Thanks for the feedback. I responded on one point:
On Jul 20, 2010, at 9:34 AM, Steve K Speicher wrote: > Some initial feedback/thoughts below. Can discuss more at tomorrow's > meeting. > >> 2) We remove the step-by-step instructions for generating RDF/XML, >> JSON and Atom from the Core spec because they are not well specified >> or widely implemented enough to be in the final OSLC Core >> specification. > > Agree for RDF/XML. > For JSON and Atom, I believe an algorithm/approach/guidance is still > needed since there are no well-defined or industry standards to use. I agree too, but... we will still have the algorithm approach. They will be in the guidance with the RDF/XML rules. The JSON algorithm has the same flaws as the RDF/XML subset algorithm, it's a new and non-standard format that needs better specs, more implementation experience, etc. I don't see why it should not be treated in the same way. - Dave
