, including
the Holland and Lincoln Tunnels, the United Nations, and the FBI's New York
headquarters in lower Manhattan;  and the case of Jose Padilla, arrested on
a material witness warrant and believed to have returned to the United
States to detonate a high-radiation bomb and to blow up apartment buildings
by sealing apartments, filling them with gas, and then detonating them.

 

Since February 2009, Judge Mukasey has been a partner in the New York firm
of Debevoise & Plimpton, where he is a member of the litigation department
and focuses his practice primarily on internal investigations, independent
board reviews and corporate governance. 

The honors he has received include the Federal Bar Council's Learned Hand
Medal for Excellence in Federal Jurisprudence and an honorary Doctorate of
Laws from Brooklyn Law School.

 

I am delighted and honored to interview Judge Mukasey  for FSM. It is also
daunting after reading his caveat in a
<http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052748703583404576079930494332352.h
tml?mod=WSJ_newsreel_opinion> recent column in the Wall Street Journal in
which he reviews and dissects two books on the war on terror: 

 

"What gets bypassed in the process are two basic rules of both journalism
and history: that if you ask the wrong questions you get the wrong answers,
and that if you don't look for facts you won't find them."

 

http://www.familysecuritymatters.org/imgLib/20110113_JosePadilla.jpg

 

Ruth King:  Jose Padilla also known as Abdullah al-Muhajir after he
converted to Islam, was arrested on a material witness warrant and initially
slated for a civil trial.  In 2003 you displayed independence and a
willingness to defy President Bush  by ruling that Padilla had rights to a
lawyer. During your confirmation hearings you were praised by liberals for
this action. Could you tell us what happened and how he came to be tried and
convicted in Florida?

 

Michael B. Mukasey:  The Jose Padilla case took several twists and turns
before he was ultimately tried.  The case came to me initially as an
application by the government for a material witness warrant to apprehend
Padilla when he arrived in Chicago from abroad.  The material witness
statute permits the government, or a defendant, to apply to a court to
arrest someone who has information about a crime the government is
investigating or prosecuting, if the evidence suggests that that person
would not be available to testify if allowed to remain free.  The
information submitted about Padilla indicated sufficient connection between
him and al Qaeda to conclude both that he had information and that he would
not be available of his own free will if permitted to remain at large.

 

That law requires the person detained to be brought before a court, assigned
a lawyer if he cannot afford one, and get a hearing on the propriety of
continuing to detain him until whatever evidence he has can be obtained in a
form useful to the party that asked for the warrant.  It bears mention that
the law allows a warrant to be issued at the request of a defendant to
detain a witness the defendant would need at trial if it appears that that
witness would not willingly make himself available.

 

In any event, the law is not a preventive detention statute, and I made it
clear to the government lawyers that they would have to put Padilla before a
grand jury to obtain his testimony, if he was willing to provide it, charge
him with some crime that would warrant his continued detention, or let him
go.  Those were the options.  After a couple of weeks, I imposed a deadline.
On a Sunday, just before the deadline ran out, the U.S. Attorney told me
that the President had designated Padilla an unlawful enemy combatant and
directed that he be transferred to military custody.  Military authorities
were on their way to pick him up, and therefore the government wanted to
cancel the material witness warrant so that the military could take custody
of Padilla.

 

I pointed out that Padilla's lawyer no doubt would want to challenge that,
and was told that the government did not dispute that Padilla had the right
to file a habeas corpus petition challenging his continued detention.  When
the deadline ran a day later, the parties appeared in court but Padilla was
no longer in the jurisdiction; he had been transferred to the Navy brig at
Charleston, South Carolina.  The government had conceded that Padilla could
file a habeas corpus petition, and I ruled that although the President had
authority to detain Padilla as an unlawful enemy combatant, the only
practical way for him to do that was to consult with a lawyer, only about
the limited issues on a habeas petition, which would simply involve a
challenge to the lawfulness of his detention.  The government objected, and
took an appeal.  The Court of Appeals ruled 2-1 that the President did not
have authority to detain Padilla as an unlawful combatant.  When the case
got to the Supreme Court, they held that Padilla had to file his petition in
the jurisdiction where he was then detained, which was South Carolina.

Padilla filed his petition in South Carolina, where the District Court
agreed with him that the President had no authority to detain him, but the
Fourth Circuit reversed, finding the President did have that authority, as I
had held.

 

Before the case got to the Supreme Court, the government decided to charge
Padilla in a civilian court with plotting to blow up apartments by filling
them with gas and then using a cell phone as a detonator.  He was tried in
Florida on that charge, convicted, and sentenced to a long term of
imprisonment.

 

RK: In the aforementioned Wall Street Journal review you state :  "Finally,
consider Mr. Bergen's assertion that "mainstream Islam" is rejecting al
Qaeda and that the 9/11 attack was "un-Islamic," a judgment that fails twice
over, including once on his own evidence. If by "mainstream Islam" Mr.
Bergen means moderate Islam, there is no such thing. There are many moderate
Muslims, but there is simply no body of doctrine within Islam that provides
a principled basis for condemning the 9/11 attacks. There are many devout
Muslims in America who practice a rigid form of Islam. How can one be alert
to those citizens who adhere to strict Koranic doctrine without impinging on
their liberty and rights?

 

MBM: I think citizens are free to adhere to whatever doctrine they wish, be
it rigid Islam or anything else.  I think what Americans must practice is
what the intel and military folks call situational awareness.  When someone
advocates a point of view that could have a negative effect on our security,
or when someone urges a particular public policy that could affect our
security or the content of our culture, it is perfectly acceptable to make
ourselves aware of the belief system that motivates that person, and to
consider whatever evidence may bear on that, including who that person's
close associates are and who that person has associated with in the past.
We are not under any obligation to change the culture of this country to
make it more congenial to people who do not find it so, or to suffer in
silence their attempts to impose cultural changes on us.

 

RK:  The House just passed an extension of the Patriot Act. Conservatives
think the law invades individual privacy. Liberals say it infringes on civil
liberties. Any thoughts on that?  Do you think any provisions of the Patriot
Act are critical to national security ?

 

MBM: The Patriot Act has generated a lot of controversy, but it consists
principally of authorities for the Justice Department to use in terrorism
cases investigative tools that it can use in other cases as well.  So for
example, many criminals use successive cell phones, discarding them
periodically so as to avoid surveillance.  The Patriot Act allows the
government to obtain what are called roving wiretaps, so they can overhear
the conversations of a particular subject regardless of which telephone he
uses.  That authority was available in narcotics cases; the Patriot Act
simply extended it to terrorism cases.  The business records provision
allows the government to apply to a court to obtain business records
maintained by a third party in connection with a terrorist investigation.
So, for example, the government could obtain records of the telephone
company showing which long-distance calls had been placed from a particular
telephone.  These are records already in the hands of the telephone company,
so there is only a weak privacy interest, if any, that is implicated.  These
provisions are vital to investigating the kinds of threats we face now,
which involve smaller plots by individuals or loosely organized groups.  

 

http://www.familysecuritymatters.org/imgLib/20110119_MEKlogo.jpg

 

RK: Recently you advocated that the Mujahadin-e-Khalq be removed from the
State Departments' list of terrorist organizations.  That made some of your
critics go viral. Tell us about that.

 

MBM:  Muhadin e Khalq - This Iranian group, known as MEK, which now opposes
the mullahs, was placed on the State Department's list of foreign terrorist
organizations based on activities it had engaged in when the Shah was still
in power in the 1970's, in part because some in the State Department thought
it would help us engage with Iran.  It was kept on during the Bush
administration because some believed that if MEK were taken off the list the
Iranians would retaliate by sending IED's and other equipment to insurgents
in Iraq, which of course the Iranians are doing anyway.  People in the
intelligence community concede that MEK has not engaged in any terrorist
activities for decades, that it wishes to overthrow the current Iranian
regime and replace it with one that would be not only secular but also
democratic and nuclear-free.  There are now some 3400 members of MEK who are
living in a settlement in Iraq not far from the Iranian border who are being
harassed by Iranian thugs and by Iraqi authorities who are under the
influence of Iran.  MEK cannot raise money or travel in the United States,
and the Iranians use the terrorist listing to confirm their own persecution
of members of the group, many of whom have been executed by the regime.
There is no good reason to maintain MEK on the list, and removing it would
not only help the people in that settlement, known as Ashraf, but would also
send a signal to the Iranian government that we are prepared to side with
people who oppose the regime.  

 

RK: What do you think about the fact thatthe Obama administration has fired
an unprecedented number of Inspectors General who serve to monitor
government agencies?

 

MBM: Inspectors General are supposed to function independent of political
influence, and report to Congress.  Their independence should be respected.

 

RK: And finally a few questions about Eric Holder.  In Jennifer Rubin's
recent interview you characterize your successor's conduct as "amazing."

 

1.    Can you comment on the DOJ'shandling of the New Black Panther party,
not only their controversial decision not to prosecute what seemed a clear
case of voter intimidation, but the charges of racism within the department
that accompanied it?

2.    What do you think of the Holder Justice Department on national
security?

3.    What about his challenge to Arizona's immigration law?

 

 

MBM: You have asked me a series of questions related to Department of
Justice issues, and I am happy to answer them, but I want to make clear that
whatever differences I have with the current administration relating to such
issues, they are differences over policy for reasons that I have explained
at various times; they are not personal issues relating to my successor.

 

That said, I think the handling of the New Black Panther Party case is
something that seems deeply disturbing, and warrants either a full
explanation, or a serious outside inquiry, possibly from Congress, or both.
Two members of the New Black Panther party were seen intimidating voters
outside a poll in Philadelphia during the 2008 election, and a case against
them resulted in a decision for the government, which the defendants did not
contest.  A witness to the intimidation who had served as a highly civil
rights lawyer at the Justice Department in the 1960's, Bartle Bull, said
that the defendants' conduct was the most blatant kind of intimidation he
had ever seen, including what he witnessed in Mississippi in the 1960's. 

 

Despite that, and even though the government had already won the case, the
Justice Department voluntarily discontinued the case after the new
administration took over.  

 

As I said, I have policy differences with my successor.  As to national
security, I think that some sound decisions have been made, including
continuing to protect the government's state secrets privilege so that
sensitive information is not disclosed publicly, and continuing to use the
authorities provided under the Patriot Act and the Foreign Intelligence
Surveillance Act, as amended.  However, I think it is a mistake to keep
articulating support for the proposition that unlawful enemy combatants
should be tried in civilian courts, which I think are ill suited to the task
and which present considerable security risks for us and opportunities for
terrorists and those allied with them.  

 

I note that Guantanamo, a military facility, remains open; it should.

 

So far as the Department's challenge to the Arizona statute, I see no
inconsistency between the Arizona law and federal law, and believe that the
Arizona statute simply recognizes as unlawful behavior that is already
unlawful under federal law - namely, being in the country unlawfully. 

 

Whatever differences I have with Eric Holder concern policy, and I think he
is capable of implementing sound policies if permitted by the administration
to do so.  

 

RK: Thank you very much for taking the time for this interview.  In FSM's
opinion you were a superb Attorney General . You restored our faith in
American jurisprudence and justice. We wish you continued good luck and
success. 

 

http://www.familysecuritymatters.org/imgLib/20110227_MBMukasey2.jpg

 

 <http://familysecuritymatters.org/> FamilySecurityMatters.org Contributing
Editor
<http://www.familysecuritymatters.org/authors/id.67/author_detail.asp> Ruth
S. King is a freelance writer who writes a monthly column in
<http://mideastoutpost.com/> OUTPOST, the publication of Americans for a
Safe Israel.

 



[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]



------------------------------------

--------------------------
Want to discuss this topic?  Head on over to our discussion list, 
[email protected].
--------------------------
Brooks Isoldi, editor
[email protected]

http://www.intellnet.org

  Post message: [email protected]
  Subscribe:    [email protected]
  Unsubscribe:  [email protected]


*** FAIR USE NOTICE. This message contains copyrighted material whose use has 
not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. OSINT, as a part of 
The Intelligence Network, is making it available without profit to OSINT 
YahooGroups members who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the 
included information in their efforts to advance the understanding of 
intelligence and law enforcement organizations, their activities, methods, 
techniques, human rights, civil liberties, social justice and other 
intelligence related issues, for non-profit research and educational purposes 
only. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of the copyrighted material 
as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use 
this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' 
you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.
For more information go to:
http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtmlYahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/

<*> Your email settings:
    Individual Email | Traditional

<*> To change settings online go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/join
    (Yahoo! ID required)

<*> To change settings via email:
    [email protected] 
    [email protected]

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
    [email protected]

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
    http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/

Reply via email to