Free speech is a fundamental freedom. But all it takes is a few Muslim
murders and Reid, Breyer and Graham eagerly hold up their lighters to the
Constitution


Muslims and Moral Handicaps

        

 - Daniel Greenfield  Monday, April 4, 2011 

Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid wants an investigation into
<http://www.newsmax.com/InsideCover/HarryReid-QuranBurning-Afghanistan-/2011
/04/03/id/391567>  Koran burning. Supreme Court Justice Stephen Breyer
suggested
<http://sultanknish.blogspot.com/2010/09/will-america-ban-criticism-of-islam
.html>  that this form of free speech could be banned. Senator Lindsey
Graham is also looking for ways to limit free speech
<http://gatewaypundit.rightnetwork.com/2011/04/rino-lindsey-graham-freedom-o
f-speech-is-a-great-idea-but-were-at-war-video/> , saying, "Free speech is a
great idea, but we're in a war".

Free speech is more than a great idea, it's a fundamental freedom
untouchable by legislators. But all it takes is a few Muslim murders- and
Reid, Breyer and Graham eagerly hold up their lighters to the Constitution.
Free speech has been curtailed before in the United States during a time of
war-but only free speech sympathetic to the enemy.  During WW1 a suspected
German propagandist filmmaker was jailed. But could anyone have imagined
anti-German propagandists being jailed? The Wilson administration was
behaving unconstitutionally, but not insanely. 

        

Today we aren't jailing filmmakers who traffic in anti-American propaganda
in wartime. If we did that half of Hollywood would be  behind bars. Instead
Democratic and Republican Senators are discussing banning speech offensive
to the enemy. Because even though they're killing us already-we had better
not provoke them or who knows how much worse it will become.

Traditionally it's the victors who give their laws to the defeated. But
massive immigration at home and nation building occupations abroad mean that
the defeated of failed states are imposing their Sharia law on us. We're
asked to trade in our Constitutional freedoms out of fear of Muslim
violence. And so the murderers impose the terms of peace on us. And then
don't abide by them.


Violence in the Muslim world is a constant


Violence in the Muslim world is a constant
<http://www.thereligionofpeace.com/> .  We have been fighting Muslim
violence since George Washington's time.  And we have been subject to it
even longer. Whether it's Muslims killing Hindus, Christians, Jews,
Zoroastrians or any and every religion under the sun-there is a pattern
here. It's a story as old as time. And it's not one that we can stop by
ladling out honeyed words of appeasement. 

Senator Graham warns us to shut up in a time of war-but is there any
foreseeable future in which we won't be fighting in a Muslim country?
Democrats elected the most anti-war candidate of the bunch only to see him
begin his 2012 reelection campaign by bombing another Muslim country. And
what's surprising about that. Most of the trouble spots in the world that
directly or indirectly affect us are located in Muslim countries. The major
threat to the United States comes from the Muslim world. And that means
we're going to be tied up dealing with the Muslim world in one way or
another, whether as soldiers, diplomats or aid workers. And even if we
weren't-there are hundreds of thousands of Americans still living and
working in Muslim countries. Hostages to the latest Muslim temper tantrum.


As Muslim terror has gotten worse, we have started treating the Muslim world
like a ticking bomb


As Muslim terror has gotten worse, we have started treating the Muslim world
like a ticking bomb-tiptoeing around them to avoid setting them off.
Whatever they don't like about us, we're willing to change. The paradigm of
the angry dog or the ticking bomb means that we're damned if we do and
damned if we don't. Whatever you do, the dog mauls you and the bomb blows
up. But by pretending that you control the situation, you can feel better
about your role in the outcome.

When a man teases a dog on the other side of a chain link fence-we blame the
man for provoking the dog, not the dog for being provoked. Animals have less
of everything that makes for accountability. And so don't hold them
accountable. Instead we divide them into categories of dangerous and
harmless, and treat them accordingly.

Our response to Muslim violence in Afghanistan, supposedly touched off by a
Koran burning in Florida, uses that same canine logic. The Muslims are
dangerous and violent, so whoever provokes them is held accountable for what
they do. Don't tease a doberman on the other side of a chain link fence and
don't tease Muslims on the other side of the border or the world. That's the
takeaway from our elected and unelected officials. 

But the Muslim rioters are not dogs, they are human beings whose moral
responsibility is being denied by treating their violence as a reflexive
act. Their violence is not unconscious or instinctual-it emerges out of a
decision making process. There is nothing inevitable about what happened in
Afghanistan. If Muslims had some sort of hair trigger, then why was the
violent rioting confined to a very specific part of the world. For the same
reason that the reaction to the cartoons took so long. And why was it
directed at the UN and not the US. The Koran burning was not the cause of
Muslim violence-but a rationalization for existing violence that would have
occurred anyway for reasons having nothing to do with Terry Jones. And by
treating Muslims like the 'Morally Handicapped' who have no choice but to
kill when something offends them, we are not doing any favors for them or
us.

It is far more insulting to treat Muslims as if they have no ability to
control themselves and have no responsibility for their actions-than it is
to burn their Koran. That is an assessment that even many Muslims would
agree with. 

To blame Jones for their actions, we must either treat murder as a
reasonable response to the burning of a book, or grant that Jones has a
higher level of moral responsibility than the rioters do. There are few
non-Muslims who could defend the notion that burning the Koran is a
provocation that justifies bloodshed. And virtually no liberal would openly
concede that he believes Muslims are morally handicapped-but then why does
he treat them that way?

If a Christian had torched a mosque in response to the Muslim arson of
churches in Africa-is there any liberal columnist or pundit who would have
directed the lion's share of the blame at the original Muslim arsonists? No.
The mosque burning would be treated as an independent act with no linkage to
the church arsons. That is the attitude of Western jurisprudence which does
not allow one crime to justify another, let alone one provocation to justify
a crime. Individuals are treated as responsible moral actors-not shooting
balls in a pinball machine. Why then does this standard fly out the window
when it comes to Muslims? Why does the press so easily sink into the
rhetoric of 'retaliation and 'provocation', treating Muslim terrorism as a
reflex, rather than a chosen act.

Is it not because for all their fanciful prose about the Religion of Peace,
they do indeed see Muslims as dogs on the other side of a chain link fence.
"Don't tease the dog, son, and it won't hurt you."


Liberalism begins as condescension toward lower class violence and
culminates in complicity with it


Liberalism begins as condescension toward lower class violence and
culminates in complicity with it. Class warfare treated the poor as less
morally responsible than the rich because of their deprivation and
persecution. By treating physical deprivation as equivalent to moral
deprivation, they became guilty of a far worse prejudice than those they
were combating. They had declared that the poor were subhuman. When class
warfare gave way to race warfare, they repeated the same ugly trick,
romanticizing the Black Panthers and empowering thugs and rioters who
destroyed black and white communities. The discriminated against were not
bound by the same moral code as the discriminators. Their violence was
'purer' because it was a reflex against their conditions that they could not
control. And so liberals who lectured ceaselessly about racism, were
treating minorities as less than human.

Now in the age of Globalism-Muslims are the new oppressed, exempted from the
norms of civilized society. The morally handicapped who cannot be expected
to turn the other cheek, the way we're supposed to. 

But Muslims are not morally disabled-they are immorally enabled. Muslim
violence is a choice. Their choice. It is not a reflex or a reaction or a
pinball bouncing off the cycle of violence. It is not something that we are
responsible for. It is something that they and only they are responsible
for. By pretending otherwise, we are immorally enabling them. Treating them
like mad dogs or ticking time bombs just guarantees that they will play
their part and fulfill our expectations by mauling or exploding.

We have never held Muslims morally accountable for anything they do. Not as
a religion or as countries or individuals. Instead we pretend that Osama bin
Laden or Saddam Hussein or Gaddafi are the problem. A handful of extremists
and a few bad leaders somewhere. Not the people themselves. Never them.

Instead we have treated Muslims as the morally handicapped, too morally
feeble to understand that violence is not the answer to everything from your
daughter sneaking out with a boy to a pastor torching the Koran for a BBQ.
And they have reacted exactly as people do when they know they will not be
held accountable for their actions.

Treating someone as dangerous gives them power over you. They will test that
power and then use it. Allowing yourself to be intimidated is the first step
to being defeated. For many it is also the last step. We treated Muslims as
dangerous and then we insist loudly that we love them very much and aren't
afraid of them at all. Guess who we're fooling?  Only ourselves. Every time
there's a terror alert or American politicians talk about the wonders of the
Koran-the Muslim world sees it as evidence of their power over us. And when
a Koran is burned, that just means we need further intimidating. It's a
cycle of violence, but we're not the ones driving it except through our
appeasement.

Muslims have stifled their own moral development-but we haven't helped
either. And the only way we can do that is to push them toward a moral
reckoning. Instead we have bought into their genocidal narrative, enabled
their violence and empowered the murderous aspects of their ideology. It's
time that stopped. Lies and flattery will not prevent the violence. Only the
confrontation of truth can force a moral reckoning.

Senator Graham wishes there was a way
<http://mypetjawa.mu.nu/archives/207148.php> to hold Koran burners
accountable for violence carried out by Koran readers, but what we really
need is a way to hold Koran believers accountable for their own violence.

 



[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]



------------------------------------

--------------------------
Want to discuss this topic?  Head on over to our discussion list, 
[email protected].
--------------------------
Brooks Isoldi, editor
[email protected]

http://www.intellnet.org

  Post message: [email protected]
  Subscribe:    [email protected]
  Unsubscribe:  [email protected]


*** FAIR USE NOTICE. This message contains copyrighted material whose use has 
not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. OSINT, as a part of 
The Intelligence Network, is making it available without profit to OSINT 
YahooGroups members who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the 
included information in their efforts to advance the understanding of 
intelligence and law enforcement organizations, their activities, methods, 
techniques, human rights, civil liberties, social justice and other 
intelligence related issues, for non-profit research and educational purposes 
only. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of the copyrighted material 
as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use 
this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' 
you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.
For more information go to:
http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtmlYahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/

<*> Your email settings:
    Individual Email | Traditional

<*> To change settings online go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/join
    (Yahoo! ID required)

<*> To change settings via email:
    [email protected] 
    [email protected]

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
    [email protected]

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
    http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/

Reply via email to