> > Based upon documentation, this should 'just' work, but well, it doesn't.
> The
> > two slave interfaces seem to always be disabled.  I have the following:
> >
> > # ovs-vsctl add-bond ovsbr0 bond_mlnx enp8s0f0 enp8s0f1 lacp=active
> > trunks=64,65
> 
> After sending that message, I read at the following that lacp mode is not
> supported and is problematic, and that I should use bond_mode=balance-tcp
> which does bring the interfaces up.
> 

After more digging, the Mellanox is dropping the lacp frames, so no sync is
happening.

Any Mellanox users on the list who are aware of the following?  And maybe
suggest an alternate setup?

I took a look at the ovs-vswitchd.conf.db lacp / bond parameters and saw no
knobs which might deal with something like this.

The key two lines from the following:

Jan 22 11:59:12 mlnx02 issd[3931]: TID 139885316582432: [issd.NOTICE]: LA:
LaHandleRxDataFrame: Port: 9:COLLECTING NOT Enabled !! DISCARDING FRAME

Jan 22 11:59:12 mlnx02 issd[3931]: TID 139885316582432: [issd.NOTICE]: LA:
LaHandleRxDataFrame: Port 9 FATAL ERROR :



Jan 22 11:57:32 mlnx02 mgmtd[2828]: [mgmtd.NOTICE]: Config change ID 148:
requested by: user admin (System Administrator) via CLI, 2 item(s) changed
Jan 22 11:57:32 mlnx02 mgmtd[2828]: [mgmtd.NOTICE]: Config change ID 148:
item 1: debug protocol to be logged in debug file added
Jan 22 11:57:32 mlnx02 mgmtd[2828]: [mgmtd.NOTICE]: Config change ID 148:
item 2: debug protocol to be logged in debug file: Minimum trace level
initially set to 8
Jan 22 11:57:32 mlnx02 issd[3931]: TID 139884917987072: [issd.NOTICE]:
issd_mgmt_handle_event_request: Received event: /mgmtd/notify/dbchange
Jan 22 11:57:32 mlnx02 mgmtd[2828]: [mgmtd.NOTICE]: Entering:
md_db_commit_apply
Jan 22 11:57:32 mlnx02 issd[3931]: TID 139884917987072: [issd.NOTICE]:
Handling change event for /log/config/debug/protocol/lacp
Jan 22 11:57:32 mlnx02 issd[3931]: TID 139884917987072: [issd.NOTICE]:
Handling change event for /log/config/debug/protocol/lacp/event
Jan 22 11:57:33 mlnx02 issd[3931]: TID 139884403714720: [issd.NOTICE]: LA:
LaProcessLacpFrame:Dumping LACP frame received from lower layer...
Jan 22 11:57:34 mlnx02 issd[3931]: TID 139884403714720: [issd.NOTICE]: LA:
LaProcessLacpFrame:Dumping LACP frame received from lower layer...
Jan 22 11:57:42 mlnx02 mgmtd[2828]: [mgmtd.NOTICE]: Config change ID 149:
requested by: user admin (System Administrator) via CLI, 1 item(s) changed
Jan 22 11:57:42 mlnx02 mgmtd[2828]: [mgmtd.NOTICE]: Config change ID 149:
item 1: debug protocol to be logged in debug file: Minimum trace level
changed from 8 to 10
Jan 22 11:57:42 mlnx02 issd[3931]: TID 139884917987072: [issd.NOTICE]:
issd_mgmt_handle_event_request: Received event: /mgmtd/notify/dbchange
Jan 22 11:57:42 mlnx02 issd[3931]: TID 139884917987072: [issd.NOTICE]:
Handling change event for /log/config/debug/protocol/lacp/event
Jan 22 11:57:42 mlnx02 mgmtd[2828]: [mgmtd.NOTICE]: Entering:
md_db_commit_apply
Jan 22 11:57:43 mlnx02 issd[3931]: TID 139884403714720: [issd.NOTICE]: LA:
LaProcessLacpFrame:Dumping LACP frame received from lower layer...
Jan 22 11:58:34 mlnx02 last message repeated 4 times
Jan 22 11:58:44 mlnx02 last message repeated 2 times
Jan 22 11:58:55 mlnx02 mgmtd[2828]: [mgmtd.NOTICE]: Config change ID 150:
requested by: user admin (System Administrator) via CLI, 1 item(s) changed
Jan 22 11:58:55 mlnx02 mgmtd[2828]: [mgmtd.NOTICE]: Config change ID 150:
item 1: debug protocol to be logged in debug file: Minimum trace level
changed from 10 to 65546
Jan 22 11:58:55 mlnx02 issd[3931]: TID 139884917987072: [issd.NOTICE]:
issd_mgmt_handle_event_request: Received event: /mgmtd/notify/dbchange
Jan 22 11:58:55 mlnx02 issd[3931]: TID 139884917987072: [issd.NOTICE]:
Handling change event for /log/config/debug/protocol/lacp/event
Jan 22 11:58:55 mlnx02 mgmtd[2828]: [mgmtd.NOTICE]: Entering:
md_db_commit_apply
Jan 22 11:58:56 mlnx02 issd[3931]: TID 139884403714720: [issd.NOTICE]: LA:
TMR: Started Timer
Jan 22 11:59:04 mlnx02 last message repeated 41 times
Jan 22 11:59:04 mlnx02 issd[3931]: TID 139885316582432: [issd.NOTICE]: LA:
Called LaEnqueueControlFrame for Port 221
Jan 22 11:59:04 mlnx02 issd[3931]: TID 139884403714720: [issd.NOTICE]: LA:
Called LaProcessLacpFrame for Port 221
Jan 22 11:59:04 mlnx02 issd[3931]: TID 139884403714720: [issd.NOTICE]: LA:
LaProcessLacpFrame:Dumping LACP frame received from lower layer...
Jan 22 11:59:04 mlnx02 issd[3931]: TID 139884403714720: [issd.NOTICE]: LA:
TMR: Timer Stopped SUCCESSFULLY
Jan 22 11:59:04 mlnx02 issd[3931]: TID 139884403714720: [issd.NOTICE]: LA:
TMR: Started Timer
Jan 22 11:59:04 mlnx02 last message repeated 3 times
Jan 22 11:59:04 mlnx02 issd[3931]: TID 139885316582432: [issd.NOTICE]: LA:
Called LaEnqueueControlFrame for Port 61
Jan 22 11:59:04 mlnx02 issd[3931]: TID 139884403714720: [issd.NOTICE]: LA:
Called LaProcessLacpFrame for Port 61
Jan 22 11:59:04 mlnx02 issd[3931]: TID 139884403714720: [issd.NOTICE]: LA:
LaProcessLacpFrame:Dumping LACP frame received from lower layer...
Jan 22 11:59:04 mlnx02 issd[3931]: TID 139884403714720: [issd.NOTICE]: LA:
TMR: Timer Stopped SUCCESSFULLY
Jan 22 11:59:04 mlnx02 issd[3931]: TID 139884403714720: [issd.NOTICE]: LA:
TMR: Started Timer
Jan 22 11:59:11 mlnx02 last message repeated 39 times
Jan 22 11:59:11 mlnx02 issd[3931]: TID 139885316582432: [issd.NOTICE]: LA:
LaHandleRxDataFrame: Port: 9:COLLECTING NOT Enabled !! DISCARDING FRAME
Jan 22 11:59:11 mlnx02 issd[3931]: TID 139885316582432: [issd.NOTICE]: LA:
LaHandleRxDataFrame: Port 9 FATAL ERROR :
Jan 22 11:59:11 mlnx02 issd[3931]: TID 139884403714720: [issd.NOTICE]: LA:
TMR: Started Timer
Jan 22 11:59:12 mlnx02 issd[3931]: TID 139885316582432: [issd.NOTICE]: LA:
LaHandleRxDataFrame: Port: 9:COLLECTING NOT Enabled !! DISCARDING FRAME
Jan 22 11:59:12 mlnx02 issd[3931]: TID 139885316582432: [issd.NOTICE]: LA:
LaHandleRxDataFrame: Port 9 FATAL ERROR :
Jan 22 11:59:12 mlnx02 issd[3931]: TID 139885316582432: [issd.NOTICE]: LA:
LaHandleRxDataFrame: Port: 5:COLLECTING NOT Enabled !! DISCARDING FRAME
Jan 22 11:59:12 mlnx02 issd[3931]: TID 139885316582432: [issd.NOTICE]: LA:
LaHandleRxDataFrame: Port 5 FATAL ERROR :
Jan 22 11:59:12 mlnx02 issd[3931]: TID 139884403714720: [issd.NOTICE]: LA:
TMR: Started Timer
Jan 22 11:59:13 mlnx02 last message repeated 9 times
Jan 22 11:59:14 mlnx02 issd[3931]: TID 139885316582432: [issd.NOTICE]: LA:
Called LaEnqueueControlFrame for Port 217
Jan 22 11:59:14 mlnx02 issd[3931]: TID 139884403714720: [issd.NOTICE]: LA:
Called LaProcessLacpFrame for Port 217
Jan 22 11:59:14 mlnx02 issd[3931]: TID 139884403714720: [issd.NOTICE]: LA:
LaProcessLacpFrame:Dumping LACP frame received from lower layer...
Jan 22 11:59:14 mlnx02 issd[3931]: TID 139884403714720: [issd.NOTICE]: LA:
TMR: Timer Stopped SUCCESSFULLY
Jan 22 11:59:14 mlnx02 issd[3931]: TID 139884403714720: [issd.NOTICE]: LA:
TMR: Started Timer


-- 
This message has been scanned for viruses and
dangerous content by MailScanner, and is
believed to be clean.

_______________________________________________
discuss mailing list
[email protected]
https://mail.openvswitch.org/mailman/listinfo/ovs-discuss

Reply via email to