I have few comments as mentioned below. Automation plan: Can we just call it Automation. Do we gain any meaning with plan.
Automation plan: We don't have oslc_auto:automationType attribute. Without this we can't distinguish whether Automation is for build, test, deployment, cloud etc.. I think this needs to be typed. Automaton Request: oslc_auto:state - Probably it's value can be defined by specification, rather loosely relying on the provider. This will allows clients to write more predictable code rather writing specific code to each provider. I think verdict domain can be different for different provider but state of the Automation Request can be guided by specification across all providers. AutomationResult: oslc_auto:verdict is used for end result's verdict, oslc_auto:state - I am not sure why this property is mandatory when verdict is already available. In RQM there is only one field for verdict, there is no other state for result. I am thinking this should not be one-many but zero-many property. Regards, ___________________________________________________________________________ -|- Pramod K Chandoria Advisory Software Engineer IBM Rational, India Software Lab Bangalore, India | +91-80-417-77045 | +91 99805 68253 What's new in 4.0 RC0 | Ask Question in forum | Online Help | Download RQM 4.0 RC0 From: Michael F Fiedler <[email protected]> To: [email protected], [email protected] Date: 05/08/2012 07:49 PM Subject: [Oslc-Automation] Request for review of OSLC Automation specification Sent by: [email protected] The Automation workgroup continues to make progress on the specification and is working to move towards convergence with several early implementations beginning now. The workgroup would like to invite you to review the current draft [1] of the specification. All comments are welcome. We would especially be interested in feedback from Core members and Automation members who have not been in attendance lately. [1] - http://open-services.net/bin/view/Main/AutoSpecificationV2 Regards, Mike Michael Fiedler IBM Rational Software [email protected] 919-254-4170_______________________________________________ Oslc-Automation mailing list [email protected] http://open-services.net/mailman/listinfo/oslc-automation_open-services.net
